Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Condoms and rate of failure

107 replies

SisterAct123 · 14/02/2023 16:29

Condoms are also 98% effective at preventing pregnancy. This means that 2 out of 100 women using male condoms as contraception will become pregnant in a year. In real world use, about 15 in every 100 women a year who use condoms as contraception become pregnant (85% effective).

This is from the nhs website. How can they be so ineffective?

OP posts:
LittleLegoWoman · 15/02/2023 07:43

Sorry @Onnabugeisha , I had you mixed up with a poster called Cuppasouper. Who really was completely infuriating, asking for stats and then ignoring them, misunderstanding them, dismissing them and making up their own. It was exactly the problem of not being able to see that varied individual outcomes go into making up improbable probabilities.
I still stand by my view that it’s extremely unlikely (which does not mean impossible) that this baby has condom-using-man as the father.
Condoms really do not have a 2% failure rate everytime you use them. It’s 2% over a year. So if the average women in the surveyed was having sex once a week then it would be around 50 times less likely to happen in one er, usage. So more like 2/ 100x50 or a 1/2500 chance of falling pregnant from that one off. Of course there are things that we could take into account to make that stat more accurate. Like what point in her cycle she had sex with condom-wearing man. The odds of her getting pregnant from unprotected sex are more like 80-95% over a year (depending on age) and depending on what point in her cycle the sex happened, you could be looking at odds more like 1/3 for a one off occasion.

MummOf5 · 15/02/2023 07:38

I came across this thread by accident and thought I’d comment after reading other replies. I’ve fallen pregnant once while using condoms years ago. I couldn’t tell you exactly what happened…there was no obvious damage/rip/tear to the condom and it didn’t come off during so I concluded there must have been a leak that we couldn’t see. Perhaps it was just that small?
Additionally, I’ve also fallen pregnant whilst on the contraceptive pill. Before anyone asks…yes I was taking my pill every day and hadn’t missed any either! I’d been taking that specific pill regularly for a couple of years beforehand and I was meticulous about never missing any. No contraceptive is 100%! To be fair though, I have been told I’m extremely fertile so that probably didn’t help me.
Today I’m a mother of 5

LoveMAFS · 15/02/2023 07:23

In my 50+yrs, I've never once had a condom tear. How the f can they tear? I don't believe it.

sorrynotathome · 15/02/2023 07:17

User error. In 25 years of marriage the only times I got pregnant were planned (and within a month both times). Yes, we had a lot of sex thank you.

Heathcote294 · 15/02/2023 07:14

DH and I have used condoms for 25 years. Never had one fail. However, I know at least 10 babies born due to contraceptive pill failure.

EarringsandLipstick · 15/02/2023 07:11

So what protection does the app offer?

It's not guesswork. I mean (as per my post) relying on it is probably not a good idea. But you track where you are in your cycle, and will have information on your fertile time.

I wouldn't rely on it myself (given that cycles can vary randomly) but absolutely it can be used as a part of contraceptive approach. Not sure why that's so hard to understand?

Anyway aren't you more worried about your your friend's pregnancy & likely father of same, rather than the finer details of cycle tracking?

DemiColon · 15/02/2023 04:04

Most people totally underestimate the likelihood of accidental pregnancy with condoms or the Pill. They fail because they aren't perfect, and people aren't perfect either.

SisterAct123 · 15/02/2023 02:05

EarringsandLipstick · 14/02/2023 21:56

The app isn't protection?

Of course it is - it's a form of contraception (albeit not very reliable) based on when you are fertile in your cycle.

(The favoured & permitted form of family planning in the Catholic Church & the cause of many of the larger families of my youth! I found a great booklet about it in my parents' house - clearly an app can work out as more reliable but this booklet had all sorts of guidelines & calculations that could be made).

How is it protection?

It seems to be guess work. Hormonal contraction is obvious, you trick you body into thinking it's pregnant/stop ovulation. Barrier method you stop the seamen.

So what protection does the app offer?

OP posts:
PrincessHoneysuckle · 14/02/2023 23:50

@QuietlyConfident I decided against it snd I'm carrying on will the pill

QuietlyConfident · 14/02/2023 23:47

PrincessHoneysuckle · 14/02/2023 22:35

I was shocked when told by a gynae consultant that female tube tying is less effective than the pill!

Yes, contrary to our natural intuition, standard female sterilisation isn't really good enough if pregnancy would be an absolute disaster (eg if pregnancy would be dangerous and abortion is illegal).

xogossipgirlxo · 14/02/2023 23:39

I think it’s incorrect use, i.e. wrong size? Bought in dodgy place? We’ve been using condoms for 13 years and not a single accident, planned pregnancy now. I know a couple who had broken condom 3 times. They must be doing something wrong.

Deathbyfluffy · 14/02/2023 22:58

Tuilpmouse · 14/02/2023 22:44

OP - Given that your friend is apparently a very anxious person and doesn't believe in abortion, WTAF was she thinking?

Also, I'm thinking the likelihood of getting pregnant over a course of a year when using a condom would be very dependent on sexual frequency. Someone having sex twice a day, every day (exhausting!) with a condom would be massively more likely to get pregnant than someone doing it once a month.

I was thinking this - especially with two blokes in close succession 😬

Blablablanamechangagain · 14/02/2023 22:52

SisterAct123 · 14/02/2023 21:17

Doesn't it need for the sperm to get on the cervix?

Are you the "friend"?...

LumpySpaceCow · 14/02/2023 22:48

MrMarkham · 14/02/2023 20:09

Anyone else thinking of Ross from friends? 😬

Haha! Me! Came here to see if anyone else was 🤣🙈

Tuilpmouse · 14/02/2023 22:44

OP - Given that your friend is apparently a very anxious person and doesn't believe in abortion, WTAF was she thinking?

Also, I'm thinking the likelihood of getting pregnant over a course of a year when using a condom would be very dependent on sexual frequency. Someone having sex twice a day, every day (exhausting!) with a condom would be massively more likely to get pregnant than someone doing it once a month.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 14/02/2023 22:35

I was shocked when told by a gynae consultant that female tube tying is less effective than the pill!

RealBecca · 14/02/2023 22:34

When she had sex during her cycle will factor into it as well.

DifferenceEngines · 14/02/2023 22:00

Scaevola · 14/02/2023 20:01

If someone was to use a condom correctly would there be no chance of pregnancy?

No, the 'perfect use' still has a failure rate. So you can have used condoms correctly, assiduously and with no sign of anything amiss, and still a (very small) number will end up with a pregnancy.

The same is true for every other method (including sterilisation)

Only abstinence and hysterectomy appear to be 100%

Implant is pretty close, as long as it's in the skin properly.

EarringsandLipstick · 14/02/2023 21:56

The app isn't protection?

Of course it is - it's a form of contraception (albeit not very reliable) based on when you are fertile in your cycle.

(The favoured & permitted form of family planning in the Catholic Church & the cause of many of the larger families of my youth! I found a great booklet about it in my parents' house - clearly an app can work out as more reliable but this booklet had all sorts of guidelines & calculations that could be made).

Devoutspoken · 14/02/2023 21:51

Yes they are ineffective

LondonQueen · 14/02/2023 21:49

I imagine it includes people who don't use them or who use them incorrectly. Out of date condoms probably have a high failure rate too.

SisterAct123 · 14/02/2023 21:48

Hubblebubble · 14/02/2023 21:25

I've had condoms come off completely and had to fish them out. I've had them split too. I got pregnant as a result of a condom combined with a tracker app. So never had sex in my calculated fertile window and when I did it was with a condom. Nothings 100 percent and someone has to be the statistic. Its cool, all turned out for the best. But 3 forms of protection, not 2 I reckon.

Three forms of protection? The app isn't protection?

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 14/02/2023 21:39

@LittleLegoWoman

Regardless of what the other thread was about, it's totally unfair to come on a new thread and start detailing it like this, as well as berating a poster in the way you did. If you've got @Onnabugeisha mixed up with someone, I hope you'll acknowledge this.

Hubblebubble · 14/02/2023 21:25

I've had condoms come off completely and had to fish them out. I've had them split too. I got pregnant as a result of a condom combined with a tracker app. So never had sex in my calculated fertile window and when I did it was with a condom. Nothings 100 percent and someone has to be the statistic. Its cool, all turned out for the best. But 3 forms of protection, not 2 I reckon.

Onnabugeisha · 14/02/2023 21:21

@LittleLegoWoman
The thread where you totally failed to understand stats was about breastfeeding where for some reason you seemed to believe the health benefits of breastfeeding are always irrelevant at an individual level despite the fact that stats like ´average number of hospital admissions for gastrointestinal illness’ are binary outcomes like getting pregnant/not get pregnant and so for some individual babies breastfeeding must be the thing tipping the balance or those stats would not exist.

Could you please link me to this thread? I honestly have no memory of being on a thread about breastfeeding & health benefits. I tend to steer clear of such debates. I think you may have me confused with someone else?