Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scottish teachers pay offer

272 replies

GneissGuysFinishLast · 14/02/2023 21:10

AIBU to think that it’s not really an improved offer, and that 12% over 2 years is overall a worse deal than 10% in one year, and that they are only making this offer to delay strikes?

(reported on BBC News here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-64642699)

OP posts:
Botw1 · 15/02/2023 22:22

I'm honestly not.

You said teachers face abuse and that's not comparable with other roles

Im not sure what else you could have meant

You used abuse of staff to prove how teaching isn't comparable to other roles

Proving my point that some teachers think teaching is worst off

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 22:18

@Botw1 ive explained twice what I meant - it’s as if you are deliberately trying to twist it!

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 22:17

@Botw1 i did not say other roles do not face abuse at all.
I imagine a police officer taking abuse from a gang of full grown men is far far worse, for example.

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 22:15

@FamilyLife2point4

Theyre not the same no

But you said other roles don't face abuse so they're not comparable?

Which is obviously not true.

A hedge fund manager isn't comparable to a nurse either but I can still say one deserves their wage and one doesn't

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 22:12

@Botw1 i don’t believe being a police officer is the same as a fireman, or a nurse the same as a social worker - their jobs are not comparable.
Do they have aspects, like perhaps admin, that intersect all roles, yes, does that make them comparable - no.

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 22:09

And again, as Ive said repeatedly

I do blame Westminster

I also support the strikes and think teachers pay should be competitive and in line with other public sector roles.

That doesn't meaning I think teaching or how teachers come across is above criticism.

I don't think any role is

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 22:07

@FamilyLife2point4

But it is comparable?

To lots of roles. Tons.

Why say its not?

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 22:06

Oh and if you need something to pick at / a finger to point - again I’ll ask:

WHO’S FAULT IS IT?

Westminster - get pissed at them for running the country into the ground!

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 22:04

@Jellycatspyjamas and @Botw1 as per my previous post - the point was that what teachers have to deal with is crap too - what they can face from under 18s daily whilst trying to instil values and education in them, is not comparable to any other professional role - so why compare, unless you’re just bitter about your own situation.
We should all be in support of each other - but instead it’s as if some people are just trying to ‘pick at something / anything’.

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 22:01

@Jellycatspyjamas primary teachers can’t mark, maybe tutor. Secondary needs apply, only so many places available etc - it’s not as cut and dry as picking up a shift as overtime

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/02/2023 21:50

*'The reports in the news of teachers being verbally and physically assaulted with little consequences for the wee souls that do

is this comparable to any other profession - no it’s not,'*

You think teachers are the only people who get verbally and physically abused at work, and have to continue working with the people who abused them? Seriously?

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/02/2023 21:49

Teachers do not get a say in the amount of unpaid holidays they have to take but they knew it was a job perk (or downside as it’s 6 weeks they can’t work)

So teachers don’t take on additional work during the holidays marking exams?

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 21:43

People compare (as has been explained more than once) because that's how we determine value.

And the easiest way to do that is to compare to your own situation

It happens on any discussion about wages and even wealth

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 21:42

@FamilyLife2point4

Can you clarify what you meant by

'The reports in the news of teachers being verbally and physically assaulted with little consequences for the wee souls that do

is this comparable to any other profession - no it’s not,'

Did you mean that it didn't happen in other roles? If not what did you mean?

Pinkchilli · 15/02/2023 21:41

Exactly this!!! do an equivalent role in public sector and even if the teachers took 6% this year they would be paid 2-3000 more per year than me. My job is extremely stressful often working long hours with half the holidays of teachers.
I feel unions are holding working parents to ransom and I’d be shocked if they get what they ask for because they will then have to pay the rest of pub sector who cannot fight on a pay grade basis so lower paid workers jumped at 10%. Others like myself got 5% like it or not.
my child will miss 11days of school in 20 due to hols and strike action it’s so unsettling. I am fortunate enough to have childcare around. Lower paid single parents are being hit the worst and vulnerable kids

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 21:39

@Botw1 the point is - no professional job is comparable and teachers do have their genuine struggles, so why is anyone trying to compare professions that ain’t comparable!

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 21:36

*general public

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 21:36

@LoopyGremlin fair enough. At a real term pay cut of ~10% over 2 years, I genuinely don’t think I’d be chuffed at that either.

I can completely see other folks point about teachers looking greedy to the vegetal public given the % other professions have accepted / been offered but others have accepted these offers and the teachers have not.
That’s their right to hold out for more - why should they effectively accept a pay cut, why should anyone (others shouldn’t be bitter their unions have rolled over for less - I suggest they switch unions to one that won’t) Teachers will lose salary for strike days but I personally believe that’s worth it for them. They should hold out for what they are worth which is at the very least not to suffer a pay cut!

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 21:32

Sorry are you saying that teachers being abused at work isn't comparable to any other profession?

Ie it's unique to teaching?

Because that's a perfect example if you are, but maybe I'm misreading

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 21:24

@Botw1 i don’t see that narrative though. They are campaigning for better pay. It seems to me as if other professions want to compare and gripe because teachers unions have actively fought year after year just to match inflation.

The reports in the news of teachers being verbally and physically assaulted with little consequences for the wee souls that do it - I believe it - no-one deserves to go to their work scared of what they’ll face and forced to stay in it. Do I also believe it’s far more widespread than reported, yes, yes I do - kids talk.

is this comparable to any other profession - no it’s not, so why are comparisons even raised in the first place?
Could folk choose teaching over nursing if they wanted the unpaid summer holidays where most resorts cost triple - yes they could have, or they could re-train - so why moan about it / raise it? Teachers do not get a say in the amount of unpaid holidays they have to take but they knew it was a job perk (or downside as it’s 6 weeks they can’t work) so why do others gripe at this? Do it if you want it - don’t if you don’t - but don’t ‘have a go’ at others for their job perks when they are simply demanding that they arent penalised due to inflation (which isnt their fault either).

LoopyGremlin · 15/02/2023 21:12

My union are putting it to a ballot, but at this point I think I'll reject it.

Botw1 · 15/02/2023 20:59

@FamilyLife2point4

It is possible to do all that and still be sceptical of the teachers are the cleverest/hardest worked/worst off narrative

FamilyLife2point4 · 15/02/2023 20:56

To answer your original point OP (given the new info of rejecting offer) I think the offer was reasonable, was it what was asked, no.

I believe they asked for 12% in one year, and they’ve offered 6% in one year, and to offset any future strikes and stop the current campaign (unions would need to re-apply for strike action and Tory’s have passed new laws making this more difficult in future - how sneaky)!

The reality is they have suffered through a year (as have we all) where inflation has risen ~10% and they’ve been offered 6% - this equates to a real term pat cut of 4% for 2022-23. can’t say id be chuffed at this given we know the reality of things costing double, let alone ~10%.

The reality is we don’t know how inflation will go for 2023-24 - but it’s predicted to be as high as 12% (correct me if I’m wrong) and they’ve offered 5.5% so another real term pay cut of ~6%.
Therefore in 2 years their wage will have diminished by ~10% and they should be happy at this?

Just because other professional unions are not as good as theirs, others needs to stop ‘throwing their toys out the pram’ - we’re all feeling the pinch, we all deserve to be paid more - and who’s fault is it that we are not? I know it’s not the teachers fault - they work a tough shift and I’d rather my children were taught by those who were well remunerated with good T&Cs to ensure good mental health - that only benefits our children, everyone’s children!

You know what else benefits everyone - well paid nurses, who aren’t strung out worrying about finances whilst carefully balancing life and death situations.

Point the finger of blame where it belongs - get mad at the man in charge - demand better for yourselves, your colleagues, and your sister professions all round instead of trying to find petty squabbles that really don’t benefit anyone except the establishment that caused it - cos we ain’t banging down their door demanding better!

MistressIggi · 15/02/2023 20:38

Janeay · 15/02/2023 20:12

Agreed ! Teachers thinks they are more qualified because they got a A in the highers is laughable teachers in Scotland are well laid ! Second highest in the country next to London! its time to invest in other public sector workers and the NHS nurses (who actually worked in lockdown!) and allied health professionals.

Teachers worked in lockdowns, including online lessons and staffing the key worker hubs, and returning to the classrooms without social distancing and pre-vaccines while most of the country were still working in their living rooms.
Nothing compared to being a nurse during covid, but a claim that we didn't work cannot to unchallenged.

Janeay · 15/02/2023 20:38

from the Herald, I believe teaching along with many other professionally qualified
Jobs is a difficult career and hard working however personally I think it’s a good wage.

The study shows the average annual salary for full-time teachers and other education professionals north of the Border is £41,350. This compares with a UK average of just over £40,000.

Salary levels for Scottish staff are also second only to those in London, where average annual pay is just under £43,500. Yorkshire and the Humber reported the lowest salaries among teachers and educational professionals in the UK, with a figure of £35,306.