Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My niece creeped me out - death comment

143 replies

Lanzy · 15/02/2023 21:15

Tonight my niece (7 year old) looked at the hand print I had recent done with my 7 week old. My niece then innocently goes is that so you can remember Em? Then does this gesture of putting hand to throat (slit) I went what does that mean and she went death.

I’m now worrying as niece also few weeks ago kept saying “EM I don’t want you to grow up be this size forever” of course maybe innocent but had seen some TikTok of woman who said that then next thing.. tonight it freaked me though ger saying that!
i’m now :( - I said why did she think that and she didn’t really say…

OP posts:
ourflagmeansdeath · 16/02/2023 00:28

Ahh, Wednesday may have affected it?? It is a fairly child friendly show I think, but the main character is obviously quite deathly and death obsessed. She could be mimicking that. I wouldn't worry, just talk to her parents if it happens again I'd say. I think she's just getting stuff of Youtube etc. especially as you said she's a lovely kid and loves her cousin. Kids get influenced all the time.

jennyofthenorth · 16/02/2023 00:19

Id be a little nervous but kids say odd things: I was teaching and had a child who was 3 at the time look at me and say "We dont kill our friends" totally straight faced, fallowed up a few minutes later with "Neby! SISTERS name is gonna stab Mr. Steve with a knife." I told the parent who assured me that the sister very much liked moms boyfriend (mr. steve) but she would keep a eye on her "weird" child/

keeprunning55 · 16/02/2023 00:13

I can imagine why it has upset you and freaked you out. But, from my experience, children say some absolutely awful things sometimes about babies and death.
I know a really lovely girl who said the strangest and vilest thing to someone when she was pregnant. It was completely out of character. The child was in a lot of trouble for saying it though.

Try not to let it worry you and know you’re not alone with children saying weird things that don’t mean anything.

JudgeRudy · 16/02/2023 00:10

Lanzy · 15/02/2023 21:21

Just for her to say for me as an adult to remember my daughter then implying death…it was such an odd :(

I'd guess she has seen it done for someone else, possibly a dead child or possiblh justvasca momento. I don't think she's psychicly predicting your baby's death nor is she planning to murder her cousin.
Kids say weird stuff all the time.

Dazed77 · 16/02/2023 00:06

Does your niece play Roblox or Among us? Or does she watch YouTubers who play these games. Making a slit throat sign seems to be a universal way of signifying death in these things without saying the word, as the word can get videos taken down and advertising pulled on them. My kids and the kids in my family use it as a way to mean death, it doesn’t mean they’re going to actually cause the death. I just think your niece is trying to make sense of the world. Kids nowadays are far more technologically advanced and because you’ve done something that isn’t taking a picture she’s probably just trying to figure out why. In my opinion I wouldn’t worry about it at all, kids say the weirdest things but they’re just trying to figure things out. My kids say the weirdest stuff but now I’ve learned to roll with it. I would only worry if you’ve seen her attempting to hurt your baby, but by the sounds of it she loves her as much as you do. Hope this helps

Daffodil18 · 15/02/2023 23:55

I know it’s a personal choice but I was given a hand imprint present when my baby was born and never used it as I associate it with dead babies. Not from experience but seeing things on the TV so maybe she has seen things too and the slit throat thing is something my son used to do to describe death when he was around that age. So really wouldn’t worry, it sounds like your niece got worried when you did the hand print.

Saschka · 15/02/2023 23:55

Hiddenvoice · 15/02/2023 21:58

She probably doesn’t realise you want the prints to remember the baby size as she won’t realise parents are sentimental about that. She probably thinks you want them incase something happens. She most likely isn’t meaning it to scare you and has just popped into her head.

I 100% associate baby footprint keepsakes with stillbirths/dead babies. To the point where one of my friends bought me a kit when DS was born and I chucked it away because I felt making one would be tempting fate (I’d had a lot of miscarriages prior to high-risk premature DS and did not want any more jinxes).

So it isn’t necessarily weird that she thought that. I literally don’t know anyone with a non-dead child who has one. DH even refers to them as “dead baby footprint pictures”. People with living children have photos and videos of the actual child, which you often can’t really do with a stillbirth or neonatal death.

PuppyQuestions · 15/02/2023 23:55

I wouldn’t have her in your house again tbh

Eyerollcentral · 15/02/2023 23:54

Theglowofcandles · 15/02/2023 23:46

I wouldn't leave her alone with your baby. I think you are worried and don't want to say it because so many are minimising it and patronising you with the question, what are you worried about. Please follow your gut instinct.

Some years back when a child of the family was around 8 he said he wanted to throw my dd out of a window so she broke every bone in her body. It goes without saying that he has never has been, and never will be, in a room alone with her. He is now 15 and has numerous services involved with him due to severe behavioural issues.

I remember a friend telling me around 15 years ago that her young cousin (around age 5) told her to put bleach in her babies bottle because her baby wasn't settling. That 5 year old is now a fully grown adult and all i will say is she was right to be worried about it.

Follow your gut instinct and don't leave her alone in a room with your baby.

Fgs this is ENTIRELY different. Stop trying to freak a first time mother out. Unreal.

Lanzy · 15/02/2023 23:53

My niece has never done any harm to anyone, I asked why she said it and she said she didn’t want to talk about it. I said it had upset me to make comment like that.
My niece is always happy to see her cousin, excited. Wants to cuddle her, sing to her, feed her.

My worry is that I couldn’t understand why she would think from print to that, it seemed so random. She never sees her dad but is very happy child and to the point, she has no friends where someone has died. She has recently moved school and still doesn’t know anyone
she does love the ipad and youtube, and it seems like she has watched Wednesday but I have no idea what is in that.

i have seen her make the throat gesture in the past to mean death before Wednesday came out.
the reason she does the gesture is because she doesn’t like using the word death.

In convo too tonight she went “I made a wish for my family to live forever”

”angels have wings and good go to heaven and bad go to hell”

OP posts:
Theglowofcandles · 15/02/2023 23:46

I wouldn't leave her alone with your baby. I think you are worried and don't want to say it because so many are minimising it and patronising you with the question, what are you worried about. Please follow your gut instinct.

Some years back when a child of the family was around 8 he said he wanted to throw my dd out of a window so she broke every bone in her body. It goes without saying that he has never has been, and never will be, in a room alone with her. He is now 15 and has numerous services involved with him due to severe behavioural issues.

I remember a friend telling me around 15 years ago that her young cousin (around age 5) told her to put bleach in her babies bottle because her baby wasn't settling. That 5 year old is now a fully grown adult and all i will say is she was right to be worried about it.

Follow your gut instinct and don't leave her alone in a room with your baby.

Lanzy · 15/02/2023 23:46

I know she knows that handprints aren’t associated with death/stillborn because my 17 year old nephew had them done as baby and she knew that as she made that comment shortly after.

OP posts:
Lanzy · 15/02/2023 23:43

SkivingSnackboxes · 15/02/2023 22:43

@Lanzy tell your sister that you think your niece is going to kill your child and see how ridiculous you are actually being. No doubt you won't be allowed to see her again and frankly I think that's the best for everyone

When did I say I thought my niece was going to kill my child? If I thought that my niece would be nowhere near my baby. She is actually in the next room and loves my baby. It was more the words that come out her mouth that concerned me. Jesus

OP posts:
impossible · 15/02/2023 23:27

I think she's just exploring ideas and she's very likely been influenced by something she's seen. At that age death isn't a taboo, it's a curiosity as is life.

My ds at that age wrote a list of everyone in our extended family in order of who was going to die first, with (perceived) oldest at top of list and so on. He was rather amused by his list, even though he adored his grandparents, who were of course first in line. He had no sense of what it would be to lose someone he loved. It was just interesting to him.

15 years on that list has proved very wrong - the oldest grandparent still standing and several other family members gone far too early. There was no magic involved or premonition. He was just a kid thinking about the meaning of life.

Strawberrydelight78 · 15/02/2023 23:18

That's very dark I'm sure most children have a few handprints and footprints pic's at various age's. She probably has some herself. Maybe she's heard they take hand and footprints of stillborn babies and babies with a terminal illness in the hospital for parents. But it's still odd.

MakeItADouble2 · 15/02/2023 23:18

Your sister shouldn't be letting her watch Wednesday. Some children do have a dark side - it can be a phase but it could be how she is.
Definitely do not let your baby with her alone, ever. Not until you really see a difference for the better in her behaviour.
People do act out of what they have seen, all the time.

whynotwhatknot · 15/02/2023 23:11

Yes Wednesday does that on her show

not approriate for a 7 year old

Suzi888 · 15/02/2023 23:09

Mooshamoo · 15/02/2023 22:25

I remember being 7 years old playing Barbie's with my cousin.

We had the Barbie's committing suicide, we had them jumping off the couch pretending it was a cliff. And lying at the bottom. It totally freaked my aunt out.

I had no concept of what suicide was really. I remember I had the Barbie's doing it , because I had seen it on a TV show.

Children just repeat what they see on TV shows.

Wtf tv show was that …. YouTube?

She has obviously watched something inappropriate.

midnightblue12 · 15/02/2023 23:06

It's very eerie isn't it.
I would just mention it to her parents and then don't leave them alone together 😵‍💫

Yahyahs22 · 15/02/2023 22:59

That's what happens when you let a 7 year old watch something that is made for teenagers twice her age and above. She's mimicking something from Wednesday.

Climbles · 15/02/2023 22:56

She’s seen something on TV with a foot print memorial for a baby. She’s not predicting anything she’s just a kid and they say weird stuff.

MysteryBelle · 15/02/2023 22:53

It’s also a very unkind and gruesome thing to say. If others think it’s fine, ok 🙄

Xmasbaby11 · 15/02/2023 22:53

Hmm it's an unsettling comment with the gesture but I wonder if she meant it as a joke and got the tone wrong. My ASD daughter still does this at 11 - she doesn't 'get' how to make something clear it's a joke, but of course we all know her.

The comment about staying a baby forever, I wouldn't take any notice or connect it to the other one. People say that all the time!

MysteryBelle · 15/02/2023 22:51

It’s not a common nor a natural thing for a child to say about a baby. It’s not getting worked up to let the parents know and to limit contact until you’ve found out what got her thinking and saying those things. That is perfectly reasonable and logical.

SkivingSnackboxes · 15/02/2023 22:43

@Lanzy tell your sister that you think your niece is going to kill your child and see how ridiculous you are actually being. No doubt you won't be allowed to see her again and frankly I think that's the best for everyone