Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think your reading level might be?

242 replies

2023a · 16/02/2023 00:17

I think lots of us have had the odd frustrating conversation on here, where the other person just hasn’t seemed to be able to grasp what we’re saying. Apparently, it’s very possible that the posters in question genuinely don’t understand.

A 2011 government survey of adult literacy skills found that 14.9% (or 1 in 7) of adults in England have literacy levels at or below Entry Level 3, which is equivalent to the literacy skills expected of a nine to 11-year-old.

More recently, in 2015, the OECD conducted its Survey of Adult Skills, known as PIAAC (Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies). This survey found that 16.4% (or 1 in 6) of adults in England, and 17.4% (or 1 in 5) adults in Northern Ireland, have literacy levels at or below Level 1, which is considered to be 'very poor literacy skills'.

More info here, if you’re interested: literacytrust.org.uk/parents-and-families/adult-literacy/what-do-adult-literacy-levels-mean/

OP posts:
BornFreeButinChains · 17/02/2023 08:41

@Hankunamatata.. Yes there are many ways to tackle it aren't there.

My dd has only read three books and she's 10. However she has a decent vocabulary that we are boosting

BornFreeButinChains · 17/02/2023 08:38

@JackiePlace yes I could definitely see the words as she read. I was very young when it happened maybe 4 and was then known as an early reader at school.

HardStareBear · 17/02/2023 06:11

1 in 15 people have Developmental Language Disorder (DLD), a lifelong condition that affects all areas of language learning. Quite often people that read (decode) fluently can't fully understand what they have read due to language difficulties.
radld.org/

Natsku · 17/02/2023 05:14

noodlezoodle · 16/02/2023 21:47

This is me. We weren't taught English grammar at school; I am pretty good at knowing if something is correct or not, but I can't tell you the why.

I'm currently learning Spanish and really struggling with learning the 'rules' of grammar and what they mean. As with English, I'm getting pretty good at telling if something sounds right or wrong, but again I can't tell you why. I think I need to buckle down and really focus on the grammar but most of the time when I try, my brain clangs shut and doesn't want to cooperate Grin

I know how you feel. I recently restarted learning Finnish and the grammar learning (sooo many different cases which change the words, differently depending on the word type and some word types look the same but conjugate differently and you just need to know which is which) is driving me insane. I can tell if something sounds wrong as well but don't know how to make it sound right. I need to get on a level good enough to read and understand textbooks and complicated instruction manuals by August - not going to happen at this rate!

Hankunamatata · 17/02/2023 01:54

I have severely dyslexic children. One however listens to lots of audio books and podcasts and watches lots of documentaries. I am constantly surprised by the depth of his spoken vocabulary.

AlmostaMamma · 17/02/2023 00:51

JackiePlace · 17/02/2023 00:44

@MRex can you please send me or post the link that describes the levels of reading (as in level 5 as mentioned in your post)? x x

The link is in the OP.

JackiePlace · 17/02/2023 00:47

BornFreeButinChains · 16/02/2023 22:22

Hi op.

I've only read the first few pages.
This has become a special interest of mine because I learned to read with no effort. One day as my mother was reading me a book the letters made sense.
Then I could read.

One dc also learned by phonics with seemingly no issues and her reading suddenly took off in year 1.

However the next dc seemed to struggle and the school kept saying wait it's fine and tricky trigraphs and double speak.
Well...thank you covid.

Year 3 on level ort 6 stuttering through simple sentences I thought how much longer to have to wait? She can't read, she's bored and she can't access the curriculum.

I did so much research and asked on here and I found my own stragety which was basically, forget phonics.

Flash cards everyday for first 100 hfw.
Peter and Jane books which gave her a huge sense of achievement and were fast!
Reading chest to get level 6 books she enjoyed.

I'm not joking by ditching phonics and using this we got her up to pages with a few paragraphs reading smoothly in a few months...

The question is, why did she need us to step in.
Why can't our school system cope with a flexible approach to learning to read?

We are hobbling our children by this fanatical obsession with phonics.

One day as my mother was reading me a book the letters made sense.
Then I could read.
@BornFreeButinChains I suspect your mother was reading WITH you rather than reading TO you? i.e., you were sitting in a place where you could see the pages as she was reading them, and she might even have been pointing to the words or following them with her finger as she read?

This is the best way for all parents to start reading with their children.

JackiePlace · 17/02/2023 00:44

MRex · 16/02/2023 18:49

I've spent large parts of my career doing what is effectively level 5; find and synthesise the information while drawing out extra conclusions. Looking for interesting nuggets basically, though usually with a heavy focus on numbers as well as content. I hired on two separate occasions super smart astro-physicists; after training them to do some stuff and letting them do it for a bit, each one came to me a bit baffled. They found it entertaining, but didn't understand why it was a job, "because anyone at the client could just do this". I was able to explain that "no, it doesn't seem to be the case that anyone can do this", but it was hard to explain why apart from "not everyone's brain works like ours". It isn't as simple as intellect, because not every person of high intelligence can do it. I think that level 5 is logic skills merged with linguistic skills, rather than linguistic ability alone.

@MRex can you please send me or post the link that describes the levels of reading (as in level 5 as mentioned in your post)? x x

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/02/2023 22:24

I'm level 5 in both. My working life consists of data gathering, analysis, comparison and presenting the findings in easy to understand graphical forms, along with interpreting Statutory guidance and instructions/laws into working practise and translating it for others so they understand why particular actions have to be taken.

Unfortunately, my attention span is more in keeping with a bored 7 year old, so I do find myself slowly losing the will to live when I'm at the point of saying 'We have to do it this way because I said so, OK?'.

BornFreeButinChains · 16/02/2023 22:22

Hi op.

I've only read the first few pages.
This has become a special interest of mine because I learned to read with no effort. One day as my mother was reading me a book the letters made sense.
Then I could read.

One dc also learned by phonics with seemingly no issues and her reading suddenly took off in year 1.

However the next dc seemed to struggle and the school kept saying wait it's fine and tricky trigraphs and double speak.
Well...thank you covid.

Year 3 on level ort 6 stuttering through simple sentences I thought how much longer to have to wait? She can't read, she's bored and she can't access the curriculum.

I did so much research and asked on here and I found my own stragety which was basically, forget phonics.

Flash cards everyday for first 100 hfw.
Peter and Jane books which gave her a huge sense of achievement and were fast!
Reading chest to get level 6 books she enjoyed.

I'm not joking by ditching phonics and using this we got her up to pages with a few paragraphs reading smoothly in a few months...

The question is, why did she need us to step in.
Why can't our school system cope with a flexible approach to learning to read?

We are hobbling our children by this fanatical obsession with phonics.

noodlezoodle · 16/02/2023 21:47

Natsku · 16/02/2023 14:03

I never knew about the subjunctive, and many other grammatical concepts, until I started formally learning another language. Funny how learning another language improved my grasp of English.

This is me. We weren't taught English grammar at school; I am pretty good at knowing if something is correct or not, but I can't tell you the why.

I'm currently learning Spanish and really struggling with learning the 'rules' of grammar and what they mean. As with English, I'm getting pretty good at telling if something sounds right or wrong, but again I can't tell you why. I think I need to buckle down and really focus on the grammar but most of the time when I try, my brain clangs shut and doesn't want to cooperate Grin

bluebeardswife7 · 16/02/2023 21:40

GramCracker · 16/02/2023 08:05

Such an interesting topic. I am very much guilty of forgetting to account for adult literacy levels. It's so easy to forget the variety of aptitude and mistake miscomprehension* for willful obstinacy.

It's definitely cause for thought, and I wonder how I can do better with this in mind.

just made that word up - hope that's ok with you lexicants*
** just made that up too

Did you spell lexicants right??? 😉

EffortlessDesmond · 16/02/2023 20:30

I sort of know what you mean @DinosaurBaby. I Iearned my living by getting paid for writing, but it has never been about writing on spec. I have only ever written to get paid. I don't do it for fun. I get paid for turning customer's ramblings into intelligent prose. Yes, sometimes I have creative ideas, but I have never been motivated to try and sell them into a market where I don't already have a reputation, even when I think, "that's a good idea". I won't write a word, except for fun here on MN, unless I am getting paid.

DinosaurBaby · 16/02/2023 20:23

I love this thread.

No matter how many times I read about levels of literary, I’m still shocked. Words have always given me such pleasure and it makes me sad to think there are people out there who haven’t had the opportunity to explore that.

My mother taught me to read before school (one of the few things she got right) and I’ve always loved books. I write extensively in my day job, I’m also published (fiction and soon to be non-fiction), and I have a degree (First) and soon to be MFA (Distinction so far) in Creative Writing. Hoping to pursue a PhD after.

EffortlessDesmond · 16/02/2023 20:16

@Jaslima , I'm not being awkward here but asking, do you read for pleasure or for information mainly? I read for fun, I actively prefer to read stuff written down.

MRex · 16/02/2023 18:49

I've spent large parts of my career doing what is effectively level 5; find and synthesise the information while drawing out extra conclusions. Looking for interesting nuggets basically, though usually with a heavy focus on numbers as well as content. I hired on two separate occasions super smart astro-physicists; after training them to do some stuff and letting them do it for a bit, each one came to me a bit baffled. They found it entertaining, but didn't understand why it was a job, "because anyone at the client could just do this". I was able to explain that "no, it doesn't seem to be the case that anyone can do this", but it was hard to explain why apart from "not everyone's brain works like ours". It isn't as simple as intellect, because not every person of high intelligence can do it. I think that level 5 is logic skills merged with linguistic skills, rather than linguistic ability alone.

Lilyhatesjaz · 16/02/2023 18:01

I am not always good at reading books with complicated or old fashioned language, I don't have the patience to persist if they are hard work.
And I wasn't really taught parts of speech in school,or university.
However I am constantly frustrated that people on mumsnet have failed to understand what was said in the original post, you could be right that this is due to reading compression skills, but I also suspect that some people look at a post and think what nasty thing can I say to make the OP feel bad.

2023a · 16/02/2023 17:26

MarshaMelrose · 16/02/2023 16:03

I used to be able to do level 5. After spending the covid years on MN, I don't think I could even do level 4. SM has decimated my concentration levels and just focusing on reading those descriptors tires me out.

You’re definitely not alone in this! I suspect that social media has done a number on most people’s literacy.

The reverse is probably also true, though. People are writing more, more often and across more media than ever before (texts, emails, SM platforms). So I suppose in some ways the current generations are probably more comfortable with (and better at) written communication than any prior. It’s just often somewhat inelegant and/or surface communication as opposed the sort of thing covered by the above descriptions.

So interesting.

OP posts:
Jaslima · 16/02/2023 16:09

Mommawasafarmgirl · 16/02/2023 15:32

"I'm currently learning a new language and my spoken skills are much superior to my comprehension in the language."

I find this fascinating. I'm the opposite and stupidly assumed it was the same for everyone.

I've always loved reading , but have found writing and answering questions about literature much more difficult - so, again, the opposite of your experience. I felt I could instinctively understand the nuances in the books I read, but having to explain just how or why the author had chosen to convey their message really was a chore. I didn't, and don't, like dissecting books.

You are the normal one! Most people learning a new language start off by understanding more than they can speak and reading is normally stronger than writing. I don't know why I'm such a weirdo!

MarshaMelrose · 16/02/2023 16:03

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 13:50

the ability to reason from A to B, or extrapolate that if C is true, D must follow

That is literacy and reading comprehension, though. It’s the foundation for this:

Level 4: Adults can integrate, interpret or synthesise information from complex or lengthy texts. Adults can identify and understand one or more specific, non-central idea(s) in the text in order to interpret or evaluate subtle evidence-claim or persuasive discourse relationships.

Level 5: Adults can search for, and integrate, information across multiple, dense texts; construct syntheses of similar and contrasting ideas or points of view; or evaluate evidence based arguments. Adults understand subtle, rhetorical cues and can make high-level inferences or use specialised background knowledge.

I used to be able to do level 5. After spending the covid years on MN, I don't think I could even do level 4. SM has decimated my concentration levels and just focusing on reading those descriptors tires me out.

Mommawasafarmgirl · 16/02/2023 15:32

Jaslima · 16/02/2023 13:35

My literacy level is pretty good. I did English literature for A-level and got a First in my degree (not English Literature). I went to a school where we were pushed. We weren't really allowed to speak in colloquial English and good use of grammar was drummed into us.

My parents are both very articulate, with good vocabularies and I grew up in a language-rich home. My mother gave me 'word of the week', where she taught me a new word and we used it in conversation a lot that week. My parents didn't dumb down their communication with me, and made sure to speak clearly and expressively.

However, none of us were very avid readers, strangely, instead preferring to write. I mean, I can read as fluently as the next person, unless the theme is something very technical. However, I much, much prefer to write. I'm currently learning a new language and my spoken skills are much superior to my comprehension in the language. I don't know if the two are connected, but I was a lacklustre reader in school who always excellent at written assignments.

My children are both very expressive and articulate, and yet neither love reading either (but can read just fine for their respective ages). The thing that really propelled my literacy skills was reading the academic papers/research as part of my degree/postgraduate. The language definitely informed my own writing. I would say I'm probably the only person I've ever met who loves writing essays!

"I'm currently learning a new language and my spoken skills are much superior to my comprehension in the language."

I find this fascinating. I'm the opposite and stupidly assumed it was the same for everyone.

I've always loved reading , but have found writing and answering questions about literature much more difficult - so, again, the opposite of your experience. I felt I could instinctively understand the nuances in the books I read, but having to explain just how or why the author had chosen to convey their message really was a chore. I didn't, and don't, like dissecting books.

Reugny · 16/02/2023 14:20

AlmostaMamma · 16/02/2023 13:50

the ability to reason from A to B, or extrapolate that if C is true, D must follow

That is literacy and reading comprehension, though. It’s the foundation for this:

Level 4: Adults can integrate, interpret or synthesise information from complex or lengthy texts. Adults can identify and understand one or more specific, non-central idea(s) in the text in order to interpret or evaluate subtle evidence-claim or persuasive discourse relationships.

Level 5: Adults can search for, and integrate, information across multiple, dense texts; construct syntheses of similar and contrasting ideas or points of view; or evaluate evidence based arguments. Adults understand subtle, rhetorical cues and can make high-level inferences or use specialised background knowledge.

It is also logic.

At my primary school we use to do "games" which when I started doing stuff in computing I realised they were simple logic problems.

The children who were good at them at my primary school also tended to have good reading comprehension skills.

Reugny · 16/02/2023 14:17

@user1471453601 one of the problems with those tests is that you need to be using the same cultural references as the person who sets the questions to get the answers "right". (This is why those types of tests are accused of being classist and racist.)

So while I can see the connection between your answer and the question, which is a is right answer, when I saw the question I immediately knew what they were asking for.

However I had to train to answer questions that way. It did help when I was about 8/9 one of my siblings was applying for graduate jobs and left some books around the house with those type of questions. I then had a nosey and started doing them.

RampantIvy · 16/02/2023 14:05

Same here @Natsku.
I had never heard of the subjunctive until I did A level French.

MarshaMelrose · 16/02/2023 14:04

I said the answer was hand. Because you measure a human in feet, and horses in hands. Wrong answer, right answer was hoof.

How do you know you got it wrong, though? The marker might have given you credit for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread