Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scottish teachers pay offer

272 replies

GneissGuysFinishLast · 14/02/2023 21:10

AIBU to think that it’s not really an improved offer, and that 12% over 2 years is overall a worse deal than 10% in one year, and that they are only making this offer to delay strikes?

(reported on BBC News here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-64642699)

OP posts:
YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 02:02

@Botw1 I worked for the NHS for 10 years prior to becoming a teacher, my sister is a healthcare support worker, I know exactly what it entails, thanks.

My sister takes home more as an unqualified band 3 if she’s working nights than I do as a teacher. My point was that I have no scope to use my role as a teacher in the same capacity in that I can’t top up my wage by picking up an extra shift or deciding to commit myself to night shifts.

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:59

@YerAWizardHarry

You could always retrain as a nurse?

Easy to get into (allegedly) and loads of vacancies so plenty scope for OT

SueVineer · 15/02/2023 01:57

YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 01:54

I’m a primary school teacher so exams aren’t relevant to me. I’m a teacher not a tutor, next you’ll be saying I should pick up bar shifts to top up my wages… you know exactly what my comment meant- there is zero scope to earn overtime by actually doing the job you’re trained and employed to do.

Why should you earn overtime when you are supposed to be a salaried professional?

SueVineer · 15/02/2023 01:56

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:47

I'm all for the 10%

And reworking of the contracts so teachers stop doing voluntary work then saying they are underpaid

If that means paying overtime for work that can be evidenced as necessary maybe that's the way to go

It’s normal for salaried workers to work beyond 9-5. Most teachers I know work far less than average

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:55

@YerAWizardHarry

I didn't twist your words

Op said you were talking about a nqt teacher pay, I was only pointing out 10 years down the line isn't newly qualified

Yeah there's loads of people in loads of jobs with mortgages childcare etc. Lots of them on less than 28k.

YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 01:54

I’m a primary school teacher so exams aren’t relevant to me. I’m a teacher not a tutor, next you’ll be saying I should pick up bar shifts to top up my wages… you know exactly what my comment meant- there is zero scope to earn overtime by actually doing the job you’re trained and employed to do.

SueVineer · 15/02/2023 01:54

GneissGuysFinishLast · 15/02/2023 01:44

So what’s the answer then?

The answer really should be that we should be able to down tools after 35 hours, and still do our jobs well.

In my experience, the ones who do down tools after 35 hours are not the ones campaigning for more pay. I could tell you exactly who in my school works to their contracted hours (and I’ll say it again - they are perfectly entitled to do so! They shouldn’t HAVE to work unpaid overtime or during their summer - they aren’t being paid for it!) - and I could also say, these people aren’t the ones I see at the picket line on each strike day.

Generally speaking, the ones who feel that they aren’t well paid, are the ones working more hours than they are paid for.

I don’t know what the answer is. One solution would be decreasing contact time, to allow more time in the school for preparation. But I got into teaching because I love actually being on the chalk face, so that would decrease my job satisfaction (and potentially also my stress levels right enough)

Or, do we use more centralised resources? Well, yeah, that would work for certain subjects, but not all. And it would probably also decrease my job satisfaction, because I get a good sense of accomplishment when I make my own resources.

Or, do we remove the hours stipulation? No, because then we can have ever expanding workload placed on us, and we will just be expected to do it, like in England.

Or, do we pay teachers overtime reflective of what they actually work, at their normal hourly rate? That would boost the average FTE(based on the approx 50 hours that most teachers seem to claim) to £65k. Obviously they’d need to evidence the extra work they do, so someone would probably need to be employed to do that in each school too.

In the balance, I think 10% is fair.

So you even admit lots of teachers just work the minimum hours! Yet they deserve to make twice the average Scottish wage and get twice the average holidays. Not entitled or anything!

YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 01:52

@Botw1 youre twisting my worsts- my point was that the new teacher excitement and wanting to do good inevitably wears off when you’re ground down by the pressures of the stuff they seemingly “should have been aware of” due to placements.

Also believe me there lots of teachers on £28K who have children/mortgages/nursery fees too (myself included)

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:51

There are options for teachers to make more money?

Marking exam papers. Tutoring

SueVineer · 15/02/2023 01:50

FamilyLife2point4 · 14/02/2023 23:28

@Botw1 they are paid for working 195 days plus 40 days holiday = 235 days per year full time. Average teacher salary is standard around 42k = £172.78 per day.
Heres where the debate comes in - teachers are paid for a 35 hour week (or 7 hours per day) making their hourly rate £25.53 - most teachers will tell you they work at least 10 hours per day otherwise there’s no time to prep / mark etc therefore it’s realty is £17.87 per hour.
Deductions of 10% pension, student loans, and getting pushed into the 40% tax bracket means their pay rise won’t be much of a rise either (heavily taxed). Doesn’t make it an appealing graduate profession without the stuff they have to put up with (thinking of recent news articles with students with knives etc)

How many graduate jobs in Scotland get paid more than that though? Once you take the employer pension contributions into account it’s about £55k if not more. Few in the private sector get that salary in Scotland even as a graduate and none get those holidays.

YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 01:50

I’d 100% give up my time to make more money. Just in the same way my nurse sister picks up a double time bank holiday shift or a 1.5 time night shift when she has a holiday booked or weekend away she’s saving for.

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:49

She said 10 years down the line it doesn't seem a good deal.
10 years down the line it's not still 28k

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:48

If you don't know what being a teacher involves by the end of the super duper degree course plus probation year then there are big failings in a course that has such high entry requirements

GneissGuysFinishLast · 15/02/2023 01:47

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:44

Pp said they were on 42k?

And I think most working parents will empathise

At least you get the holidays off with the kids

Silver linings and all that

£42k is top of the pay scale, not probation year which is what they are referencing. You don’t get to £42k for many years.

OP posts:
Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:47

I'm all for the 10%

And reworking of the contracts so teachers stop doing voluntary work then saying they are underpaid

If that means paying overtime for work that can be evidenced as necessary maybe that's the way to go

YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 01:45

Absolutely the holidays are a benefit but I was answering your post about the fact that new teachers should be “aware” because of placements etc (post grads only get a total of around a 16 weeks in total!)

GneissGuysFinishLast · 15/02/2023 01:44

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:29

'So we can legitimately stop work after 35 hours, down tools and leave.

Could I do my job in 35h? Yeah I probably could cobble together a paragraph to read and find some questions on it, mark it, hand it back and go home. Maybe fire some grades into a report too. Job done.'

Meaning they are taking home a full time, whole year salary for 35 hours a week, term time.

And they want another 10% because its a 4 year degree and should be a competitive salary?!

So what’s the answer then?

The answer really should be that we should be able to down tools after 35 hours, and still do our jobs well.

In my experience, the ones who do down tools after 35 hours are not the ones campaigning for more pay. I could tell you exactly who in my school works to their contracted hours (and I’ll say it again - they are perfectly entitled to do so! They shouldn’t HAVE to work unpaid overtime or during their summer - they aren’t being paid for it!) - and I could also say, these people aren’t the ones I see at the picket line on each strike day.

Generally speaking, the ones who feel that they aren’t well paid, are the ones working more hours than they are paid for.

I don’t know what the answer is. One solution would be decreasing contact time, to allow more time in the school for preparation. But I got into teaching because I love actually being on the chalk face, so that would decrease my job satisfaction (and potentially also my stress levels right enough)

Or, do we use more centralised resources? Well, yeah, that would work for certain subjects, but not all. And it would probably also decrease my job satisfaction, because I get a good sense of accomplishment when I make my own resources.

Or, do we remove the hours stipulation? No, because then we can have ever expanding workload placed on us, and we will just be expected to do it, like in England.

Or, do we pay teachers overtime reflective of what they actually work, at their normal hourly rate? That would boost the average FTE(based on the approx 50 hours that most teachers seem to claim) to £65k. Obviously they’d need to evidence the extra work they do, so someone would probably need to be employed to do that in each school too.

In the balance, I think 10% is fair.

OP posts:
Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:44

Pp said they were on 42k?

And I think most working parents will empathise

At least you get the holidays off with the kids

Silver linings and all that

SueVineer · 15/02/2023 01:43

GneissGuysFinishLast · 15/02/2023 00:39

No I didn’t - I said we were supposed to get the pay rise in April but it wasn’t processed til November. Because I got 8 months of backdated pay in one month, that figure along with my backdated holiday pay put me into the higher rate tax for that month alone. If I had been paid that value each month I would have been taxed less on it. I’m yet to be rebated.

My salary is £25k and I work 30 hours per week.

It’s not up to me to find the money - there is plenty of pointless things the government pay for that could be invested in vital services, IMO. That’s the governments job.

It’s still not £16 an hour. You get loads of holidays and a generous pension that costs at least about 25-30% of your salary. So don’t talk rubbish

it’s not realistic for you to get 10% pay increase when there is a huge public sector funding crisis. Who else in society is getting that? What should be cut do you can get yet more money?

YerAWizardHarry · 15/02/2023 01:40

@Botw1 I did a training course as a probationer recently where they were spouting “remember your why!!” They brainwash you in the beginning, young girls who have always wanted to be teachers and see it as their calling and what they were born to do. Generally people go in to teaching because they want to make children’s lives better.

When you’re 21 years old graduating and earning £28K and you live at home/have no other commitments it doesn’t seem too bad a deal!

Fast forward 10 years, you’ve got 2 kids of your own at home and your nursery has just upped their daily fees to over £70 per day, you have no energy to do your older child’s homework because you’re too busy marking the 30 homework books of your class and it’s all pretty fucking grim…

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:31

@FamilyLife2point4

Dont you get practice placements and a probation year?

They must have a rough idea

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:29

'So we can legitimately stop work after 35 hours, down tools and leave.

Could I do my job in 35h? Yeah I probably could cobble together a paragraph to read and find some questions on it, mark it, hand it back and go home. Maybe fire some grades into a report too. Job done.'

Meaning they are taking home a full time, whole year salary for 35 hours a week, term time.

And they want another 10% because its a 4 year degree and should be a competitive salary?!

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 01:27

@Botw1 i don’t believe anyone fully understands what any job entails until they do it - I’m thinking if my customer service days, people can be awful - my cousin was held at knifepoint working for farmfoods, didn’t sign up for any of it.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 15/02/2023 01:21

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 01:11

@GneissGuysFinishLast

Theres your answer as to why some people think teachers don't deserve a pay raise

What part of this post explains why people don’t think teachers deserve a pay rise? It would be helpful if you could quote it as I have no idea what part you mean?

OP posts:
GneissGuysFinishLast · 15/02/2023 01:16

FuckingHateRats · 15/02/2023 00:52

I would disagree with you there - we have a lot of flexibility and pupil choice in our BGE curriculum, and still use a lot of centralised resources. The point is we've designed them to be flexible and adapt to the class. You cannot meaningfully differentiate when you're constantly creating new material - the goal becomes to have something to teach with, but cannot include appropriate scaffolding and support and challenge when you're always in new-resource territory. Because we have core units, were able to create meaningful differentiation work for EAL learners, or those with first level literacy. I could never support as well if I was creating from scratch all the time.

Plus, CfE is a bag of shite. I teach English - it's like they hate the idea of knowledge and knowing ANYTHING concrete. All wooly, generalised nonsense without a strong foundation of any core conceptual knowledge. It's an embarrassment. If my resources don't really fit with the CfE framework, good. They might actually be half-decent then.

I love your last sentence 😂 so true.

I wonder how long til the next thing comes along. I feel like covid has distracted them a little. It’s been a while since they introduced something “new”

OP posts: