Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To request a new health visitor?

157 replies

Mooshmallow · 15/02/2023 13:05

I booked the soft play for my toddler and baby last night as my toddler has the week off nursery i remebered this morning the health visitor was coming so i text to let her know and asked her to come another day it was sent on imessage and i saw she read the text any way i got in the shower and she rang but i couldnt answer 10/15 mins later i heard my door and my partner answered it was her asking to come in my partner said no and reminded her i had let her know not to come today as we are going out she said she knows and began begging too come in saying she needs to see the kids my partner kept kindly saying no as we are busy ( i needed to get the kids showered after mine and we was already rushing for our booking ) i found what she did disrespectful and im confused as to why she did this she is also always judging me and asking very personal questions about my childhood and other things she even knows my biological mums name which i have never mentioned? and when i rang up to request a new health visitor i was told all the things that she is doing is what any health visitor does is this correct what is everyones opinions on this please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NotThatoneagain · 16/02/2023 20:19

Do a subject access request to the health visiting team and that will tell you everything and what their concerns, if any are.

Languagelanguage · 16/02/2023 20:16

My concern would be that this HV is so clumsy and demanding that the op will struggle to meet her demands for time and endless meetings, triggering a safeguarding concern where there would be no concern. I think she's probably paying for the sins of her biological mother and is being viewed through a lens that has nothing to do with the way she parents. Many hvs are good but others are undermining and bossy. Perhaps the HV should be forced to articulate her concerns to SS if she really has any as they will be far too busy for pretend concerns and she'll be set free from the drama and stress of these visits.

Imo hvs natter on with conflicting advice and no regard for the child's routine and how they're interrupting it by being there. Once a year is tolerable but I would be breaking after weekly visits.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 16/02/2023 18:37

This is why I rejected a HV when mine were tiny. I didn’t need them and I don’t like how intrusive they can be. OP you don’t HAVE to have a HV. Say you no longer need their services

NumberTheory · 16/02/2023 18:33

Toddlerteaplease · 16/02/2023 02:44

@MoreSleepPleasee yes it is optional, but only on Mumsnet have I ever seen this attitude. Never in real life and am a paediatric nurse!
However there are obviously issues as the OP has had a huge amount of input. If there are safeguarding concerns then that is not optional.

If there are safeguarding concerns it’s still optional. The HV would need to forward to SS who would do a proper assessment and, if the concerns were valid, they would actually let OP know what they were so she could address them. Which would probably be better for OP than having someone tell her everything is fine but keep turning up to sit on her couch for an hour every few weeks and undermine her confidence.

You might not have seen this “if you don’t find them useful you don’t have to see them” attitude much in your work because most people who don’t want an HV just don’t engage with them much. Most places HV are so over stretched you either have to be on their radar or actively engage after the first or second visit.

Young, inexperienced mothers and those lacking in confidence often put up with HVs even though they don’t want them (like OP has done so far) because they are scared to say “no.” Often because they get told it’s voluntary unless they don’t want to, and then that will be taken as a sign they are at risk and they’ll be forced to. It’s a somewhat abusive approach to get compliance where there is no requirement.

ChilliBandit · 16/02/2023 15:23

I had the opposite of the OP, we didn’t see a HV for the first 2 years, not through lack of trying. I feel like they decided I was low risk from my notes and that was that. There was a number to ring that they never answered.

Between the midwife signing us off at 2 weeks to 2 years, not one medical professional saw my child apart from jabs with the nurse and there was a couple of GP phone appts. We went for the 2yr check which they tried very hard to put us off of even booking. They told me to make sure DC gets to be active (what toddler isn’t) and not to let them eat batteries, erm yeah… move to my area OP, the HV service seem to be allergic to work.

FourFour · 16/02/2023 15:06

I've had my second baby in this country so first experience with this whole midwife and HV thing. I found their visits to be such a nuisance and waste of time. I'm surprised that people said that they do just a few visits. We had about 6-8 visits between them. They often came when the baby was feeding or asleep and woke them up! One asked me to wake the baby up so that they can do some alert check or something. A few days old, I can't really see the need for that. It often felt like a tick bock exercise that they were doing, nothing useful at all. They wanted one more visit or for me to come to them and I turned it down. The next thing was my GP calling me all concerned and eventually got to the point of asking me to please call the HV for a final checkup. I can completely understand that this service is valuable for those who need it but for those who don't it's just a waste of time.

