Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I BU to my daughters dad?

113 replies

livelyliv · 15/02/2023 17:14

This may sound very familiar to some of you as I've posted about my situation before, and have returned yet again for more advice!

I posted last month asking for advice regarding my ex, as he was asking to have our 6 month old baby (who he's never looked after on his own before and has had limited contact with) for a whole day. After a lot of back and forth, I suggested he have her for 3-4 hours. This is because she is a breastfed baby (who doesn't accept bottles) so I would need to come back after that time to feed her. He thought this was unfair and wouldn't agree, so in the end, I didn't end up taking her to his house, as I was not going to allow her to be there all day with no milk. I also wasn't comfortable with her going there as he said he would "make" her drink from a bottle.

Shortly after I asked for advice on here, I received a really lengthy text from him basically saying that since I've shown that I don't need him (his words), he will no longer be involved in DD's life and she can contact him when she's 18 if she wishes. He ended the text with "do not contact me again", so I did just that, didn't contact him and have spent the past month enjoying being able to just be a mum without all the added stress he brings to my life. That is until now, because he has decided to return, apologising for what he said "out of anger" and is demanding to know when I will be bringing DD to see him. I have reluctantly said he can see DD, but it must be at my house until he can actually learn how to be a parent and prove that he's going to stick around (it's not the first time he's done something like this) He has called me controlling and I feel he may take this to court.

I don't feel that I'm being unreasonable and neither do my family, but of course, they're very biased. So just interested to hear what other people thought.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 15/02/2023 21:05

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:52

@Whatafliberty - on top of what you said the OP hasn’t tried to stop him seeing the baby! It can’t all just be on his terms. I’ve seen that poster before, all about the poor menz.

Yup penis privilege penis portions it's tiresome

"Who cares of breast is best for baby I am a MAN I HAVE MANLY WANTS GIVE ME THE CHILD THEY WILL TAKE A BOTTLE OR STARVE"

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:52

@Whatafliberty - on top of what you said the OP hasn’t tried to stop him seeing the baby! It can’t all just be on his terms. I’ve seen that poster before, all about the poor menz.

Whatafliberty · 15/02/2023 20:49

Court aside, I think it’s pretty harsh you are keeping his kid away from him.
a child really should have access to both parents. Breastfed or not. Also IMO I believe it’s not just down to you how to feed your joint baby.

this one of worst replies I have ever read. Of course it is the mother's decision.

blackbeardsballsack · 15/02/2023 20:43

Oh aye yeah, stop breastfeeding your little baby and 'get them on a bottle' just in case the dad who hasn't had a minute of contact with her for weeks and didn't want to be involved in her life at all decides to rock up for a few hours ad hoc.

Don't listen to the goady posters, OP. They do not know what they profess to know about the family courts. Perfectly reasonable to offer contact in a safe, comfortable setting for your baby for now, to be reviewed as time passes (he won't commit to it though). You're promoting contact, you're being reasonable.

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:33

@Dixiechickonhols 100% agree

Dixiechickonhols · 15/02/2023 20:31

Also if I recall his thread he wasn’t paying maintenance.

So single parent Op is supposed to buy bottles/formula/steriliser just so he can have her all day or overnights.

Instead he could see her at Op’s, then take her out in pram for short periods. In a few months time baby will be eating more solids, he’d have built up his skills with baby and baby would be used to him.
A decent Dad would want what is best for baby.

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:25

I couldn’t ever imagine telling the father of my child I wanted nothing to do with my child and then not have any contact for a month because I was annoyed at my ex.

Does he really care about his child or is his child just a weapon to use against OP? I know I would be accepting 3-4 hours of contact every day over not seeing my child because good parents put their child’s best interests at the forefront of their actions.

NoGoodUsernamee · 15/02/2023 20:11

Also IMO I believe it’s not just down to you how to feed your joint baby.

@Anotherposter76 well IMO, your opinion sucks!

People will argue about this for days but breastfeeding is the best option WHEN it is emotionally and physically possible for the mother & baby to do so. Are you seriously suggesting the baby (who is obviously very happy BF) should be supplemented with formula so the father can spend the whole day with the baby? That’s just batshit to me. OP isn’t stopping him seeing the baby, she’s just saying he can’t take baby alone outside of hours where the baby will need feeding. I can sort of understand fathers feeling a bit put out at this stage in a babies life, but if he genuinely loved and cared for his child and had her best interests at heart then he would understand that is how she is most comfortable and work around it until inevitably she will no longer be a BF baby and be able to spend extended periods of time with him. His needs do not trump the babies!

Dixiechickonhols · 15/02/2023 19:57

Op isn’t saying no she’s letting him see baby just not for hours or days away from her at first.

That’s not an unreasonable approach. I suspect if he bothered to take legal advice then he would be advised to accept this and make application to court. Then this contact would form part of his application - he’s cared adequately for her, baby knows him, baby is happy and safe in his care.

Instead he’s done the cut nose off to spite face. My way or highway which doesn’t work with a baby.

So if he did go to court he won’t have seen baby for months. Court isn’t going to say immediately hand over bf baby to stranger for 48 hour stints or whatever he wants. Court will at best say start contact (maybe at contact centre) and build up, which is exactly what he can have now if he stops only thinking about himself and his ‘rights’.

Scienceadvisory · 15/02/2023 19:55

CalmBeforeStorm01 · 15/02/2023 18:16

My experience of this is that the court will think it is in the best interests of your mutual child to have contact with both parents. The judge won't consider he said, she said stuff. Put the child first and try to minimise your anger. Get her on a bottle and make sure she knows she's loved equally by both parents.

Unfortunately she's not loved equally by both parents though, is she? Her dad is happy to not see her for weeks at a time whenever he isn't allowed to control the child's mother. Any man who can walk away so easily from his child is not a loving parent.

The OP has been putting the child first. She's been trying to build up a relationship between dad and baby slowly while single-handedly raising the baby. It's the dad who has never put the child first.

FriedasCarLoad · 15/02/2023 19:53

I have no idea about legalities, but I do think you're being very reasonable.

LIZS · 15/02/2023 19:48

Not intending to victim blame, just suggest firmer boundaries

Theunamedcat · 15/02/2023 19:47

Anotherposter76 · 15/02/2023 19:02

@livelyliv you can still breastfeed - pump and put into bottles - I’m sorry but you can’t use that as an excuse to only allow him to see his child around you or around your timings. He would be within his rights to go to court and you wouldn’t look very good - and I have experience with this. I think this is a mask for you either wanting to spend time with him or not wanting to share your time with your child - but you need to get over it.

She isnt using breastfeeding as an "excuse" it's the fact that he has already pissed off and flounced at least once and the child is barely 6 months old it would be a piss poor judge that overlooked that

Scienceadvisory · 15/02/2023 19:43

Anotherposter76 · 15/02/2023 18:58

@Ponoka7 a father’s time is more important than breastfeeding and the mother will be expected to either pump or wean.

You didn't properly read that, did you? It clearly says if a court feels the mother is using breastfeeding to be obstructive. Agreeing to 3/4 hours of contact at a time when the dad's been largely absent is not obstructive. It also uses the word probably which is far from the absolute you suggest so stop trying to scare the OP into going along with her ex's wishes.

sonjadog · 15/02/2023 19:36

I suspect court is an empty thread. Tell him to go ahead. I bet he does nothing.

PaigeMatthews · 15/02/2023 19:36

LIZS · 15/02/2023 19:22

Why are you allowing you, and your dd, to be messed about? She needs constancy and reliability, if he is serious he can go to court for access. Bet he does not bother

It isnt op’s fault. It is the father’s lack of decency which is the problem. Stop blaming women for men being dickheads.

PaigeMatthews · 15/02/2023 19:34

Anotherposter76 · 15/02/2023 19:12

@livelyliv i highly doubt someone would actually force a bottle down a baby’s throat - if he is - it begs the question of why you decided to have one with him in the first place because he wouldn’t be a very nice person would he?

BUT if he wanted to encourage the baby to have a bottle with gentle persistence and in a responsible manner, there isn’t much you could do about it whilst baby was in his care.

@Anotherposter76 you said this about the man YOU chose to have a child with.

he hasn’t seen child in over a year because of safeguarding concerns about him…(dv, he injured our disabled child because of his temper, drinks heavily, always unemployed).

maybe come down from that very high horse if yours and stop being a nob.

op, have you contacted cms about him paying financial support? Or is he already?

why do you have to be the one driving around? Is he incapable in some way?

tbh id just go through cms and tell him to crack on with court. As the poster above agreed, he probably will lose interest anyway.

Suedomin · 15/02/2023 19:33

"Get her on a bottle and make sure she knows she's loved equally by both parents.*
The best interest of the child is to be breast fed for as long as the mother wants to/is able to feed her. It is certainly not to 'put her on a bottle' just because her irresponsible, immature father thinks he wants to play at being her father.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/02/2023 19:31

livelyliv · 15/02/2023 19:18

This is exactly what I've suggested. Slowly build up the visits until she can be with him all day, yet I'm still accused of not letting him see his child!

Just keep copies of your messages. This is a reasonable approach and if he genuinely wanted to see her then he’d take it.
When corresponding think about how would it look if read out in court and couch everything in best interests of baby. I recall he came across as a complete idiot banging on about his ‘rights’ with no appreciation of baby’s needs. Good luck.

ImAvingOops · 15/02/2023 19:31

I would take advice as above and make all communication with him very calm and framed entirely around baby's best interests. I would refer to his threats in the texts you send him, so say things alone the lines of "You threatened to force the baby to take a bottle and so I won't leave the baby with you unsupervised until I am certain you won't do this" Or, "I happy for you to visit and spend time with baby but since you have previously refused contact i won't hand her over until I am reassured she is safe in your care". Don't respond angrily and keep all messages.

Personally I'd be tempted to move and not pass on my new address/phone number. If he takes you to court, it will take time and money and he might not if it's too much like hard work. Don't make it easy for him by parenting your baby in a way that goes against your own wishes, just for his convenience - he doesn't deserve that consideration!

If he does eventually get access, make sure you pursue him for proper child support.

Mumsanetta · 15/02/2023 19:29

@livelyliv i would just ignore @Anotherposter76 as they are very obviously goady.

Past behaviour is always the best indicator of future behaviour. Your ex failed to stick around last time, highly unlikely he will manage it this time. If he refuses to agree to your very reasonable request, let him take you to court. My guess is he will once again run out of steam.

I actually remember his post and, unsurprisingly, MNetters saw straight through him and handed him his arse. What a shame the thread got deleted.

LIZS · 15/02/2023 19:22

Why are you allowing you, and your dd, to be messed about? She needs constancy and reliability, if he is serious he can go to court for access. Bet he does not bother

animalprintfree · 15/02/2023 19:19

PeekAtYou · 15/02/2023 18:48

If he takes you to court suggest supervised contact at a contact centre as a compromise. Yanbu to want him to prove that he can be consistent and have his parenting skills observed as you have no clue if he can look after a baby.

I think this is terrible advice. Having volunteered at contact centres, I think they should very much be a last resort. Try and sort it out more amicably without the courts. Perhaps try a family mediator.

livelyliv · 15/02/2023 19:18

Dixiechickonhols · 15/02/2023 19:16

If Op was starting back at work and booking baby in nursery there would be settling in sessions. Eg mum stay with baby, then baby stay short while, then baby go full days. Mum would trust that nursery would call if baby was very distressed or wouldn’t freed.
It’s not in baby’s best interests to go to someone she doesn’t know for hours, a gradual transition is in baby’s best interest.

This is exactly what I've suggested. Slowly build up the visits until she can be with him all day, yet I'm still accused of not letting him see his child!

OP posts:
livelyliv · 15/02/2023 19:17

Anotherposter76 · 15/02/2023 19:12

@livelyliv i highly doubt someone would actually force a bottle down a baby’s throat - if he is - it begs the question of why you decided to have one with him in the first place because he wouldn’t be a very nice person would he?

BUT if he wanted to encourage the baby to have a bottle with gentle persistence and in a responsible manner, there isn’t much you could do about it whilst baby was in his care.

You can "doubt" it all you like, you don't actually know him.

The why would I have a baby with him thing is a really ignorant comment. It is widely reported that some men become abusive during their partners pregnancy, which is exactly what happened in my case. Don't comment on things you have no idea about.

OP posts: