Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the watch would be left to him?

85 replies

Flamesbegin · 15/02/2023 21:45

I have 2 DC, DS 10 from a previous relationship and DD from my current DH.
Totally informal conversation between DH and our friends today about DH’s dad’s watch worth around 15k. DH said hopefully we have a boy next so he has someone to leave his watch to. Total emotional reaction from me was, well won’t my DS be left it, he’s the first born, DH replied instantly, he’s not my first born. It hurt me to hear that quite a bit, DH has been in DS’s life since he was two, been a very present, (seemingly) happy step parent and DS calls him Dad. DS has a very sporadic relationship with his bio Dad due to him living 3 hours away and him being a bit unpredictable, he does see him and enjoys the time he has with him, we have all come to terms with the sporadic nature of their relationship and get on with life.

I’m not a step-parent so obviously can’t fathom how this relationship really works in DH’s head but I’d always assumed he treats him as if he’s his own child and was happy with having a DS that may not be his but essential is.

He’s got DS interested in his hobbies and plants wee seeds of DS following in his career footsteps.
Trying to wrap my head around the fact the relationship I imagined in my head isn’t actually reality. It’s not about the value of watch, but the sentiment behind. I can’t help but feel DS would feel hurt if he knew how DH felt.

So genuinely, if you’re a step parent to DC you’ve been involved with for a long time and are a huge part of your life do your see them as yours or AIBU?

OP posts:
JofraArchersFastestBall · 16/02/2023 09:30

Such a fixed and unquestioning patriarchal view. Very off putting.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/02/2023 09:24

Tbh it’s a daft thing to be talking about at this point.

Your DS is 10. Your DH has been around him 8 years and his own dad is around.

In 20/30/40 years things could easily be vastly different. Either in a better or worse way.

GrumpyPanda · 16/02/2023 09:24

GoodChat · 15/02/2023 21:53

Because it's a men's watch

So? I've worn plenty of men's watches. Depends on the watch, not the really clunky ones. I've got fairly sturdy wrists though.

Furrydogmum · 16/02/2023 09:22

If there is more than one child then all things being equal, the watch should be sold if it is an appreciating asset.. My mum raised this the other day, that she wanted to sell her valuable engagement ring now, to share the money between me and my sisters. It is a gorgeous ring and still fits her - I asked her to keep it and trust us to do the right and fair thing with all her jewellery, hopefully in the distant future!

Riverlee · 16/02/2023 09:16

Can your dh get a watch to give to your son for his 18th or 21st so he has a family watch as well? Ie. Create a new family heirloom?

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 16/02/2023 09:06

Flamesbegin · 15/02/2023 22:04

Not important, not at all. I think I just get a bit sad that DS is left in limbo, a Dad that he sees in person about 6 times a year and a step-dad that isn’t really his Dad. Should just be happy they have the relationship they do have, which has meant a great deal to DS.

Your son being left in limbo is the fault of his actual dad.

It’s just a watch. Mayb try to get a family heirloom from your side that is earmarked for you son? Have you inherited anything from grandparents etc?

Ursuladevinia82 · 16/02/2023 09:04

DisplayPurposesOnly · 16/02/2023 08:34

So what?

Because men’s watches generally have a much bigger face than ladies, and women’s wrists are generally much slighter

my brother’s watch looks ridiculous on my pencil wrist

Naunet · 16/02/2023 09:02

GoodChat · 15/02/2023 21:53

Because it's a men's watch

Will her tits fall off if she wears it?! Don’t be ridiculous, of course she could still wear it, but having been born female, she’s expected to stand aside with grace and be happy her brother is given 15k over her.

KimberleyClark · 16/02/2023 09:02

I have no children. I inherited my mother’s engagement ring. I have no nieces either. I will leave my mother’s ring and mine to my nephew. Given what my wedding ring symbolises I would rather be buried/cremated with it on as my mother was.

Ursuladevinia82 · 16/02/2023 09:01

one of the many reasons why i will never ever blend families

I don’t want any other child getting a penny of my money other than my children (and any possible grandchild)

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 16/02/2023 09:01

Your husband sounds like a wonderful man. He’s accepted your son as his own, treats him as his own.

He’s still totally right that a family heirloom should be passed from father to son - ie biological son. Don’t let this distract from what sounds like a wonderful family dynamic.

Brefugee · 16/02/2023 09:00

Lucky you're not my brother then he wasn't the slightest bit offended and he wears the piece of jewellery he bought all the time.

and that is also fine. Nothing to be "offended" about. When my dad died there were things of his that related to shared experiences with me. My mum offered them all to my brother ("men" things) and he pointed out a few things that I'd probably like. No offence taken or given.

Every family is different. But we should also challenge ideas about "this must go to my first born son" as though any daughters that come before that are chopped liver. If it's a watch that the grandfather bought, it's not exactly an heirloom as such, although they may may want to start a tradition of passing the watch to boys. Which is fine, as long as they aren't ignoring the girls, and have provision for what if one doesn't have a son, would a step-son be acceptable.

Maybe in asking "why not DD" the DH might have a lightbulb moment and say - oh yeah, of course she could have it. Or "she can have x, y, z - we want this to be a tradition for the male line".

SoupDragon · 16/02/2023 08:57

I would expect a man's watch to be passed to a son in the same way I expect women's jewellery to be passed to a daughter.

this "penis operated" nonsense is just dumb in this respect.

Ursuladevinia82 · 16/02/2023 08:57

Good grief OP

my firstborn is MY first born and no other child will ever ever be MY first born.

He is yours and your ex’s. Period

UsernamePain · 16/02/2023 08:53

I am a step mum and I have 2 children with my husband. My will states that all of my jewellery be left to my biological children. I feel that they should have the bracelet from my grandmother, the ring from my mum and my wedding rings. My step daughter should inherit that from her own mum.

Cosyblankets · 16/02/2023 08:53

Brefugee · 16/02/2023 08:50

When my mum died I inherited her wedding ring, engagement ring and eternity ring. She didn't leave a will. My dad gave them to me. My brother got some money with which he bought himself a piece of jewellery to remember her. Is that sexist as well?

in your brothers shoes? yeah, I'd have probably wanted one of the rings and if my mum did that I'd probably offer him the choice of which he wanted and i keep 2. Or something.

Lucky you're not my brother then he wasn't the slightest bit offended and he wears the piece of jewellery he bought all the time.

Brefugee · 16/02/2023 08:50

When my mum died I inherited her wedding ring, engagement ring and eternity ring. She didn't leave a will. My dad gave them to me. My brother got some money with which he bought himself a piece of jewellery to remember her. Is that sexist as well?

in your brothers shoes? yeah, I'd have probably wanted one of the rings and if my mum did that I'd probably offer him the choice of which he wanted and i keep 2. Or something.

Tinkeytonkoldfruit · 16/02/2023 08:49

I have three DSC who I love very much, I have been involved with the youngest since he was 3. I have my own DD too. I don't love the DSC less but it is a different love. I won't get much or any inheritance but I have said that what I do get will then latterly pass solely to my DD not to the DSC. I know that's what my parents would want (although they have a good relationship with DSC).

Bellalalala · 16/02/2023 08:48

Most people are really careful about where family heirlooms go. I have a ring that’s only been passed down the female line for a reason.

Though went from my great grandmother to her daughter in law (my Nana) because my great grandmother had no daughters.

Things change. Your dh may change his mind depending on how his relationship develops with ds.

My dp is a great step parent, I would never refer to my eldest as ‘our first born’. I would expect dp to give a family heirloom to a child that wasn’t his.

I also don’t get why a mens watch couldn’t be given to the dd though either.

rainbowstardrops · 16/02/2023 08:43

I can see why you've been taken aback by this but in all fairness, your DS is not his blood DS.
I would absolutely be angry that your DD wouldn't be first in line for it!
I have several items and pieces of jewellery that belonged to my dad. Just because I might not wear them is irrelevant!

BubziOwl · 16/02/2023 08:43

I can't profess to know how a step parent does or should feel about a step child, but I can only imagine it will be very hurtful for your son to one day realise the man he (I assume, from your posts) views as his father didn't view him as his son.

I hope your husband at least intends for your existing son and daughter to have extra cash to match the value of the watch left for them?

Cosyblankets · 16/02/2023 08:42

It is not misogynistic to not leave it to the daughter. For a start we have no idea what provision has been made for the daughter.
When my mum died I inherited her wedding ring, engagement ring and eternity ring. She didn't leave a will. My dad gave them to me. My brother got some money with which he bought himself a piece of jewellery to remember her. Is that sexist as well?

heldinadream · 16/02/2023 08:40

I completely agree with you OP. Day to day life should completely override blood. Blood is actually meaningless to me. The fact that his instant thought was to default to the bloodline rather than the reality of your family would be a shock for you. I also agree with posters about the daughter! It's a watch, there's nothing male-specific in inheriting it.

MidgeHardcastle · 16/02/2023 08:36

Unless it's a watch that you wear on a penis then you should be upset on your daughter's behalf.

And as for someone saying a daughter might take her husband's name so won't be part of the family any more. WTAF??

DisplayPurposesOnly · 16/02/2023 08:34

GoodChat · 15/02/2023 21:53

Because it's a men's watch

So what?