Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yet another V day thread

36 replies

AWholeNewWorls · 15/02/2023 02:25

Bear with me here.. I've been reading about lots of cynical things about hallmark events. I used to be super cynical about things like Valentine's etc. but deep down I secretly want to be spoiled and my DH to plan something cute and romantic. (In the past I have done little cute things for him, like a handmade card and baked his favourite cookies - DH prefers perishables as gifts as he has a thing about clutter/too many possessions).

Anyway, DH is generally very anti all things Vday/anniversaries because he thinks they're gimmicky etc. but like I said, I secretly just want to be surprised and spoiled. Every year I'm expectant and hopeful and every year I try and talk myself down and every year I am disappointed with DH's efforts. For example, I got a card, roses and a teddy bear this year. And I am still unhappy. I hate this about myself.. I truly do. I rationalise Valentines isn't important and to get over it.

For people who aren't into valentines, is this because a) you've always thought it was dumb or b) you've had your fill of being spoiled and now are just generally over it or c) you feel you're spoiled/in a very loving relationship already and just don't see why it's so important.

For the record DH is generally a very lovely and thoughtful husband (definitely does more than his fair share around the house, we have lovely dinners out, going on holidays etc. Perhaps I don't get physical gifts so much but he does the aforementioned list without me paying half) he just doesn't get the big deal about things like Valentine's.

I am quite nervous people will hate me for this post but I truly want to stop feeling like I'm lacking something because DH doesn't want to celebrate or make a fuss of things like Valentine's, birthdays, anniversaries etc.

OP posts:
Wildfloral · 15/02/2023 04:09

BleepBipBoop · 15/02/2023 03:14

I’d say I am B and C. My husband tells me how much he loves me every day and he shows me in a million ways like sorting out all of my/our paperwork and bills, bringing me ice cream in bed, taking my car for its MOT, getting up early with the kids when it’s clearly my turn, being patient and kind with me when I screw up. Because of that I have no desire for him to spend our money on ridiculous “romantic” gestures. He is out of town today and I got a flower delivery, which surprised me because he knows I don’t like spending money on something that is trash in a week. It turned out he had gotten a really nice plant that will last for years. The fact that he knew exactly what I wanted is the best gift.

Wow, your husband sounds lovely. He does so many things for you! You are very lucky, I can see why don't need Valentines Day. I think I would be the same way if I was with someone lovely like your husband.

Wildfloral · 15/02/2023 04:04

AWholeNewWorls · 15/02/2023 02:25

Bear with me here.. I've been reading about lots of cynical things about hallmark events. I used to be super cynical about things like Valentine's etc. but deep down I secretly want to be spoiled and my DH to plan something cute and romantic. (In the past I have done little cute things for him, like a handmade card and baked his favourite cookies - DH prefers perishables as gifts as he has a thing about clutter/too many possessions).

Anyway, DH is generally very anti all things Vday/anniversaries because he thinks they're gimmicky etc. but like I said, I secretly just want to be surprised and spoiled. Every year I'm expectant and hopeful and every year I try and talk myself down and every year I am disappointed with DH's efforts. For example, I got a card, roses and a teddy bear this year. And I am still unhappy. I hate this about myself.. I truly do. I rationalise Valentines isn't important and to get over it.

For people who aren't into valentines, is this because a) you've always thought it was dumb or b) you've had your fill of being spoiled and now are just generally over it or c) you feel you're spoiled/in a very loving relationship already and just don't see why it's so important.

For the record DH is generally a very lovely and thoughtful husband (definitely does more than his fair share around the house, we have lovely dinners out, going on holidays etc. Perhaps I don't get physical gifts so much but he does the aforementioned list without me paying half) he just doesn't get the big deal about things like Valentine's.

I am quite nervous people will hate me for this post but I truly want to stop feeling like I'm lacking something because DH doesn't want to celebrate or make a fuss of things like Valentine's, birthdays, anniversaries etc.

Hey I totally understand you, as I feel very similar about Valentines. I never cared before. Now I'm married I care and I'm not sure why it matters now. My husband never meets my expectations on any special day, birthday, Christmas, Valentines. These are just days where, no matter how much a lower my expectations, I still get hurt. I usually bring it up a few days later, we have a falling out, and he ends up promising clearly that he understands these things are important to me, but the next year he fails again.

Can I ask, did he initially give you any gifts for special occasions when you first started dating?

Because my husband didn't. If he'd given me chocolates on Valentines year 1 I'd have been over the moon, and flowers on Valentines 2 I'd have been stoked... a Teddy on Valentines 3...and so forth... even up to the whole lot (like you got today) on Valentines 6 or 7... then by now I would be sort of okay if this year all he did was give me a card and cook me dinner.

But I'm guessing he never gave you these small gifts early on in the relationship?

And that is why despite getting a lot of proper typical gifts today, it still feels empty. It feels like it's too little, too late. Let me know if I am off the mark here.

I got my first ever box of chocolates tonight, heart shaped, just like in the movies... after six years of hinting and outright saying this makes me feel loved etc ...but it just felt vacant. Because after all the hurt and let downs over the years (like giving him gifts at the restaurant for him to vacantly stare back at me and tell me he got me nothing...) I felt like I deserved balloons, dinner out and poetry or a trip to Paris in a helicopter and jewellery haha.

So I know people will say what you're saying is shallow or something, but it's to do with his thoughts behind it. And the years of actions or inactions behind it. And you know your husband best, and whether it was a lazy stab at making you happy or if it was actually legitimately sweet. Trust your instincts.

I really do think people who miss out on romance/gift-giving early on in a relationship, get permanently hurt. True gifts can be handmade, poems, songs, seashells... as well as bought items - cheap or expensive - so long as they are thoughtful, considered and planned..... However only grand gestures or large expenses or exceptionally sweet or thoughtful gifts can make up for the years of neglect if you never get this kind of attention in the beginning.

Sorry for the ramble.

CharlotteRose90 · 15/02/2023 03:43

For me I don’t believe in it as it’s a made up holiday for people to buy overpriced gifts. If you really love your partner show them all year round not just one stupid day.

emptythelitterbox · 15/02/2023 03:40

I'm also curious about what you'd really like done for valentine's day?

I suspect the people who say they hate it were influenced by a parent, or were disappointed, shamed, humiliated, or embarrassed in some way by someone at some point in their life.

Donotgogentle · 15/02/2023 03:33

Sparklingbrook · 15/02/2023 03:31

I just feel that it’s for teenagers/young people. Had loads of fun at school trying to guess who cards were from etc.

I wouldn’t appreciate cut flowers or teddies or chocolates or any other Valentine’s cliche gifts or supermarket meal deals after 20+ years of marriage.

He buys me gifts at other times, and is a very thoughtful husband in loads of ways all year round.

I’m not sure what the problem is as you got cards and gifts?

But yes, when I was single I loved getting cards.

Donotgogentle · 15/02/2023 03:32

I’m option A tbh. I think it’s materialistic BS and you don’t need to buy stuff to show you love your partner.

Sparklingbrook · 15/02/2023 03:31

I just feel that it’s for teenagers/young people. Had loads of fun at school trying to guess who cards were from etc.

I wouldn’t appreciate cut flowers or teddies or chocolates or any other Valentine’s cliche gifts or supermarket meal deals after 20+ years of marriage.

He buys me gifts at other times, and is a very thoughtful husband in loads of ways all year round.

I’m not sure what the problem is as you got cards and gifts?

BleepBipBoop · 15/02/2023 03:14

I’d say I am B and C. My husband tells me how much he loves me every day and he shows me in a million ways like sorting out all of my/our paperwork and bills, bringing me ice cream in bed, taking my car for its MOT, getting up early with the kids when it’s clearly my turn, being patient and kind with me when I screw up. Because of that I have no desire for him to spend our money on ridiculous “romantic” gestures. He is out of town today and I got a flower delivery, which surprised me because he knows I don’t like spending money on something that is trash in a week. It turned out he had gotten a really nice plant that will last for years. The fact that he knew exactly what I wanted is the best gift.

MavisMcMinty · 15/02/2023 03:05

Poor guy - he doesn’t believe in Valentine’s Day but has learnt enough about you to get you traditional presents and cards, etc., and you’re still dissatisfied? Sheesh. You sound very lucky to me, give yer head a wobble.

Bootsandbooks · 15/02/2023 03:04

What is your definition of making a fuss or being spoiled? Would you want an expensive dinner? Jewellery? A holiday? What he got you seems sweet and thoughtful.

Donotgogentle · 15/02/2023 03:00

Hold on a minute, your DH got you a card, teddy bear and roses this year. In what way is that your DH not celebrating Valentines?

I don’t understand. It sounds like you’ve lost sight of what’s important.