Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think your reading level might be?

242 replies

2023a · 16/02/2023 00:17

I think lots of us have had the odd frustrating conversation on here, where the other person just hasn’t seemed to be able to grasp what we’re saying. Apparently, it’s very possible that the posters in question genuinely don’t understand.

A 2011 government survey of adult literacy skills found that 14.9% (or 1 in 7) of adults in England have literacy levels at or below Entry Level 3, which is equivalent to the literacy skills expected of a nine to 11-year-old.

More recently, in 2015, the OECD conducted its Survey of Adult Skills, known as PIAAC (Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies). This survey found that 16.4% (or 1 in 6) of adults in England, and 17.4% (or 1 in 5) adults in Northern Ireland, have literacy levels at or below Level 1, which is considered to be 'very poor literacy skills'.

More info here, if you’re interested: literacytrust.org.uk/parents-and-families/adult-literacy/what-do-adult-literacy-levels-mean/

OP posts:
ItsaStupidSillyThing · 16/02/2023 14:03

'. I would say I'm probably the only person I've ever met who loves writing essays!'

@Jaslima you've just met one. I loved all of the written work, it ignited my passion for words. I adored writing my dissertation for my English Literature degree, probably alittle too much (had to heavily edit it to stick to the word limit)!

Natsku · 16/02/2023 14:03

EBearhug · 16/02/2023 10:33

Mine is high. I grew up in a household with no TV, so I read a lot as a child. I've also studied other languages and I know about the subjunctive, although remarkably few people appear to be interested in discussing the subtleties of its use... I was always top in reading tests at school. I've written a lot for work, and as much of the audience doesn't have Englias their first language, I try to use clear wording - although many of my European colleagues have better English than my British ones.

I never knew about the subjunctive, and many other grammatical concepts, until I started formally learning another language. Funny how learning another language improved my grasp of English.

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 13:50

Barbie222 · 16/02/2023 13:46

I don't know about adults, but I've worked extensively with young children and the ability to reason from A to B, or extrapolate that if C is true, D must follow, is in my experience a bigger predictor of future success than the ability to decode / read. Some children never get there and continue to struggle with most of the curriculum.

I have a hunch it's related to how many separate parts of information your brain's able to retain and manipulate at once - there's often a day when with children the ability to hold three things in their head just clicks, and it gets better from there. Really interested to read up on some of the links.

the ability to reason from A to B, or extrapolate that if C is true, D must follow

That is literacy and reading comprehension, though. It’s the foundation for this:

Level 4: Adults can integrate, interpret or synthesise information from complex or lengthy texts. Adults can identify and understand one or more specific, non-central idea(s) in the text in order to interpret or evaluate subtle evidence-claim or persuasive discourse relationships.

Level 5: Adults can search for, and integrate, information across multiple, dense texts; construct syntheses of similar and contrasting ideas or points of view; or evaluate evidence based arguments. Adults understand subtle, rhetorical cues and can make high-level inferences or use specialised background knowledge.

Spendonsend · 16/02/2023 13:50

I used to hear readers at my sons school and was responsible for moving them up bookbands. (I did have training). It amazed me how some of the very confident sounding decoders didn't really understand the text. Then others would stumble through it and appear to struggle but had great comprehension.

Barbie222 · 16/02/2023 13:46

I don't know about adults, but I've worked extensively with young children and the ability to reason from A to B, or extrapolate that if C is true, D must follow, is in my experience a bigger predictor of future success than the ability to decode / read. Some children never get there and continue to struggle with most of the curriculum.

I have a hunch it's related to how many separate parts of information your brain's able to retain and manipulate at once - there's often a day when with children the ability to hold three things in their head just clicks, and it gets better from there. Really interested to read up on some of the links.

DaveyJonesLocker · 16/02/2023 13:44

I'm in the bottom 2% for speed and bottom 12% I think for ability / accuracy. I'm dyslexic. I actually did well though school because I'm "academically gifted", I have a degree. I read for pleasure. I just skip alot to get though it quicker. Not being able to actually read some words doesn't really matter in your head, I just garble over them.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 16/02/2023 13:39

MagicCat83 · 16/02/2023 01:21

If you can find studies and stats - and generally some reading on these ideas - please do post them. I have since tried to look this up again (after stumbling across it by accident years ago) but can't find the right search terms.

I'd be interested in descriptions of these kind of concepts and statistics of the % of the population who can understand them.

There's some interesting stuff on language and thought here:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_and_thought#%3A%7E%3Atext%3DLanguage_neither_creates_nor_distorts%2Cexpress_all_that_they_think.?wprov=sfla1

Jaslima · 16/02/2023 13:35

My literacy level is pretty good. I did English literature for A-level and got a First in my degree (not English Literature). I went to a school where we were pushed. We weren't really allowed to speak in colloquial English and good use of grammar was drummed into us.

My parents are both very articulate, with good vocabularies and I grew up in a language-rich home. My mother gave me 'word of the week', where she taught me a new word and we used it in conversation a lot that week. My parents didn't dumb down their communication with me, and made sure to speak clearly and expressively.

However, none of us were very avid readers, strangely, instead preferring to write. I mean, I can read as fluently as the next person, unless the theme is something very technical. However, I much, much prefer to write. I'm currently learning a new language and my spoken skills are much superior to my comprehension in the language. I don't know if the two are connected, but I was a lacklustre reader in school who always excellent at written assignments.

My children are both very expressive and articulate, and yet neither love reading either (but can read just fine for their respective ages). The thing that really propelled my literacy skills was reading the academic papers/research as part of my degree/postgraduate. The language definitely informed my own writing. I would say I'm probably the only person I've ever met who loves writing essays!

lobeliasb · 16/02/2023 13:30

This really does explain so much. I've left threads feeling infuriated by how off topic it becomes as the comments come in. One commenter will misunderstand something in the OP, and the proceeding posters will start incorporating that misunderstanding into their reply until most of the the replies are barely relevant to the OP's situation or question. Then the OP comes back to try to clarify things, and is accused of lying or drip feeding. The thread ends up snowballing out of control. It's nuts.

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 13:29

EffortlessDesmond · 16/02/2023 12:34

It's very telling that so many of the posters who have "found" this thread are clearly super-literate in one or more languages, and that many self-taught to read. We would be interesting as a self-selected group to study more closely.

Like others, I worked in communications (advertising, marcomm and B2B/financial) used Flesch scoring, and then did a PGCE. The lack of literacy was a real bar to accessing secondary education. But the example of the Aldous Huxley interview encapsulates how the mass media have dumbed down over the years.

As the thread title was so clear, I suspect posters who aren’t extremely confident about their literacy have largely steered clear.

However, I do think one or two posters have still missed the point a bit.

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 13:25

Sunriseinwonderland · 16/02/2023 12:41

It depends on what I'm reading.
I semi read posts sometimes and miss things because I'm in a hurry, bored or don't feel its fantastically important. Same with replies, I don't do a lot if any research for my replies on forums.
I have an MSc and a very busy medical job and when I'm home I like to read books and will read all evening, I'm just reading a Hilary Mantel, I like a book that makes you think. I think I have a high level of literacy.

This is interesting to me. I’ve often seen people say ‘I skimmed that and missed X’. I don’t think I’d know how to do that. If I’ve read something, I’ve read it.

And, much as I adore Hilary Mantel, I’m not sure I’d call those ‘books that make you think’.

thing47 · 16/02/2023 13:15

MagicCat83 · 16/02/2023 12:40

These days, I don't think the mainstream media is much more than thinly disguised adverts, click bait and propaganda telling us what to think and do.

At least you can find good long form interviews and information if you find the right podcasts or substacks.

MSM always has a bias, you just need to know what that bias is (though it's often fairly obvious). However, it's only fair to point out that the bias frequently isn't the writer's, it's the medium's – the angle the paper wants to promote is done in the editing process and via headlines, introductions, pull-quotes, and the rest of the page furniture. On newspapers, these are rarely written by the original writer. I think a healthy dose of scepticism is the best approach! Apologies for the slight digression.

Our house is packed with books, including the classics (DH has an English degree) and an awful lot of not-so-classics… And non-fiction too. DH and I both read all the time, but only 2 of my 3 have become big readers. Not sure what that tells us in the nature v nurture debate.

Sunriseinwonderland · 16/02/2023 12:41

It depends on what I'm reading.
I semi read posts sometimes and miss things because I'm in a hurry, bored or don't feel its fantastically important. Same with replies, I don't do a lot if any research for my replies on forums.
I have an MSc and a very busy medical job and when I'm home I like to read books and will read all evening, I'm just reading a Hilary Mantel, I like a book that makes you think. I think I have a high level of literacy.

MagicCat83 · 16/02/2023 12:40

These days, I don't think the mainstream media is much more than thinly disguised adverts, click bait and propaganda telling us what to think and do.

At least you can find good long form interviews and information if you find the right podcasts or substacks.

RampantIvy · 16/02/2023 12:40

dizzydizzydizzy · 16/02/2023 00:55

I'm a copywriter so I hope my literacy level is high.

I have been a copywriter in a previous life and am still involved in website content, so I would like to think that mine is also high.

I admit to getting frustrated when posters have clearly not understood what the OP is trying to say, even when it is all written in the first post.

EffortlessDesmond · 16/02/2023 12:36

Also, after glancing at the National Literacy website, I noticed that nowhere is there an option to train as a volunteer.

