Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Generational finances

231 replies

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 12:45

I don’t expect I can word this right/fairly but essentially, if retired grandparents have some wealth (e.g., 5 figure savings or assets) and their adult children are bringing up young children on barely enough to pay rent/mortgage, energy bills, childcare and food - is this okay? What are your thoughts and beliefs about how to balance wealth and finances more fairly? What role should grandparents play financially?

OP posts:
Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 17:03

Who gets to decide what constitutes a "decent standard of living" ? Does that include meat or just beans & rice? Takeaways? Starbucks? Charity shop clothing or Primark or John Lewis? Music lessons? A new car? One bedroom per person or shared rooms? Smartphones? Childcare? Holidays? Caravan, camping or overseas by air travel? Legoland?

I think people's expectations are quite inflated these days, in general.

Meat is once or twice a week, no takeaways and no Starbucks, clothing is handed down or vinted bundles (charity shops are not cheap), one car (not bought new), shared bedroom, yes I have a smartphone, yes I pay childcare, holidays are every 2-3 years and in uk not abroad. Never taken kids to Legoland or any other theme park. I’m fine with all of that. I don’t think my kids need holidays abroad or takeaway pizzas to have a decent life. Your post comes across as resentful that younger generations are ungrateful, and whilst expectations and lives have surely changed that doesn’t always mean we are swimming in privilege that we can’t see.

OP posts:
ididntwanttodoit · 16/02/2023 17:00

I do think that grandparents should spread their money around rather than allowing it to sit in a bank gathering minimal interest. However, I wouldn't dream of making a "regular" contribution, which could potentially lead to dependency. I prefer to offer a lump sum whenever it seems appropriate (eg need a new car? here's a couple of grand towards it. No holidays this year? let us pay for the flights), That way I'm not handing out more than I can afford, and it takes the pressure off their finances a bit. My own in-laws used to often (but not always) give us £20 towards the petrol money, back in the day, when we visited them. It was great! we never expected it, but whenever we got it we felt like we'd won the lottery!

RedToothBrush · 16/02/2023 16:59

What are your thoughts and beliefs about how to balance wealth and finances more fairly? What role should grandparents play financially?

There is nothing to balance fairly because your children aren't your parents responsibility. The decisions you make, including to have kids and your choice of career and home, are yours and not your parents. They have no financial obligation to you.

Equally they may well be planning their care in old age, in order to not hit you with that responsibility, either emotional or financial, further down the line.

They may have made sacrifices in order for you to have certain things in childhood and feel that you have a better lifestyle all the same. They may not realise the extent to which you are struggling.

It's not their problem ultimately. And there isn't something to make fair here. You trying to make it their issue or as if they don't care is too simplistic. And wrong.

Iateallthewotsits · 16/02/2023 16:59

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 16:53

So who will pay for your care, then?

Well I won’t be scrimping and making my children eat shit food to save and for it all to go on care like my dad did.

And after what I’ve seen my dad go through, paying over a grand a week on “care”, I don’t intend to be here long enough.

I hate these arguments.

Yes, I’ll be a terrible person making the state pick up the bill because I want to help my children out instead of saving it all to pay to sit gibbering in a corner in distress like my dad.

Justalittlebitduckling · 16/02/2023 16:56

Boomer generation got so much of the wealth. Affordable housing on one income, free university etc. Now NI increases to pay for their care as they age.

Also the selfish generation. I read one theory that they’re selfish and focused on accumulating wealth because they grew
up believing a nuclear war was going to wipe out the earth at any moment, so just wanted to enjoy life while they could. We talk a lot about different types of inequality but generational inequality is real for sure.

Aleaiactaest · 16/02/2023 16:54

OP what professions are you in and how old are your DC? My parents were not that well off when we were very little and bought an old run down house which they did up gradually and scrimped and saved. As we got older they got richer by climbing career ladders (and they also inherited relatively late). The same has been the case for us (early 40s now). Most people I know in great careers go through a difficult stage especially if you have children relatively young (eg start before 30) and the huge associated childcare costs. If live in the South East housing and childcare costs are enormous. We found ways to holiday when the kids were little at friends houses and returned the favour. Not the most comfortable but the kids loved it. My parents did the same- visit relatives for free etc and return the favour. Holidays have also become extortionate.

