Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To request a new health visitor?

157 replies

Mooshmallow · 15/02/2023 13:05

I booked the soft play for my toddler and baby last night as my toddler has the week off nursery i remebered this morning the health visitor was coming so i text to let her know and asked her to come another day it was sent on imessage and i saw she read the text any way i got in the shower and she rang but i couldnt answer 10/15 mins later i heard my door and my partner answered it was her asking to come in my partner said no and reminded her i had let her know not to come today as we are going out she said she knows and began begging too come in saying she needs to see the kids my partner kept kindly saying no as we are busy ( i needed to get the kids showered after mine and we was already rushing for our booking ) i found what she did disrespectful and im confused as to why she did this she is also always judging me and asking very personal questions about my childhood and other things she even knows my biological mums name which i have never mentioned? and when i rang up to request a new health visitor i was told all the things that she is doing is what any health visitor does is this correct what is everyones opinions on this please?

OP posts:
SweetStrawberry · 15/02/2023 21:05

If the HV has concerns it's very cruel not to share them with the OP and to lie and say they have no concerns.

Also really weird people keep saying about OPs troubled past and her being in care when that hasn't been mentioned. I refer to my 'bio' father as such because he was never in my life - but my mum was. OP might have been brought up by her father. People don't half jump to conclusions.

Biscuits1011 · 15/02/2023 20:39

I would just tell them you don’t want to see the health visitor anymore unless it’s for routine development appointments. The worst they would do is report to mash, and by the sounds of it would find nothing to be concerned about so would leave you be.

Fuckityfuckfuck123 · 15/02/2023 20:38

OP, I'd agree that there must be an additional concern from the HV for them to be dedicating so much time to your family. I do say this as someone who has both been taught safeguarding which was lead by a health visitor, and as someone who sees quite a lot of my sons HV, even with mitigating factors like quite severe MH issues, and a pretty fractured family, I see less of my HV than you do yours.

Can I ask, were you in care? Was your childhood abusive? What does the HV knowing your mums name suggest? What might her opinion be of you given the link between you and your mother? ....these things are how they make a lot of their judgements on the parents they see, and support they can offer.

TBH, I can see things that might be concerns, from what you've said, you're a young mum, who when you had your first child, didn't have family nearby, your HV says you're not engaged, you cancelled an appointment at late notice to go to soft play, you then refused her access to your children when she either didn't know the appt was cancelled, or was trying to do a welfare check.

In your position, I would call the HV team, and ask if you can discuss your concerns with her manager, and how you feel, and discuss from there whether you want to change HVs or if you want to completely ditch the service. Children's centres can offer many of the same services as a HV.

Your HV should be someone that makes you feel at ease and supported, not the way you're feeling.

CoffeeWithCheese · 15/02/2023 20:30

Hankunamatata · 15/02/2023 17:46

You cancelled very last minute this morning. She may have read your message but thought it was easier to drop by.
It sounds like you have more intervention than standard HV does. Perhaps this is due to your age or personal circumstances etc.
I would try to keep and open and honest approach as anything else just raises more red flags on the system. It can be intrusive but it's best to grin and get on with it

To be fair, I work a community healthcare role and I'd be very likely have been on the road and not picked up a text message until I got to the house with that timescale. I'm fairly relaxed about it, I know people forget stuff when they're not leading very structured lives - those off work, or not working etc... and I'd be keeping an eye on the situation in case it looked like you were disengaging, versus just being "appointmented-out" (which again, I get cos it does get draining after a while).

Sounds like you're on some kind of higher level of support pathway - although she's trying to do it in a way that you're not feeling supported by. Personally I'd try taking some ownership of it politely - say that you're finding the hour long visits a bit too much when you'd like to be out and about doing things with the kids - can you drop it down to half-hour ones? Same frequency so they're still getting eyes on the children - but can cut the waffly bit down somewhat (I'm guilty of getting drawn into chatting if people have time to spare sometimes and I know I am!) Or can you alternate so you do one home visit and then one clinic one so that you're not stuck in the house waiting for her to come around and you get a bit of a change of scenery/detour for a cuppa en-route if both kids fall asleep in the pram.

Cancelling via text wouldn't bother me - it possibly will do some on MN but I know that different generations have different ways of communicating and texts are fine.

It's a pain in the arse - and it used to drive me bloody insane when my HV (who was fucking lovely) did the whole "Oh I'll be around sometime on Monday" thing - and just assumed that I'd be sat at home all day on Monday twiddling my thumbs waiting for her to get round to me! I put up with it for a while as I knew there had been a SS referral when the oldest was born, so knew being seen to engage with services was important, and when she realised that I told her I wasn't blooming waiting in all day - I'd pop down on her day at baby clinic instead - and she was fine at that (apart from moaning at me when I dared have my second - tiny age gap - when she was on annual leave!)

Notaboutyouthistime · 15/02/2023 20:18

Maybe the op's mum is known to SS and this is concern by proxy, as it were.

Boomboom22 · 15/02/2023 20:18

Sorry don't know why mn hates of. It always changes to if!

