Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I BU to my daughters dad?

113 replies

livelyliv · 15/02/2023 17:14

This may sound very familiar to some of you as I've posted about my situation before, and have returned yet again for more advice!

I posted last month asking for advice regarding my ex, as he was asking to have our 6 month old baby (who he's never looked after on his own before and has had limited contact with) for a whole day. After a lot of back and forth, I suggested he have her for 3-4 hours. This is because she is a breastfed baby (who doesn't accept bottles) so I would need to come back after that time to feed her. He thought this was unfair and wouldn't agree, so in the end, I didn't end up taking her to his house, as I was not going to allow her to be there all day with no milk. I also wasn't comfortable with her going there as he said he would "make" her drink from a bottle.

Shortly after I asked for advice on here, I received a really lengthy text from him basically saying that since I've shown that I don't need him (his words), he will no longer be involved in DD's life and she can contact him when she's 18 if she wishes. He ended the text with "do not contact me again", so I did just that, didn't contact him and have spent the past month enjoying being able to just be a mum without all the added stress he brings to my life. That is until now, because he has decided to return, apologising for what he said "out of anger" and is demanding to know when I will be bringing DD to see him. I have reluctantly said he can see DD, but it must be at my house until he can actually learn how to be a parent and prove that he's going to stick around (it's not the first time he's done something like this) He has called me controlling and I feel he may take this to court.

I don't feel that I'm being unreasonable and neither do my family, but of course, they're very biased. So just interested to hear what other people thought.

OP posts:
canfor · 16/02/2023 09:07

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:06

This is a controversial opinion so sorry if others disagree but no baby anywhere has ever died because they couldn’t breast feed enough and simply ‘wouldn’t take a bottlé’
ive not read the OPs previous threads/back story and by no means do I think you should just force a bottle down a babies throat but this is an actual fact, eventually every baby will find a food source if one is removed.

That's all well and good but why cause a child significant distress for the sake of a father that seems to want access on his terms only to be controlling? Why can't he accept building up contact with a baby that doesn't know him in short visits and over time the contact can increase as the baby is being weaned now. There's no real need to immediately take this child away from the parent it knows, force it to take a bottle and make it distressed...that shows a lack of concern for the baby's welfare and a lack of understanding of how difficult it is to see your baby cry with hunger and for it's mother - I can't imagine how he would cope with a little six month old who had been crying for hours because that's the reality...

fairgame84 · 16/02/2023 08:01

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:32

If you say so, but there arnt swathes of people who what chosen not to breast feed out of a personal preference all with an epidemic of babies that are on the brink of death.
Not everyone can/wants to breast feed. That’s completely OK. And that is why paediatricians and midwives sont ‘mandate’ breastfeeding. A baby, like any other animal, will eventually find another food source. I’m sure it won’t be a pleasant week or two, nor will it kind to the baby, but the concept that the baby ‘simply won’t breastfeed’ is complete BS. They all have the ability to take a bottle.

What a load of shite.
There are babies who have been exclusively breastfed from birth that will not take a bottle. It's not the same as choosing not to breastfeed and offering a bottle to a newborn. Feeding from a bottle is a different skill to feeding from a breast and not all babies can switch if they have spent months breastfeeding.
Usually you need to offer a bottle in the first 4 weeks if you want a baby to mixed feed. This baby is 6 months old so that ship has sailed.
Not only that, OP has said that she can't get anything off when pumping so there will be nothing to feed the baby even if she could take a bottle. OP shouldn't have to put the baby on formula just to please her ex.

QuinkWashable · 16/02/2023 07:59

To put it out there, my kids don't see much of their dad since we split - because they don't want to (they're old enough to choose) - he'd like overnights, but can't be bothered to put in the effort to encourage the kids to do so - it's laziness and immaturity - they want it all now, and don't realise that with kids, you have to put in a lot of work.

QuinkWashable · 16/02/2023 07:57

but the concept that the baby ‘simply won’t breastfeed’ is complete BS. They all have the ability to take a bottle.

Are you seriously suggesting that it's better that the baby is denied food until she submits? Doesn't that sound cruel and abusive?

Vs the father taking the time to build up to full days, as the baby is weaned?

You think the first is in the kid's best interests vs the second? Because I really don't!

NeverThatSerious · 16/02/2023 07:50

Let him take you to court then. I doubt it ever even gets that far, seeing as he didn’t see his daughter for a fucking month(!!) because he got his arse in his hand that you wouldn’t do exactly as he wanted when he wanted it. He is a selfish arsehole and I’m sorry you and your daughter have to deal with him.

Codlingmoths · 16/02/2023 07:48

Mostexpensiveplug · 15/02/2023 21:08

When you first had you child - like every first parent that has every existed anywhere- there was probably no (already established) ‘evidence’ that you are able to look after a child

Well now there’s lots. And he walked out and is refusing to come visit at all , says he will make baby take a bottle (any parent knows it’s not that easy I’ve just spent 6 months trying to get mine to) etc etc so there’s also lots of evidence he’s a crap dad.

ChilliBandit · 16/02/2023 07:45

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:43

also by suggesting that some children have to be breastfed as there is no other option, you are implying that some mothers don’t have a choice about how to feed their child, and I think that all mothers have a choice they should be free to make at their will.

Yes and OP has chosen to breastfeed. Is her choice not as equally valid as other mother’s because it’s not convenient for the baby’s father. Is it the mother’s choice unless Dad wants something different in your world?

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:43

also by suggesting that some children have to be breastfed as there is no other option, you are implying that some mothers don’t have a choice about how to feed their child, and I think that all mothers have a choice they should be free to make at their will.

ChilliBandit · 16/02/2023 07:42

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:32

If you say so, but there arnt swathes of people who what chosen not to breast feed out of a personal preference all with an epidemic of babies that are on the brink of death.
Not everyone can/wants to breast feed. That’s completely OK. And that is why paediatricians and midwives sont ‘mandate’ breastfeeding. A baby, like any other animal, will eventually find another food source. I’m sure it won’t be a pleasant week or two, nor will it kind to the baby, but the concept that the baby ‘simply won’t breastfeed’ is complete BS. They all have the ability to take a bottle.

You are seriously lacking in comprehension skills if you think choosing or not being able to breastfeed from newborn stage is the same as suddenly expecting a child who has been exclusively breastfed for nearly 6 months to suddenly take a bottle.

rainbowstardrops · 16/02/2023 07:41
  • Unfortunately she's not loved equally by both parents though, is she? Her dad is happy to not see her for weeks at a time whenever he isn't allowed to control the child's mother. Any man who can walk away so easily from his child is not a loving parent.

The OP has been putting the child first. She's been trying to build up a relationship between dad and baby slowly while single-handedly raising the baby. It's the dad who has never put the child first.*

This ^

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:32

BatshitBanshee · 16/02/2023 07:10

Not a controversial opinion, just talking shite. Perhaps your plug has malfunctioned.

If you say so, but there arnt swathes of people who what chosen not to breast feed out of a personal preference all with an epidemic of babies that are on the brink of death.
Not everyone can/wants to breast feed. That’s completely OK. And that is why paediatricians and midwives sont ‘mandate’ breastfeeding. A baby, like any other animal, will eventually find another food source. I’m sure it won’t be a pleasant week or two, nor will it kind to the baby, but the concept that the baby ‘simply won’t breastfeed’ is complete BS. They all have the ability to take a bottle.

wishuponastar1988 · 16/02/2023 07:12

The OP isn't withholding contact** is what my comment above should say.

Also OP if there was domestic abuse in your relationship I would be mindful of your safety in terms of promoting contact at your home. I would either let him make the application to court or could you have a third party also present to facilitate that contact with you? Risk of abuse increases during pregnancy and post partum so please be mindful of that x

BatshitBanshee · 16/02/2023 07:10

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:06

This is a controversial opinion so sorry if others disagree but no baby anywhere has ever died because they couldn’t breast feed enough and simply ‘wouldn’t take a bottlé’
ive not read the OPs previous threads/back story and by no means do I think you should just force a bottle down a babies throat but this is an actual fact, eventually every baby will find a food source if one is removed.

Not a controversial opinion, just talking shite. Perhaps your plug has malfunctioned.

wishuponastar1988 · 16/02/2023 07:08

Some of these comments are ridiculous. The OP withholding contact, this man has barely seen his own baby in the last 6 months so of course it isn't in their best interests to be handed over to a stranger. Why did he not continue to pursue contact instead of saying he was walking away? He's now back on the scene demanding to see the baby - why now? Of course the baby has a right to see their father but k haven't seen anything saying the OP is going to prevent that contact. What is the impact on the child if the father is in and out of their life? How will a young baby settle with someone who is practically a stranger? I think the offer of contact is reasonable OP, let him take you to court if he wishes however a court would want to see he is being consistent with building a bond with his baby before he spends time with them alone.

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 16/02/2023 07:06

This is a controversial opinion so sorry if others disagree but no baby anywhere has ever died because they couldn’t breast feed enough and simply ‘wouldn’t take a bottlé’
ive not read the OPs previous threads/back story and by no means do I think you should just force a bottle down a babies throat but this is an actual fact, eventually every baby will find a food source if one is removed.

Gh12345 · 16/02/2023 06:16

I actually think you’re doing the right thing. This isn’t really a child yet, it’s a baby who needs it’s mother and until your ex can the grow the f up… I’d do the same. He can’t just pick and choose when he’s in her life and wants it his way. No court will side with a parent who’s just not bothered for a month. All this ‘you’re harsh for keeping the father away’… you haven’t but he just wants it his way.

liveforsummer · 16/02/2023 06:00

And yes as @BatshitBanshee says if he dies decide to go to court and comes out with the self entitled shit he did on his thread then he'll get laughed out of the room. Has he run out of excuses for not paying maintenance yet?

BatshitBanshee · 16/02/2023 05:53

I remember your darling ex's posts OP. He was vile, I've never seen some so arrogant, immature and lacking any basic baby parenting knowledge. Personally, I'd call his bluff and say take it to court and have it settled that way.

A) He never will because he has the mental age of a pre teen and
B) Even if he does, a judge will see him for what he is.

Keep your receipts. All of them. Stay neutral in your communications and make sure you inform him that refusing anymore compromises is his choice, he initially decided to cut all contact "out of anger" by his own admission and if and when he's making you uncomfortable or feel threatened.

Best of luck.

liveforsummer · 16/02/2023 05:51

I remember his and your threads. This is not a reasonable man with his child's best interests at heart. Let him take you to court. Your generous even offering the visit at your house and I'd certainly not be letting him be on his own with her or do all the running - he comes to you!

canfor · 16/02/2023 05:42

I breastfed and couldn't get my child to take a bottle of expressed milk, I would have loved a full nights sleep, but many many attempts ended in failure. You are right that his idea that he can just take your child for a long period and force a bottle on them demonstrates that he is not ready to look after her. And he is a stranger so at least for the first few visits it makes sense for you to be around.
If I couldn't be with my child and the only option was to see them for an hour supervised by the other parent, I'd jump at that.
You are completely reasonable OP. Ignore the crazy posts on here and keep going, as PPs have mentioned always frame your responses to him around the interests and wellbeing of the child.

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 21:52

I don't understand how 3/4 hrs contact is not acceptable given the fact he has hardly seen the child, as well as stopping contact due to his anger, seems pretty reasonable to me. If he wanted to show he was trustworthy then surely he would have done anything he needed to.

Re breastfeeding, I had one DC that I just could not express at all for, didn't matter how much I tried. The other DC I could express loads, no idea why specifically. I did ensure they could take a bottle from early on though. I didn't need to do this but felt that it would be easier for DH/my mum when looking after them.

If he was willing to adhere to your terms regarding contact so it is clear he is able to look after her then it will only be a few weeks until she is mainly on solids surely so it would all work out ok. I don't understand why many posters would be happy to ship their babies off to essentially a stranger to the child. He's already proved he's not responsible yet.

Dixiechickonhols · 15/02/2023 21:39

Mostexpensiveplug · 15/02/2023 21:08

When you first had you child - like every first parent that has every existed anywhere- there was probably no (already established) ‘evidence’ that you are able to look after a child

He hasn’t been present, has disappeared for large chunks of time as his own volition.
Instead from memory he suddenly demanded baby for long periods at his house (think it inc overnight) and was woefully ignorant of bf - she can bf, baby will just have to have a bottle with me. I’ve got rights! No appreciation baby might be upset away from her only food source and primary carer.
If he’d been spending lots of time with baby from birth and baby was comfortable with him and he wasn’t a knob so Op was reassured he’d call her if baby wasn’t ok then it would be a different scenario.

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 21:24

Mostexpensiveplug · 15/02/2023 21:08

When you first had you child - like every first parent that has every existed anywhere- there was probably no (already established) ‘evidence’ that you are able to look after a child

At yet there is already established evidence this man does not understand the needs of a child given he went AWOL for a month.

Poppy44 · 15/02/2023 21:20

Any man who can drop contact with his own child for a month because he was angry - is not a man I'd be jumping through hoops to please.

I hope you have taken screenshots of messages. I'd also suggest you keep records and diaries of conversations you've had (e.g phone calls). I would also install some cameras at home. Needn't be fancy. Get an SD card and a tapo camera from Amazon. The reason being if he does come to your house and you get into a conversation about access - you will have proof that you aren't stopping him from seeing his DD. You are just doing it in your home due to your daughters young age.

Keep good records in the event that he does decide to go to court and you will have evidence for your reasonable behaviour and his unreasonable behaviour.

It's the difference between saying something like - well he didn't even see her for a month cos he was angry Vs on the 15th January I had a conversation with Mr X and stated that he was welcome to visit his DD in my home for 3-4hrs. Mr X did not take up the offer and I heard no more until 15th February etc.

I'd keep a running Word document with the facts for several years. I'd also record every time he was either late, a no show or asked to rearrange.

You just don't know when you may need it....and if there's a threat of court, you wanna be prepared.

Mostexpensiveplug · 15/02/2023 21:08

livelyliv · 15/02/2023 19:08

Have you read any of my posts? I've literally just said, I can't pump. I'll have the pump on for 20 mins and won't even get a drop of milk. Also, SHE WILL NOT ACCEPT A BOTTLE. I've tried multiple times. What do you suggest? I leave my 6 month baby with her father who she barely knows, and allow him for force her to have a bottle?

My reasons for wanting contact at my house (as already stated) is because there is no evidence to suggest he can even look after a baby, he's only seen her a handful of times, he's barely even changed her nappy before, he's absconded three times, and has made claims such as "I will make her have a bottle". None of these things suggest he is a capable or responsible father. Without me there and in an unfamiliar environment, DD would be very distressed and confused. I am putting my child's interests first, it's nothing to do with that pathetic little narrative you just made up.

When you first had you child - like every first parent that has every existed anywhere- there was probably no (already established) ‘evidence’ that you are able to look after a child