Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leave DD behind to go on holidays

137 replies

Itsybitsyminion · 15/02/2023 11:45

Just picking your brain on this one. We have a 3yo and no much family support as DH parents live in another city (we don't see them much) and my family lives abroad. DD knows well both grandparents but she's not exactly used to be left with them except for a short time. They are also on their 70s and have some mobility problems.
In conversation with a dear friend with no kids I mentioned I would love to go on holidays to Mexico but will wait a couple of years so my DD can enjoy more the experience abroad with us and handle better such a long flight. She asked me why won't I leave her behind for 7 or 10 days with grandparents? If I will never go on holidays again just with DH and enjoy ourselves? Now, I am not sure if my mind would be at rest leaving her for so long, not sure if I am ready for that, and I actually feel like holidays like this should mean making memories as a family. Is this first time mum syndrome? Am I right in not wanting to leave DD behind? Or is my friend being unreasonable because she has no idea what it is to have children?

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 15/02/2023 14:56

When the dc is older,possibly but to leave them for that long when they haven't stayed before could be traumatic for them at this very young age.
I wouldn't do it but she's your child.

IWasFunBeforeMum · 15/02/2023 14:49

I wouldn't as you say holidays are for family memories IMO

Redglitter · 15/02/2023 14:16

She asked me why won't I leave her behind for 7 or 10 days with grandparents? If I will never go on holidays again just with DH

I dont know anyone who'd leave children for that length of time. A weekend is fair enough but not a week & not that far away

You'll have years of holidays just you & your husband once your child/children are grown up

Ignore her

GloomyDarkness · 15/02/2023 14:11

IL did this - DH doesn't seem to mind now or at the time - he was left at scout camp, friends family and GP.

We did find it annoying though when they gatecrash our annual family holiday and then complained were weren't putting the kids in kids camp -so they could speed even more time wanging on about their previous decades holidays to us.

I would wait till she was older and leave her with GP she know well - but frankly holidays with kids are fun in their own ways - or I found them so - and you do have before and after their childhood to go for kid unfriendly ones.

So while we've not done this - can't really see any harm.

Abraxan · 15/02/2023 14:06

LuckySantangelo35 · 15/02/2023 13:07

all those who couldn’t abide the thought of your kids not coming on holiday for years and years…

do you not miss holidays just you and your DH?

where you’re just yourself and not a parent?

where you can go sight seeing or day drinking or scuba diving or whatever - basically adult only stuff?

no judgment, just genuinely curious!

I don’t understand and would like to?!

do you not miss holidays just you and your DH?

Not really. We had different priorities and wants when Dd was smaller. We'd had many years of holidays before Dd arrived. We still got nights/weekends free occasionally if and when we wanted them.
Dd still chooses to holiday with us as a young adult and we love having her with us.

where you’re just yourself and not a parent?

Been there and done that for years before. Had time when we could just be ourselves at home anyway.

where you can go sight seeing or day drinking or scuba diving or whatever - basically adult only stuff?

We did sight seeing with Dd anyway. She was never into just being on a beach or by the pool. We didn't really do much 'adult only' type activities much on holidays before. I guess we didn't drink so much when Dd was smaller but then didn't really do holidays involving lots of day drinking anyway. Even before Dd, I think we probably drank more back in the U.K. than we did on holidays. And once she was a little older it was easier again. We did a fiat number of holidays with family or friends when Dd was younger so childcare was a bit more shared, even when we spend the whole time together. Dd was entertained by friends her age or family members, not just us. And our holiday choices changed a little bit.

I can imagine it'd be really hard to enjoy an all inclusive beach type holiday with a toddler/young child. But we didn't really do that before or after Dd was born.

And obviously now we can do day time drinking and the likes when we've r we want. Dd just joins us. It's just a lot dearer now 😂

BurbageBrook · 15/02/2023 14:05

@StandALot so you're literally away from your kids for almost 4 percent of their life, every year? That's quite a lot!

LongRoadtoNowhere · 15/02/2023 14:03

This is probably quite silly but a couple years ago my family and I watched some home movies from when my brother and I were kids. There was some footage from a “family” holiday, except I was nowhere to be seen.

My DM then told me that I’d been left at home (although she couldn’t remember who with) as I was too young to enjoy the trip and they didn’t want to worry about me being near a pool 🙄

I’m still annoyed about it! So yeah, I’d definitely not leave my kid behind to go on holiday without them 🤣

Suedomin · 15/02/2023 14:01

I didn't go on holiday without my children until the youngest was 16. Me and DH were perfectly happy about that. We had children because we wanted a family and to spend time together as a family. Honestly there is plenty of time to do things without children when they are grown! I certainly would never leave a 3 year old for 10 days. That would be unfair on both your child and their grandparents. So no you are not being unreasonable.

Jimboscott0115 · 15/02/2023 14:01

7+ days, no I wouldn't. I always saw it as part of the deal that long holidays when you have kids become family holidays and always thought that by doing it I'd actually be actively making the kids miss out on an experience they'd get loads out of.

Long weekends/city breaks for 2/3 nights though? Yeah I think that's ok as the kids would likely be fairly bored anyway and a weekend at grandparents was good for them all.

BurbageBrook · 15/02/2023 14:00

It would be frankly weird to leave your DD with grandparents she doesn't often stay with! Poor thing would be bewildered. I don't plan on leaving my DC to go on holiday ever. One night away or a weekend, sure, but not any more than that.

SnackSizeRaisin · 15/02/2023 13:58

Swiftswatch · 15/02/2023 13:15

Otherwise…what was the point?

So you don’t do a single thing throughout the year without your children? They accompany you every second of every day?

Whats the point in having kids if you’re going to go to the gym without them? Or work? Or go on a girls night? Or go out to lunch with your mum? Or go shopping with your sister? Or go for a meal with your husbands? Or a work Christmas party?

It said in the post that she works FT so presumably kids are in childcare most of the time, certainly not glued to her side. In that scenario I can completely see that the precious 4 weeks of the year you aren't working you would want to spend with children.

Most of the things you mentioned could be done in an evening after bed time so are irrelevant

FoodieToo · 15/02/2023 13:57

Do the grandparents who have their own issues want your child for nearly 2 weeks??

SnackSizeRaisin · 15/02/2023 13:55

I think 3 is a bit young to leave for a whole week unless GP are already doing a lot of childcare. Also it depends on the GP and whether they would be completely exhausted by it.

Maybe start with a weekend and see how that goes?

My 3 year old wouldn't want to be left overnight without us yet. I am thinking when she's 4 I will try her at grandma's for a night. Obviously children differ and some would be fine at 3.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/02/2023 13:55

And those three years were the Covid years so basically you’ve not missed any time at all for child free long haul holidays so far.

MajorCarolDanvers · 15/02/2023 13:52

We are fortunate that we can afford both 'making memory family holidays' and 'adult jollies when we palm the kids off on the GPs'

You are quite reasonable to not want to leave your child. Others are also quite reasonable to leave their children with loving GPS fir an adult holiday l.

You do what's right for you. Your friend was only making a suggestion. Nothing wrong with that.

LadyHarmby · 15/02/2023 13:50

LuckySantangelo35 · 15/02/2023 13:07

all those who couldn’t abide the thought of your kids not coming on holiday for years and years…

do you not miss holidays just you and your DH?

where you’re just yourself and not a parent?

where you can go sight seeing or day drinking or scuba diving or whatever - basically adult only stuff?

no judgment, just genuinely curious!

I don’t understand and would like to?!

Yes, I would like to go scuba diving still but my desire to do that comes second to the well-being of my children. I had plenty of time to do it before they came along and will have again once they’re grown. It’s only a few short years where you put their needs before your own.

Plus I do lots of things with DH and other adult centric things that don’t involve going to Mexico for 10 days.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/02/2023 13:47

Theres a lot of middle group between Mexico for 7-10 days and never leaving dc at all. Plus they’re only three - not being ready now is hardly a case of “never again” - it’s only been three years!

A weekend in Paris or something would be more reasonable than a long haul holiday

KvotheTheBloodless · 15/02/2023 13:42

I wouldn't leave my 5-year-old for 7-10 days, but I don't think it's a bad thing for parents to do if they have a resilient child who will cope well.

If the child would be miserable or very upset then I think it's cruel, but sometimes it's a necessity due to health issues/family deaths overseas.

Newnamenewme23 · 15/02/2023 13:39

LuckySantangelo35 · 15/02/2023 13:07

all those who couldn’t abide the thought of your kids not coming on holiday for years and years…

do you not miss holidays just you and your DH?

where you’re just yourself and not a parent?

where you can go sight seeing or day drinking or scuba diving or whatever - basically adult only stuff?

no judgment, just genuinely curious!

I don’t understand and would like to?!

We don’t go on holiday very often. Budgeting for a holiday for me and dh and the kids not getting to go away feels wrong.

children can go sight seeing and scuba diving? That’s not adults only. In fact we probably do more with the kids than we would without as we book more activities- there’s quite a few things I’ve done on holiday that I’ve unexpectedly loved. Only done it because the kids wanted to, would never have thought about it just me and dh. Stuff like theme parks, water parks, boat trips, paddle boarding, excursions etc.

we don’t drink so kid don’t make a difference there.

dh and I have plenty of plans to travel when we’re older and kids have their own lives. They can come with if they choose.

it’s nice to spend time as a family as well.

honeylulu · 15/02/2023 13:31

*do you not miss holidays just you and your DH?

where you’re just yourself and not a parent?

where you can go sight seeing or day drinking or scuba diving or whatever - basically adult only stuff?*

Yes to all of that. But grandparents were never keen and I didn't want our children to go where they're not wanted. Having said that I've worked FT since they were babies so maybe my career is my chance to "be myself". Plus our kids got used to holidaying with us and are seasoned travellers now. Most of our best memories are family holidays,looking on the bright side!

anya21 · 15/02/2023 13:27

I think it could be a very traumatic even scarring espeience for your DC to be left with people whe does not really know that well.Time passes very slowly when you are young, 10 days will seem like a very long time and she wont understand where you have gone

Beseen22 · 15/02/2023 13:19

My DP wouldn't take my kids for that amount of time (50s) and I wouldn't want them to. They've never done an overnight.

I am however going away next year for DSIL big birthday and we have deliberated taking the kids as the eldests would really love it and there is plenty for them to do but decided in the end that it is a completely different dynamic of a holiday and they will be at home with their dads, will be much more affordable and we can actually speak without being interrupted for the first time in 8 years. We both are definitely the primary parents and do every school drop off pick up sick day strike day etc etc and I don't feel guilty for having a long weekend childfree.

new2mn · 15/02/2023 13:16

I also went on some holidays with my parents when I was little but tbh don't really remember them, I have zero or very faint recognition looking at pictures. I only strongly remember those magical times at my grandparents'.

new2mn · 15/02/2023 13:15

My parents did this when I was little and I have such fond memories of my time staying at my grandparents' magical place, knowing my parents were away in "grown up" or "parents" land or whatever. I think the romance/ couple time was probably good for them as well.

Swiftswatch · 15/02/2023 13:15

mybunniesandme · 15/02/2023 12:54

I wouldn't personally do it no and I'd be a bit judgy of parents who did. Just being honest there. I do work full time though and so time with my children is precious. Spare time is to enjoy them, make memories, have fun. Otherwise....what was the point?

Otherwise…what was the point?

So you don’t do a single thing throughout the year without your children? They accompany you every second of every day?

Whats the point in having kids if you’re going to go to the gym without them? Or work? Or go on a girls night? Or go out to lunch with your mum? Or go shopping with your sister? Or go for a meal with your husbands? Or a work Christmas party?