Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is in the wrong and is being insensitive

587 replies

Roarlikealiontonight · 14/02/2023 21:10

Work colleague (we are friends but admittedly no where near close friends) turned up at my house around 30 minutes ago. ago crying with her daughter. She had her bags and stuff in her car. She was asking if she could stay the night as her husband has kicked her out after she said she didn't feel safe with him anymore, I probably should have asked more about what happened to make her not feel safe. She asked if she can sleep at ours for the night. Before I could even say anything DH jumped in and said no. I would probably have said yes as we have enough room. I told her I’d speak to DH and gave her some money to get a coffee with in the meantime, I told her to text me with what coffee shop she’s in and then once I’m dressed and once I’ve spoken to DH I’ll come and get a coffee with her and check she’s ok. She’s now texted me with what coffee shop she’s in but my DH is telling me not to go as I apparently “shouldn’t get involved”. There’s no way he’ll let her sleep here tonight if he doesn’t even want me to go to a coffee shop with her and check she’s ok. What do I do? Aibu to think DH is in the wrong here and is being insensitive to her?

OP posts:
stripedsox · 15/02/2023 08:00

mrs bennett it seems a lot of posters live in a movie state on mn, big salaries, perfect this that and whatever.
So many go for the 'popular view' responses as they don't want to be seen as different or outsiders. It's like the negative playground of if you think differently to the rest of us you're in for it.
As I said before I'm a bit of a cynic about the whole thing, too many whys for my liking.
I'm interested to read any updates as I obviously hope the woman and her dd are okay. Before anyone says it, it's someone's life not a soap opera so keeping in prespective, the 'I'd leave my dh because of it' would you really?

Simonjt · 15/02/2023 08:00

slashlover · 15/02/2023 07:52

You'd honestly use this to accuse your DH of having an affair? Honestly?

Shocking how many people think emotional blackmail is a completely normal thing in a relationship.

Stravaig · 15/02/2023 07:59

It's not a 'disagreement'. My marriage ends when a fundamental difference in values is revealed. Turning away a desperate woman and child, refusing to even let them in the door to keep them safe while you settle them and call the police or a women's refuge or a hotel is a breach in fundamental values to me.

Your values and standards may be different.

BadNomad · 15/02/2023 07:52

It's easy for people to judge when it's not them who is having to face potentially being confronted by an angry, violent man coming to their house. It would be the OP's DH who would be expected to protect everyone.

slashlover · 15/02/2023 07:52

Stravaig · 15/02/2023 07:30

@ButterBastardBeans This occurred to me too, as a possibility, albeit unlikely. It's certainly how I'd challenge DH - 'I'm assuming your vehement refusal means this is about an affair and she is the OW, in which case you need to pack a bag and leave anyway. She and her daughter stay.' One way of underlining how unreasonable he's being.

You'd honestly use this to accuse your DH of having an affair? Honestly?

Lockheart · 15/02/2023 07:49

Stravaig · 15/02/2023 07:30

@ButterBastardBeans This occurred to me too, as a possibility, albeit unlikely. It's certainly how I'd challenge DH - 'I'm assuming your vehement refusal means this is about an affair and she is the OW, in which case you need to pack a bag and leave anyway. She and her daughter stay.' One way of underlining how unreasonable he's being.

This is a the best (craziest) example I've ever seen of batshit manipulation and control. Who knew you should just accuse your H of an affair whenever you disagree?

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 07:48

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/02/2023 00:29

I am amazed at the number of people making excuses for the DH's behaviour.

I get that some people might not want the woman to stay, and that they think a hotel is a better idea. Fair enough, I don't necessarily agree but I can understand that point of view. But the OP's DH wouldn't even let the poor woman come into the house for just a few minutes, and then he told the OP not to go and meet her at the cafe because it was better not to get involved.

Just think about it. The OP's friend - not close but she is a friend - arrives on their doorstep with her child in a desperate state, having been kicked out by a partner who made her feel unsafe. That vulnerable friend is asking for help, and all the OP's husband can do is tell the OP not to get involved?

On what planet do people think it's OK to shrug off a plea for help from a vulnerable friend because it's better not to get in involved? Clearly, some of you are happy enough to share your lives with men like this, but personally, I have higher standards.

Some of us did that for our friends and ended up being threatened, stalked, bullied, some in actual immediate physical danger.

Helping doesn't have to mean letting them stay but help find somewhere to stay and contact people who actually know what they are doing.

I even understand his "don't get involved" though disagree. Because getting involved does bring it to your door as well.
I do wonder if he knows someone or experienced the aftermath.
I was quite a bitch apparently for wanting to break them up and adding oil into the fire by letting her stay and think he is too bad for her. This woman is from work. If similar were to happen she can cost op a job because it becomes incredibly upsetting situation.

There are lots of people here who have some movie fantasy of help and happy ending. Nah. Sometimes you don't get raknbows and unicorns, but threatening messages, rrputation attack and car parked by your house.

IndiaDreamer · 15/02/2023 07:48

stripedsox · 15/02/2023 07:44

Some posters are very dramatic on here. Irl they probably wouldn't have even opened the front door.

Of course 90% of MN don't open the door unless they've had written notice of a visitor.

But they would open it if it was a police officer, because they have a distinctive "knock" apparently. One which no one else could possibly copy. (Actually said by one poster on a thread about answering/ignoring the door).

Itsmyturnnow1 · 15/02/2023 07:46

Eastereggsboxedupready · 14/02/2023 21:15

Your dh doesn't get to refuse. Unless he wants to be labelled also abusive..

This is a bit OTT! Maybe he’s worried about the repercussions of the husband turning up when they have kids?! Hardly abusive it it!!

stripedsox · 15/02/2023 07:44

Some posters are very dramatic on here. Irl they probably wouldn't have even opened the front door.

IndiaDreamer · 15/02/2023 07:41

@Figmentof so you'd immediately end your relationship and leave your DH?

That's what the PP said to do.

I'm not saying don't help, Im saying find out what has actually happened.

stripedsox · 15/02/2023 07:35

I'm in for a kicking but like you sugar I'm too full of questions and whys also.
Sadly life experiences have made me very wary, suspious and pragmatic. It's a horrible way to feel tbh.

MySugarBabyLove · 15/02/2023 07:30

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/02/2023 07:12

She is not a random acquaintance, she is a friend.

Why didn't she go to a hotel? Who knows, maybe she is being financially abused and doesn't have access to cash?

Why didn't she go to a friend or family member? Well, she did go to a friend. Not a close one, maybe, but the OP says that they are friends. Why didn't she go to a closer friend or family member? I don't know, maybe she hasn't got any? Maybe they don't live in the same part of the country? Maybe she's been isolated by her DH and has lost touch with them? Maybe they're away? Maybe she's afraid that he will know where she is?

Why do you think she turned up on the OP's doorstep?

They’re not close friends by any stretch of the imagination, OP said so in her OP.

If the husband is financially abusive and controlling, then if the friend knows where the OP lives, then so will he.

OP knows nothing about this woman. She hasn’t even previously confided in the OP, that’s how not good friends they are. And yet she’s turned up randomly, bags packed, on her doorstep. Why? Because based on some of the responses on this thread, purely saying “I’m afraid to go home” with absolutely no context means that you should throw open your doors and give the person somewhere to stay.

If she was so afraid to go home that she couldn’t go to anyone else where her dh might know where she was, then she wouldn’t be sitting in a public coffee shop either, bearing in mind there are very few coffee shops that are open at 9:30 at night so she wouldn’t be hard to find if the dh went looking.

And if OP put this friend up she wouldn’t necessarily just be putting her family at risk while the friend was there. If the dh was that abusive, she could be putting her family permanently at risk. Without any context or knowing who and what you are dealing with, including the fact that you don’t really know this woman, it would be foolish to just throw open your doors and let them stay for god knows how long.

Stravaig · 15/02/2023 07:30

@ButterBastardBeans This occurred to me too, as a possibility, albeit unlikely. It's certainly how I'd challenge DH - 'I'm assuming your vehement refusal means this is about an affair and she is the OW, in which case you need to pack a bag and leave anyway. She and her daughter stay.' One way of underlining how unreasonable he's being.

Figmentof · 15/02/2023 07:30

IndiaDreamer · 15/02/2023 07:25

I think that's a bit extreme, let OP find out the situation and then decide.

How would you feel if your DHs work colleague, who you didn't know just turned up on your doorstep wanting to stay the night?

If it was a woman and child escaping domestic violence, I would be happy to help.

To be honest, I am incredulous that OP apparently sent them away as well, and where on earth is a coffee shop open at 9:30pm anyway?

IndiaDreamer · 15/02/2023 07:25

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 15/02/2023 06:57

What a fucking bastard, if I were you I'd be joining her and leaving him to enjoy having the whole house to himself on a permanent basis.

I think that's a bit extreme, let OP find out the situation and then decide.

How would you feel if your DHs work colleague, who you didn't know just turned up on your doorstep wanting to stay the night?

FitAt50 · 15/02/2023 07:22

Maybe your husband is concerned that she has no family or friends she can stay with. You said she was a work friend and you are not close.

BigGreen · 15/02/2023 07:22

Your H is stone cold. I wouldn't be able to look at him the same way again.

IndiaDreamer · 15/02/2023 07:20

ButterBastardBeans · 15/02/2023 06:21

Sorry to sound this cynical but are you sure your DH is not responsible for the breakdown in this woman's marriage OP?

His immediate and vehement 'no' would ring alarm bells for me.

You read too many books! Your imagination is off the scale!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/02/2023 07:18

slashlover · 15/02/2023 07:17

What the hell? Why do some people go straight to "he must be shagging her" for EVERYTHING?

No idea, it's quite a leap!

slashlover · 15/02/2023 07:17

ButterBastardBeans · 15/02/2023 06:21

Sorry to sound this cynical but are you sure your DH is not responsible for the breakdown in this woman's marriage OP?

His immediate and vehement 'no' would ring alarm bells for me.

What the hell? Why do some people go straight to "he must be shagging her" for EVERYTHING?

Idontgiveashitanymore · 15/02/2023 07:17

He’s probably worried it will end up being for more than one night.
I did the same for my friend and it ended up ruining my life because she wouldn’t leave .

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/02/2023 07:12

MySugarBabyLove · 15/02/2023 07:03

Something doesn’t sit right here.

This random acquaintance, who the OP knows little about, and who it seems has never trusted the OP enough to confide in her about the apparently abusive relationship she’s in, turns up on her doorstep, bags packed, and asks to stay because she’s “afraid to go home,” with no further context than that?

Why hasn’t she gone to a hotel?

Why hasn’t she gone to a friend or family member?

She has picked a random colleague and just turned up on their doorstep.

It’s incredibly manipulative behaviour, and I would be wondering what there really is to the situation.

I would offer to help her book a hotel, if she was genuine then she would accept, but no, I wouldn’t just let her in without knowing any details, and knowing whether she was genuine or whether her violent husband was going to turn up on my doorstep and put my family at risk.

She is not a random acquaintance, she is a friend.

Why didn't she go to a hotel? Who knows, maybe she is being financially abused and doesn't have access to cash?

Why didn't she go to a friend or family member? Well, she did go to a friend. Not a close one, maybe, but the OP says that they are friends. Why didn't she go to a closer friend or family member? I don't know, maybe she hasn't got any? Maybe they don't live in the same part of the country? Maybe she's been isolated by her DH and has lost touch with them? Maybe they're away? Maybe she's afraid that he will know where she is?

Why do you think she turned up on the OP's doorstep?

MySugarBabyLove · 15/02/2023 07:03

Something doesn’t sit right here.

This random acquaintance, who the OP knows little about, and who it seems has never trusted the OP enough to confide in her about the apparently abusive relationship she’s in, turns up on her doorstep, bags packed, and asks to stay because she’s “afraid to go home,” with no further context than that?

Why hasn’t she gone to a hotel?

Why hasn’t she gone to a friend or family member?

She has picked a random colleague and just turned up on their doorstep.

It’s incredibly manipulative behaviour, and I would be wondering what there really is to the situation.

I would offer to help her book a hotel, if she was genuine then she would accept, but no, I wouldn’t just let her in without knowing any details, and knowing whether she was genuine or whether her violent husband was going to turn up on my doorstep and put my family at risk.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 15/02/2023 06:57

What a fucking bastard, if I were you I'd be joining her and leaving him to enjoy having the whole house to himself on a permanent basis.