Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Generational finances

231 replies

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 12:45

I don’t expect I can word this right/fairly but essentially, if retired grandparents have some wealth (e.g., 5 figure savings or assets) and their adult children are bringing up young children on barely enough to pay rent/mortgage, energy bills, childcare and food - is this okay? What are your thoughts and beliefs about how to balance wealth and finances more fairly? What role should grandparents play financially?

OP posts:
Iateallthewotsits · 16/02/2023 17:57

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:32

So you're OK with your friends, neighbours, co-workers, etc. footing the bill for your care so that you can give your adult children treats? Hmm.

Oh sod off.

No I don’t care. Just like I don’t care about where my taxes go.

Do you know how much care homes cost privately? I doubt helping out with a bit of shopping would make a dent.

And don’t forget the council will be taking my pensions etc and only leaving me with £24 a week.

Not that i’d ever have more than about 6 months of private care fees anyway.

I’ve been through hell with my dad and his care so you can save your outrage, I don’t care. The situation made me sducidal last year and put me in the worst place of my life.

My much younger PIL have put their home in trust after seeing the awful care that their parents has the privilege of paying for alongside people who didn’t have a penny and were in the same place and good luck to them.

Don’t come at me with “don’t you care” because no, I’m long last that.

howmanybicycles · 16/02/2023 17:55

It doesn't sound like your parents are that wealthy and it's great that they have some rainy day funds behind them. I think you need to pay for the lifestyle you want yourself. That is of course hard, and sometimes impossible. Maybe post on another thread and see if there is any help you can get which you're not already or any budgeting tips. Things to get easier when childcare bills reduce too and it sounds like you are still in some of the worst of that. Good luck.

bobbytorq · 16/02/2023 17:53

I agree with poster who have highlighted that people generally struggle more earlier in life and reap the rewards later. I remember being in my twenties and studying full time ofr my two postgraduate degrees whilst also working full time (2 evenings and 2 14hr shifts on a Saturday and Sunday) which I did for 3 years and also had two toddlers at that time too. It was really hard work physically, mentally and financially but I'm reaping the rewards now as are my children.

seekingafreshstart · 16/02/2023 17:49

SovietKitsch · 16/02/2023 17:43

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune with strangers? Or other family?

Because you described a lodging situation in your post, and no sane parent today would have an unrelated man live in their family home.

No sane unrelated man would want to live with a family. He'd rent a house share with other single people.

I'd say 1) parents wanting to look after their children's safety and 2) unrelated adults not wanting to abuse a child both have the same reaction to living together... hard pass.

The previous mention of a commune is interesting, though. You could potentially get families willing to live with other families - do your vetting correctly, and that could be an amazing setup with mutual childcare and understanding. However, I don't think the UK is really geared up to that kind of lifestyle.

seekingafreshstart · 16/02/2023 17:44

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:39

Funny how all of my extended family managed it with no problems for most of the 20th century...

That's just an excuse because people really can't be arsed to make any sacrifices at all in order to save and put by money for hard times.

I don't think safeguarding comes into it at all.

It's more people can only tolerate their own small children - no one wants to share a house with someone else's child. That's why people try not live under the same roof anymore (unless there is a cultural expectation).

SovietKitsch · 16/02/2023 17:43

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune with strangers? Or other family?

Because you described a lodging situation in your post, and no sane parent today would have an unrelated man live in their family home.

Justalittlebitduckling · 16/02/2023 17:42

greenspaces4peace · 16/02/2023 17:15

@Justalittlebitduckling did you cut and paste that BS from the housing thread I’ve read it word or word recently.
i did nothing but continue on the path and example of the generation before me.
I’m no more selfish than the next person.
there was a lot of pain going on in the 50-70’s that simply was not discussed.
Your view is blinkered and fueled by tictok trope.

I’ve never been on TikTok in my life! And I wrote
every word of that myself, so you definitely have not.

You obviously seem quite challenged by it. Threatened even, perhaps.

Justalittlebitduckling · 16/02/2023 17:40

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:10

So, do you think they should have turned down the benefits society offered at the time, like help going to uni?

Does that mean you think people nowadays should turn down the universal credit or free childcare hours, whether they need it or not, so the money can be saved to help future generations??

Absolutely not. But I think government policy should reflect the realities of the historical situation.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:39

SovietKitsch · 16/02/2023 17:37

There’s a very good reason people don’t house share when raising a family @ZeldaWillTellYourFortune - child safe guarding 🤦🏻‍♀️

Funny how all of my extended family managed it with no problems for most of the 20th century...

That's just an excuse because people really can't be arsed to make any sacrifices at all in order to save and put by money for hard times.

SovietKitsch · 16/02/2023 17:37

There’s a very good reason people don’t house share when raising a family @ZeldaWillTellYourFortune - child safe guarding 🤦🏻‍♀️

seekingafreshstart · 16/02/2023 17:35

Disappointingbiscuit · 16/02/2023 17:18

I thank God every day that I have generous parents with enough money to help us. The alternative is it sits in the bank until we inherit it less tax and struggle in the mean time, just to hold some sort of moral high ground. Seems pointless to me.

Your assumption is that if your parents didn't spend the money on you now, you'd get it later, because there's nothing they could possibly spend it on instead.

As someone with unwell parents, I'm glad that they've kept their money for themselves, and they can now spend it on accessing the private healthcare that is making their final years more comfortable. NHS waiting lists for certain things are terrible - it's almost like they hope people will die before they reach their place in the queue.

Yes, the state will probably pick up the tab for any old person with no money to their name. Doesn't mean that quality of care is something I'd wish on my parents. My parents sacrified in bringing me up - they don't owe me anything now I'm a grown up myself and they're retired. I just want them to be OK.

Of course, if your parents are multimillionaires, maybe you have a point about them having more money than they could possibly ever need. For most people though, that's not true. For most people, grandparents spending their money on their adult children and grandchildren means those grandparents are going to have to do without.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:34

Housesharing and flatsharing: do many people do it whilst raising a family? That's what I meant.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:32

Iateallthewotsits · 16/02/2023 16:59

Well I won’t be scrimping and making my children eat shit food to save and for it all to go on care like my dad did.

And after what I’ve seen my dad go through, paying over a grand a week on “care”, I don’t intend to be here long enough.

I hate these arguments.

Yes, I’ll be a terrible person making the state pick up the bill because I want to help my children out instead of saving it all to pay to sit gibbering in a corner in distress like my dad.

So you're OK with your friends, neighbours, co-workers, etc. footing the bill for your care so that you can give your adult children treats? Hmm.

Zipps · 16/02/2023 17:31

I think a lot of older people have spent so long accumulating wealth that they hoard it for way too long. We're retiring this year and over the next years are going to have to get used to selling our investments and spending our savings. Some people just can't change their mindset.
We don't want to end up ridiculously wealthy 70+ year olds with hundreds of thousands left that could've been used and have missed out on lots of holidays and fun. We have a lot more than 5 figures so we can treat our adult dc, even though one of them is very well off. However we wouldn't be bankrolling regular money for bills as that just becomes unhelpful.
We fully intend to spend as much as possible before it gets taken away. Our friends all seem to be saying similar.
We've all got parents that live in huge houses that have squirreled away small fortunes, that have became too old to benefit from any of it and have children who are in their 50's 60's that have all paid off mortgages and got their own finances sorted years ago. We aren't going to make those mistakes. Our dc will benefit if it's needed with house deposits while they are young and struggling and we will spend the rest.

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 17:28

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:20

Agree with you about intergenerational living. The most upwardly mobile cohorts/cultures still do quite a bit of it. I know that my parents, grandparents and great-grandparents, who went from dirt-poor semi-literacy to professionals in a couple of generations, always had elders, cousins, aunts, uncles living together at various times; no household was composed of a nuclear family. It's one huge factor in how they were able to save -- by pooling resources.

The home I live in now, the couple who had it for 40 years before me always had boarders. It is a two-bed, one-bath cottage. The second bedroom had a deadbolt when I purchased it, and upon asking a neighbour she said "Well, Al and Doris always had a lodger; he worked in a factory and there was always some young man or another just starting out who needed to rent a room. It helped them pay off their mortgage faster."

I don't know too many people today who would be willing to share a bathroom with a stranger whose bed was less than 20 feet away from theirs, in a 900 square foot cottage, in order to save more.

I am always surprised that few of the struggling lone parents we hear so much from don't team up with at least one other and form a communal living situation to again, pool resources and try to get ahead economically. Every family having its own isolated dwelling is a brief blip in human history.

I don't know too many people today who would be willing to share a bathroom with a stranger whose bed was less than 20 feet away from theirs, in a 900 square foot cottage, in order to save more.

That's house/flatsharing and millions of people do it.

EmmaEmerald · 16/02/2023 17:26

Moose “FIL would come and visit and make fun of our hallway carpet as it was ripped and threadbare and then show off about how much "spends" he had in his current account and expect me to provide a 3 course meal.”

there’s no excuse for anyone behaving like that. That’s someone I’d not speak to again, they’d be ushered across said carpet out the door v quickly!

seekingafreshstart · 16/02/2023 17:26

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 17:03

Who gets to decide what constitutes a "decent standard of living" ? Does that include meat or just beans & rice? Takeaways? Starbucks? Charity shop clothing or Primark or John Lewis? Music lessons? A new car? One bedroom per person or shared rooms? Smartphones? Childcare? Holidays? Caravan, camping or overseas by air travel? Legoland?

I think people's expectations are quite inflated these days, in general.

Meat is once or twice a week, no takeaways and no Starbucks, clothing is handed down or vinted bundles (charity shops are not cheap), one car (not bought new), shared bedroom, yes I have a smartphone, yes I pay childcare, holidays are every 2-3 years and in uk not abroad. Never taken kids to Legoland or any other theme park. I’m fine with all of that. I don’t think my kids need holidays abroad or takeaway pizzas to have a decent life. Your post comes across as resentful that younger generations are ungrateful, and whilst expectations and lives have surely changed that doesn’t always mean we are swimming in privilege that we can’t see.

I don't think your standards are unreasonably high, and assuming you have closer to 2 children rather than 20, if you are struggling to maintain this standard, given both you and your husband work, there is a problem. I'm not saying you've caused the problem - we all know the cost of living is ridiculous at the moment - but I think it's a problem that the Government should be addressing. So I don't think your resentment should be towards your parents for not giving you extra whilst you're struggling, but at the Government, who have let you struggle.

They managed to shake the magic money tree to pay all their mates for shoddy PPE - they should be able to shake the magic money tree to support working families better. You're already doing all you can. It's your Government who have failed you.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:20

AnotherForumUser · 16/02/2023 17:04

I'm sorry I seemed so abrupt. I'm touchy on this subject as a relative seriously suggested to me that I didn't contact my dad's GP for help when he started showing signs of rapidly onsetting dementia. All simply because that relative didn't see my dad's money should be used for his care. (I ignored that suggestion and my dad was found a fabulous care home which was worth every penny. I also ignore that relative.)

Intergenerational living does seem to be the best solution. While I couldn't have children I know I want to help my nephews and nieces but also need to ensure I can support myself when the time comes. If they want a home with their crazy old aunt I'd be delighted...

Agree with you about intergenerational living. The most upwardly mobile cohorts/cultures still do quite a bit of it. I know that my parents, grandparents and great-grandparents, who went from dirt-poor semi-literacy to professionals in a couple of generations, always had elders, cousins, aunts, uncles living together at various times; no household was composed of a nuclear family. It's one huge factor in how they were able to save -- by pooling resources.

The home I live in now, the couple who had it for 40 years before me always had boarders. It is a two-bed, one-bath cottage. The second bedroom had a deadbolt when I purchased it, and upon asking a neighbour she said "Well, Al and Doris always had a lodger; he worked in a factory and there was always some young man or another just starting out who needed to rent a room. It helped them pay off their mortgage faster."

I don't know too many people today who would be willing to share a bathroom with a stranger whose bed was less than 20 feet away from theirs, in a 900 square foot cottage, in order to save more.

I am always surprised that few of the struggling lone parents we hear so much from don't team up with at least one other and form a communal living situation to again, pool resources and try to get ahead economically. Every family having its own isolated dwelling is a brief blip in human history.

2023a · 16/02/2023 17:18

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 15:35

I’ve thought about it and I don’t think I know anyone with what I’d consider ‘comfortable’ parents who isn’t pretty comfortable in their own right. Basically, our parents funded excellent education, lots of extracurriculars and essentially paid for shitloads of social capital. Then they sent us off into the world to make our fortunes, as it were. And make our fortunes we did.

It would be easy to say that DH and I haven’t had ‘help’ from our parents since uni. We don’t need it, it hasn’t occurred to us to ask for any and they’d probably be rather disgusted if we did. On the other hand, my father paid for our wedding and PIL gave us £15K as a wedding present. So, there’s help and there’s ‘help’.

We’re unlikely to ever be in the dire straits described by pp. I have no idea how our parents would react if we were. I imagine they’d be quite bitterly disappointed, but I honestly don’t know if it would even occur to them to give us any money.

Your £15k wedding present might be negligible to you and your parents, but for a lot of people that would definitely be HELP (uppercase for emphasis).

Disappointingbiscuit · 16/02/2023 17:18

I thank God every day that I have generous parents with enough money to help us. The alternative is it sits in the bank until we inherit it less tax and struggle in the mean time, just to hold some sort of moral high ground. Seems pointless to me.

greenspaces4peace · 16/02/2023 17:15

@Justalittlebitduckling did you cut and paste that BS from the housing thread I’ve read it word or word recently.
i did nothing but continue on the path and example of the generation before me.
I’m no more selfish than the next person.
there was a lot of pain going on in the 50-70’s that simply was not discussed.
Your view is blinkered and fueled by tictok trope.

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 17:12

@AnotherForumUser that’s ok. Glad your dad got such good care. I would never want to take that option away from my parents or pil. I think access to affordable good quality care in later life is as important an issue as access to affordable good quality childcare for the next generation.

OP posts:
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 16/02/2023 17:10

Justalittlebitduckling · 16/02/2023 16:56

Boomer generation got so much of the wealth. Affordable housing on one income, free university etc. Now NI increases to pay for their care as they age.

Also the selfish generation. I read one theory that they’re selfish and focused on accumulating wealth because they grew
up believing a nuclear war was going to wipe out the earth at any moment, so just wanted to enjoy life while they could. We talk a lot about different types of inequality but generational inequality is real for sure.

So, do you think they should have turned down the benefits society offered at the time, like help going to uni?

Does that mean you think people nowadays should turn down the universal credit or free childcare hours, whether they need it or not, so the money can be saved to help future generations??

CupEmpty · 16/02/2023 17:10

@chopc ive had a good education in that I went to a state grammar school, not private. Then went to uni but I took out a loan like everyone else. My parents did pay for my textbooks and things, but not for the actual university fees. Altho I am lucky that they were only £3k/ year when I went.

AnotherForumUser · 16/02/2023 17:04

Mummyongin · 16/02/2023 16:47

I’m sorry it has come across like this. I have offered for my mum to live with us in the past but she prefers to be independent and I have no problem with that. I have organised and paid for nice parties and gifts for grandparents, and don’t get or expect the same in return. I have recently paid extra childcare costs so I could provide care to one grandparent for health reasons.

I'm sorry I seemed so abrupt. I'm touchy on this subject as a relative seriously suggested to me that I didn't contact my dad's GP for help when he started showing signs of rapidly onsetting dementia. All simply because that relative didn't see my dad's money should be used for his care. (I ignored that suggestion and my dad was found a fabulous care home which was worth every penny. I also ignore that relative.)

Intergenerational living does seem to be the best solution. While I couldn't have children I know I want to help my nephews and nieces but also need to ensure I can support myself when the time comes. If they want a home with their crazy old aunt I'd be delighted...

Swipe left for the next trending thread