Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers are taking the piss? Extended working hours.

135 replies

FrostyNethers · 15/02/2023 15:28

Looking for a new job in admin.

Many jobs are being advertised with working hours of 8am-5pm, 9am-6pm, 8.30am-5pm or even 8am-6pm!

Where are all the 9-5s which you used to see?

Its not like the pay is higher for these jobs, it’s actually low in the region of £20-25k.

I though we worked the longest hours in Europe already!

AIBU to think this is a piss take?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thecatsthecats · 16/02/2023 15:42

Blip · 16/02/2023 15:13

@thecatsthecats so good to hear!
In France the working week is 35 hours. You can work more than this but only if you take the time back via additional annual leave. The French have higher work productivity than the UK.

Tbh, I think I scare future employers by referencing this sort of thing in interviews! They think that I'm going to come and unionize their staff.

But it all came from a selfish motivation: I was sick of working in a shit company, and as soon as I got the power, I started bloody well using it to fix what I didn't like.

And it worked. These policies aren't big, clever or original. The research is all there, but I think lots of people are scared of reforms like this because they think it costs them power or authority. Since I don't care about those things, I didn't mind sharing them amongst the staff, who were all good at their jobs, and didn't need chivvying to be productive.

Sadly the PT role I took to go alongside training is also shit, but I'm only here another month!

SleeplessInEngland · 16/02/2023 15:16

In short: yes, it is a piss-take. 9-5 is a cliche precisely because it was the norm, and now it isn't - even though real wages have definitely not caught up to the extra hour.

Blip · 16/02/2023 15:13

@thecatsthecats so good to hear!
In France the working week is 35 hours. You can work more than this but only if you take the time back via additional annual leave. The French have higher work productivity than the UK.

thecatsthecats · 16/02/2023 14:43

Blip · 16/02/2023 02:38

DH company bucking the trend here has just reduced the working week from 37 to 35 hours. No pay reduction.

Our local council is trialling the four day week so has reduced hours from 37.5 to 30 for the next 12 months. Again, same pay.

For both the workload remains the same despite reduction in hours.

My findings on cutting hours from 40 to 37.5 were:

  1. A few months where the half hour back put a spring in everyone's step. They cheerfully just worked a bit faster at the same tasks, and faffed a little less.
  2. They started designing/redesigning tasks to lighten the load. It removed unneeded perfectionism in the workforce (e.g. productivity that didn't produce a meaningful, profit driven output - deckchair straightening)
  3. Because this was accompanied by other morale boosting perks (free food, office downtime, wfh and actually using employee feedback rather than filing it in the bin), about a year in, the company REALLY started ticking. Incredibly productive ideas meetings, greatly improved team relationships, and a total diffusion of discontent and burnout.

We all just about tolerated each other before, but in the end we all had a huge amount of respect for each other. After all, it's hard to be a grump when you have a greatly improved home life balance and you're well rested.

MaverickGooseGoose · 16/02/2023 08:30

I've never had 9-5. 9-530 is the lower normal. Most of our admins are 930-6.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 16/02/2023 07:56

I'm encouraged by the younger generation recognising the reality of their situation - particularly their attitude to stupid employers offering 'competitive salaries' - if they're too embarrassed to advertise it, it is anything but.

Same. More power to them!

Allblackeverythingalways · 16/02/2023 07:33

I think it would be interesting to know what normal office hours were pre war.
I know we are getting on for 100 years now, but I think a lot of people are referring to some post war golden era when there was tremendous house building, cheap social housing etc.
People could afford to be picky and take the 35 hours full time, paid lunchbeak jobs.
So office jobs were good! Even in the 80s they were great. The 90s is where they started to get worse in terms of hours, breaks and pension I think. A little job at the local council really was desirable.
I have a relative that is close to 65 now, she had a little job at HMRC in the 80s, only stayed a few years, left to have kids, never went back and still has a better pension than me 🙄

I'm still a lot better off in my 37.5, unpaid lunch job than I was working retail though.

Blip · 16/02/2023 02:38

DH company bucking the trend here has just reduced the working week from 37 to 35 hours. No pay reduction.

Our local council is trialling the four day week so has reduced hours from 37.5 to 30 for the next 12 months. Again, same pay.

For both the workload remains the same despite reduction in hours.

Johnisafckface · 16/02/2023 02:05

I’m my 30 years of employment I have never worked an 8-5 or 9-6 job until my recent job. I’ve always worked from either 7 - 3:30 (30 min lunch) or 7:30 - 4:30 (hour lunch). Now I work 8-5/9-6 (days vary) with an hour lunch. We have those hours because work across time zones so we have cover the other time zones as well.

TongueTwistr · 15/02/2023 23:29

As someone who had been working for more than a decade before I commenced my 'career', it has been interesting watching my DC start a career straight from Uni.
The biggest difference that I notice is that I had a lot less to lose from changing jobs - whether through my choice or not. Starting a career in 2023 seems to have a lot more downside, a highwire act that can end almost before it has started.
I'm encouraged by the younger generation recognising the reality of their situation - particularly their attitude to stupid employers offering 'competitive salaries' - if they're too embarrassed to advertise it, it is anything but.

Halfpint737 · 15/02/2023 23:02

I have always worked in the public sector and it was always 35 hours a week and an hour for lunch. I would never apply for 37.5 hours a week.

RosaGallica · 15/02/2023 23:00

t makes me absolutely MAD that very senior managers pat themselves on the back at having made "cost savings", and then they get a bonus for doing so. All they've done is push more work onto fewer people, who are earning less money!

Amen, and this is what upper management mean when they talk about “improving productivity”.

Coffeepot72 · 15/02/2023 22:12

Public sector, 37 hour week, hybrid, 8.30-5 Monday to Thursday, 8.30-4 on Fridays. I can never work out if lunch hour is paid or not, but this feels like a sensible working week

CurlyhairedAssassin · 15/02/2023 21:35

OopsAnotherOne · 15/02/2023 16:05

I'm a trainee professional but still doing an admin based role for a lot of the time I'm at work. I, along with everyone else in my office, do 9-5.30 for 5 days per week with an hour for lunch. The extra half an hour beyond 5pm drags the most. I'm below the £20k annual salary but the admin in the office are on above £20k but below £25k depending on their role and the general consensus from what they've said is that they don't feel they're fairly compensated for the hours they work. It's longer than a 9-5 (albeit by 2.5 hours per week, but still) and they have an ever-increasing workload and the responsibility that comes with it.

The parents in the firm also have to pay for wraparound care as at least two of them use an after school club that finishes at 5, so one has to pay for a childminder (possibly, can't remember the exact term) to pick her child up from the club and the other lady has her mother collect her child from the club.

My DM's role as what started as a secretary in a different company has, over two decades, developed and morphed into about 4 people's roles, with ridiculous amounts of responsibility and work. Her pay during that time has not increased anywhere near enough to reflect the fact that she now does the jobs of three other employees, all of whom were made redundant and not replaced so their responsibilities were passed to my DM. Her hours have also steadily increased but as she's not always given a pay increase when her hours increase, it actually decreases her hourly rate as she's getting the same annual salary for more hours.

Your mother's experience is exactly what has been going on in the workplace for the last 30 years or so. The deterioration of terms and conditions. People getting made redundant when it should only be the role that is redundant. Employers shouldn't be passing the work that still needs doing onto other people for no extra money. It's all so wrong. And as you say the young people coming in just don't know any different. They can accept it when they are young and energetic with no ties. But no-one can sustain that pace while the age of retirement gets further and further away.

It was happening when I first started work in the late 90s. People who had been there years had much better contracts. More leave, their FT hours were slightly less, at 35 hours. Pension much better.

It makes me absolutely MAD that very senior managers pat themselves on the back at having made "cost savings", and then they get a bonus for doing so. All they've done is push more work onto fewer people, who are earning less money! It's actually scandalous when you really stop to think clearly about it. But people who are approaching 50 are too scared to say anything for fear of being accused of being past it or lacking the energy and zest for the job that the youngsters can manage. You do see a lot of young people at work being taken advange of, as they want to impress and know no different. The ones who have been around a while are fed up of the bullshit corporate strategic nonsense: "initiative-itis", "cost-saving strategies", being told to "work smarter not harder" or "bring me solutions not problems". They keep schtum and just wait for retirement.

2022again · 15/02/2023 21:23

SpringFlowers87 · 15/02/2023 21:14

Interesting, I wonder if there is a (grey) line where working longer days and over your contracted hours is just expected?

I find a lot of people saying they work their contracted hours and log off at 5pm (or whenever they finish) are on lower salaries, say £20-30k? And as someone mentioned above, are these ‘jobs’ as opposed to ‘careers’ (not saying one is better than the other just noting the difference)?

I’m generally expected work work a 45-50 hour week instead of the 37 hours I’m contracted to, although my manager is flexible and happy for me to take an afternoon off for an appointment now and again so that is a good thing. And I feel like a jobsworth by clocking off at 4pm even though I could because I’m paid over £50k- but maybe I’m still a mug.

Is there a level of seniority or salary where working over your contracted hours is just expected?

I think it’s very profession specific - although I was nhs I had much more control over my hours in my profession than many nurses who frequently worked over their paid hours with no hope of ever taking it back plus barely time to eat /drink. There are certain careers where it’s culturally expected , I think law is one, hence why so many women struggle to stay in certain professions once they have kids.

thecatsthecats · 15/02/2023 21:20

It may be a norm, but it's not a competitive work offering.

I cut working hours and increased pay at my office. Great effect on productivity, loyalty, retention... It was a no brainer.

SpringFlowers87 · 15/02/2023 21:14

Interesting, I wonder if there is a (grey) line where working longer days and over your contracted hours is just expected?

I find a lot of people saying they work their contracted hours and log off at 5pm (or whenever they finish) are on lower salaries, say £20-30k? And as someone mentioned above, are these ‘jobs’ as opposed to ‘careers’ (not saying one is better than the other just noting the difference)?

I’m generally expected work work a 45-50 hour week instead of the 37 hours I’m contracted to, although my manager is flexible and happy for me to take an afternoon off for an appointment now and again so that is a good thing. And I feel like a jobsworth by clocking off at 4pm even though I could because I’m paid over £50k- but maybe I’m still a mug.

Is there a level of seniority or salary where working over your contracted hours is just expected?

Weallgottachangesometime · 15/02/2023 21:02

I don’t think it standard, or maybe it’s just the jobs I’ve had. I’ve always done 9-5 pretty much (with occasional changes for events that start or end different times).

I wouldn’t even apply for a job with these extended hours as part of the contracted hours.

BKenny87 · 15/02/2023 20:59

Work in a uni, contract is 35.5hrs a week ft. Good benefits and work/life balance.

Wotcha23 · 15/02/2023 20:57

My first job, when I was a teenager, in retail, in the 80s was definitely 9-5 with an hour for lunch and a 10 minute break in the afternoon as well. Same in NHS admin job. There’s definitely been a creeping up of hours.

RosaGallica · 15/02/2023 20:54

In practice working conditions have been badly eroded across the board in the U.K. I can remember when 9-5 with an hour off for lunch and 2 paid breaks was standard and the boomers thought they were badly wronged for having to work that. Now 8-5 with no break at all is quite normal, and the health services are having to work 12 hour shifts as standard. Zero hours contracts eroded the idea of sick pay and holiday pay.

Fools have tried to tell me in the past that we have never had more rights, but having things written down does not reality make.

Jimboscott0115 · 15/02/2023 20:46

I think it varies OP, loads of roles in my field will say something like 9-6 but ultimately my role is one where I'll work what it takes to get the job done. Some days I'm off before 5, some days I'm logged in at 7am (I rarely if ever work late) and work to 5.

Ultimately it comes down to pay and whether it's worth it in terms of working arrangements etc, I don't see a huge difference in 40 WFH or 35 in the office for example.

Artemisty · 15/02/2023 20:45

My first office job nearly 20 years ago was 8am - 6pm and paid less than £20k
Now am on a 37.5 hours a week. I've never heard of a 9-5 apart from the song. It's not the 'norm' in any of the jobs I've been in.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/02/2023 20:44

TongueTwistr · 15/02/2023 17:50

For those 23 and over, the National Minimum Wage will rise by 9.7% to £10.42 per hour. I wonder if all of those managers offering long contractual hours appreciate that?
For anyone needing to take a job under unreasonable terms, your prospective employer has discounted the rate to exclude any necessity for loyalty, be sure to give them what they're paying for.

This is definitely something to bear in mind. £10.42 x 40 x 52 is £21673 per year.

So the NMW has caught up with a lot of workers, if this is your salary, if you work more hours, your hourly rate is under the NMW so your employer will ve breaking the law after April.

Time to either ask for a pay rise, work fewer hours, or look for another job especially if your job requires more than a typical NMW job, eg qualifications or experience.

Satiredandexhausted · 15/02/2023 20:41

I'm quite a high-ish earner (higher end of the 5 figures near 6), so I guess presenteeism factors into it, but I'm useless after 7 hours truth be told and the job that got the most of out of me, asked for the least out of me in terms of hours and was very flexible and completely remote

Swipe left for the next trending thread