EffortlessDesmond · 16/02/2023 12:34

It's very telling that so many of the posters who have "found" this thread are clearly super-literate in one or more languages, and that many self-taught to read. We would be interesting as a self-selected group to study more closely.

Like others, I worked in communications (advertising, marcomm and B2B/financial) used Flesch scoring, and then did a PGCE. The lack of literacy was a real bar to accessing secondary education. But the example of the Aldous Huxley interview encapsulates how the mass media have dumbed down over the years.

EatYourVegetables · 16/02/2023 12:30

@MagicCat83 Have you talked to any bots recently?? They make more sense than people, and have better grammar and spelling skills too!!

viques · 16/02/2023 12:27

user1471453601 · 16/02/2023 01:10

@Calistan do you mean the type of things I used to do at she 10 when I took my 11+? Because if so, you've awakened a very painful (😁) memory.

The question was " foot is to human, as ....... Is to horse".

I said the answer was hand. Because you measure a human in feet, and horses in hands. Wrong answer, right answer was hoof.

But, but (the 11 year old in me shouts) I'm still right!! I am. Sigh. It still rankles 62 years later.

These things stick with you don’t they? I still remember one of my 11 plus questions, I think it must have involved some sort of anagram relating to popular sayings, I can’t quite remember the question, but I later learned the answer was ointment.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 16/02/2023 12:22

Calistan · 16/02/2023 01:47

@MagicCat83 Yes. I took a few at job interviews too.

Brave new world is great BTW, there are debates on yt about which is more prescient, bnw or 1984, pretty interesting

We read 1984 for O Level English, and we read BNW as a comparison. I remember we had a class debate about which scenario we'd prefer to live in, and we all said BNW. Our English teacher was appalled and gave us loads of reasons why we'd be better off in a 1984 world.

MorrisZapp · 16/02/2023 12:15

Mine is genius level thanks to my dear mum who had me on Fay Weldon by primary six, but I have a colleague who can just barely function.

He does most tasks verbally, including speaking into Microsoft word which tidies it up a bit, then if it's important he asks me to glance over it.

He works in sales and is quite good at it but I do cringe at how he pronounces some words. Such a shame his own parents were unable to give him a better start.

Ylvamoon · 16/02/2023 12:09

I am bi lingual and read in 3 languages- 2 fluent 3rd only short articles.

So I think I should be in the top % in English literacy. I can read/ understand both fiction and academic texts ( in history and Law). I started to learn English was acquired in my mid teens

But then, once in a while I come across something where I draw a complete blank!

BrieAndChilli · 16/02/2023 12:01

I think you generally surrond yourself with people who are on the same 'level' as you so it can often be shocking when you realise that not everyone else has the same knowledge. Often things that are obvious to me and DH and even our kids are really difficult for other people to know or understand.

I was a very early reader (I'm adopted so I dont know the exact details but it wasnt a household that valued education so I think i pretty much taught my self to read at preschool age). I was always a really big reader as a child and DH has also always been a reader too. DS1 was assessed as reading age 14+ when he was 4 and the other 2 also have much higher reading ages than thier 'real age'.

I found the stat that 1 in 10 people do not have a single book in thier house quite sad. We have possibly 1000's of books scattered around - aoart from the bathrooms there are books in every room including several boxes in the attic.

I think it is interesting how different peoples brains work and I'm not sure if it is nature or nuture! For example at work we were asked to fill a form in with some info that went off to somewhere else. I found out my colleague had no idea why the info was asked for or what was done with it whereas I had asked a load of questions to understand the whole process. So evidently some people are just happy with thier piece of the puzzle whereas others like to understand how thier piece fits with surronding oones and the big overall picture!

OMG12 · 16/02/2023 11:46

MagicCat83 · 16/02/2023 01:14

I've meant to re-read it for the past 3 years but I don't dare to.

Same with Brave New World but I now know more about the Huxley family than I'd like to.

I managed to re-read Lord of the Flies in 2020, but even that was spooky when the 7pm ritualistic clapping was in progress!

Brave New World is frightening when you look at it in the context of today’s society.

Almost every important point has come true, or is on the cusp of becoming true.

from 1958 is amazing - wish this sort of tv still existed
ManchesterGirl2 · 16/02/2023 11:34

user1471453601 · 16/02/2023 01:10

@Calistan do you mean the type of things I used to do at she 10 when I took my 11+? Because if so, you've awakened a very painful (😁) memory.

The question was " foot is to human, as ....... Is to horse".

I said the answer was hand. Because you measure a human in feet, and horses in hands. Wrong answer, right answer was hoof.

But, but (the 11 year old in me shouts) I'm still right!! I am. Sigh. It still rankles 62 years later.

I love your answer. Totally logical, by a path that's much more interesting than the official one.