Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher shouting at Dd to eat

79 replies

Makesmewanttogohome · 15/02/2023 16:17

We’re in another European country, more emphasis is placed on eating and I’d heard stories of kids in school being forced to eat their lunch etc ( or *Strongly encouraged)
Knowing this, I mentioned to the teacher when Dd started school that I was fine if she didn’t want to eat lunch etc and that she eats well at home and I’m not worried if she misses a meal etc. Dd also gets constipated easily and suffers tummy troubles sometimes and gets full and doesn’t want to eat (teacher knows all this)
At the end of today, the assistant came to me with a very serious face, I was thinking ‘God, what’s she done?’ 🙈 She then said that Dd didn’t eat any of her lunch, not one bit, I said ‘Oh were you not hungry?’ To Dd, she said no, I said to the assistant it was fine, she ate lots last night and was no problem, she looked a bit confused.
DD’s just been sat having a snack (she’s eating fine) then told me she was crying at lunch because her teacher and dinner assistant were shouting at her to eat, she basically said the word ‘Eat’ where we are and said the teacher was shouting it. Dd then said she wasn’t allowed fruit because the teacher was shouting that if she didn’t eat, she couldn’t have the fruit, I understand this a bit more, but am feeling really pissed off that she’s been made to cry for not feeling hungry and eating, surely she knows when she’s hungry like we all do?
Aibu here? Don’t want to come across as a precious parent but ffs

OP posts:
EllieM27 · 15/02/2023 19:36

You should talk to them about the food issue, though it does sound like she would benefit from some of the suggestions that other posters have made. They are not going to be thrilled with the idea of letting her eat nothing and opening themselves up to her being hungry and whiny later in the day, and then potentially having to give her a snack and having other children get upset about it. Perhaps if she’s not very hungry she can just eat a snack at lunch rather than nothing.

It is unlikely that she was shouted at so I would not mention this. How do you speak to her at home? Do you have a husband/partner? Is she the only/first child? The most likely situation is that she isn’t used to hearing stern tones or the louder voice needed to talk over a gaggle of young children so she calls it “shouting” when it’s not. You should probably explain the difference to her so that she knows. Single children in particular are often used to a much quieter environment at home and have a bit of culture shock when they are in a place with more children and noise.

lailamaria · 15/02/2023 19:12

once again mumsnet and their weird attitude towards teaching staff, they do get things wrong you know, they aren't perfect but apparently on here they can do no wrong

TiaI · 15/02/2023 18:15

I’d speak to the head and inform him about how your dd saw teachers treatment of boy

musicforthesoul · 15/02/2023 18:12

You probably need the opinion of other parents in the country you're in tbh
rather than predominantly UK based opinions so you can decide what the best move is.

What you've described doesn't sound great to me but you're unlikely to get very far if how you want your dd treated goes against cultural norms other parents are all happy with.

Mysmallgarden · 15/02/2023 18:10

It sounds very like the French approach to food. Children are encouraged to eat what they are given but this sounds OTT. If you're not hungry then you're not hungry, end of. It's counter productive to try and force food on anyone, and cruel to do it to a young child.
When I lived in France, the local school had a neon sign at the entrance, giving the day's menu and a list of absent teachers, in that order. Says it all really.

Eyerollcentral · 15/02/2023 18:09

I think it’s different with a small child though, they do need to eat. I’d be alarmed at the mother saying she had loads to eat least night, had she not eaten breakfast either, surely regular meals would be useful in getting the constipation issue solved? If the child has just started a French school and all the other children have been through a childcare setting where the expectations on them to eat were the same it’s going to take the OP’s daughter some time to adjust, but she will have to adjust as that’s the way they run schools. It would be more helpful for her if that were backed up at home. I also had a relative who had decades of experience as a TA and worked the breakfast club too. She told a boy one day in a non shouting voice to eat his toast as his mum had paid for it and next day parent complained he’d been shouted at. He hadn’t and your daughter was likely told rather than screamed at.

Marmunia10661975 · 15/02/2023 18:09

This happened at my primary school where we were 'forced' to eat everything. I ended up vomiting every day and having panic attacks until I was 21 when I was faced with a 'closed-in' eating situation.

Arewethereyet22 · 15/02/2023 18:06

I was just going to ask if you’re in France too? We are as well and whilst my daughters school definitely isn’t like this at lunch I’ve heard from lots of friends about upsets at cantine. In general french teachers are a lot ‘shoutier’ and stricter, although we haven’t used the Uk school system so maybe I’m wrong. If it were my child I would either take out of cantine, at least for 2 days a week if possible or speak to the teacher and explain she was upset, how you treat food and meal times and hope there is improvement. I will say though that if you’re planning on staying France a long time (if this is where you are) then you need to do some research in the french school approach.

LikeAStar1994 · 15/02/2023 17:57

All this pressure to eat lunch when you're not hungry FFS. Thie actually happened to me a couple of years ago but this was in a working environment! They started getting "really concerned" because I didn't want to eat anything Hmm

laalaaland · 15/02/2023 17:56

I can totally empathise. We spent quite a few years in a different European country. The approach to eating really went against the grain for me and was very triggering as I was forced to eat as a child. However, pp are I think correct, it is what other parents expect so the school has to be consistent. Considering your child has some digestive issues though, surely they could take a slightly gentler touch with her?

Ludo19 · 15/02/2023 17:55

Untitledsquatboulder · 15/02/2023 17:47

Tbf it's really easy to make some children cry. And lots of children here "shouting" when an adult is being strict or telling them off.

I think if constipation has got to the stage where a child is not able to eat lunch then some medical intervention is necessary. No child works or plays well on an empty stomach.

Yeah you do have a point. All children are different I just think it's sad to make a child cry for not being hungry.

parrotonthesofa · 15/02/2023 17:51

Let me guess, you are in France?

(I live in France!)

Eyerollcentral · 15/02/2023 17:49

JarByTheDoor · 15/02/2023 17:25

I guess from their point of view, it might be that the majority of parents expect staff to ensure that children eat the food that's been paid for so that parents haven't wasted their money, and so the children can pay attention through the afternoon and aren't coming out of preschool tetchy and unmanageable.

In that context, a parent who wants their child treated differently from the others, so that they're allowed to refuse lunch and go straight to the fruit instead, could feel difficult and disruptive to have to manage in among all the other preschoolers who are told that the rule is that they need to eat their lunch and then their fruit.

Yes very much this. Other European countries aren’t as indulgent of fussy eaters. As the above poster says all the children are expected to follow all the rules, they can’t make an exception for your daughter or everyone will want their own exceptions made. It’s a sensible approach.

Untitledsquatboulder · 15/02/2023 17:47

Ludo19 · 15/02/2023 17:42

She's only 4.5yrs old imagine making a child of that age week any child for that matter cry, that's gut wrenching

Tbf it's really easy to make some children cry. And lots of children here "shouting" when an adult is being strict or telling them off.

I think if constipation has got to the stage where a child is not able to eat lunch then some medical intervention is necessary. No child works or plays well on an empty stomach.

Ludo19 · 15/02/2023 17:42

*well

Ludo19 · 15/02/2023 17:42

She's only 4.5yrs old imagine making a child of that age week any child for that matter cry, that's gut wrenching

honeyytoast · 15/02/2023 17:40

Why does it sometimes feel that on mumsnet teachers can do no wrong

Makesmewanttogohome · 15/02/2023 17:34

@JarByTheDoor Yes, the not having the fruit for dessert is perhaps a grey area as I can see that being unfair if children see her having fruit but no dinner etc and they’re not allowed.
But, the shouting at her to eat and reducing her to tears if she’s not hungry isn’t on

OP posts:
Makesmewanttogohome · 15/02/2023 17:25

@Porkyporkchop Totally agree!

OP posts:
JarByTheDoor · 15/02/2023 17:25

I guess from their point of view, it might be that the majority of parents expect staff to ensure that children eat the food that's been paid for so that parents haven't wasted their money, and so the children can pay attention through the afternoon and aren't coming out of preschool tetchy and unmanageable.

In that context, a parent who wants their child treated differently from the others, so that they're allowed to refuse lunch and go straight to the fruit instead, could feel difficult and disruptive to have to manage in among all the other preschoolers who are told that the rule is that they need to eat their lunch and then their fruit.

Makesmewanttogohome · 15/02/2023 17:25

@donttellmehesalive Fair enough, but would you shout at them to eat and make them cry?
Would you withhold the only thing they did want to eat/feel like eating -a piece of fruit and tell them it was their punishment as they didn’t eat their other food? Whilst all
the other children ate their fruit?

OP posts:
Porkyporkchop · 15/02/2023 17:25

Wow. This would be a red flag to me , I’m sorry I am sure people will not agree, but I would be seriously on the war path. Children should never be force fed, and let’s be honest that is what this is. Totally unacceptable. Child could be Ill for all they know. How dare they do this to children.

donttellmehesalive · 15/02/2023 17:22

I'm a teacher and can tell you that we do get a fair number of parental complaints from people concerned that we didn't try hard enough to encourage their child to eat their lunch - because they went home hungry, or told their parents they were sad and hungry all afternoon, or because parents pay for them and are annoyed that they didn't get their money's worth.

I think your original message - that you don't mind if she doesn't eat anything - has been forgotten. I would put it in writing so that it can be shared with all midday staff.

cakeandteajustforme · 15/02/2023 17:21

I read a lot about constipation when my DS was little; the sugars in fruit can be a helpful natural way of moving things along so actually your DDs body was probably telling her exactly what she needed to eat. You could mention to the teacher that you would prefer she ate only fruit than nothing?

OopsAnotherOne · 15/02/2023 17:17

Yeah they shouldn't shout at her to eat. I'm in my 20s now but even when I was in school we had the lunchtime assistants making us finish all of our lunchbox and drink all of our drink. I remember dreading it as I wasn't always hungry enough to finish everything and being nervous about being told off actually made it worse. This ended when I was 9 though as I moved to a bigger school with less lunchtime monitoring. It's not the best way to build a healthy relationship with food but I do understand why the teachers have to do it as if the kids didn't eat, the parents wouldn't be happy with that either.

As others have suggested, contact the school and in the first instance maybe just let them know that you have no concerns if your DD doesn't always finish her food so in future she doesn't need to be made to finish her lunch? Seeing how they react to that would determine the next steps.

Swipe left for the next trending thread