Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Condoms and rate of failure

107 replies

SisterAct123 · 14/02/2023 16:29

Condoms are also 98% effective at preventing pregnancy. This means that 2 out of 100 women using male condoms as contraception will become pregnant in a year. In real world use, about 15 in every 100 women a year who use condoms as contraception become pregnant (85% effective).

This is from the nhs website. How can they be so ineffective?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RosaBonheur · 16/02/2023 08:52

I used condoms as my sole method of contraception for about three months with my now husband when we were in a long distance relationship. One came off and I found myself crouching on the bathroom floor with my fingers in my vagina, rooting around up by my cervix to retrieve it. The next day I made an appointment to have a coil fitted.

AndTheSurveySays · 16/02/2023 08:46

The condoms do hurt him a little and bigger ones could slip off, so we don't use the latter

If the condoms hurt they are too small and at risk of splitting. Too big and they slip off.
Try other brands. Pasante is well known and sold on the NHS site. Your husband could even get measured and try a more tailored condom from a company like MySize.

BertieBotts · 16/02/2023 08:17

Condoms really do not have a 2% failure rate everytime you use them. It’s 2% over a year. So if the average women in the surveyed was having sex once a week then it would be around 50 times less likely to happen in one er, usage. So more like 2/ 100x50 or a 1/2500 chance of falling pregnant from that one off. Of course there are things that we could take into account to make that stat more accurate. Like what point in her cycle she had sex with condom-wearing man. The odds of her getting pregnant from unprotected sex are more like 80-95% over a year (depending on age) and depending on what point in her cycle the sex happened, you could be looking at odds more like 1/3 for a one off occasion.

But this is not quite right either. I know that you said that it matters where she was in her cycle, but it matters much, much, much more than you seem to be suggesting. It is not a 1/2500 chance per occurence of sexual intercourse because that is not how conception chance works. This is a huge misconception that many people have, myself included until I started to look into it due to infertility.

Basically, a woman can only get pregnant if she has sex during her fertile window. It does seem that some women can ovulate more than once so may have multiple fertile windows, though I really don't know how common that is. But in any case, although you would logically think that having sex 10 times during the fertile window would result in 10x higher chance of pregnancy than once, that's not actually the case at all. The reality is if you have sex even once during your fertile window, there is around an 80% chance that at least one sperm will come into contact with that egg. So it doesn't matter if you have sex multiple times or once, because you're already going to have a zygote get created more often than not. You'd have a slightly higher chance if having sex multiple times, but the main benefit (if TTC) or risk (if trying to prevent pregnancy) of having sex multiple times is that most methods we have to determine the fertile window are not particularly accurate and/or only work in retrospect, so if you only have sex once, you might miss the fertile window all together. Some TTC methods even refer to shagging every other day as "carpet bombing" which refers to the attempt to ensure that the fertile window is hit.

Now I'm sure you're going to say but wait, it's not an 80% chance of pregnancy after one fertile cycle, and you're right, because what happens next depends on the quality of the sperm and egg. Even in a young, healthy couple with no genetic issues or sperm issues, around 3/4 of the time, the body rejects this egg/sperm combo as being too low quality and it simply never gets to the stage of implantation and comes out with the woman's period. (Thus reducing the 80% to about 20% conception chance per fertile window) This is not a miscarriage, or even a chemical pregnancy, it's a failure of implantation. It happens before any of those things and it is quite common and normal and not even medically considered to be pregnancy at all. As both men and women age, their egg and sperm quality degrade, so you go from roughly a 20-25% chance of conception per cycle to a lower and lower chance the older that you get, that is the mechanism by how fertility declines with age, as well as of course menopause.

But this is why it doesn't matter how often you have sex and why percentage chances don't vary hugely between different couples even if one couple has sex once a month and another has sex every day. The fertile window is approximately 25% of a woman's cycle, but many people prefer not to have sex on their period, (and if you did, you'd know that you were not fertile) so that wipes out another 25% or so, and biology tends to mean that we are more likely to want to have sex during our fertile phase, so the chances of you having sex at a random time and it just happening to be within the fertile window are quite high, probably about 1/2 or 1/3.

Chance of pregnancy with condom used perfectly during fertile window = about 0.1% / 1 in 1000.
Chance of pregnancy with condom used perfectly during non-fertile part of cycle = essentially null
Chance of pregnancy with condom used perfectly, unknown time in cycle = maybe 1 in 2000-3000?

Hmmm OK so I actually came to the same conclusion as you in the end 😂 I think in a roundabout way, we agree, even though I thought that I was saying something different.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 21:51

Sexypyjamas · 15/02/2023 21:22

We rely on condoms. I won't let DH inside without a condom on. When it's my fertile time I tend to not want sex because I'm that anxious about things going wrong with the condom. The pill made me feel suicidal so I had to stop it. Couldn't take Microgynon because of headaches. I refuse to have a coil fitted (heard horror stories). DH won't get the snip (he's scared of losing sensitivity or things going wrong). We use Durex and always check the expiry date. We are careful and check it hasn't slipped off mid sex. The condoms do hurt him a little and bigger ones could slip off, so we don't use the latter. I'm now a bit worried after reading this. I love sex with my DH but I'm terrified of getting pregnant at 40. I've never had problems with condoms in the past. I don't want to jinx myself.

durex are very reliable, imo

Sexypyjamas · 15/02/2023 21:22

We rely on condoms. I won't let DH inside without a condom on. When it's my fertile time I tend to not want sex because I'm that anxious about things going wrong with the condom. The pill made me feel suicidal so I had to stop it. Couldn't take Microgynon because of headaches. I refuse to have a coil fitted (heard horror stories). DH won't get the snip (he's scared of losing sensitivity or things going wrong). We use Durex and always check the expiry date. We are careful and check it hasn't slipped off mid sex. The condoms do hurt him a little and bigger ones could slip off, so we don't use the latter. I'm now a bit worried after reading this. I love sex with my DH but I'm terrified of getting pregnant at 40. I've never had problems with condoms in the past. I don't want to jinx myself.

QuietlyConfident · 15/02/2023 20:58

Talking about the stats that way round isn't that helpful I've always thought. If you're not very numerate then 95%, 98%, 99%, 99.5%, 99.6% all sound "really effective, you'll be fine". Even the "real world" condom failure rate of 85% effective sounds pretty good. But there's a world of difference between one in twenty and one in two hundred and fifty.

steppemum · 15/02/2023 17:56

BertieBotts · 15/02/2023 09:26

I think this is a societal myth - younger people are more likely to be on less-reliable forms of contraception and the costs are higher of an unplanned pregnancy so these pregnancies are more "visible" but I'm not sure that the rate of failure is actually higher when these things are taken into account.

I disagree, as I was told it by a medical professional on a talk about supporting teens.
Anyone using them for the first time without some explanation is likely to do things wrong. Eg not put them on properly, not withdraw as soon as ejaculation has happened etc.
That leads to failure rate.
This is of course not that the condom has failed, but rather that they are not being used correctly.

98% always sounds like a nice solid safe number, until you look at a year group on school, eg 200 kids. If they all paired up and all had sex, then there would be a pregnant teen. That is a much scarier, statistic.

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 16:42

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 15:06

And it was always broken in this short window of fertile days?

I didn’t put my friend on trial and impugn her honesty as that’s a stupid question unless you are implying one is lying. Of course she was fertile, she got pregnant and of course the condom malfunctioned, as they were using them. With 15 in 100 getting pregnant every year, your odds are not that good over thirty years.

Icedlatteplease · 15/02/2023 16:32

I'm fantastic at squeezing the damn things off. Four different partners, drunk or stone cold sober, they put it on or I do, I can only think of one occasion I was 100% confident it worked. I'm always agog at people who actually rely on them.

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 16:12

@xogossipgirlxo very true. We will never know lol

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 16:00

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 15:58

@xogossipgirlxo I will add that would be the first out of the supply from the family planning pack that's ever failed on me.
However he didn't want to wear it and was having a strop when I insisted he wore it so he faffed around putting it on. So I guess he made it useless by doing that

Yeah, probably user error was incorporated. Unless it's done in strict scientific environment, it's hard to say who's being honest about using pill, condom etc. properly.

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 15:58

@xogossipgirlxo I will add that would be the first out of the supply from the family planning pack that's ever failed on me.
However he didn't want to wear it and was having a strop when I insisted he wore it so he faffed around putting it on. So I guess he made it useless by doing that

Sartre · 15/02/2023 15:48

People don’t use them properly, especially when drunk or inexperienced. They try to take them off whilst still inside for example or just don’t fit it properly in the first place. They can also fall off on their own or tear although this isn’t as common.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 15:44

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 15:42

@xogossipgirlxo hahaha well the ones that split with my daughter were supplied by the family planning clinic. It says XCS on the packet. I should actually bin them tbh lol

The other times were about 20 years so sorry can't remember those ones but the guy brought them both times

Wow, well done to family planning clinic😂Goal achieved. Just kidding. We always use Durex and honestly never had a problem with them. It would be interesting to see if i.e. those extra thin ones break more often etc. I need to do my research.

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 15:42

@xogossipgirlxo hahaha well the ones that split with my daughter were supplied by the family planning clinic. It says XCS on the packet. I should actually bin them tbh lol

The other times were about 20 years so sorry can't remember those ones but the guy brought them both times

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 15:17

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 15:13

@SisterAct123 the first two no. Only realised when my period was late.

3rd time yes - the tear was really visible so I went that morning (the happy act happened at about 4am) to the chemist and got the MAP that's supposed to cover you for 72 hours.
Seriously didn't think I could be preggers because of no period for 3 months but took it anyway

Out of curiosity do you know the brand of condom? I'm wondering which ones have the highest accidents rate

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 15:13

@SisterAct123 the first two no. Only realised when my period was late.

3rd time yes - the tear was really visible so I went that morning (the happy act happened at about 4am) to the chemist and got the MAP that's supposed to cover you for 72 hours.
Seriously didn't think I could be preggers because of no period for 3 months but took it anyway

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 15:06

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 10:59

There’s no need to explain, 3 condom failures over thirty years of sex isn’t unbelievable at all.

And it was always broken in this short window of fertile days?

SisterAct123 · 15/02/2023 14:51

doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 11:13

I've got pregnant three times in my life while still using a condom (2 resulted in miscarriages unfortunately)
But the third (my beautiful DD) was conceived when I hadn't ovulated for months, used a condom that had a massive tear when he pulled out, I then went and got a morning after pill.
None of this worked and my daughter was born in the July. I wasn't happy to be pregnant because the guy was a knob but she is the most beautiful thing in my life so silver lining and all that lol

Thanks for sharing.

Did you know the condom had broken on all occasions?

OP posts:
doublechocolatedigestives · 15/02/2023 11:13

I've got pregnant three times in my life while still using a condom (2 resulted in miscarriages unfortunately)
But the third (my beautiful DD) was conceived when I hadn't ovulated for months, used a condom that had a massive tear when he pulled out, I then went and got a morning after pill.
None of this worked and my daughter was born in the July. I wasn't happy to be pregnant because the guy was a knob but she is the most beautiful thing in my life so silver lining and all that lol

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 10:59

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 10:44

But how to explain condom failure three times? Unless she's chosen one and should try playing Jackpot with this amount of weird luck.

There’s no need to explain, 3 condom failures over thirty years of sex isn’t unbelievable at all.

xogossipgirlxo · 15/02/2023 10:44

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 10:30

One of my closest friends is like this. She got pregnant on the pill. So then she used the pill + condoms, and still got pregnant. She then went on the implant + condoms, and still got pregnant- three more times. The whole time she was blamed for not taking the pill/using condoms correctly or it was a ‘bad batch’ of implants.

I have read studies though where a minority of women are immune to hormonal contraception. Their bodies literally produce counter hormones to override the contraception. Like this study: www.discovermagazine.com/health/genetics-may-explain-why-birth-control-doesnt-always-work-for-some-women

Different women have sperm friendly to sperm hostile vaginas & cervical mucous as well. How easy it is for the sperm to swim and survive affects fertility too.

But how to explain condom failure three times? Unless she's chosen one and should try playing Jackpot with this amount of weird luck.

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 10:30

KimberleyClark · 15/02/2023 08:30

I knew someone who claimed to have got pregnant while on the pill and using condoms, with no apparent condom malfunction or reason for reduced effectiveness of the pill. I found it difficult to believe, the chances of condom malfunction happening exactly the same time as the pill failing must be pretty small…….

One of my closest friends is like this. She got pregnant on the pill. So then she used the pill + condoms, and still got pregnant. She then went on the implant + condoms, and still got pregnant- three more times. The whole time she was blamed for not taking the pill/using condoms correctly or it was a ‘bad batch’ of implants.

I have read studies though where a minority of women are immune to hormonal contraception. Their bodies literally produce counter hormones to override the contraception. Like this study: www.discovermagazine.com/health/genetics-may-explain-why-birth-control-doesnt-always-work-for-some-women

Different women have sperm friendly to sperm hostile vaginas & cervical mucous as well. How easy it is for the sperm to swim and survive affects fertility too.

WaltzingWaters · 15/02/2023 10:22

I used condoms/and or pills for 16 years with various partners and never once had a problem. Then current partner we had one split early on, used a morning after pill, still got pregnant. Next used the pill, took consistently, got pregnant. Nothing but abstinence is going to completely prevent you from pregnancy.

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 10:14

LittleLegoWoman · 15/02/2023 07:43

Sorry @Onnabugeisha , I had you mixed up with a poster called Cuppasouper. Who really was completely infuriating, asking for stats and then ignoring them, misunderstanding them, dismissing them and making up their own. It was exactly the problem of not being able to see that varied individual outcomes go into making up improbable probabilities.
I still stand by my view that it’s extremely unlikely (which does not mean impossible) that this baby has condom-using-man as the father.
Condoms really do not have a 2% failure rate everytime you use them. It’s 2% over a year. So if the average women in the surveyed was having sex once a week then it would be around 50 times less likely to happen in one er, usage. So more like 2/ 100x50 or a 1/2500 chance of falling pregnant from that one off. Of course there are things that we could take into account to make that stat more accurate. Like what point in her cycle she had sex with condom-wearing man. The odds of her getting pregnant from unprotected sex are more like 80-95% over a year (depending on age) and depending on what point in her cycle the sex happened, you could be looking at odds more like 1/3 for a one off occasion.

Thank you @LittleLegoWoman for acknowledging you mixed me up with another poster. I’ve done it myself, it can be hard to keep track of who said what. So no hard feelings.

I haven’t commented on or disagreed with you on the likelihood of which man is the father. Fwiw, I think your reasoning on that count is perfectly sound.

I suppose I should reply to you & others by saying briefly what I agree with in future, not just what I’m adding to or clarifying as it gave you the impression I disagreed with everything you said- when I actually agreed with 95%. I need to slow down sometimes.