SpainwithouttheS · 16/02/2023 14:52

If there’s no cause for concern regarding yourself or your children then you have every right to decline the visits. The only other thing I can think of which other people have pointed out is that she knows something that you don’t. If that’s the case that’s really unfair on you.

If I was you I would contact the person above your HV & explain how she’s asking very personal questions & you’re finding her visits unproductive & unnecessary. If you haven’t anything to hide then they can’t do anything other than agree.

ChilliBandit · 16/02/2023 13:59

I think it would be unwise to decline the service altogether, although within your rights to do so. This might cause the HV service to escalate any concerns they do have. Not saying it’s right but if they have concerns and you suddenly start being uncooperative it could backfire on you. It’s all well and good for some people on here to say confront her or decline the service, they are unlikely to have been flagged as a potential concern, even if that flag is wrong on this occasion.

I would take a softer approach. Contact the general email/phone line for the HV service if possible, asking if they have concerns as you are finding the constant visits difficult to accommodate and you would rather discuss any concerns up front so you can address them. If the HV is doing something she shouldn’t, this flags it to management without you appearing difficult. Or ask for a new HV as you feel you haven’t connected with this one. I think communication here is key. Appear to be willing and open so that if there is an issue with her behaviour it shines a light on it in a non confrontational way.

mumoffpurminimes · 16/02/2023 08:41

The HV is being very inappropriate and I would make a complaint citing harassment and request a different one (or decline the service altogether if you wish). She's got a bee in her bonnet about you and won't leave you alone or respect your time and choices. Nothing you do will ever be good enough for her.

But don't think all HVs are the same.

You may well find some support helpful in your situation but clearly this woman you are finding the opposite! I'd ask for a HV who can be supportive rather than judgemental and discriminatory.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 16/02/2023 08:28

I've only read OP's post so don't know if it's already been stated but I haven't seen OP address it.

The fact that you messaged to cancel and the bell went 15 mins later indicates that it was a VERY last minute cancellation and the HV was already on her way, so you ABVU for that alone.

She probably figured she was already there she might as well come in. Surely being a bit late for a soft play session isn't an issue?

Everyonehasavoice · 16/02/2023 02:55

You are not obliged to use the services of a health visitor and they have no right to enter your house …. So just say you don’t need their services anymore.

If there were any safe guarding issues, OP would have been told of their concerns and why
The health visitor can’t keep visiting because OP isn’t engaging….she doesn’t have to engage.

If you want their services they come once a month for 6 months, although most seem to just visit the once. I never had a health visitor come to us, even with twins, just the midwife a couple of times. But I did go to the local clinic for baby weigh ins etc

Toddlerteaplease · 16/02/2023 02:44

@MoreSleepPleasee yes it is optional, but only on Mumsnet have I ever seen this attitude. Never in real life and am a paediatric nurse!
However there are obviously issues as the OP has had a huge amount of input. If there are safeguarding concerns then that is not optional.

KalvinPhillipsBoots · 16/02/2023 02:43

Mooshmallow · 15/02/2023 13:10

I also forgot to mention my baby was born in august last year and i have seen her way more than ten times already she told me that is because sometimes i can be disengaging this makes me feel as though it is mandatory when i am well aware its volountary i just dont know why im being treat this way at all.

Well you have cancelled on her so I agree with the HV, you come across disengaging. Your children's welfare comes before a play date, you are in the wrong here.

londonrach · 16/02/2023 02:33

There's concerns as that amount of input is an awful lot.

MoreSleepPleasee · 16/02/2023 02:29

Toddlerteaplease · 15/02/2023 19:46

Absolutely this. Why on earth did you prioritise soft play over a health visitor appointment. She's right to be concerned.

Why? It's an optional service.

MoreSleepPleasee · 16/02/2023 02:25

I'd be opting out of that now.

NumberTheory · 15/02/2023 23:45

From what you’ve said about your situation, I can see why an HV might think you could use more support than most people. But you clearly aren’t finding her supportive and she’s told you she doesn’t have any concerns.

So I think you should call her up and either tell her you no longer want an HV or ask for another. If she tries to put you off tell her you’ve found her visits time consuming without being at all useful and that her behaviour coming to the house after you canceled was rude, so unless she can suggest a different HV with a different approach that’s actually supportive and helpful you’ll end your engagement with the HV service and you’ll just go to the GP if you have any concerns about your DC.

Engagement with the HV service isn’t mandatory, whatever she’s said to you. She could pass on concerns to SS if she has any, but she says she doesn’t. If she threatens you with SS if you end engagement, you’re probably better off. At least that way you’ll find out what the real concerns are and have a chance to demonstrate they are unfounded. I suspect, though, that SS will be too busy to do anything more than a cursory visit if they get a referral that boils down to - “I keep going round but client doesn’t want to see me”.

One caveat I would add, though, is that HVs can be a route to support if you’re struggling. And you sound like you have little support. So if you are struggling at all, or if things are okay at the moment but they could go south at a moments notice, it might be better to try and maintain a relationship with the HV. But perhaps start making it more on your terms and tell her “No.” if she wants to come more often than you want to see her or when it’s not convenient. Ask her to leave if she’s over stayed her welcome. If she calls round when you haven’t got an appointment, call her out. Tell her to stop trying to catch you out with surprise visits, that you deserve more respect than that. Just remember - You have the power here. She has no authority at all.

user375242 · 15/02/2023 23:41

When I first read your post I thought it was very rude of you to cancel a HV appointment at all, never mind on the day and for soft play. But then when you said how often she comes, I changed my mind. This sounds deeply worrying. Either she has concerns she and she is trying to catch you out, or she has some weird interest in you for another reason. But coming weekly and staying so long is very intrusive if she is denying concerns.

I think you should either decline services, request a new HV, or start attending a local family community centre and ask her to meet you there. If you are attending a community centre regularly it will be good for you too, if she does come up with any allegations. It shows you are engaged in parenting, and are building a local support network. It also might stop her from overstepping.

sunshinenroses · 15/02/2023 23:25

If you're that annoyed by having a health visitor you don't need to prove yourself or argue with strangers on the internet, you can just go ahead and call them saying you don't need the service anymore and you would like to remove consent for anymore visits. You don't need to give them a reason.

GinIronic · 15/02/2023 23:17

The HV sounds like you are her pet project - but you are unaware if it and what her agenda is. She is not being open and transparent with you. I would email or speak to her supervisor. If the HV has genuine concerns then it is only fair that you know what they are so that you can begin to address them.

Fuckityfuckfuck123 · 15/02/2023 23:07

OK, so the HV knows your mum's name through SS, might be worth having a talk with her, because you don't know your mum yourself maybe she can enlighten you as to what she knows- this could give you a greater understanding of what the HV is thinking.

Also, quite wrongly in my view, they do assume that there are risks of certain situations repeating themselves, so your HV may be thinking if you didn't know your mum, maybe you won't know how to bond with your children without support. Has this been discussed? Have you had opportunity to explain that this isn't the case?

Do you have any support outside of your relationship?

TBH, the more I read your replies, the more I'm feeling like the HV has gone about this the wrong way with you... I wish your JV was more like mine. She turns up, has a mug of tea, gets on with whatever she needs to, answers any questions I might have, tells me to stop aiming for perfection and goes off on her merry way, no judgement whatsoever.

Eyerollcentral · 15/02/2023 22:44

Tragically though you both were without any support at 16 and 19 having babies. And you as a young mother as a result must tick boxes in terms of vulnerability as you have no other close family to rely on for help, which people typically do. No doubt you are doing a good job but the HV is just making sure you are ok. Welcome the support, it’s not an attack.

Mooshmallow · 15/02/2023 22:42

I haven’t known my mum all my life I only knew her name through my grandparents and the health visitor also knew her name I questioned it on the phone earlier and I was basically told the health visitor service work with social services

OP posts:
Mooshmallow · 15/02/2023 22:40

I live in Scotland as I was brought up by my grandparents and when my grandad died I had no where to live and my partner is from Scotland originally so we came here he has no family either due to his mum dying the rest of our families our distant people I wasn’t in care and I had a good upbringing

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 15/02/2023 21:10

Most people with happy and secure family backgrounds don’t end up living in another country on their own away from their family with a baby at age 16 on top of everything the OP has said.

Swipe left for the next trending thread