Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Condoms and rate of failure

107 replies

SisterAct123 · 14/02/2023 16:29

Condoms are also 98% effective at preventing pregnancy. This means that 2 out of 100 women using male condoms as contraception will become pregnant in a year. In real world use, about 15 in every 100 women a year who use condoms as contraception become pregnant (85% effective).

This is from the nhs website. How can they be so ineffective?

OP posts:
Mainlinethehappy · 15/02/2023 09:51

SnakeOiler · 15/02/2023 08:59

As the woman who suffered from two split condoms, one resulting in pregnancy and termination and the follow on mental health issues linked to that, I find your comment deeply vulgar and quite frankly, nasty.

I should also add they were durex condoms, and in date!

@SnakeOiler I’m with you. I’ve had condoms split many times. Blowing them up and filling them up with water doesn’t replicate friction, ffs! Ignore the idiots x

QuietlyConfident · 15/02/2023 09:43

BertieBotts · 15/02/2023 09:24

No that's not what the stats say at all. It's not that you'd have to try for 50 years to get a pregnancy, it's that 2 couples out of 100 will get pregnant in that one year. That is cumulative, so after 10 years, you have about a 20% chance - 1 in 5 couples will have an unplanned pregnancy within that 10 year period of using condoms.

The rate slows down over time (because there is a smaller group left who have not yet had an accidental pregnancy) so it's about 37 years before you get to it being more likely than not (over 50% odds) of an accidental pregnancy. It tops out at about a 75% chance at 61 years because the rate is then increasing much more slowly - although, obviously, nobody is fertile for 61 years, so it's irrelevant.

That's true of course - I was over-simplifying to make the true point that the posters who've used condoms for a couple decades with no unwanted pregnancies don't disprove the failure rate stats at all.

BertieBotts · 15/02/2023 09:26

steppemum · 15/02/2023 09:23

my understanding is that the failure rate is extremely high among young peoepl using them in their first year of having sex, about 60% failiure rate or something.

So that will skew the stats.

I used them all through uni and had 2 break/fall off and had to have morning after pill. We were sensible and careful too.

I think this is a societal myth - younger people are more likely to be on less-reliable forms of contraception and the costs are higher of an unplanned pregnancy so these pregnancies are more "visible" but I'm not sure that the rate of failure is actually higher when these things are taken into account.

BertieBotts · 15/02/2023 09:24

QuietlyConfident · 15/02/2023 08:30

The stats suggest that you'd expect one pregnancy every fifty years. All the people on this thread are saying they've used them successfully for ten, fifteen, twenty five years: they still probably wouldn't expect a failure leading to pregnancy with perfect use.

That said, is there anyone on this thread saying that they used condoms perfectly but still had an unintended pregnancy? I can't remember without reading all the way back.

No that's not what the stats say at all. It's not that you'd have to try for 50 years to get a pregnancy, it's that 2 couples out of 100 will get pregnant in that one year. That is cumulative, so after 10 years, you have about a 20% chance - 1 in 5 couples will have an unplanned pregnancy within that 10 year period of using condoms.

The rate slows down over time (because there is a smaller group left who have not yet had an accidental pregnancy) so it's about 37 years before you get to it being more likely than not (over 50% odds) of an accidental pregnancy. It tops out at about a 75% chance at 61 years because the rate is then increasing much more slowly - although, obviously, nobody is fertile for 61 years, so it's irrelevant.

steppemum · 15/02/2023 09:23

my understanding is that the failure rate is extremely high among young peoepl using them in their first year of having sex, about 60% failiure rate or something.

So that will skew the stats.

I used them all through uni and had 2 break/fall off and had to have morning after pill. We were sensible and careful too.

BertieBotts · 15/02/2023 09:09

Any form of contraception that requires action at the moment of intercourse is doomed to a higher failure rate, because when you are sexually aroused, your brain chemistry changes and people are less moral, less cautious, less aware of longer-term risks or goals, and more likely to take risks.

Even if you are a conscientious, risk-averse person when you are at a baseline, when you're aroused you're more likely than usual to throw caution to the wind and prioritise short term pleasure over long term concerns. This directly contributes to lower usage of contraception. It's also behind a phenomenon where people will look at porn that normally disgusts them, apparently.

It's probably an evolutionary thing, as in when you're in a position to get pregnant, nature tries its best to make sure you get pregnant. I know that condoms aren't part of nature, but for example abstaining from sex or pulling out is a natural form of contraception and nature/evolution favours the humans that did not do those things.

I don't think it's true that the stats are untrue because people lie; they don't get those stats from polling people who are already pregnant, they are pretty robust studies where couples are randomly assigned a method.

People saying that the number of contraception fails on this site (or any) are unbelievable simply have a poor understanding of statistics. A 2% failure rate every year means 1 in 50. There are many, many, many times more than 50 people on this website and most people are sexually active for several years of their life, not just one year.

The amount of unplanned pregnancies is very high - I think it's something like 1 in 4? We don't notice the majority of them because if people are already coupled up/married and decide to go through with it, it is not always obvious whether the pregnancy was actively tried for or came along a little early in the plan or was an "oops, oh well, just one more!" and for somebody who it would be a disaster, thankfully we have fairly easy access to abortion in this country so she would not have to go through with it. Therefore, the amount of unplanned pregnancies we "see" is much lower and we assume that it is something rare, but it isn't really, it's very common. That is all unplanned pregnancies ranging from contraception failure with perfect use to contraception failure due to incomplete knowledge about how to use it, and from not using contraception at all or knowingly using it wrongly but thinking it won't matter.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 09:08

EatYourVegetables · 15/02/2023 07:44

I’ve been using condoms as a main method of contraception for 25 years now. In that whole time two of them broke - both from the same box.

i think 98 involves some very incorrect use.

I agree, but I would blame 50% on user error. People very often buy wrong size, or don't store them properly. Personally, I don't think I could use a condom taken out from wallet, god knows how long it's been sitting there, but people do it anyway.

ellie09 · 15/02/2023 09:03

Any method has a failure rate. Absitenence is the only way to avoid.

In my experience of condoms, which I usually associate with one night stands or short relationships, are sometimes used when drunk.

Back with one of my exes at the start, we were both very drunk and realized the next morning that the condom actually fell off as it wasn't put on properly. Its safe to say I got the coil a short time later.

Aphrathestorm · 15/02/2023 08:59

Also I don't know how the stats are skewed by incidences where you know the condom split etc then used the map right away.

An advantage of condoms over hormones is that you usually know at the time if they have failed.

Then at least you can try to minimise the chances-map to hand, good wash and spermicide etc!

SnakeOiler · 15/02/2023 08:59

Pyewhacket · 15/02/2023 08:36

I’d agree with that. And as for splitting. There’s that old student gag of pulling one over your head and blowing it up using your nose. They blow up to double the size of your head without splitting and they’ll easily hold 4/5 litres of water. But then the rate of contraception failure on this site overall is quite literally, unbelievable !.

As the woman who suffered from two split condoms, one resulting in pregnancy and termination and the follow on mental health issues linked to that, I find your comment deeply vulgar and quite frankly, nasty.

I should also add they were durex condoms, and in date!

Moopsi · 15/02/2023 08:46

MrMarkham · 14/02/2023 20:09

Anyone else thinking of Ross from friends? 😬

Yes! As soon as I saw the title.

QuietlyConfident · 15/02/2023 08:42

After checking back, there's three women on this thread saying they got pregnant while using condoms perfectly in their opinion: two from obvious splits and one from invisible error.