Boomboom22 · 15/02/2023 20:17

Bit they signed her off with 1 baby, she now has 2 and is only 19. It's a whole new set if circumstances that the hv has not actually signed off! And perhaps having a second child so young when she already has 1 is a bit of a flag to services that a one off at 16 isn't?

Notaboutyouthistime · 15/02/2023 20:15

Boomboom22 · 15/02/2023 20:03

If you do this and show so little insight as to why a 19yr old with 2 kids with a clearly troubled past may not be equipped to be an amazing parent just like that then expect to be referred to social services. It's not ageist, but realistic.

Without any reason to have concerns (which they don't unless they've lied) there's not a thing they can do. SS need evidence. They don't have it as they were happy to sign her off. HV isn't saying she has any concerns either. They won't suddenly be able to manufacture concerns reaching a threshold just because she's withdrawn from the service. Lessons should be learned here.

Misunderstoodagain · 15/02/2023 20:14

@Notaboutyouthistime yep agree with all you said.

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:14

HVs/ medical professionals have to make some initial judgements based on age/history etc. Unfortunately in general terms children of teenage parents have worse outcomes. Does that mean all teenage parents are bad? Of course not, but the NHS would be doing teen parents a disservice if they just ignored huge amounts of research that says there is a risk here, provide more support. This HV here sounds like she is not communicating what’s going on very well.

Misunderstoodagain · 15/02/2023 20:13

Sorry didn't see the 'biological mum' bit so will reread.
But different country is a bit dramatic, technically yes but she could still be a couple of hours from England

Notaboutyouthistime · 15/02/2023 20:12

TessoftheDubonnet · 15/02/2023 16:09

Both the factual information you have disclosed and the way you come across in this thread suggest that maybe, just maybe, the HV may be justified in having some niggling concerns

Bollocks.

She has come across as a lovely engaged mum who has the care, organisational skills and motivation to not only take her children to soft play but also book in advance. She's in a long term relationship, was signed off SS years ago and clearly has a partner who is considerate to her feelings. She's not obviously depressed (showers, gets the children out and about) and has not got stroppy despite considerable provocation.

Very few mothers would tolerate an intrusive 'talker' in their home on an almost weekly basis without explanation.

The op should be able to either address concerns or get on with raising her children.

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:10

@Misunderstoodagain - People normally only refer to their mum as their biological mum if they’ve been adopted/in foster care. It’s not a term used regularly to describe a parent you have a good, ongoing relationship with.

GoodChat · 15/02/2023 20:09

@Misunderstoodagain people are saying she had a troubled past because she had a baby at 16 and was in a different country to her whole family

Misunderstoodagain · 15/02/2023 20:08

@Boomboom22
But where does the OP say she had a troubled past?? People keep referring to her being in care or having a troubled upbringing but where is that comment exactly?
I think having a healthy 3 year old with no concerns raised, a baby with the same father who she has been with for 4 years doesn't scream issues to me.
Just because she's young doesn't give them the right to intrude and belittle her. She's an adult doing the best for her children it seems. She hasn't even asked to stop seeing them, just her right to ask for another HV instead.

ChilliBandit · 15/02/2023 20:04

I think you need to tread a bit carefully OP. I can see why you may have raised some red flags. Young parent with 2 children isolated from support who may have been in care themselves, cancelling last minute then refusing access. If they just ignored the red flags there could be hell to pay.

It sounds like this HV is not communicating with you very well and is overstepping but you need to be careful not to give any more ammunition. I would write a polite, calm email to her and her manager saying you’ve realised you are getting a lot more visits than normal, do they have any concerns and if so can you have a meeting to discuss them. Be proactive but level headed about it.

Boomboom22 · 15/02/2023 20:03

Misunderstoodagain · 15/02/2023 19:58

OP you're getting some unfair comments on here I think. It's really only in the last 30-40years 19 has been young to have children. All my mothers generation were married with children by 18 in my family. (I'm 37). I have plenty of friends who had kids straight out of school etc so your age really shouldnt be a factor.
Your HV has clearly overstepped the boundaries here. Do you have a record of all the times she has been? I would write an email to the team lead with all the times she has been there and how long for. Tell them that you find her questioning on your personal life and background intrusive and unproductive in supporting you with the health of your child. That you no longer wish to be seen by their service anymore as its not helpful or beneficial in any way.
You need to stand up for yourself here and not let them think your a push over.

If you do this and show so little insight as to why a 19yr old with 2 kids with a clearly troubled past may not be equipped to be an amazing parent just like that then expect to be referred to social services. It's not ageist, but realistic.

Misunderstoodagain · 15/02/2023 19:58

OP you're getting some unfair comments on here I think. It's really only in the last 30-40years 19 has been young to have children. All my mothers generation were married with children by 18 in my family. (I'm 37). I have plenty of friends who had kids straight out of school etc so your age really shouldnt be a factor.
Your HV has clearly overstepped the boundaries here. Do you have a record of all the times she has been? I would write an email to the team lead with all the times she has been there and how long for. Tell them that you find her questioning on your personal life and background intrusive and unproductive in supporting you with the health of your child. That you no longer wish to be seen by their service anymore as its not helpful or beneficial in any way.
You need to stand up for yourself here and not let them think your a push over.

Autumndays22 · 15/02/2023 19:50

bluelollipop99 · 15/02/2023 18:27

I'm genuinely disgusted at some of the incredibly rude replies to the OP .

As I pointed out earlier in the thread , if the OP said she was 39 and having problems with what sounds like a rude and innapropriate health visitor people would be supportive. As she's 19, people are taking glee in telling her that she must need "support" with her parenting and she's immature . Disgusting and ageist and I think MNHQ would stamp down a lot quicker if the OP was 39 instead of 19.

I agree with this. Some of the replies are coming across as very judgemental and presumptuous. A voluntary support agency is supposed to be helpful. If it is found to be unhelpful and intrusive then disengagement is the natural consequence. OP, I hope you manage to talk this through with the service for the sake of transparency on both sides

Toddlerteaplease · 15/02/2023 19:46

bussteward · 15/02/2023 13:43

You had an appointment that you cancelled last minute via text, not call, then your partner answered the door and refused entry – that kind of behaviour is what’s raising concerns.

Absolutely this. Why on earth did you prioritise soft play over a health visitor appointment. She's right to be concerned.

Hiddenvoice · 15/02/2023 19:43

My baby is 10 months old, I had regular check ins with my health visitor until my baby hit 5/6 months. Mainly due to my mental health and the fact that I was unwell during my pregnancy. I cancelled my appointment last minute one day due to being unwell. My health visitor phoned and explained thag sometimes when appointments are cancelled with short notice then they like to do a welfare check on mum and baby.
It sounds like your health visitor has some concerns. She has said you’re disengaged but she may be meaning she’s asking questions and you’re answering them differently tk what she is expecting. It also sounds like she’s using your age to keep checking in on you.
Personally I’d phone the main office and ask to speak to the manager. Raise your concerns and ask if it is appropriate for this health visitor to be trying to stop by even when she has finished work.
Could she possibly know someone who knows you and they’ve mentioned anything? I ask this since you said she knows your mums name and you’ve never brought it up.

Choconuttolata · 15/02/2023 19:41

Of course you can request a different HV if this one makes you feel uncomfortable. Find out if you are under a specialist young parents team as they will often visit more frequently and this might be why you have had more visits.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 15/02/2023 19:33

Monr0e · 15/02/2023 19:06

OP, I'm a health visitor (yeah yeah, put your pitch forks down 😎)

The amount of visits is well over and above a regular visiting schedule

In our trust we visit around day 10, again around 7 weeks then invite parents to clinic for development reviews at 9 months and 2 years. Outside if that, parents can visit clinic or contact the team direct. We are extremely short staffed, so extra visits are for those where we feel there is a need. Quite often mums mental health or feeding issues. If it was a safeguarding concern, parents are clearly informed of this. We are not an extension of social services, we don't generally do welfare checks, so if a social worker requested that, we may do it as a one off but certainly not every other week.

No, it's not great to cancel short notice, we are very stretched, however it does sound like this hv has her own agenda here that she is not being clear about. I would be asking to speak to a team leader and for a clear explanation of why you are being treated so differently. I would also point put that the service is optional, and unless they can state a clear safeguarding concern, you can decline any further contact.

Different parts of the UK have different schedules. My little one had seen the health visitor around 6/7 times by the time she was 8 months old. Certainly no safeguarding issues, nor were there any issues about her development or my mental health. NHS Scotland is very good with their health visiting service, or my health board is I should say, I don't know about others.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 15/02/2023 19:28

It was quite rude of you to have a medical appointment and then cancel it very last minute because you've booked soft play.

Alarm bells probably also rang - you cancelled very last minute so she turned up anyway as she was probably already on her way, partner was trying to prevent her from coming in to see you and the kids....I would be concerned as well if i was her. I also very much doubt she was "begging" to come in.

Respectfully, based off your posts and the information you've given along with how you seem to go about things, I'm not surprised that you're being kept a close eye on by the HV/SS.

Eyerollcentral · 15/02/2023 19:19

Mooshmallow · 15/02/2023 18:46

I never had this with my daughters health visitor and she is 3 I got a new one with my son and it’s only her that has treat me this way, I can see the majority of people are saying I must be doing something wrong but I’m not I understand i shouldn’t have cancelled but my child has just started feeling better after being Ill since last Friday and I wanted her to at least do something fun on her week off I do also work for the person who said I am wasting “ us taxpayers “ money and today was my day off also I’m sorry but I’d rather spend it with my children having a nice day than sitting in for someone that is unhelpful and sees me on a weekly basis, thank you to the people who have helped me and not judged me like some of the others it’s nice to be kind.

OP you know you could have made the booking for soft play at a time other than the appt you had for the health visitor to come. You choose to cancel her at the last minute. I’ve asked if your partner is always there and you haven’t answered. There is something that is keeping her involved with you, it’s not to give you a hard time. Your actions today are only going to cast more light on you.