Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of MH problems

82 replies

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 00:38

I’m not so inconsiderate that I don’t believe they exist but it seems that nearly everyone I meet has mental health problems, I was married to a man that was in the forces & he seriously suffered from PTSD but now it seems that everyone & his wife has depression/anxiety/PTSD/ADHD & I honestly feel it’s all self diagnosed

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 15/02/2023 09:04

MH problems are genuinely extremely common though. The statistic that gets bandied about is that 1 in 4 experience mental health problems each year. Therefore it stands to reason that we all know several people who have one and it feel like it's "everywhere".

In a given year I'm sure many more people will experience a variety of clinically significant physical issues too. Do we feel the need the same need to impose some sort of quota? I think not so much. If someone "self-diagnoses" with migraine, are we equally suspicious of the validity? Again, I don't think so.

So I think this is probably all part of the stigma around mental health problems.

ssd · 15/02/2023 08:54

I partly agree with you op.
I don't know if its a good thing or not.
Mental health needs brought out into the open but i still think people suffering badly dont get any actual real practical help.
I think the powers that be like us all talking about it without them doing anything to help us.

Crouchendtigermum · 15/02/2023 08:21

Probably attitudes like the op is why so many people kill themselves
sad world we living in with all the stresses around like cost of living crisis
working poor
working homeless
the fact you can’t see a gp or it’s v v difficult too
war
covid
brexit

BigMandysBookClub · 15/02/2023 08:15

I get anxious though. I say to people I can be anxious or have anxiety, but I always say I manage it (with lots of avoidance 😀) . Isn't it the issue of the person on the receiving end that is the problem, assuming it always has to be very severe? I just don't understand why people aren't allowed to have mild illnesses or traits of an illness anymore. Mild issues can still affect your life and give you daily struggles, just not to the extent that its utterly debilitating and you can't function. I just think our culture has shifted to accept that mild issues along with the increasing amount of daily pressures people experience does affect someone's functioning - even if it is mildly - and we need to understand that.

You will always get people feigning illness or making it appear worse than it is. Happens a lot with physical health too though. You can force them not to behave like that. Just don't indulge in it if you have an issue. I do know a few people who have really struggled with MH but are very private about it. I don't say they can't be ill because they don't choose to have a breakdown in front of me.

Mumof3teenagers · 15/02/2023 08:08

Xol · 15/02/2023 07:53

I do agree that far too many people instantly claim to have "anxiety" as an excuse for, well, anything, including not taking quite elementary steps to improve their situation. People often post on here with some problem that is easily soluble, most notably by actually going and talking to someone, but it becomes insoluble because their anxiety is going "through the roof" at the thought of resolving their problem so easily. For some reason, people like this never just have rising anxiety, it's always going through the roof.

It is precisely because clinical anxiety is a genuine debilitating illness that it is really quite offensive that so many people claim to have anxiety when the reality is that they are being asked to do something they find a little bit difficult or that they don't want to do.

I also feel people forget that feeling anxious is part of life. It’s always been there. Previous generations would have said I’m stressed or worried about something. Anxiety has become a buzz word.
My dd attends CAMHS for anxiety and ocd. The therapist has made it clear that they will try to reduce her anxiety but it will never be totally gone, because anxiety is part of the human experience and can be a very helpful instinct eg: sensing something is not right or danger. They will also work on her reaction/ response to anxiety, to make it more manageable.
So, a certain amount of anxiety is normal and makes us human.
People need to realise, it’s when it becomes all consuming that a clinical diagnosis is reached.

Im all for people minding their mental health and doing things to reduce stress levels or improve a low mood. However, labelling every emotion like a mental health crises belittles those who are actually experiencing the real thing.

Xol · 15/02/2023 07:53

I do agree that far too many people instantly claim to have "anxiety" as an excuse for, well, anything, including not taking quite elementary steps to improve their situation. People often post on here with some problem that is easily soluble, most notably by actually going and talking to someone, but it becomes insoluble because their anxiety is going "through the roof" at the thought of resolving their problem so easily. For some reason, people like this never just have rising anxiety, it's always going through the roof.

It is precisely because clinical anxiety is a genuine debilitating illness that it is really quite offensive that so many people claim to have anxiety when the reality is that they are being asked to do something they find a little bit difficult or that they don't want to do.

PermanentTemporary · 15/02/2023 07:22

I'm not completely unsympathetic to the thesis; I think either living with or caring for someone living with a severe MH problem is so tough and unsupported that it leads to feeling pretty impatient with social media chain posts etc. And the conflation of 'feeling X' with 'having a diagnosable condition called X' is difficult to take.

But I'm afraid I know the stuff about the past is cack. The vocabulary was different but the emotions and experiences, and the disapproval of other people who were disbelieved weren't - read a few novels. And suicide rates are actually much better now, with some deterioration in recent years (my dh took his own life in 2018 after decades of psychosis, anxiety and depression). If greater awareness that it is, yes, normal to have some MH challenges in life but that they ARE MH challenges, is what it takes to get suicide rates down, I'm fine with that.

Nowdontmakeamess · 15/02/2023 07:19

People are starting to use illnesses or neuro diversity as a badge of honour and it does get on my nerves when they've suddenly decided it's cool but have had none of the actual shit that goes with it.

But you’ve actually no idea what ‘shit’ they’ve been through if they, like you, didn’t share it with anyone.

Plenty of people with mental health problems struggle in silence. Getting a diagnosis can bring understanding and support, and help people feel their problems are real/valid.

BigMandysBookClub · 15/02/2023 07:18

You are looking at MH in a very black and white way which is why you are struggling to understand it OP. It is a spectrum. people who function normally and have no diagnosis may have occasionally hear voices or felt elated for no reason and made a bad decision on it. If you have any other illness you have differing stages of presentation or severities of illness. Same with MH. Some people may have a severe illness they manage quite well.

I get why you are saying about influencers and celebrities using it for attention and some people using it for another excuse, but we don't really know what there inner world is like, so we just have to give them the benefit of the doubt. I think it is just a sign of the times, poor economic prosperity, younger generations poorer than their parents, huge social pressures and pointless culture wars. This isn't going to create a nation of happy people.

whatkatydid2013 · 15/02/2023 07:14

I can see what you are saying but I also think that poorer mental health recently is likely connected to the environment (covid, background threat from war in Ukraine, cost of living etc). There are loads of people, myself included, who’ve found these things have added a significant amount of stress/anxiety to already busy lives. I don’t think I would classify myself as mentally ill but I would definitely say I’ve seen impacts on my wellbeing at times - struggling to sleep, feeling sick/sometimes throwing up due to churning anxious feelings, shorter temper/agitation/less patience, inability to focus. It can feel like people think if you have these kinds of issues you are just failing to cope well and you should do better. If classifying yourself as having anxiety makes people more understanding/constructive than as being anxious I can see why people say it. Even though it’s temporary and resolvable if you can manage to change your situation &/or find time to fit in things to help with regulation just being very stressed/anxious can be pretty debilitating. It likely feels worse if you’ve previously always felt mentally well as you struggle to understand why you are coping less well now than you did before, are aware others are in much worse situations etc

ijphoo · 15/02/2023 07:11

Nearly every person in my family has a serious mental illness. I am describing the issues as 'serious' because they are long term clinically diagnosed and have impacted on the individuals' lives to the extent where the individual cannot function fully in society in terms of employment, enjoying relationships or even keeping themselves safe and clean.

My eldest son, who has a psychotic illness, is in sheltered accommodation, and doing very well with daily support and medication. My youngest son (also a young adult) has a profound eating disorder and a cluster of anxiety disorders. I work from home so that I can support him. My husband (with whom I do not live) also has serious anxiety disorders that have led to chronic hypertension (contributing to a mini-stroke and hospitalisation before Christmas). My mother and mother in law, have dementia (both in the earlier stages). I also had a serious eating disorder in my youth, for which I was hospitalised many times.

So, I can fully understand how, when mental illness has impacted our own lives, directly and indirectly, for so long, we can become 'tired' of it.

Mental illness is relentless and unpredictable. In my family, there is probably a predisposition towards mental illness, however, I also think the disconnected nature of society, the social and environmental pressures and the vast changes we are experiencing on a personal, national and global scale may all contribute to the apparent escalation in mental health issues.

wherethewaterisdarker · 15/02/2023 07:10

OP, your ignorance is showing. MH is a spectrum, like physical health - it runs the gamut from mild to extremely severe. We’re all on that spectrum too - we all have mental health in the exact same way we all physical health. Attitudes like yours are damaging, not least to your self.

MissCrowley · 15/02/2023 07:03

TW; suicide.

And I'll also say something else which is probably controversial.

I have known people to take their own lives, they do it on the quiet, they don't make a massive song and dance about it before hand. The people that do (on social media) are desperately seeking attention and wanting reassurance.
I have been suicidal and I was keeping that shit to myself in case I wanted to go through with it because I didn't want to be stopped.

MissCrowley · 15/02/2023 07:00

Apologies to OP, I've seen that they've explain themselves, my fault for not RTFT.

In this case I do agree OP.
My mother says she has OCD.. definitely does not in any stretch of the imagination. I do and have been diagnosed with it- it's only mild but has the potential to become an issue if I'm stressed. But she'll say things like "oh I don't like that being there, it's my OCD".
I had a nervous breakdown in Oct- Dec 2021 nobody knew about it. It took till Feb 2022 to speak to a psychiatrist-which is really quite quick considering some of the wait times in the UK. I didn't write about it on Facebook or tell anyone. My head wasn't in the right space to even look at my phone never mind try and hold a conversation. I couldn't even hold a conversation for longer than a couple of minutes with my kids before I was too exhausted.