DashboardConfessional · 16/02/2023 16:54

I don't expect anything from mine. They helped us out with £5k house deposit in the 00s, for which I will be forever grateful as we'd not have our current levels of equity without it.

That said, I'm also not up for nodding along dutifully when they start on about the 3 months they paid 15% interest on a 28k mortgage in the 80s as if it is the same thing as house prices now being 12x household incomes at the same time as £400 energy bills.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 16:53

Iateallthewotsits · 16/02/2023 16:51

I’d give my dc my last penny.

I’ve got fuck all though. I would love to help out my 21 year old.

My dad held his money over me my whole life. I had a childhood of nothing while he saved. He wouldn’t even buy me school uniform that fitted.

He watched me struggle but told me it was for after he was dead.

Then he got dementia and everything has gone to a care home owner.

He really, really regretted that when he still knew what was going on. He used to cry and say he wished he’d helped me out.

I won’t be making that mistake.

So who will pay for your care, then?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 16:53

BlueHeelers · 16/02/2023 16:41

and their adult children are bringing up young children on barely enough to pay rent/mortgage, energy bills, childcare and food - is this okay?

Of course it is.

I imagine that the grandparents had their times of struggle when they had a young family.

And when you’re retired, savings in “five figures” is not a lot.

It is normal to struggle somewhat in life. You don't reap what you've sown till much later, if ever. People seem to have forgotten that and are increasingly entitled.

Iateallthewotsits · 16/02/2023 16:51

I’d give my dc my last penny.

I’ve got fuck all though. I would love to help out my 21 year old.

My dad held his money over me my whole life. I had a childhood of nothing while he saved. He wouldn’t even buy me school uniform that fitted.

He watched me struggle but told me it was for after he was dead.

Then he got dementia and everything has gone to a care home owner.

He really, really regretted that when he still knew what was going on. He used to cry and say he wished he’d helped me out.

I won’t be making that mistake.

Fairysilver · 16/02/2023 16:48

It's down to relationships. How close the family are and how they view things.
We are a very long way from being wealthy but have enough. We give our DC money regularly which they never asked for and are very appreciative of.
Neither DH nor my parents had a bean so we didn’t get any " family money". I just feel the DC would benefit from our money more now than when we die.

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 16:47

AnotherForumUser · 16/02/2023 16:38

Sadly I think you are right. Money that could be spent on her having nice experiences with her children is so much more important than her parents having the funds to pay for care with at home or in a care home. I wonder would the council be able to come after her? I'd hope so.

I’m sorry it has come across like this. I have offered for my mum to live with us in the past but she prefers to be independent and I have no problem with that. I have organised and paid for nice parties and gifts for grandparents, and don’t get or expect the same in return. I have recently paid extra childcare costs so I could provide care to one grandparent for health reasons.

OP posts:
IDontWantToBeAPie · 16/02/2023 16:44

CrotchetyQuaver · 16/02/2023 16:42

They need to hang onto that money for a rainy day - to pay carers or nursing home fees!

To be fair when they run out the state takes over nursing home fees

CrotchetyQuaver · 16/02/2023 16:42

They need to hang onto that money for a rainy day - to pay carers or nursing home fees!

BlueHeelers · 16/02/2023 16:41

and their adult children are bringing up young children on barely enough to pay rent/mortgage, energy bills, childcare and food - is this okay?

Of course it is.

I imagine that the grandparents had their times of struggle when they had a young family.

And when you’re retired, savings in “five figures” is not a lot.

AnotherForumUser · 16/02/2023 16:38

Liorae · 16/02/2023 16:35

I'm sure OP is fine with that as long as she is not expected to pay.

Sadly I think you are right. Money that could be spent on her having nice experiences with her children is so much more important than her parents having the funds to pay for care with at home or in a care home. I wonder would the council be able to come after her? I'd hope so.

Indáirire · 16/02/2023 16:37

I have quite a wealthy parent who gives us no help at all. I'm used to it at this stage but you reap what you sow. Now they're* *getting to be quite elderly, I don't bother to see them much and I would never spend too much of my money doing it. I just do the duty I need to do. It goes both ways.

Liorae · 16/02/2023 16:35

KangarooKenny · 16/02/2023 16:28

And if the wealthy parents give away their money, who will pay their care home bill ? The tax payer will.

I'm sure OP is fine with that as long as she is not expected to pay.

KangarooKenny · 16/02/2023 16:28

And if the wealthy parents give away their money, who will pay their care home bill ? The tax payer will.

UdoU · 16/02/2023 16:26

Five figures isn’t that much for retirement.

YABU.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 16:12

Changes17 · 16/02/2023 15:57

Wouldn't it be more intergenerationally fair if society as a whole paid enough tax to ensure all families had a decent standard of living, rather than if wealthy parents just hand on their cash to their own kids?

Society as a whole, that is the net taxpayer, already pays quite a bit to sub parents who had children they couldn't afford.

Who gets to decide what constitutes a "decent standard of living" ? Does that include meat or just beans & rice? Takeaways? Starbucks? Charity shop clothing or Primark or John Lewis? Music lessons? A new car? One bedroom per person or shared rooms? Smartphones? Childcare? Holidays? Caravan, camping or overseas by air travel? Legoland?

I think people's expectations are quite inflated these days, in general. They want the lifestyle of middle-aged people who have put 30-40 years into the workforce when they are barely 5 or 10 years out of school. It's unrealisitc.

EnglishwithSubtitles · 16/02/2023 16:12

I agree that five figure savings isn't much of a sum to rely your whole retirement on so it's a bit of a red herring for me.

However, as a concept I do think there is something in generational wealth that makes sense with the massive disparities between the current generations. I think a lot of it stems from poor financial education and a lack of a good understanding of compound wealth.

For example, it doesn't make much sense for Granny to have hundreds of thousands sitting in a 3% savings account while her children struggle to pay astronomical mortgages at 5.75%. Even a sensible targeted gift in that situation that took the child over a threshold in LTV could make a massive difference to the younger family in the long-run. A lower mortgage repayment could mean more funds at the end of the month, meaning being able to save for the next generation of children to go to university with smaller student loans and hopefully get better paid jobs....meaning they might be able to get on the housing ladder younger and pay their mortgages off earlier and so it goes on......

I'm not saying the older generation needs to live on bread and water and pass everything on to their children, but so many people take short termist attitudes to this sort of thing, instead of thinking even 2 or 3 generations ahead.

Cynically, I would say the BB generation seem to be the worst for failing to see this. So many expect to retire early 60s but see nothing wrong with Millenials coming behind them looking at retiring 10-15 years later and overall having had a much poorer quality of life. I think it will come to a crunch point in the next few years, as Millenials will not be in a position to help with care due to needing to work longer and more more hours to continue to pay off their large mortgages coupled with a care industry that won't be able to cope with the number of people whose children will be unable to physically supplement their care.

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 16:09

Dyrne · 16/02/2023 16:06

People saying parents should help their DC if they are struggling, or treat the grandchildren etc are missing the point the OP originally made; which is that support should go above and beyond helping out or treats; but come in the form of a substantial ongoing income; even when the parents actually have a relatively small pot to have to live off for the rest of their lives.

I absolutely did not say that

OP posts:
ScribblingPixie · 16/02/2023 16:08

Was it this article in the Times, sydneysunset, which said:

"Middle-class homeowners are deepening inequality in Britain by passing down wealth to their children, a leading think tank has claimed.

Parents give away or loan around £17bn to their adult children every year, according to research from the Institute for Fiscal Studies.

Household wealth has boomed in recent decades thanks to a buoyant property market, but passing this down onto the next generation contributes to the nationwide “transmission of inequality”, the IFS said."

Dyrne · 16/02/2023 16:06

People saying parents should help their DC if they are struggling, or treat the grandchildren etc are missing the point the OP originally made; which is that support should go above and beyond helping out or treats; but come in the form of a substantial ongoing income; even when the parents actually have a relatively small pot to have to live off for the rest of their lives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread