Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think your reading level might be?

242 replies

2023a · 16/02/2023 00:17

I think lots of us have had the odd frustrating conversation on here, where the other person just hasn’t seemed to be able to grasp what we’re saying. Apparently, it’s very possible that the posters in question genuinely don’t understand.

A 2011 government survey of adult literacy skills found that 14.9% (or 1 in 7) of adults in England have literacy levels at or below Entry Level 3, which is equivalent to the literacy skills expected of a nine to 11-year-old.

More recently, in 2015, the OECD conducted its Survey of Adult Skills, known as PIAAC (Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies). This survey found that 16.4% (or 1 in 6) of adults in England, and 17.4% (or 1 in 5) adults in Northern Ireland, have literacy levels at or below Level 1, which is considered to be 'very poor literacy skills'.

More info here, if you’re interested: literacytrust.org.uk/parents-and-families/adult-literacy/what-do-adult-literacy-levels-mean/

OP posts:
BadNomad · 22/02/2023 11:25

Natsku · 22/02/2023 11:13

@BadNomad That's part of the curriculum in Finland (DD started being taught how to critically evaluate media in 3rd grade and I assume the teaching carries on in older grades too), I agree its needed, especially in this age of (dis)information warfare.

That's good! Maybe it is taught here now, I wouldn't know, but it definitely wasn't taught when I was in school. We covered Nazi propaganda, but there was no attempt to link it to modern times or other areas. I did make the connection by myself, and now apply "why?" to everything. The media, politics, advertisements, threads on MN etc. But from having conversations with friends and colleagues, it is apparent that not everyone looks beyond the surface.

Natsku · 22/02/2023 11:13

@BadNomad That's part of the curriculum in Finland (DD started being taught how to critically evaluate media in 3rd grade and I assume the teaching carries on in older grades too), I agree its needed, especially in this age of (dis)information warfare.

BadNomad · 22/02/2023 10:45

Personally, I think schools need to do more to educate young people about the media. It's frightening how some people really do believe everything they read. They don't ask "Why?" Why am I being told this. Why has the journalist used these particular words. What is their agenda. How do I check this is factual.

People vote based on the shit they read in the Daily Mail (other sources of propaganda are available). That is terrifying. Teaching reading comprehension and critical thinking skills in this area would be much more valuable to society than understanding poetry.

OMG12 · 22/02/2023 10:34

Kokeshi123 · 22/02/2023 02:39

Well.... it's not like they deliberately tried to make men look better by "picking texts that men are bound to do better at."

They will have chosen largely non-fiction texts because these surveys of adult skills are about whether people have the capacity to be effective workers, informed voters, intelligent consumers, safe users of medical care and so on, and the ability to read non-fiction texts is really important for all of these things, a lot more than being able to mentally enter the inner life of a poem or talk about a character in a work of fiction.

I get that there is some defensiveness about this, but if women are generally somewhat less informed than men about current affairs, scientific matters (example: how nuclear power works) and so on, then the rational response would be, "let's improve this situation," rather than wanting the test to be changed.

Well it depends what you mean “improve the situation”

I would suggest being able to enter the inner life of a poem is far more beneficial to humanity than understanding the workings of a nuclear power station. The patriarchy has got is valuing things that actually hardly matter at all.

Kokeshi123 · 22/02/2023 02:39

JaninaDuszejko · 21/02/2023 11:10

reading comp exercises tend to be on non-fiction texts where general knowledge is the key to comprehension

So the test is gendered and then they are surprised they get a gendered result? A better test would include non-fiction and fiction and poetry. Harder to test comprehension of texts where it can be interpreted in multiple ways of course so they go for the easy option.

Well.... it's not like they deliberately tried to make men look better by "picking texts that men are bound to do better at."

They will have chosen largely non-fiction texts because these surveys of adult skills are about whether people have the capacity to be effective workers, informed voters, intelligent consumers, safe users of medical care and so on, and the ability to read non-fiction texts is really important for all of these things, a lot more than being able to mentally enter the inner life of a poem or talk about a character in a work of fiction.

I get that there is some defensiveness about this, but if women are generally somewhat less informed than men about current affairs, scientific matters (example: how nuclear power works) and so on, then the rational response would be, "let's improve this situation," rather than wanting the test to be changed.

thing47 · 21/02/2023 14:35

A better test would include non-fiction and fiction and poetry. Harder to test comprehension of texts where it can be interpreted in multiple ways of course so they go for the easy option.

Totally agree with you @JaninaDuszejko, but of course they solve that via those dire 'compare and contrast' type questions. You know the ones: 'Compare and contrast James Joyce's description of Dublin in Ulysses with how TS Eliot talks about The Wasteland in his famous poem of the same name.' Totally nonsensical.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 21/02/2023 12:41

I suspect it’s quite high, I write and interpret documents for a living, and reading and writing have always been things I enjoyed. Perhaps that’s the key to it: enjoyment? My sibling doesn’t really like reading so doesn’t do it for pleasure, whereas I live my life surrounded by books, can’t imagine a train journey without taking a book with me and so on.

As a child I was put up several reading levels when a wonderful teacher realised I found my “age” level far too easy and was getting bored. I think it also helps that I went to schools where reading was absolutely encouraged, school libraries were freely available etc. as well as my parents being readers who understood the importance of children being encourage to choose books and read.

JaninaDuszejko · 21/02/2023 11:10

reading comp exercises tend to be on non-fiction texts where general knowledge is the key to comprehension

So the test is gendered and then they are surprised they get a gendered result? A better test would include non-fiction and fiction and poetry. Harder to test comprehension of texts where it can be interpreted in multiple ways of course so they go for the easy option.

CrikeyPeg · 21/02/2023 03:31

2023a · 21/02/2023 01:27

The link is in the OP.

Grin
2023a · 21/02/2023 01:27

JackiePlace · 21/02/2023 00:30

@2023a Before I can answer your question I need to know: what defined "reading levels" are you referring to? Please send or post the link. thank you

The link is in the OP.

OP posts:
JackiePlace · 21/02/2023 00:30

@2023a Before I can answer your question I need to know: what defined "reading levels" are you referring to? Please send or post the link. thank you

Natsku · 20/02/2023 12:42

After the ridiculously easy test posted in the thread earlier I went looking for a different one and found these www.verbalreasoningtest.org found I did have to read carefully to answer the questions so not too easy

I then clicked on a link for other tests, tried a logical reasoning one and did absolutely terribly Grin clearly logic is not my strong point!

DeanVolecapeAKAelderberry · 20/02/2023 11:41

I'd assume I'd a 5 because I have a PhD in a subject that needed me to read texts including scientific stuff an analyse them rather than accepting everything.

I was interested in jaslima's comment a few days back about reading scripture - that can involve layer upon layer of understanding - there's the immediate text, sometimes something you've read or heard since childhood with all the lazy distortion that can hold; there's historical background or absence of same regarding both the writer and the narrative; awareness of how scholars have interpreted it over the millennia and how it was used to affect people's lives; and the immediate 'what does this mean for me, as a woman, as a feminist, as a person living now but still drinking from this well?' And of course, the question of who translated the version you're reading, and what the translator is trying to do in their mediation between the ancient text and their expected reader.

Lots and lots going on there.

Kokeshi123 · 20/02/2023 10:30

Actually, surveys show women read a lot more at all ages than men (not just kids' books - their own books). But there is a small gap in men's favour, when it comes to tested reading comprehension, in the international surveys of adult skills. Probably because men have slightly better general knowledge (science, current affairs, geopolitics etc.) than women and this tends to accumulate over time - and reading comp exercises tend to be on non-fiction texts where general knowledge is the key to comprehension.

paintingwithcampbells · 20/02/2023 07:51

JaninaDuszejko · 20/02/2023 06:18

That'll be a motherhood penalty.

All those years of reading the same 4 picture books, you mean?

JaninaDuszejko · 20/02/2023 06:18

That'll be a motherhood penalty.

user1477391263 · 20/02/2023 00:06

www.brookings.edu/research/girls-boys-and-reading/

My reading age will be very good, I think, as it’s basically what I do all day as an adult in my job.

One interesting fact about reading skills: girls do much better than boys in reading in all societies, but the difference evaporates with age. In adulthood, men improve at a quicker rate than women so that it evens out, and after age 35, men tend to have somewhat better reading skills than women - even though women read for pleasure a lot more than men.

www.brookings.edu/research/girls-boys-and-reading/

CrikeyPeg · 19/02/2023 23:47

MagicCat83 · 16/02/2023 00:58

Do you work for a newspaper? If so, I have some bad news for you..... ;)

@MagicCat83 I've recently come to the conclusion that my daily newspaper (New Zealand Herald) has been using ChatGPT to write most of their articles for some considerable time now 😁

Gwenhwyfar · 19/02/2023 20:26

caringcarer · 17/02/2023 11:59

I have a friend who runs literacy programs in prison and secure accommodation. He shocked me years ago when he told me approximately 89 percent of inmates have not passed English GCSE and even more can't read properly and virtually none of them can understand 24 hour clock on railway timetables etc. He says they all seem to understand money though.

Why would that shock you for a prison?

BounceyB · 19/02/2023 17:46

This is really interesting. I love learning and reading generally. Did the test and a 5. I think the issue with a lot of people who don't read is undiagnosed learning difficulties. Thinking that you're not very good at something is probably the biggest limitation to a decent literacy level.

Kucinghitam · 19/02/2023 17:12

Oh, and this is a really fascinating thread!

Kucinghitam · 19/02/2023 17:11

English is my second language, but looking at the criteria, I'd be L5 (those skills are a vital part of my job).

Gremlinsateit · 19/02/2023 03:40

bagelbagelbagel · 18/02/2023 18:03

On a good day, 5 (have three degrees). On a day like today, frazzled and with a migraine, barely 2.

Yeah, I reckon maybe I might have been a 5 once, but between quite repetitive technical work, joys of parenthood/middle age, and chronic insomnia, I would be heading down the levels at a rate of knots nowadays!

CrackedLookingGlass · 18/02/2023 23:17

Simonjt · 18/02/2023 19:11

Probably not that high, I’m not a native speaker and I can’t read my first language at all. I’m not a great second language speaker as I have to translate, I can’t talk in English with natural fluent flow, so with reading I can really struggle with things like tone and context.

I recognise your username from on here, and this has really surprised me — your written English seems native-speaker level.

Simonjt · 18/02/2023 19:11

Probably not that high, I’m not a native speaker and I can’t read my first language at all. I’m not a great second language speaker as I have to translate, I can’t talk in English with natural fluent flow, so with reading I can really struggle with things like tone and context.