Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of MH problems

82 replies

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 00:38

I’m not so inconsiderate that I don’t believe they exist but it seems that nearly everyone I meet has mental health problems, I was married to a man that was in the forces & he seriously suffered from PTSD but now it seems that everyone & his wife has depression/anxiety/PTSD/ADHD & I honestly feel it’s all self diagnosed

OP posts:
Hope551 · 15/02/2023 04:39

I think it's multiple reasons.

  1. It was probably prevalent throughout history but hidden. Those that were noticed were locked away in asylums, or ostracised so they would just disappear. Therefore people didn't know and it wasn't recorded.
  1. There is a lot of trauma in the world. Abuse, war, poverty. Oddly enough there doesn't seem to be much protection. Most abusers don't fear police anymore, someone attacks you and they generally get away with it. Unless there is video evidence or a clear cut case there isn't much justice, even if there is it's a lengthy court case. So victims live in fear. In history other people would defend you and you'd get some sort of protection. In this society self defence isn't really allowed. So I can see how ptsd is prevalent not just in veterans.

Anxiety, we have a very hardcore pace of life. Esp for women who use to only focus on family, now have to do that whilst running a home and financially providing for their family. In history a home was generally guaranteed, either left by family or easy to obtain, now most people who work even have to fight not to be homeless, that's anxiety provoking. I think life is just so complicated that most adults are in constant fight or flight mode. We don't have each other's back like in communities so most people are completely on their own and loneliness is not great for humans who I think are like pack mentality animals.

I guess if we are going against our natural instincts constantly somethings going to mess up and perhaps it's our minds 😬

LazyDaisy89 · 15/02/2023 04:35

Ugh. As someone who struggles SO much with my mental health, I really, really hate people who say stuff like this. Speaking out and admitting to having MH issues is SO hard and it’s so distressing and worrying and just horrible in every way to know that some people - people like you - will just be rolling your eyes and assuming it’s fake or some kind of weird lie. I hate this so much. It makes me feel like I can’t be open or honest about my struggles for fear of being ridiculed. Try to be sensitive. MH isn’t a competition.

Cuppasoupmonster · 15/02/2023 04:29

Actually as somebody who has been a psychiatric inpatient, YANBU.

I’m tired of hearing about it too. I told close friends and family when I was in hospital but that was it - I didn’t feel the need to do an ‘okay not to be okay’ Instagram post, or some kind of ‘raising awareness’ type thing when I was out.

Normal feelings have now been pathologised so being nervous is ‘anxiety’, being sad is ‘depressed’ - everyone seems to think anything more than a fleeting moment of discomfort warrants a diagnosis and medication.

I was glad at one point that stigmas were being broken but now I feel we’ve gone beyond that, my social media news feeds are just rammed with navel gazing nonsense and much less humour than they used to be. This obsession with introspection is really irritating and actually makes me feel worse, sometimes all you want to do is be distracted and have normal conversations or jokes yet everything is so serious and revolves around ‘mental health’

emptythelitterbox · 15/02/2023 03:53

There are some who pretend to have something for attention, because they think it's edgy or trendy, to get out of doing something, to get money.

Then there are those who truly have issues and it's obvious, but they deny it and refuse to do anything about it.

It's fairly easy to tell the difference after spending time with them.

The stigma is still very real and I can truly only count on hotlines and professionals the times I spiraled out of control.

GemmaFoster · 15/02/2023 03:52

Totally agree OP. Everyone has a physical health & a mental health. But a serious mental health illness is very different from the normal ups and downs of how you are feeling mentally. In the same way that having a serious physical illness is different from having normal aches & pains. I take anti anxiety medication but I don’t see myself as having a mental health illness - in the same way I might take ibuprofen for a sore back after too much gardening. Having seen my son critically ill with psychosis and then bipolar I find it frustrating when the ‘mental elf’ gets wheeled out so frequently.

echt · 15/02/2023 03:41

bonzaitree · 15/02/2023 03:29

OP you’re wrong. Soz.

educate yourself.

So unhelpful.

CharlotteRose90 · 15/02/2023 03:41

You know what I was all ready to disagree with you but I actually agree with you. People bring out the mental health card in some circumstances to excuse shitty behaviour. Or people will see someone explain that they have it and explain symptoms and automatically think they have it too. Honestly it’s a joke. I’ve had to fight for the treatment for my diagnosed conditions and people think they can just lie .

keeprunning55 · 15/02/2023 03:37

I think there are varying levels of MH illnesses and I agree that many use the words associated with them flippantly.
I have diagnosed PTSD and I’m having treatment for it. I have only told my close family because I know others won’t understand the seriousness of it and impact on my life, which will make me feel even worse than I do.

RenegadeMasterx · 15/02/2023 03:35

I have bipolar (type 2) after being on antidepressants and mood stabilisers from the age of 16 (I'm now 28) properly diagnosed by a psychiatrist.
I think the problem is.. we're in some sort of phase where it's edgy or trendy to have a mental illness which I think is absolutely terrifying. I've come across so many TikTok videos recently of people saying if you have these symptoms, you have ADHD. I, and most my household tick every box... but I know of people with diagnosed ADHD and we do not even compare!
Anxiety is a common feeling and I'd be worried if no one ever felt or experienced it. It's only a problem when it's continuous and you feel it for no specific reason, and it starts to take control of your daily life.
I don't know what I'm saying here, it's not that I don't 'believe' people have these problems of course I do. But I can see where OP is coming from, suddenly there's an enormous influx of it I think, and self diagnosing mental health illnesses is not cool (and most people who have them will never shout about them, barely anyone I know knows I have bipolar as I hate it).

bonzaitree · 15/02/2023 03:29

OP you’re wrong. Soz.

educate yourself.

icefishing · 15/02/2023 03:28

ADHD isn't a mental health problem if that helps?

Fifi00 · 15/02/2023 03:18

I work within MH and I think it's fantastic the stigma is somewhat eroding for some MH conditions. Sadly the more serious ones like Schizophrenia and personality disorders still have stigma. I'd say there's more people saying they have depression/anxiety but it's minor . I had my first serious episode of endogenous depression at the age of 12 I couldn't really get out of bed and I had to be hospitalised. I don't really get offended by people saying they are depressed the erosion of stigma has really helped.

Overthebow · 15/02/2023 03:13

Yes I agree with you op. It makes it harder for those of us with diagnosed conditions to be understood. Those saying they have anxiety because they’re a bit worried about something which is a normal reaction for example.

MavisMcMinty · 15/02/2023 02:48

These are very anxious, worrying times. Cost of living crisis, polarised division across political, cultural, societal and financial lines, anger in all quarters… It’d be hard not to have mental health problems in today’s world.

Isithotinhere · 15/02/2023 02:38

I agree - there was a recent thread where a woman complained that breastfeeding had damaged her mental health, but it read as if like she found it demanding and boring, it didn't impact on her mental health eg by contributing to PND - which in itself gets self-diagnosed quite a bit now. There was a trend a few years ago that over 50% of celebrity new mothers seemed to announce that they had PND. I thought it was to make them relatable - "don't envy me my day and night nannies, I'm just like you" - or to get colum inches and for people to be nice to them, as they are giving fake intimacy. Now that we're all healthy and self-actualised, the PND notices a lot more subdued.

I find it irritating - it can all be a bit emo kid, as if it's shallow to be just getting on OK with l

crew2022 · 15/02/2023 02:06

I think mental health is a spectrum and a clinical diagnosis is at one end whereas milder feelings of anxiety and depression are at the other. It's all 'mental health' but only the more severe end is a clinical issue rather than feelings.

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:33

Vegandiva · 15/02/2023 01:25

You might find this podcast episode interesting as it touches on what you mentioned (and the guest was diagnosed bipolar at a young age so has a fair amount of insight into the topic of mental illness).

“In Bari’s view, Freddie deBoer is one of the best writers in the country. It’s not because she always agrees with him. Hardly. Freddie is a self-described Marxist.
What she appreciates about him is that he is unflinching about criticizing “his side.” Freddie is one of the most trenchant critics of what he calls “Social Justice Politics”—which he argues distracts the left from the real issue of class.
He is also unflinching in his views about mental illness and the way it is being glorified in our culture right now. Freddie knows about this subject intimately. He has severe bipolar disorder, and has been institutionalized in the past when he was on the verge of violently acting out. Today: a conversation about “the gentrification of disability,” how sickness became chic, and how our society should handle the epidemic of mental illness.”

www.honestlypod.com/podcast/episode/e8701381/does-glorifying-sickness-deter-healing

Thank you I will listen to that

OP posts:
Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:32

Mumof3teenagers · 15/02/2023 01:21

Ok, I get you now….I think some people use the terms wrongly. If they’re having a bad day, they might say they’re depressed. If they’re a bit worried, they may use the term anxious/anxiety.
My daughter has OCD ( diagnosed) and I know it annoys her when people flippantly say …. Oh that’s just my ocd …. Just because they like a neat desk or things orderly.
It does take away from the seriousness of these conditions and the impact they can have on individuals.

Yes exactly this. I’m honestly not suggesting that anyone would want to have a MH issue or minimise it for those that do but it does seem that any emotional experience people have is being treated as a MH problem when it isn’t

OP posts:
Vegandiva · 15/02/2023 01:25

You might find this podcast episode interesting as it touches on what you mentioned (and the guest was diagnosed bipolar at a young age so has a fair amount of insight into the topic of mental illness).

“In Bari’s view, Freddie deBoer is one of the best writers in the country. It’s not because she always agrees with him. Hardly. Freddie is a self-described Marxist.
What she appreciates about him is that he is unflinching about criticizing “his side.” Freddie is one of the most trenchant critics of what he calls “Social Justice Politics”—which he argues distracts the left from the real issue of class.
He is also unflinching in his views about mental illness and the way it is being glorified in our culture right now. Freddie knows about this subject intimately. He has severe bipolar disorder, and has been institutionalized in the past when he was on the verge of violently acting out. Today: a conversation about “the gentrification of disability,” how sickness became chic, and how our society should handle the epidemic of mental illness.”

www.honestlypod.com/podcast/episode/e8701381/does-glorifying-sickness-deter-healing

FriedasCarLoad · 15/02/2023 01:24

I agree with OP. I have complex and debilitating MH problems.

I get so irritated by people self-diagnosing what often sound like everyday emotional ups and downs. Itv actually makes life harder for those of us who are genuinely ill.

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:24

ashitghost · 15/02/2023 01:18

You don’t know first hand what PTSD is like. Your ex husband does. Unless you’ve got it too?

Ok yes you’re correct, however I do understand & know what it’s like to live with someone who is suffering from PTSD & it’s very difficult & unimaginable to people that have never been in that situation so when I hear people saying that they are suffering from depression/anxiety/PTSD or trauma from having a boyfriend cheat on them 20 years ago I find that very difficult to believe

OP posts:
Mumof3teenagers · 15/02/2023 01:21

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:15

I think I’m being misunderstood or misinterpreted, I’m not suggesting that MH problems don’t exist. I’m just pointing out that serious problems are being used by people without diagnosis.

Ok, I get you now….I think some people use the terms wrongly. If they’re having a bad day, they might say they’re depressed. If they’re a bit worried, they may use the term anxious/anxiety.
My daughter has OCD ( diagnosed) and I know it annoys her when people flippantly say …. Oh that’s just my ocd …. Just because they like a neat desk or things orderly.
It does take away from the seriousness of these conditions and the impact they can have on individuals.

ashitghost · 15/02/2023 01:18

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:00

It’s a genuine question. As someone who knows firsthand what PTSD is & the serious affect it has on a person I honestly don’t understand how anyone can claim they have PTSD without knowing or understanding the symptoms & trauma especially as most I have spoken to have never seen a health professional, I’m not minimising anyone’s experience but I just feel that everyone now has likes to label themselves with a problem.

You don’t know first hand what PTSD is like. Your ex husband does. Unless you’ve got it too?

albapunk · 15/02/2023 01:18

I can sort of understand where you are coming from OP.

Mental Health issues are of course genuine, and should be regarded as a proper medical issue, free of taboo with treatment and help available without judgement or scorn.

BUT

A level of anxiety, feeling down and sad, feeling upset and confused, agitated....all perfectly normal and not necessarily the result of an actual Mental Health issue.

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:15

I think I’m being misunderstood or misinterpreted, I’m not suggesting that MH problems don’t exist. I’m just pointing out that serious problems are being used by people without diagnosis.

OP posts: