Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH is in the wrong and is being insensitive

587 replies

Roarlikealiontonight · 14/02/2023 21:10

Work colleague (we are friends but admittedly no where near close friends) turned up at my house around 30 minutes ago. ago crying with her daughter. She had her bags and stuff in her car. She was asking if she could stay the night as her husband has kicked her out after she said she didn't feel safe with him anymore, I probably should have asked more about what happened to make her not feel safe. She asked if she can sleep at ours for the night. Before I could even say anything DH jumped in and said no. I would probably have said yes as we have enough room. I told her I’d speak to DH and gave her some money to get a coffee with in the meantime, I told her to text me with what coffee shop she’s in and then once I’m dressed and once I’ve spoken to DH I’ll come and get a coffee with her and check she’s ok. She’s now texted me with what coffee shop she’s in but my DH is telling me not to go as I apparently “shouldn’t get involved”. There’s no way he’ll let her sleep here tonight if he doesn’t even want me to go to a coffee shop with her and check she’s ok. What do I do? Aibu to think DH is in the wrong here and is being insensitive to her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Callmenat · 26/03/2023 16:12

The comments on here saying that your dh is abusive are laughable. It's far more nuanced than this. Must be nice to live in such a binary world.

dogdaydown · 24/02/2023 20:30

MichelleScarn · 24/02/2023 20:10

Agree @ConcordeOoter why should op care about the disruption and upset to her own kids, now sharing their home, no dad at home, as long as their mum has a warm glow from supporting basically a stranger!

Exactly!

Just divorce your DH because he's got a totally justified response to the situation.

OhwhyOY · 24/02/2023 20:18

@Roarlikealiontonight any update? Hope you and your colleague and ger child are all OK.

MichelleScarn · 24/02/2023 20:10

Agree @ConcordeOoter why should op care about the disruption and upset to her own kids, now sharing their home, no dad at home, as long as their mum has a warm glow from supporting basically a stranger!

ConcordeOoter · 24/02/2023 19:34

BadNomad · 24/02/2023 07:50

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I'm curious to know how far that selflessness goes for you. For example, would you run into a burning building to rescue a stranger even if it meant you might die and leave your child without a mother? I'm sure some people would, but I think most people wouldn't.

I personally think it's natural for people to put their important people first. Their children, their partner. I think it's natural to not want to get involved in other people's dangerous circumstances. I actually think it's rather selfish to put other people before your own loved ones.

Indeed. I've been thinking about this thread and what I would do. I might help, by securing proper professional help, but I would not necessarily bring this random woman's situation under our roof where our children sleep.

I understand how we might all struggle with this when hospitality is so core to our humanity, but often what feels Nice and what is Right are not the same thing. An adult puts their own household first and their own children before their own interests, virtues, personal safety and reputation.

Someone who puts their children's safety somewhere down the list and indulges in self-congratulatory amateur, unqualified social work bringing other people's possibly violent problems into their home without any idea of how to deal with them is, frankly, halfway between an adult and a child. I have known that attitude to go wrong for the children in a bad way.

It isn't selfless to be selfless with your children's safety. It isn't heroic, and if OH is being the grown-up trying to calm it down, that doesn't make them the bad guy.

Truth be told, if this shit goes tits up who suffers the consequences? Primarily both families' DC. Maybe the adult house guest. Maybe (if he is lucky enough to get a chance to protect his family rather than it being eg petrol through the letterbox) DH as well.

strivingtosucceed · 24/02/2023 16:40

MichelleScarn · 24/02/2023 16:17

Definitely not!
'How dare he try and tell you what happens in the family home, you only course are the one that tells HIM what happens, and if he doesn't do what you demand he's obviously q evil, controlling bastard who you should lockout and divorce'Confused

It's always funny how this only seems to work one way round 🤔.

Eleganz · 24/02/2023 16:39

MichelleScarn · 24/02/2023 16:17

Definitely not!
'How dare he try and tell you what happens in the family home, you only course are the one that tells HIM what happens, and if he doesn't do what you demand he's obviously q evil, controlling bastard who you should lockout and divorce'Confused

Mumsnet in a nutshell there.

MichelleScarn · 24/02/2023 16:17

Definitely not!
'How dare he try and tell you what happens in the family home, you only course are the one that tells HIM what happens, and if he doesn't do what you demand he's obviously q evil, controlling bastard who you should lockout and divorce'Confused

AnneLovesGilbert · 24/02/2023 16:02

BoundShark · 24/02/2023 15:21

In all fairness the op has avoided repeating the words of the threatening messages. The one she did post was not threatening in any way. Actually the OP has avoided giving her husbands words any cover at all.

surely I cannot be the only one amused by the irony of someone proclaiming ‘ I wouldn’t even ask him , I would just tell him. I won’t be told what’s what in my house’. As more than one poster has said.

You’re not.

BoundShark · 24/02/2023 15:21

ManateeFair · 24/02/2023 14:52

I can see why he might feel weird about two strangers (to him) turning up in distress and staying the night in the house, especially as she's a work colleague and not a friend. However... he is being AWFUL in the way he's handling this. Even if he doesn't want her staying in the house, he has absolutely NO business telling you not to go and meet her in a coffee shop and he has no business sending you threatening texts and setting you ultimatums. He's a bullying twat.

In all fairness the op has avoided repeating the words of the threatening messages. The one she did post was not threatening in any way. Actually the OP has avoided giving her husbands words any cover at all.

surely I cannot be the only one amused by the irony of someone proclaiming ‘ I wouldn’t even ask him , I would just tell him. I won’t be told what’s what in my house’. As more than one poster has said.

ManateeFair · 24/02/2023 14:52

I can see why he might feel weird about two strangers (to him) turning up in distress and staying the night in the house, especially as she's a work colleague and not a friend. However... he is being AWFUL in the way he's handling this. Even if he doesn't want her staying in the house, he has absolutely NO business telling you not to go and meet her in a coffee shop and he has no business sending you threatening texts and setting you ultimatums. He's a bullying twat.

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 14:39

@PeanutButterSmoothie I sense you are a very literal kind of person.

PeanutButterSmoothie · 24/02/2023 11:47

When my elderly neighbour asked me for help turning the key in her front door she could have easily looked up a YouTube video on hand strengthening exercises.

Presumably she wanted to get into the house then and there. Not go somewhere and practice hand strengthening exercises for a few weeks before getting into her front door.

How would she even look up the videos if her computer and phone charger were in the house?

MichelleScarn · 24/02/2023 08:22

BoundShark · 24/02/2023 08:06

Ok so he has already been accused several times of shagging this woman that as far as we know he has never even laid eyes on. Now he is being accused of harming his own child. And you wonder why he didn’t want them in the house??????

the story made the papers , they stayed for far longer than ‘1 night’ we don’t even know if they have left even now. He has been called an abuser and worse . I just can’t figure out why he didn’t want to be involved…..

also to everyone saying ‘he didn’t let them in for even a cup of tea’. How exactly do you propose he got them out after the cup of tea? Even when he refused all contact with them , they still took over his house for several days. Please tell me how this would have played out any differently if he had offered them a cup of tea? Would they have chugged it and left perhaps?

Quite! Am surprised no ones then brought up maybe op and the woman are actually having the secret affair and now the husband has chosen to leave the home they can both just live there happily! The presumptions made from such little information!

Bubblebubblebah · 24/02/2023 08:10

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/02/2023 07:49

Yes, help can be provided in ways that don't include physically accommodating someone. That isn't the point. The point is that the DH refused to even let the woman in and told the OP to not go to the cafe to meet her and not to get involved.

I can't quite see how help can be provided if someone chooses not to get involved.

And yes, personally I do find that approach to be morally repugnant in either a man or a woman.

Mine would also tell me not to get involved. He knows I would but he would very much say no to them staying. I wouldn't be disregarding his feelings about people in house he lives in, but I know even with his protests I would at least meet her outside like op did.
He is compassionate but he does put my wellbeing above others. But he would most likely be VERY displeased if I totally ignored him and brought people in anyway. He couldn't go to his family, but he would be very disappointed in my disregard of his feelings. I would too if shoe was on the other foot.

Bloopsie · 24/02/2023 08:07

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 07:54

Not blind eye but why get other people involved in your relationship drama,

@Bloopsie Exactly. It's not just if your husband is beating the shit out of you. Why get people involved in any aspect of your life or drama as you put it?

There's no need to ask people for directions now we have phones. When my elderly neighbour asked me for help turning the key in her front door she could have easily looked up a YouTube video on hand strengthening exercises. If you're short, as I am, there is no need to bother tall people in the supermarket by asking them to reach things on the top shelf. You could just take a stick out with you and knock them down.

The more I think about it the more I realise what a wonderful world yours would be.

If someones husband is beating them as soon as out of the house and in safe place- you need to call the police right? I would assume the police would arrest the guy and she would not have to leave her home.

Maybe OPs husband is one of these people who does not like confontration and dosent want trouble at his door, what if the colleagues husband is so violent that he will bring a knife with him,is OPs husband supposed to risk his life? No,if there is domestic violence report it to the police who will make sure he will harm no one.

BoundShark · 24/02/2023 08:06

Kibby896 · 24/02/2023 05:31

Red flags. I don't want to say anything offensive... But talk to your daughter. There might be something you don't know or want to see about him. Is he always a jerk? Is your daughter afraid of him? Does she keep her night light on? Tell you nightmares?
Sometimes we are afraid to disappoint our mom. Especially if she looks happy.

Ok so he has already been accused several times of shagging this woman that as far as we know he has never even laid eyes on. Now he is being accused of harming his own child. And you wonder why he didn’t want them in the house??????

the story made the papers , they stayed for far longer than ‘1 night’ we don’t even know if they have left even now. He has been called an abuser and worse . I just can’t figure out why he didn’t want to be involved…..

also to everyone saying ‘he didn’t let them in for even a cup of tea’. How exactly do you propose he got them out after the cup of tea? Even when he refused all contact with them , they still took over his house for several days. Please tell me how this would have played out any differently if he had offered them a cup of tea? Would they have chugged it and left perhaps?

Aphrathestorm · 24/02/2023 08:03

Hope op and friend are ok.

BadNomad · 24/02/2023 08:00

I used to know a lovely Christian couple who would bring homeless men into their house to help them get back on their feet (organised through the church). Three separate men sexually abused their autistic daughter during those stays. But it didn't stop them. They had the spare room and it was the kind thing to do.

I'm sorry, but it really isn't kind to put your own family at risk for other people. I'd rather see a homeless man on the street than my daughter getting abuse. I'd rather see a woman and child stay in a hotel than risk a violent man coming to my door.

limitedperiodonly · 24/02/2023 07:54

Not blind eye but why get other people involved in your relationship drama,

@Bloopsie Exactly. It's not just if your husband is beating the shit out of you. Why get people involved in any aspect of your life or drama as you put it?

There's no need to ask people for directions now we have phones. When my elderly neighbour asked me for help turning the key in her front door she could have easily looked up a YouTube video on hand strengthening exercises. If you're short, as I am, there is no need to bother tall people in the supermarket by asking them to reach things on the top shelf. You could just take a stick out with you and knock them down.

The more I think about it the more I realise what a wonderful world yours would be.

BadNomad · 24/02/2023 07:50

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I'm curious to know how far that selflessness goes for you. For example, would you run into a burning building to rescue a stranger even if it meant you might die and leave your child without a mother? I'm sure some people would, but I think most people wouldn't.

I personally think it's natural for people to put their important people first. Their children, their partner. I think it's natural to not want to get involved in other people's dangerous circumstances. I actually think it's rather selfish to put other people before your own loved ones.

Bubblebubblebah · 24/02/2023 07:50

Also great how family vs acquaintance difference gets disregarded, how there is masaive abuse, yet we were actually not told that at all. We were told "she felt unsafe".
Anything so eople can tell other women how terrible humans they are.

Frnkly, I think this was "good" piece of writing, hit the right notes, it makes sense now that that is all it was, but still manages to give people good stick to beat women with.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/02/2023 07:49

Bubblebubblebah · 24/02/2023 07:45

I find repugnant that women here keep trying to shame other women into putting themselves and their families into potentially dangerous positions so they don't look heartless and are not "responsible for someone's death", even if they are not comfortable with it. Totally disregarding past traumas, experiences, present and future risks etc.

Sounds very much like "be kind" and "be a good gorl" on steroids on here.

Help can be provided without providing accomodation to your and others in it, detriment.

Yes, help can be provided in ways that don't include physically accommodating someone. That isn't the point. The point is that the DH refused to even let the woman in and told the OP to not go to the cafe to meet her and not to get involved.

I can't quite see how help can be provided if someone chooses not to get involved.

And yes, personally I do find that approach to be morally repugnant in either a man or a woman.

Bubblebubblebah · 24/02/2023 07:45

I find repugnant that women here keep trying to shame other women into putting themselves and their families into potentially dangerous positions so they don't look heartless and are not "responsible for someone's death", even if they are not comfortable with it. Totally disregarding past traumas, experiences, present and future risks etc.

Sounds very much like "be kind" and "be a good gorl" on steroids on here.

Help can be provided without providing accomodation to your and others in it, detriment.

Tippexy · 24/02/2023 07:43

Bubblebubblebah · 16/02/2023 21:24

So night 3?
He saw it coming. Sorry

I would love to know where in the country coffee shops are open at 9:30pm?