Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like an idiot (friend borrowing money)

118 replies

Sparklfairy · 16/02/2023 09:43

There's a bit of backstory to this first but I'll try and keep it short.

I have a close friend who is terrible with money. He was/is addicted to weed and that came first. A few years ago I lent him a fair amount - to me - of money, but it was small amounts over time that built up and he kept promising to pay back the following week, then went silent come payday. Then he'd come back with an excuse as to why he was short again and ask for another £20/£30 and he'd promise to pay the lot back next payday. You can see where this is going, and he didn't.

At the time I was in a bad place with my MH, needed the friend, and hadn't realised just how much I had lent him.

Anyway we had a huge row and didn't speak for about a year, when he randomly got in touch, apologised and did in fact pay it all back and we became friends again about 18 months ago.

He hasn't asked for money again, until now. He's given up weed in the last few weeks, but mentioned he was tight for money because he bought his usual amount, smoked it all and then quit before payday.

The other day he texted and asked if I could spot him £20 until Wednesday - yesterday. It put me in an awkward position knowing what he did before, and my finances are tighter these days. But I messaged back saying I could, but I definitely needed it back Wednesday because of XYZ. He said absolutely, and promised it wouldn't be like before.

You guessed it, he hasn't paid.

I'm so annoyed with myself. I know it's only been a day and maybe he'll get in touch today and pay it, and although I won't starve losing £20 it's the broken promise that's upset me. I don't want to chase him, purely so I can see exactly what he thinks of our friendship. I'm half expecting responses here of 'just ask for it back' but honestly I think I need to see how this plays out and not prompt him. AIBU?

OP posts:
MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 22/02/2023 15:01

If he messages again just simply say "send the money over you have my details." Then once it's done, block the cheeky fucker. I can't believe your still waitingb

mumda · 22/02/2023 15:00

Make sure it costs you only £20 to know they're a CF.

ShakespearesBlister · 22/02/2023 14:55

I'd say you've made your point crystal clear to him. He can't not know how deeply upset you are about his behaviour. This must be the point of no return for you though. Don't go feeling bad or guilty if he comes back with sob stories. He knows full well he didn't pay you back. If you do want to stay friends on some level, money can be er ever be a part of that again now.

Thelnebriati · 22/02/2023 14:52

Reading the texts he sounds manipulative, and he uses guilt trips to make you feel like he has an urgent problem and only you can fix it. It would be worth learning to spot that technique in the early stages so you can put a stop to it before it goes any further.

TangledWebOfDeception · 22/02/2023 14:49

(Not just men, of course! If any 'friend' repeatedly uses you, disrespects you, cancels on you and makes promises they don't keep, at some point you have GOT to resolve not to take that shit anymore, stand up for yourself and tell them where to go!)

TangledWebOfDeception · 22/02/2023 14:44

He's taking the piss. You're going out of your way to help him with whatever this thing is, even eating into your weekends, and he's pissing on it. Seriously, stop putting up with that!! He's NOT a friend, he's a user! Stop calling it a friendship. He doesn't care about you one bit, and you're repeatedly letting him treat you like that??

When a man shows you who he is, BELIEVE HIM.

Sparklfairy · 22/02/2023 14:36

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/02/2023 12:56

He also rang me a couple of times in a frenzy

Probably withdrawal symptoms if he can't get the money out of anyone else.
And what's this about the weekend "cage show"? Please tell me he's not into cage fighting as well? Hmm

Anyway your choice; you can either shut this down completely so he'll bother someone else or allow him to weasel back into your thoughts and life ... I know which one I'd pick

He helps out at events for a relative but no, doesn't do it himself!

The thing he needs isn't dodgy. In fact it would be excellent for his prospects if I helped/continued helping him. I've taken weekday mornings off and worked weekends instead to help him out. Sometimes he'd be really late for a stupid reason and once he did a total no show. Then he promises to take me out to dinner or cook for me at his place "to sat thank you" and keeps cancelling.

I actually don't mind helping him out as I love what I do and it really would help him. But this money thing has shone a light on the fact he has no respect for me, my time, or our friendship. Take take take.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 22/02/2023 13:40

TightFistedWozerk · 22/02/2023 13:37

I am so sorry, he is being so horrible.

Ok so he has not paid you, there is your answer. Cut him loose now, block and delete. He IS costing you time, and headspace; the money now is not irrelevant, because he took it from you with no intention of paying back, but cutting into your time and your work time at that is unforgivable. He can get lost.

I hope you're okay, this sort of event can be really upsetting.

100% this.

Time to set him free. He is no longer of your concern. Be completely nonchalant with him. He is nothing to you now.
Ignore.
Ignore.
Ignore.
Oh, and block his number.

The fact that he isn't going to be getting a rise out of you anymore, that will probably drive him absolutely crazy.

Best to ignore the man.

Don't give in to his "Here, I'm over here, please look at me, please give me attention and money" attitude.

TightFistedWozerk · 22/02/2023 13:37

I am so sorry, he is being so horrible.

Ok so he has not paid you, there is your answer. Cut him loose now, block and delete. He IS costing you time, and headspace; the money now is not irrelevant, because he took it from you with no intention of paying back, but cutting into your time and your work time at that is unforgivable. He can get lost.

I hope you're okay, this sort of event can be really upsetting.

newfence · 22/02/2023 13:34

Good for you - glad you got to your 'I don't even care now' point. It's liberating, isn't it!

Sparklfairy · 22/02/2023 13:20

TightFistedWozerk · 22/02/2023 13:11

I note you have told him he is costing you your time as well as money, well done.

So, has he paid you yet?

No, he hasn't. I have checked.

His excuse would be 'i wanted to be sure I was sending it to the right details' but they're written right there in the whatsapp convo, sent the other bloody day. he knows damn fine they're right.

Honestly sometimes I wonder whether it's a control thing? Like someone saying, 'say please' just to be petty. Sick of it tbh. I'm ignoring him completely.

OP posts:
TightFistedWozerk · 22/02/2023 13:11

I note you have told him he is costing you your time as well as money, well done.

So, has he paid you yet?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/02/2023 12:59

He wants some help with something, that's outing to say but he really needs it and only I can help him with it

Only just noticed this too, and unless it's some concerns something deeply personal which you've unwisely got involved in with him, how can you possibly be the only one who can help him?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/02/2023 12:56

He also rang me a couple of times in a frenzy

Probably withdrawal symptoms if he can't get the money out of anyone else.
And what's this about the weekend "cage show"? Please tell me he's not into cage fighting as well? Hmm

Anyway your choice; you can either shut this down completely so he'll bother someone else or allow him to weasel back into your thoughts and life ... I know which one I'd pick

LookItsMeAgain · 22/02/2023 12:44

In response to this (and only because sometimes it really is nice to have the last word on a situation) would be to send this message to him.

"Look, I loaned you money and you have failed to pay it back. You have subsequently asked for me to do you a favour, having still to pay back the money I loaned you. You are also flooding my WhatsApp with your inane messages about whatever. You want to know how to 'fix this'? Well you don't leave your debts unpaid for starters, with fake indignation that you thought you had paid it back and blaming an illness on why you haven't transferred the money by making you forgetful. You treat your friends who do things for you and loan you money with more respect than you have, than you are.
I have had enough.
You have my bank details (they were sent to you on X date)** so I expect the money to be transferred immediately. There are no more excuses for delays. I have had enough of your hassling me so I am taking a break and I do not want to hear from you for the time being. "

Then block his number on everything - Messenger, Facebook, WhatsApp, on your phone itself and any other apps you use to communicate. Drop the rope and stop letting him in to your life. If you see him when you're out and about, that's fine and you can leave or stay, but you can limit your interaction with him at this point and I think you need to.

Sparklfairy · 22/02/2023 12:05

Well, as predicted, he got in touch today. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts. He also rang me a couple of times in a frenzy.

To feel like an idiot (friend borrowing money)
To feel like an idiot (friend borrowing money)
OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 21/02/2023 12:17

LookItsMeAgain · 21/02/2023 11:40

@Sparklfairy - I think this part of one of your posts is quite telling:
"I assume I'll get a message sometime this week chasing it, and I'm not sure how to respond, if at all. Posters think I'm wet but I have no problem being direct and saying so if I have a problem. The issue is I know how he will react, and it'll be excuses/playing the wounded party (I was ill and forgot)/maybe even blaming me (You should have reminded me and I'd have just paid it) etc. I really can't be arsed with the deflection."

Consider that you telling him about his outstanding debt is you reminding him. You could also remind him that it's not actually your job to keep having to chase him for outstanding debts or to remind him to repay his debts. As he is in debt to someone else, it is his job to repay any outstanding loan before asking for anything else, or else he ends up getting further into debt. He's asking for your help on something that only you can help him with...well, he settles up first and then you'll consider offering that help at that stage.

You could use this as an opportunity and not see it as something negative. An opportunity to let him know that asking you for money is no longer an option and to save both of you some embarrassment, you're letting him know not to ask in future.

So he has a way that he reacts. He does that so that you won't press him for the return of your money or you won't object to giving freely of your time. It's about time you put a value on your time and that you stopped writing off money you have loaned him. Why is he more entitled to your money than you are?

This!

You are not a fool, I think you are a kind generous person and he has taken advantage.
He did eventually pay you back for the larger sum, but it wasn't just the money, it was the stress of thinking it would never be repaid.

Now its started up again, not just in terms of lending money, but in terms of taking up your self-employed earning time to do a free task for him. I bet you are not the ONLY person who can help. Citizen's advice.

Given that you agreed to forfeit your earning time to help him. He abuses that by ignoring the appointment and deciding that he will grant you an audience at a time that is convenient to him.

Are you worried if yu say no to him, that he will withdraw the friendship?
"Dear Freeloader. I cannot afford to lend you money ATM and I don't being put in the position of chasing you for repayment, when you don't repay me as promised - whether its £20 - or £200. If I offer to help then you need to turn up at a time that is convenient to me or I can't help you."
Try it and see what his response is.... then you will have your answer. He will either repay and apologise for not turning up or he will withdraw the friendship.

After all the stress its caused you, I think its worth taking that risk.

MeridianB · 21/02/2023 12:08

He's a drug addict, so no surprises on the money front.

If you can make new friends and invest your time and energy with them, I doubt you'll regret it.

CleaningOutMyCloset · 21/02/2023 11:55

When he chases you, be honest

Sorry x, but I won't be assisting you going forward with x, y and z. I feel taken advantage of by you, with both my time and my money. It's not something I'm willing to put up with any longer.

Spark

If he comes back with things like 'you should have chased me, I need your help, I'll lose business etc. just ignore him. Or if you feel the need to reply simply say 'it's not my responsibility to chase you, help you etc etc' then don't respond again

Bookegg · 21/02/2023 11:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request

LookItsMeAgain · 21/02/2023 11:40

@Sparklfairy - I think this part of one of your posts is quite telling:
"I assume I'll get a message sometime this week chasing it, and I'm not sure how to respond, if at all. Posters think I'm wet but I have no problem being direct and saying so if I have a problem. The issue is I know how he will react, and it'll be excuses/playing the wounded party (I was ill and forgot)/maybe even blaming me (You should have reminded me and I'd have just paid it) etc. I really can't be arsed with the deflection."

Consider that you telling him about his outstanding debt is you reminding him. You could also remind him that it's not actually your job to keep having to chase him for outstanding debts or to remind him to repay his debts. As he is in debt to someone else, it is his job to repay any outstanding loan before asking for anything else, or else he ends up getting further into debt. He's asking for your help on something that only you can help him with...well, he settles up first and then you'll consider offering that help at that stage.

You could use this as an opportunity and not see it as something negative. An opportunity to let him know that asking you for money is no longer an option and to save both of you some embarrassment, you're letting him know not to ask in future.

So he has a way that he reacts. He does that so that you won't press him for the return of your money or you won't object to giving freely of your time. It's about time you put a value on your time and that you stopped writing off money you have loaned him. Why is he more entitled to your money than you are?

StaunchMomma · 21/02/2023 11:29

I've voted YABU but only because you were silly to give it to him in the first place!

Learn to say no, OP.

Cococomellonn · 21/02/2023 11:26

Posters think I'm wet but I have no problem being direct and saying so if I have a problem. The issue is I know how he will react, and it'll be excuses/playing the wounded party (I was ill and forgot)/maybe even blaming me (You should have reminded me and I'd have just paid it) etc. I really can't be arsed with the deflection.

I'm not sure I get this because isn't the point of being direct that you the to deal with the response? So you do have a problem being with direct because you don't want to deal with the response...

I can understand why you feel that way OP but just don't get that way of thinking.

twoshedsjackson · 21/02/2023 11:18

When he realises that he has irked you, and as you say needs you to give him help which only you can give, it may well be that he (temporarily) reshuffles his priorities and "miraculously" scrapes together the £20.
This places you in a slightly stronger position than most people in your position (been there, done that, learned to be more cautious) but if you recoup this money, don't let him kid you again.

Brefugee · 21/02/2023 11:14

Come up with an excuse and stick to it. He's an adult and borrowing and returning money isn't normal. It's a bad way of dealing with money. He needs to learn to budget.

don't come up with an excuse. Say "no because you don't pay it back on time"

Swipe left for the next trending thread