Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yet another V day thread

36 replies

AWholeNewWorls · 15/02/2023 02:25

Bear with me here.. I've been reading about lots of cynical things about hallmark events. I used to be super cynical about things like Valentine's etc. but deep down I secretly want to be spoiled and my DH to plan something cute and romantic. (In the past I have done little cute things for him, like a handmade card and baked his favourite cookies - DH prefers perishables as gifts as he has a thing about clutter/too many possessions).

Anyway, DH is generally very anti all things Vday/anniversaries because he thinks they're gimmicky etc. but like I said, I secretly just want to be surprised and spoiled. Every year I'm expectant and hopeful and every year I try and talk myself down and every year I am disappointed with DH's efforts. For example, I got a card, roses and a teddy bear this year. And I am still unhappy. I hate this about myself.. I truly do. I rationalise Valentines isn't important and to get over it.

For people who aren't into valentines, is this because a) you've always thought it was dumb or b) you've had your fill of being spoiled and now are just generally over it or c) you feel you're spoiled/in a very loving relationship already and just don't see why it's so important.

For the record DH is generally a very lovely and thoughtful husband (definitely does more than his fair share around the house, we have lovely dinners out, going on holidays etc. Perhaps I don't get physical gifts so much but he does the aforementioned list without me paying half) he just doesn't get the big deal about things like Valentine's.

I am quite nervous people will hate me for this post but I truly want to stop feeling like I'm lacking something because DH doesn't want to celebrate or make a fuss of things like Valentine's, birthdays, anniversaries etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wildfloral · 16/02/2023 03:56

AWholeNewWorls · 15/02/2023 09:14

You articulated this really well and I never really thought about it from that perspective. We had a difficult start of the relationship. I don't really want to get into it because DH is so different now. But when we met, I'd been single for 5 years and so I suppose was looking forward to all the stereotypical relationship things. But DH lived abroad for work and whenever we would meet he would combine seeing his mum and siblings the same time as me so we would meet with his family 70% of the time. And I so badly just wanted it to be us two alone. For my 30th I organised a weekend away because I was so worried we'd end up hanging out with his mum. He had promised we would do something that weekend but really nothing was planned and it would have been spent with his family so I very last minute had something booked in. I didn't get any little gifts that I felt were thoughtful. Eg. He came back from a business trip and gave me a travel pillow (he said he got me one because I already had one and I liked them..?) And I never received flowers and I absolutely love flowers and will treat myself to flowers from the florist maybe every other month. He always gets me very frazzled looking limp bunches from the supermarket. I have tried to explain to him it's a bit like a packet of digestives Vs some freshly made biscuits from a bakery ...I don't know

For those who said I never communicated, I kind of had.. I'm in my third trimester with our first DC and I said if we could sort of cram in as much couple time as possible in the 6 weeks before my due date because we'll probably have less time for each other once baby is here and I said specifically about doing something special yesterday. We worked from home and in the day he said we were going out in the evening. When work finished he said work wanted him to do more work but he said he was busy. He then asked if I wanted to come out with him because he hadn't had a chance to pick up a card and flowers and maybe we could get dinner somewhere. I asked where we were going for dinner so I knew how dressed up I needed to get and he said nowhere was booked. I guess I just got hopeful that he had thought about it but it felt it was a last minute afterthought despite saying things in the day that made me feel like he had given it thought. And with respect to the teddy bear, I too am not a fan of clutter, I just wanted something that I felt had some thought put into it. I haven't had a teddy bear since I was a child and it was some tat from Clinton's. I just wanted him to think how it's our last one together and how it would have been nice for it to be special.

Anyway, I feel so pathetic right now. Genuinely not a humble brag whoever said that. I feel so utterly worthless sometimes. I just wanted to feel like he thought about me but who even am i. I am grateful for the things he did. And appreciate I have lots complete perspective of everything.

I get the impression you are quite clear on your expectations and desires for special occasions, and that he is a flake. It is so familiar. I hate hate hate it when you said he told you you were going out for Valentines, and then acted bamboozled when you asked what he had booked. He just expected you to suggest or assist last minute. That hurt me too.

My husband is just like this. I have done so much reading on this type of person. Look into the passive aggressive husband.

You can be super clear and straight with your expectations and they will still 'fail' by feigning ineptitude. It's also a complete turnoff to receive gifts you asked for. I never give lists for presents... it's not authentic and I really feel these men are adults who can use their brains to observe their beloved wife, here and there, to figure out if she wants or needs something.

I had the same thing this year... my husband took me to jewellery stores a week or so ago and had me point to things I liked and almost bought me some earrings... then backpedalled. I let him do this, thinking he had remembered Valentines Day was in a couple of days and he should 'save' this gift for then. He had also told me a few weeks ago he bought me some lingerie (which he has not done before) and I said 'oh gosh where is it?' And he was all like 'oh I should've said, it's for later'... and I once again let him get away with this thinking he's just an silly billy who can't keep a secret for Valentines Day.

But then Valentines comes and I try to keep my chin up til like 10pm when I literally have to ask when am I getting the lingerie? He just vaguest out... I didn't even press. I mean, I am disappointed so often, it is what I expect. But it still makes me cry and feel angry all night. I really wish I could get over it, but I think I need to accept the truth which is that men like my husband just don't care about what would truly make me happy.

Like you said, you love real flowers. You would probably die if he went midnight flower stealing and brought you back the best bouquet or stolen garden roses rich in heady perfume... just so you didn't have shitty petrol station ones.

Why would you call yourself a brat? You're not. I bet you put lots of efforts to make things nice for him? And I bet he has told you that you are a brat, when you got upset to receive one of his thoughtless gifts?

It hurts when your loved one isn't listening to what you say, and doesn't seem to want to know you.

Suedomin · 15/02/2023 10:48

I think valentine's day is ok for young people/teenagers who want to send an anonymous cars or gift to someone.This is what it used to be.

But I don't like it for established couples. It's just ridiculously commercial and an excuse to spend money. If you love someone you don't need a special day to say it when expectations are impossibly high.

Wishimaywishimight · 15/02/2023 10:40

I always get quite irritated at the somewhat pompous sounding posts; "my dh and I show that we love each other every day, we don't need a Hallmark holiday..." etc etc.

It's possible to have both you know!

DH and I are loving and affectionate through the year, we do nice things for each other regularly, book surprise dinners, nights away etc. However, on 'Hallmark' days such as birthdays, anniversary, Valentines Day, we do celebrate these too - we got each other cards, had a nice takeaway, a bottle of champagne, we got each other our favourite chocolates. These days are just a bit of fun, a few hours / day out of the ordinary routine of things. Life can be very routine, why not take the opportunity to make some days a little different.

Next week we'll be doing pancakes for dinner 😀

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 15/02/2023 10:26

I get where you're coming from. You put it far better in your update.
Occasions like VD are important to me to be marked. I'm not the type to post all over social media but feel DH understands what I want/need from special days.
Yesterday I came down to a bouquet of red roses and a card. I'd be surprised if I didn't and was happy with that but what gave me the warm feeling was I'd been cleaning the oven the day before and left all the shelves in soak sealed in a bag of toxic stuff. When I went into the kitchen he'd cleaned them all and put the oven back together. After thirty years that he still wants to be make life easier and be thoughtful. I think this is the sentiment I you're after.

Donotgogentle · 15/02/2023 09:49

That makes much more sense OP. I remember feeling so vulnerable in my third trimester and it sounds like you could do with more attention and support from your DH.

AWholeNewWorls · 15/02/2023 09:14

Wildfloral · 15/02/2023 04:04

Hey I totally understand you, as I feel very similar about Valentines. I never cared before. Now I'm married I care and I'm not sure why it matters now. My husband never meets my expectations on any special day, birthday, Christmas, Valentines. These are just days where, no matter how much a lower my expectations, I still get hurt. I usually bring it up a few days later, we have a falling out, and he ends up promising clearly that he understands these things are important to me, but the next year he fails again.

Can I ask, did he initially give you any gifts for special occasions when you first started dating?

Because my husband didn't. If he'd given me chocolates on Valentines year 1 I'd have been over the moon, and flowers on Valentines 2 I'd have been stoked... a Teddy on Valentines 3...and so forth... even up to the whole lot (like you got today) on Valentines 6 or 7... then by now I would be sort of okay if this year all he did was give me a card and cook me dinner.

But I'm guessing he never gave you these small gifts early on in the relationship?

And that is why despite getting a lot of proper typical gifts today, it still feels empty. It feels like it's too little, too late. Let me know if I am off the mark here.

I got my first ever box of chocolates tonight, heart shaped, just like in the movies... after six years of hinting and outright saying this makes me feel loved etc ...but it just felt vacant. Because after all the hurt and let downs over the years (like giving him gifts at the restaurant for him to vacantly stare back at me and tell me he got me nothing...) I felt like I deserved balloons, dinner out and poetry or a trip to Paris in a helicopter and jewellery haha.

So I know people will say what you're saying is shallow or something, but it's to do with his thoughts behind it. And the years of actions or inactions behind it. And you know your husband best, and whether it was a lazy stab at making you happy or if it was actually legitimately sweet. Trust your instincts.

I really do think people who miss out on romance/gift-giving early on in a relationship, get permanently hurt. True gifts can be handmade, poems, songs, seashells... as well as bought items - cheap or expensive - so long as they are thoughtful, considered and planned..... However only grand gestures or large expenses or exceptionally sweet or thoughtful gifts can make up for the years of neglect if you never get this kind of attention in the beginning.

Sorry for the ramble.

You articulated this really well and I never really thought about it from that perspective. We had a difficult start of the relationship. I don't really want to get into it because DH is so different now. But when we met, I'd been single for 5 years and so I suppose was looking forward to all the stereotypical relationship things. But DH lived abroad for work and whenever we would meet he would combine seeing his mum and siblings the same time as me so we would meet with his family 70% of the time. And I so badly just wanted it to be us two alone. For my 30th I organised a weekend away because I was so worried we'd end up hanging out with his mum. He had promised we would do something that weekend but really nothing was planned and it would have been spent with his family so I very last minute had something booked in. I didn't get any little gifts that I felt were thoughtful. Eg. He came back from a business trip and gave me a travel pillow (he said he got me one because I already had one and I liked them..?) And I never received flowers and I absolutely love flowers and will treat myself to flowers from the florist maybe every other month. He always gets me very frazzled looking limp bunches from the supermarket. I have tried to explain to him it's a bit like a packet of digestives Vs some freshly made biscuits from a bakery ...I don't know

For those who said I never communicated, I kind of had.. I'm in my third trimester with our first DC and I said if we could sort of cram in as much couple time as possible in the 6 weeks before my due date because we'll probably have less time for each other once baby is here and I said specifically about doing something special yesterday. We worked from home and in the day he said we were going out in the evening. When work finished he said work wanted him to do more work but he said he was busy. He then asked if I wanted to come out with him because he hadn't had a chance to pick up a card and flowers and maybe we could get dinner somewhere. I asked where we were going for dinner so I knew how dressed up I needed to get and he said nowhere was booked. I guess I just got hopeful that he had thought about it but it felt it was a last minute afterthought despite saying things in the day that made me feel like he had given it thought. And with respect to the teddy bear, I too am not a fan of clutter, I just wanted something that I felt had some thought put into it. I haven't had a teddy bear since I was a child and it was some tat from Clinton's. I just wanted him to think how it's our last one together and how it would have been nice for it to be special.

Anyway, I feel so pathetic right now. Genuinely not a humble brag whoever said that. I feel so utterly worthless sometimes. I just wanted to feel like he thought about me but who even am i. I am grateful for the things he did. And appreciate I have lots complete perspective of everything.

OP posts:
JimHensonWasAGenius · 15/02/2023 08:44

Well seeing as you havn't told us randoms on the internet exactly what you DO want, how is the poor sod you are married to supposed to know?

Unless of course you are married to Zoltan.

BreviloquentBastard · 15/02/2023 08:07

For us it's because it's really for kids/teens. When I was younger the whole point of it was a fun, sweet day for kids to tell their crush they like them in secret. Husband and I do "dim sum day" instead on V-Day, which is exactly what it sounds like. We pig out on Dim Sum and watch a film.

I think my issue with this post is that you "secretly" want to be spoiled and are consistently let down. Unless your husband is Mystic Meg this is really unfair. He can't read your mind and unless I've misread, you're annually disappointed in him without ever actually communicating what you want from him.

Poor man is actually making an effort, and what he's bought you is traditional Valentine's day fodder, so he's obviously trying. All this "Valentine's day is stupid and I'm so cynical (but actually I really want to celebrate it)" nonsense is so childish. Pick a lane, communicate with your husband like a grown up for heaven's sake. Real life is not a rom com.

CrystalCoco · 15/02/2023 08:06

Can you explain what exactly your DH would have to do for you to feel like he'd made an appropriate effort? A card, flowers and a teddy are not enough?
Or is this a humble brag....

I don't really care about Valentine's Day as we celebrate our wedding anniversary each year and that's a more personal date to mark. Before I got married I would have liked a card and maybe dinner or flowers but it doesn't feel necessary now.

BoringLittleMe · 15/02/2023 08:04

I don't care about Valentines Day. It's not a special day, it's just been designated by the card manufacturers. A more meaningful date is our wedding anniversary.

But DH and I show we love each other all the time in small ways; odd little gifts, coffee or tea in bed, helping with a household task, just saying how much the other is appreciated or loved, stuff like that.

We have never and will never swap cards and gifts on Valentines Day. And I'm not bothered.

The fact you got three gifts and you're still not happy... That's a bit odd. What were you expecting? Diamonds and champagne? Why do you feel that your DH needs to buy you things on 14th February to show he loves you? Why does it matter?

TheChosenTwo · 15/02/2023 08:03

I’m more b and c if anything. It’s not that I think Valentine’s Day is dumb and anyone who celebrates it is a moron but it’s quite clearly a day targeted at people buying ‘stuff’. Who really needs more ‘stuff’?
dh came home with flowers and my favourite vodka and had booked me and paid for a hair appointment a couple of weeks ago because he knew I’d been feeling low and all the cuddles in the world hadn’t quite fixed it. He did the next best thing he knew and went for the material possessions route. It was very sweet and thoughtful and not done just because it was a certain date. That’s how he shows love, kindness and thought throughout the year. Consumables are good for me because i too hate anything I deem to be unnecessary clutter.
move on from this, it’s not important, he did what he thought was a nice low key thing on a day that we are told to.

Logburnerperils · 15/02/2023 07:59

But he did get gifts and a card so 90% of the previous posts / love language is totally irrelevant.
The post is about an ungrateful person and how they stop being so.

Zola1 · 15/02/2023 07:59

I don't really care about valentines day that much, my partner always gets me a thoughtful card and a nice message with some flowers.
An ex always used to go all out, fancy dinner and expensive jewellery or shoes etc which was nice!

IndiaDreamer · 15/02/2023 07:56

I am so confused....

thebear1 · 15/02/2023 07:42

DH and I buy each other a card and I'm happy with that because he's lovely all the other days of the years. Like a previous poster he does lots of things that show me he loves me. I'm sure I read something about love language and people have different ones. Perhaps yours is gestures such as gifts on valentines.

MichelleScarn · 15/02/2023 07:41

So he doesn't like the cluttery type of presents and in the past you've made him stuff.
What did you do this year for him? Where have you booked to take him to spoil him?
Or do you think V day is only about you getting spooled and gifts?

MelaniesFlowers · 15/02/2023 07:39

YABU. It sounds like you want a big fuss and are expecting your DH to be a mind reader and just know that.

You need to tell him.

WeWereInParis · 15/02/2023 07:39

I'm mainly option a, but I do think that it's bollocks when people say "oh I hate Valentine's Day, you don't need commercialised nonsense to show you love someone" but then they do nothing throughout the year to show they love their partner either. That doesn't sound like it applies to your partner though OP.
We just do cards, because I do like to write how much he means to me. But we don't do gifts or a fancy meal etc because it's just not really us. And because of how DH treats me generally, I wouldn't feel unappreciated or unloved because he hasn't got me a Valentine's Day present, and I hope he wouldn't either.

MadamOracle · 15/02/2023 07:35

This is a classic example of you not communicating your wants and then being disappointed when your DH fails to magically read your mind.

-You know he’s not fussed about Valentine’s Day.
-You’ve spoken cynically about such events in the past - presumably to him?
-Despite this he got you a card and 2 presents.
-But you are upset because you haven’t been ‘spoiled’.
-What does being spoiled look like to you? A weekend away? A meal out? Tickets to a show? A more expensive present?
-In the real world, people don’t suddenly become telepaths, even if they love their partner very much. If you would like to have a fuss made about Valentine’s Day when you have previously been not bothered you will either a) have to say something or b) continue to be disappointed when your DH fails to guess your ‘secret’ desires.

Weallgottachangesometime · 15/02/2023 07:34

I’m not into valentines because, like your DH, I hate being given clutter and crap. I even hate cards and can’t wait to get rid of them after my birthday. They just seem pointless.

m However I appreciate someone doing something genuinely kind for me, something that they’ve done because they know I will like it. However I like that at any point not just because it’s 14th Feb.

I don’t think you are unreasonable to feel how you do. It’s just how you feel. Maybe explicitly tell your partner this though. So he knows. Is he generally thoughtful or not? I wonder if this is a valentines specific thing or a year round need you have for being cared for/spoiled more.

Binfluencer · 15/02/2023 07:33

Well I'd have felt incredibly infantilised receiving a cuddly toy, so YANBU to be annoyed about that.

Lkydfju · 15/02/2023 07:31

This is a bit of a different answer but I know someone who does huge gestures for the women in his life on Valentine’s Day and I’ve always thought I wish my DH did things like that then this year I found out the same man also constantly cheats on girlfriends and for some reason that broke the spell of wishing this for me.
I now take a lot more enjoyment in the little things DH does for me each day liking making me a cup of tea before he leaves for work while I’m getting up and other little things

Edwardandtubbs · 15/02/2023 07:30

I hate both Valentine's and Mother's Day and I 'qualify' for both. I used to work in a big chain greeting card shop and Mother's Day was their biggest money maker followed by Valentine's (yep even over Christmas).
We had it hammered home to us that the point of both these occasions was to maximise profit. We even had strategies to make more money from the men people who'd left it til the last minute and so would buy whatever was left in the shop.
For me, it is commercialised nonsense and if anything I'll give DH a home made card for V day but it usually passes without so much as a comment in our house!

KangarooKenny · 15/02/2023 07:14

YABVU.
We don’t do valentines because it’s commercialised crap. As an adult I wouldn’t want a teddy bear, and a plant is better than cut flowers.

Sweetener12 · 15/02/2023 07:10

I think YABU, because what he did was lovely and if you had some specific expectations you should've communicated them clearly. Maybe there is a difference between your love languages, but this can be worked through by communication. My DH knows I'm not good at creating romance and stuff and a smartshow 3d slideshow with photos is the most romantic thing I could get myself to create, but we discussed it to learn our differences. Anyway, I'm sorry you feel like you're lacking something, you're dedinitely not, it's just differences in your love languages that don't define your worth whatsoever.