Pyewhacket · 15/02/2023 08:36

Babdoc · 15/02/2023 08:07

The statistics are skewed because people lie.
Some pregnant women seeking termination are too embarrassed to admit to the doctor that they didn’t use any contraception, so they claim that the condom failed.
It’s the only believable method to blame, since it would be obvious if they had never been fitted with a coil or prescribed the pill. In my experience, condoms from British manufacturers, eg London Rubber, makers of Durex, are extremely reliable when used In accordance with instructions.

I’d agree with that. And as for splitting. There’s that old student gag of pulling one over your head and blowing it up using your nose. They blow up to double the size of your head without splitting and they’ll easily hold 4/5 litres of water. But then the rate of contraception failure on this site overall is quite literally, unbelievable !.

QuietlyConfident · 15/02/2023 08:30

EatYourVegetables · 15/02/2023 07:44

I’ve been using condoms as a main method of contraception for 25 years now. In that whole time two of them broke - both from the same box.

i think 98 involves some very incorrect use.

The stats suggest that you'd expect one pregnancy every fifty years. All the people on this thread are saying they've used them successfully for ten, fifteen, twenty five years: they still probably wouldn't expect a failure leading to pregnancy with perfect use.

That said, is there anyone on this thread saying that they used condoms perfectly but still had an unintended pregnancy? I can't remember without reading all the way back.

KimberleyClark · 15/02/2023 08:30

I knew someone who claimed to have got pregnant while on the pill and using condoms, with no apparent condom malfunction or reason for reduced effectiveness of the pill. I found it difficult to believe, the chances of condom malfunction happening exactly the same time as the pill failing must be pretty small…….

Hubblebubble · 15/02/2023 08:19

I wonder how often the failure is down to the wrong size being used

Babdoc · 15/02/2023 08:07

The statistics are skewed because people lie.
Some pregnant women seeking termination are too embarrassed to admit to the doctor that they didn’t use any contraception, so they claim that the condom failed.
It’s the only believable method to blame, since it would be obvious if they had never been fitted with a coil or prescribed the pill. In my experience, condoms from British manufacturers, eg London Rubber, makers of Durex, are extremely reliable when used In accordance with instructions.

TicketBoo23 · 15/02/2023 08:04

In spite of the failure rate, even if used correctly, it's low enough that - if they used them correctly - condom wearing guy is much much less likely to father any child than non condom wearing guy.

She also needs an std check if she had unprotected sex twice in a ONS.

TicketBoo23 · 15/02/2023 08:01

SisterAct123 · 14/02/2023 16:39

If someone was to use a condom correctly would there be no chance of pregnancy?

I'm talking to a pub friend who is telling me has been dating two guys and had sex with both. One bareback and other condom, (condom guy was first).

She's stating she's worried she won't know who the farther is..... The non condom guy came in the condom and he lasted a few minutes, bareback came inside her twice.

She's very vulnerable and I've told her to seek assistance and everything.

I'm a bit confused, is she definitely pregnant?

TicketBoo23 · 15/02/2023 07:58

I would agree that the likelihood of the unprotected sex man being the father is still much higher than that with the condom wearing man.

Though is does depend on cycle.

TicketBoo23 · 15/02/2023 07:57

(the "it" being a sperm)

TicketBoo23 · 15/02/2023 07:57

*Semen

TicketBoo23 · 15/02/2023 07:56

Sent only has to get somewhere that it can swim from. That can even be the vulva. Pregnancies have occasionally happened from ejaculation on the vulva.

But he ejaculated inside her, presumably anyway?

SisterAct123 · 15/02/2023 07:49

EatYourVegetables · 15/02/2023 07:44

I’ve been using condoms as a main method of contraception for 25 years now. In that whole time two of them broke - both from the same box.

i think 98 involves some very incorrect use.

Pregnancy isn't 100% every incidence of unprotected sex so this 2% must be alot of broken condoms

OP posts:
EatYourVegetables · 15/02/2023 07:44

I’ve been using condoms as a main method of contraception for 25 years now. In that whole time two of them broke - both from the same box.

i think 98 involves some very incorrect use.