People are starting to use illnesses or neuro diversity as a badge of honour and it does get on my nerves when they've suddenly decided it's cool but have had none of the actual shit that goes with it.

tara66 · 15/02/2023 06:56

So agree - everyone and his dog have MH problems. You can't even read about someone parking their car without them saying they have MH. How did people ever manage to live through WW2?!

MissCrowley · 15/02/2023 06:50

I don't appreciate ADHD being swung around as a mental health problem by OP.
It's a condition which can bring about mental health problems but isn't one on its own.

Don't worry I'll stop being ADHD/ Autistic/ having PTSD and anxiety due to a dreadful childhood (including all kinds of abuse) as its now too mainstream and it irritates the OP. I haven't been in the forces so can't possibly have PTSD can I.

LakieLady · 15/02/2023 06:47

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:15

I think I’m being misunderstood or misinterpreted, I’m not suggesting that MH problems don’t exist. I’m just pointing out that serious problems are being used by people without diagnosis.

Given the waiting times to see a psychiatrist (at least where I live), I expect there are bloody loads of people with significant MH issues who haven't seen an MH professional.

That doesn't mean they don't have a pretty good idea of what's wrong with them.

Coffeetree · 15/02/2023 06:46

A diagnosis attracts resources, including treatment and accommodation. That's why people are encouraged to pathologise everything.

So for example, if I tell my employer I need a week off because I'm tired and sad, that's not going to go down well. However if I self-certify myself with "depression" or better yet get an actual diagnosis, then my employer must accommodate.

SheWentWest · 15/02/2023 06:42

To be fair it’s pretty nigh on impossible to get any kind of diagnosis these days unless you are at the very severe end of the spectrum. These things come in degrees. Issues from my childhood which may not appear severe from the outside have profoundly affected my life and self esteem something I now realise and am working though. You would see me as a perfectly functional person from the outside. So by your judgement I would not be considered ‘worthy’ and should just suck it up and get on with it. Why should people wait until their problems become really severe by your standards.

Zanatdy · 15/02/2023 06:41

I get what you’re saying and people do over use terms like PTSD and self diagnose themselves with things. For example someone suggested I had PTSD after I said I couldn’t think back to the 14 days I spent in ICU in agony after a major surgery as it was a terrible experience and going into the hospital can trigger me to feel anxious etc. To me that’s just a bad memory. I don’t wake at night sweating and it doesn’t impact my daily life.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 15/02/2023 06:37

I’m sick of it being used an excuses for monsters committing the worst crimes

rexythedinosaur · 15/02/2023 06:20

Tiptoearound · 15/02/2023 01:32

Yes exactly this. I’m honestly not suggesting that anyone would want to have a MH issue or minimise it for those that do but it does seem that any emotional experience people have is being treated as a MH problem when it isn’t

This whole thread is minimising MH problems, OP.

Attitudes like yours are the reason people desperate for support do not reach out for help.

Stop it.

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 15/02/2023 06:17

I agree OP - I work with young people, and I quite frequently hear people say “I can’t do that because I have anxiety” - when what they mean is I feel anxious about that - something which is very normal and healthy. Often the language around mental ill health is used as a barrier or a reason not to make changes, it’s really difficult to hear this and treat the person respectfully when part of my job is to help them to take action to change their lives.I often recommend the book ‘why did no one tell me this before’ which I love - it talks about the fact that you can getting mentally ‘fitter’ through training and practice - Talks about perspective and suggests that you spend time identifying your triggers and early stage symptoms of mental health challenges so you can make changes - rather like being aware of slight changes in blood pressure or weight gain and knowing what they could mean in terms of your physical health so you make diet or excercise changes - it’s a good read

rwalker · 15/02/2023 05:37

Having worked briefly in a MH drop in centre I think there’s a vein of truth in what OP is saying
I think some people can’t differentiate between mental illness and being a bit pissed off
there were people who lives were hell with there MH struggles crippling and affected every aspect of there lives . I’ve worked with people who have thrown themselves out of windows and set fire to themselves heartbreaking that’s MH
At work we had they unpopular task of moving people on to jobs they didn’t want to do
few claimed stress/anxiety thing is soon as they got there own way cured overnight

MNbingo · 15/02/2023 05:25

Totally agree OP, I had a freak accident a few years ago which resulted in a broken bone and now certain other routine situations make me very wary and anxious. I know I probably need some help to work through this but a well meaning friend told me I probably have PTSD! I don’t think that’s the case but if I was so inclined I’d probably wallow in that “diagnosis” as a lot of people see to do these days.