Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I have been informed?

340 replies

HereForTeaAndCake · 16/02/2023 01:23

DS10 was invited to a friend's house for the day but it turns out the children spent most of their time wandering the street unsupervised, calling on friends etc. I was not consulted and DS has no phone and has only recently been ready for playdates without me. I only learned of how little time he spent at said friend's house when he was picked up. AIBU to think that I should have been given the choice?

OP posts:
IndiaDreamer · 16/02/2023 15:11

HereForTeaAndCake · 16/02/2023 15:09

For people saying I've been mollycoddling and not letting him go around to people's houses on his own - it was as our circumstances dictated and as I said following my child's lead. He still did lots of independent activities with friends and without me.

Did he enjoy the visit?

HereForTeaAndCake · 16/02/2023 15:09

For people saying I've been mollycoddling and not letting him go around to people's houses on his own - it was as our circumstances dictated and as I said following my child's lead. He still did lots of independent activities with friends and without me.

OP posts:
HereForTeaAndCake · 16/02/2023 15:03

Dominoeffecter · 16/02/2023 11:03

My DS is 10 and I took his and his friend to the park the other day, if I had decided to let them go alone I would have asked the other parent first as you shouldn’t make decisions for other parents. You should have been asked.

I would have done exactly this.

OP posts:
zingally · 16/02/2023 13:44

With all due respect, he'll be starting secondary school either this year or next.

I can see why it might be a shock to you to discover that he's gone from supervised "mummy comes too" playdates to "out on the street knocking for mates" in a very short space of time. But I think you need to be encouraging more independence.

Dominoeffecter · 16/02/2023 13:10

Imagine if something happened to them and you hadn’t even told the other parent they were out, it’s basic stuff to let them know where their kid is.

BethDuttonsTwin · 16/02/2023 13:03

My kids are older now but I have brought up two, and at age ten, I don’t know anyone who wouldn’t check with the other parent first before allowing this. They’d go for play dates without their own parents etc, but the play dates took place within the home and garden. There’s no way I or anyone I know would have let them out to wander around at that age. Whether YABU or YANBU is impossible to say though as children playing out and the age at which they do so, obviously varies so hugely across place and I suppose social group.

I don’t really agree with the “it teaches them independence/resilience” crew though. It might work that way for a few but I mostly remember vicious bullying from older children to the point of peering round corners to make sure we didn’t bump into them unprepared, and/or exposure to situations that I simply wasn’t equipped to cope with at that age. We got ourselves into situations where we were lucky to make it out uninjured even alive.

whynotwhatknot · 16/02/2023 12:46

i wasnt allowed to wander 15 minutes away when i was 10 this was in the 80s

if i was invitged over to someones house my parents expected them to be there and supervisiing

Dominoeffecter · 16/02/2023 12:41

Drfosters · 16/02/2023 11:13

Out of curiosity to the parents who say you should have asked- did your parents call the other parents when you were younger? My mum had almost zero contact with any other parents when I was younger. I don’t recall my mum being worried about this and she was a massive worrier. I just had to be back by the set time or I’d be in trouble. (This was early-mid 90s). I remember a group of us used to ride our bikes around the local roads with one friend who always had her 2 year old brother strapped on the back of her bike. I think we just grew up faster in those days as no ability to contact home. At 12 I was training in with a close friend into Oxford street on our own to go shopping. We had to use phone boxes to call home at lunchtime to say we’re ok.

I don’t think parenting trends should be followed simply because that’s what used to happen, plenty of stuff used to happen doesn’t make it favourable. Incidentally although I’d expect to be asked if my 10 year old was allowed out (I like to have a rough idea of where my kids are 🤭) I wouldn’t necessarily say no, I’d be ok with the scenario in the OP apart from the not checking bit.

Drivingmisspotty · 16/02/2023 12:38

pizzaHeart · 16/02/2023 12:14

I amazed by all these memories about how we played on the streets and survived. As it was mentioned on the other thread some time ago : those of us who didn’t survive can’t contribute to the discussion.

Very good point.

I am also a bit bemused about these halcyon days of freedom - I am in my forties and grew up in suburbs of a city. I was allowed to play in front of my house/a friend’s house from about 9/10, walk to school/ brownies in year 6 and go to city centre and to school on bus from year 7. But definitely no running around woods/water/building sites all day long!

But I have not become some anxious, stunted mess of an adult. Late teens/early 20s I got on a plane for first time with friends for a holiday/ trains to university and to visit mates at different towns/Eurostar to Paris on my own/night buses after work on other side of town/interailing all over Europe.

Zanatdy · 16/02/2023 12:38

I personally wouldn’t have checked with the parent but perhaps it’s normal for her own child and didn’t think

Dominoeffecter · 16/02/2023 12:35

watchingpullimgepisode6 · 16/02/2023 12:18

My DD has friends over and she goes to theirs they often go out locally. I don't expect to be told nor do I tell other parents if they've gone out from here

Are they 10?

Dominoeffecter · 16/02/2023 12:34

Dishwashersaurous · 16/02/2023 09:09

I just dont understand how this situation arose.

Other parent: so off you go boys, see you later.

Child: ermmm, I'm not allowed out without an adult.

Other parent: either, OK so stay at home OR I'll just give your mum a call and check it's OK.

Yeah because that’s how ALL kids operate 🙄

Wheelz46 · 16/02/2023 12:22

YANBU OP

If my child had been invited to a friends house for a party at 10 years old, my expectation would be it's in the house and not roaming the streets. Not necessarily supervised but certainly adults present in the house.

The parents of the party child should have absolutely made it clear what the so called party involved and then it's up to those parents to decide if their child can go. I would never invite my children's friends round and let them roam the streets. Go forbid something happened and you are held accountable.

CliffsofMohair · 16/02/2023 12:19

donttellmehesalive · 16/02/2023 12:13

"When kids come over to ours they can play in the nearby streets and the garden - they are not supervised as such but know where to find a safe adult."

I wonder whether ds's friend also knew where to find safe adults. He might have stuck to areas where he knows he can find family friends if he needs them. It might not have been quite as free range as you fear.

other Mum may have had a phone/tracker set up and would be able to see where kids had gone.

kids may have been out for a short while or no time at all. They may have been close to the house or far away.

As the Queen said, recollections may vary.

watchingpullimgepisode6 · 16/02/2023 12:18

My DD has friends over and she goes to theirs they often go out locally. I don't expect to be told nor do I tell other parents if they've gone out from here

pizzaHeart · 16/02/2023 12:14

I amazed by all these memories about how we played on the streets and survived. As it was mentioned on the other thread some time ago : those of us who didn’t survive can’t contribute to the discussion.

JoeMaplin · 16/02/2023 12:13

It doesn’t seem unreasonable for 10 year olds but I would have probably let the parents know they’d be say going to the park alone, assuming I’d issued the invite rather than the kids arranging it. I would say for eg, would the boys like to come over for the day. I’ll be working at home, they can go to the park down the road for footie and I’ll provide lunch. Or similar. For my DS’s friend who I am aware has adhd, I would check with his parents if he is ok to go to X alone.

donttellmehesalive · 16/02/2023 12:13

"When kids come over to ours they can play in the nearby streets and the garden - they are not supervised as such but know where to find a safe adult."

I wonder whether ds's friend also knew where to find safe adults. He might have stuck to areas where he knows he can find family friends if he needs them. It might not have been quite as free range as you fear.

Hankunamatata · 16/02/2023 12:12

So they went out to play. Knocked on some other friends to see if they were coming out. Totally normal

pizzaHeart · 16/02/2023 12:09

I agree with OP . Inviting to ours would mean for me that they would stay inside the house or out in the garden. Otherwise I would expect : Would Jack like to go the park/ playground/ cinema/ for pizza with Andrew after school?
At 14 they would have this conversation themselves but at 10 I would expect the clarification from an adult.
It might be the case of Andrew asking Jack, then I wouldn’t expect adult to supervise or even to know so I would always check with them first.

LakieLady · 16/02/2023 11:54

Babdoc · 16/02/2023 09:17

Gosh, how times change! When I was a child I walked to school alone at 5, crossing two roads to get there, played out in the street with friends from that age, and down the local woods or park from about 8. In an outer London suburb.

My own DDs walked to school alone from
about 6, and played in the fields behind our house from about 7. Admittedly in a quiet Perthshire village. They had to get the bus alone, 15 miles to the nearest secondary school from the age of 11, too.

I understand that mothers are anxious, but you do your DC no favours by wrapping them in cotton wool for too long. They need to learn to make their own decisions, risk assess their surroundings, and learn independence and resilience.

I struggle to get my head round it, too, @Babdoc and I grew up in an outer London borough, nowhere rural. When I was still in primary school, we played in the street, in a park, I walked on my own for 20 minutes, including crossing 2 main roads (and the park), to my friend's house.

Sometimes, with another friend, we used to get a bus to the very edge of the borough to play on common land and in woods or to a large park where we'd paddle in a stream on warm days. Some of the things we used to do were worrying, in hindsight, like playing on building sites and in derelict houses.

And kids still do play out, unsupervised, where I live. There 2 families with young kids in my road, all still in primary. They skateboard and roller skate up and down the road, and are allowed to go and play in the nearest field, which is accessed from the next road. I think all this builds resilience and independence

My niece, now 21, was never allowed these freedoms. She was driven everywhere as a child. Now, she's scared to get a train on her own and if her parents go out for the evening and her boyfriend isn't there, she rings them at least a couple of times to ask something daft. Her mum is positive that she does it because she's anxious alone.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 16/02/2023 11:43

HereForTeaAndCake · 16/02/2023 10:44

I'd bet my bottom dollar you would gaslight your child into believing they are fine if they show signs of anxiety.
DC's psychotherapist wouldn't agree with your statement - unless you think your better qualified to suggest that.

Anxieties don’t come from nowhere. I’m always amazed how blind parents are to how their own anxieties run off on their child. A psychotherapist will not ever say “well it’s you” to a paying parent

HereForTeaAndCake · 16/02/2023 11:26

PhillySub · 16/02/2023 11:06

If mine was invited "to come over to ours" I would expect them to be out and about and not to be kept inside. Maybe the onus was on you to ask the question?

I will be in future.

When kids come over to ours they can play in the nearby streets and the garden - they are not supervised as such but know where to find a safe adult.

OP posts:
Badbudgeter · 16/02/2023 11:23

My eldest at ten wasn’t ready for that kind of experience. His younger brother is ten and it’s normal for him to go to a friends then they go to the park alone or for a bike ride and meet other friends and go hang out. I’ve started giving him a phone so I can track him down if needed.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/02/2023 11:21

Also you mention neurodiversity.

I would expect that if a child I'd invited over was neurodiverse and that would affect how they would respond to typical situations for the parent, or the child if older, to mention it.