Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is in the wrong and is being insensitive

587 replies

Roarlikealiontonight · 14/02/2023 21:10

Work colleague (we are friends but admittedly no where near close friends) turned up at my house around 30 minutes ago. ago crying with her daughter. She had her bags and stuff in her car. She was asking if she could stay the night as her husband has kicked her out after she said she didn't feel safe with him anymore, I probably should have asked more about what happened to make her not feel safe. She asked if she can sleep at ours for the night. Before I could even say anything DH jumped in and said no. I would probably have said yes as we have enough room. I told her I’d speak to DH and gave her some money to get a coffee with in the meantime, I told her to text me with what coffee shop she’s in and then once I’m dressed and once I’ve spoken to DH I’ll come and get a coffee with her and check she’s ok. She’s now texted me with what coffee shop she’s in but my DH is telling me not to go as I apparently “shouldn’t get involved”. There’s no way he’ll let her sleep here tonight if he doesn’t even want me to go to a coffee shop with her and check she’s ok. What do I do? Aibu to think DH is in the wrong here and is being insensitive to her?

OP posts:
Riverlee · 15/02/2023 13:40

Op - what’s the update today.? Did you find out exactly what has happened, and also what does dh say?

eyope · 15/02/2023 13:32

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:25

Why do you care so much about what I think?! It’s like you’re personally offended for some reason. I would help, and yes, I’d judge my husband if he refused and I’d judge others for not helping. So what? It doesn’t impact you at all, we’re all different. It’s nothing to do with projection, it’s about trying to be a decent human being.

Im not going to justify my stance on this to you, we disagree, end of.

Why do you care so much about what I think?! It’s like you’re personally offended for some reason

You initiated commenting on my posts, and I'm just replying to what you've said. That's kind of how internet forums work.

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:25

eyope · 15/02/2023 13:22

@Naunet

I think you're massively projecting. No one is suggesting OP shouldn't have helped, but there are sensible ways to help someone while protecting your own family. And DH isn't just some man she's appeasing - he's her husband and she has an equal responsibility to listen and consider his POV and his comfort/safety.

OP also has children of her own and putting them (and your DH) front and centre of someone's possibly violent and dangerous relationship, WITHOUT calling the police is very irresponsible.

Why do you care so much about what I think?! It’s like you’re personally offended for some reason. I would help, and yes, I’d judge my husband if he refused and I’d judge others for not helping. So what? It doesn’t impact you at all, we’re all different. It’s nothing to do with projection, it’s about trying to be a decent human being.

Im not going to justify my stance on this to you, we disagree, end of.

eyope · 15/02/2023 13:22

@Naunet

I think you're massively projecting. No one is suggesting OP shouldn't have helped, but there are sensible ways to help someone while protecting your own family. And DH isn't just some man she's appeasing - he's her husband and she has an equal responsibility to listen and consider his POV and his comfort/safety.

OP also has children of her own and putting them (and your DH) front and centre of someone's possibly violent and dangerous relationship, WITHOUT calling the police is very irresponsible.

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:14

Lockheart · 15/02/2023 13:08

Would you say it's just as nasty a comment as implying other posters have no morals and making digs about hoping they never need help?

Where did I do that? I didn’t say anyone didn’t have morals, I said I wouldn’t put them aside to appease a man. And I stand by it, if you wouldn’t help someone in need, don’t ever count on someone helping you. Why do you think you’d be entitled to help when you wouldn’t provide it yourself?

T1Dmama · 15/02/2023 13:12

Lockheart · 15/02/2023 13:04

Finances, she said if her finances allowed it. You even copy-pasted it.

Goodness! Thanks for pointing that out.

Should’ve gone to spec savers moment!

mottle · 15/02/2023 13:12

Your husband is a prick.

butterfliedtwo · 15/02/2023 13:10

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

You need to work on your reading comprehension before going off on someone like this.

Lockheart · 15/02/2023 13:08

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:05

Men aren’t women, totally different, let’s not play pretend around that fact - men are far more of a risk.

Theres nothing ‘wrong’ with me thank you very much, (what a nasty comment), I would just always want to help protect a child, because no one protected me when I was young and desperately needed an adults help. If it backfires on me, I can live with that, I couldn’t live with leaving a woman and child at risk.

Would you say it's just as nasty a comment as implying other posters have no morals and making digs about hoping they never need help?

Teaandtoast3 · 15/02/2023 13:07

Currently 1364 people have voted and 93% think the OP OH is being unreasonable… because to not even let her in for a cuppa and a conversation he most definitely is.

747jumbo · 15/02/2023 13:05

In response to people saying I don't care about the character of the people I share my life with - I care that:

  • they put me and our children first
  • they believe our safety is paramount
  • he has a cool head (and does not lack compassion)
  • he remembers when our neighbour did exactly this and all of us in the cul de sac we were terrorised by the violent ex kicking doors at 2am, smashing car windows, and screaming until the police were called
  • that he remembers the effect that on our children
  • that he has an equal say in who comes into our home and has always respected my rights in our home- just as I would now respect his.
  • that he has the sense to evaluate risk and see that professional help is likely to be the best option for us and the woman

Anyway - the people who are not in this position can judge those who are actually dealing with the reality. After all it's MN

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:05

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:05

Men aren’t women, totally different, let’s not play pretend around that fact - men are far more of a risk.

Theres nothing ‘wrong’ with me thank you very much, (what a nasty comment), I would just always want to help protect a child, because no one protected me when I was young and desperately needed an adults help. If it backfires on me, I can live with that, I couldn’t live with leaving a woman and child at risk.

That’s in response to @eyope

Naunet · 15/02/2023 13:05

Men aren’t women, totally different, let’s not play pretend around that fact - men are far more of a risk.

Theres nothing ‘wrong’ with me thank you very much, (what a nasty comment), I would just always want to help protect a child, because no one protected me when I was young and desperately needed an adults help. If it backfires on me, I can live with that, I couldn’t live with leaving a woman and child at risk.

Lockheart · 15/02/2023 13:04

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Finances, she said if her finances allowed it. You even copy-pasted it.

eyope · 15/02/2023 13:03

Cocobutt · 15/02/2023 12:52

Work friend isn't the same as real life friends though is it. You don't normally have HR policies on your relationships with people outside work.. If you've never met or been to someone's life outside work, what do you really know about them? We don't know if OP has ever met the bf or daughter or been to their house?

And again, she's said she doesn't feel safe with him and he's kicked her out. Why doesn't she feel safe? What has happened? Is he dangerous or at risk of turning violent with OP? Why doesn't she have the money to go to a hotel while she figures it out? These are details I would share with whoever I was asking for help - its pretty basic info for OP to ask.

OP has said they are friends, just not close ones.

They are good enough friends to know where OP lives - I wouldn’t know what house most of my colleagues live in.

As posters have said when they have had to flee, they literally leave with the clothes on their backs - there’s not always time to get money or a credit card etc or even your phone which is maybe why she didn’t ring OP ahead of time and why she probably hadn’t rang the police or anyone else.

Your main concern is getting out of the house and I wouldn’t be questioning a scared mother and child at 9pm about why they didn’t think to pack a bag or bring their purse.

And if there is a chance that he’d turn violent with OP then why has her DH gone and left her alone in the house whilst he slept somewhere else!

Because the ex isn't likely to turn violent on another woman like OP, far more likely to turn violent on the other man present. If I was helping someone, I wouldn't want my DH to be any situation involving a violent man. I'd call the police - I'm baffled why this hasn't been done tbh. My DP is a police officer and thinks OP should have called the police immediately as domestic abuse can escalate and civilians shouldn't try to resolve it on their own.

Teaandtoast3 · 15/02/2023 13:00

@Cocobutt with a conversation he might have even felt more reassured to let her stay 🤷‍♀️ but his reaction is just so extreme that it doesn’t make sense.

T1Dmama · 15/02/2023 12:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Cocobutt · 15/02/2023 12:53

I get that he might not have wanted her to stay. Fair enough. But they could have sorted something out if he had just let them in like a normal person

I agree.

At the very least you would let your friend in and give them a cup of tea whilst you chat to DH and try and find them a hotel or refuge for the night if they couldn’t stay.

Cocobutt · 15/02/2023 12:52

Work friend isn't the same as real life friends though is it. You don't normally have HR policies on your relationships with people outside work.. If you've never met or been to someone's life outside work, what do you really know about them? We don't know if OP has ever met the bf or daughter or been to their house?

And again, she's said she doesn't feel safe with him and he's kicked her out. Why doesn't she feel safe? What has happened? Is he dangerous or at risk of turning violent with OP? Why doesn't she have the money to go to a hotel while she figures it out? These are details I would share with whoever I was asking for help - its pretty basic info for OP to ask.

OP has said they are friends, just not close ones.

They are good enough friends to know where OP lives - I wouldn’t know what house most of my colleagues live in.

As posters have said when they have had to flee, they literally leave with the clothes on their backs - there’s not always time to get money or a credit card etc or even your phone which is maybe why she didn’t ring OP ahead of time and why she probably hadn’t rang the police or anyone else.

Your main concern is getting out of the house and I wouldn’t be questioning a scared mother and child at 9pm about why they didn’t think to pack a bag or bring their purse.

And if there is a chance that he’d turn violent with OP then why has her DH gone and left her alone in the house whilst he slept somewhere else!

Teaandtoast3 · 15/02/2023 12:50

OP I hope you are okay. For what it’s worth I think you’ve been a really good friend for someone who didn’t feel safe in her situation. I would have done the same. I’m sorry your OH has acted this way. Big conversation needed I think.

Teaandtoast3 · 15/02/2023 12:47

This so what I struggle with:

  1. The OH wouldn’t even let the friend into the house. If he hadn’t been so ridiculous she could have just come in and they could have all chatted and decided on the best course of action without all the faffing around.
  2. He obviously doesn’t trust his partners judgement. My Ex Husband would still trust my judgement and I his.
  3. If it’s not about judgement then his actions must be about control… and because he couldn’t control the situation he got the arse.
  4. I would never have left my Ex Husband alone in this situation, and neither would he. I don’t even have to ask. I know he wouldn’t.

A lot of posters on this thread keep banging on about this person being a stranger. She isn’t a stranger to the OP. She is a work colleague who is also a friend.

I get that he might not have wanted her to stay. Fair enough. But they could have sorted something out if he had just let them in like a normal person… but he didn’t act like a normal person did he? He just said no I’m not getting involved, send her away and I don’t think you should get involved either. Then when the OP said no she’s my friend I want to help in some way… he left. Nice.

eyope · 15/02/2023 12:41

T1Dmama · 15/02/2023 12:30

@eyope

Work colleague (we are friends but admittedly no where near close friends) turned up at my house around 30 minutes ago. ago crying with her daughter. She had her bags and stuff in her car. She was asking if she could stay the night as her husband has kicked her out after she said she didn't feel safe with him anymore,

Its stated they’re not just colleagues but friends (albeit not close) and that her husband had thrown her out for saying she didn’t feel safe WITH HIM.

Work friend isn't the same as real life friends though is it. You don't normally have HR policies on your relationships with people outside work.. If you've never met or been to someone's life outside work, what do you really know about them? We don't know if OP has ever met the bf or daughter or been to their house?

And again, she's said she doesn't feel safe with him and he's kicked her out. Why doesn't she feel safe? What has happened? Is he dangerous or at risk of turning violent with OP? Why doesn't she have the money to go to a hotel while she figures it out? These are details I would share with whoever I was asking for help - its pretty basic info for OP to ask.

Cocobutt · 15/02/2023 12:40

Only thing I'd say, from experience, is that knowing someone from work isn't really knowing them. People can have very very different private lives.

But her DH wasn’t worried about their safety or anything, else he wouldn’t have left OP to go and stay somewhere else.

DH wasn’t concerned about this.
If he was he would have said so and not left OP and her child alone.

Whatever reason DH didn’t want to get involved, it definitely wasn’t because he was worried this woman or her DH would cause a safety issue.

Crutcher · 15/02/2023 12:37

@T1Dmama

I don't know what I would have done. Perhaps if my finances allowed it if have helped her find a cheap b&b for the night. I might have made some calls. At the very least I'd have driven her to the police station.

Nobody is saying you have to slam the door in her face. What I'm saying is that no one has the right, and it's actually immoral, to bring in someone else into the home when their spouse doesn't allow it.

This is such a basic concept, I'm struggling to understand what went on in the OP's head. It's a shared space. Meaning you don't own it (all). It (also) belongs to someone else. You can't help one person by being immoral and robbing another.

Are you the type to steal from corner shops to feed the homeless person outside?

How much more so in this case when the other person is your spouse who should come before all others. It just beggars belief.

eyope · 15/02/2023 12:33

@Naunet

What's wrong with you? Being cautious before you jump to let someone you hardly know into your life is sensible. Especially when you have children. Their safety comes above everyone else. If this was a man asking for help, of course you'd ask all the facts before making a decision. Just because she's a woman, doesn't mean all common sense goes out the door.

And if I needed help, I wouldn't want to get a colleague I vaguely know involved, who has kids, without giving them all the details. She's been kicked out of the house - so he's letting her leave and go wherever she wants. Means she isn't in imminent danger of him tracking her down as he's asked her to leave.

So OP wanting to get all the facts about what exactly is happening before she opens the doors is an entirely sensible precaution.

Swipe left for the next trending thread