Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone well versed in end of life care?

62 replies

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 15:42

backstory: 2 very close relatives passed away in hospital. Mother is adamant the hospital, drs nurses etc killed them or at least sped up the process. She now has a friend who is sadly eol due to cancer, she’s now started saying ( I really hope not to the family) that the hospital has started to withdraw meds and fluids in an effort to hurry things along.

as she’s said this a lot, it’s quite upsetting (in relation to my family members and in general). When my relative was slipping away my mother heavily emphasised they were being deprived of resources to hasten the process, I recall talking to an ITU consultant and he said there’s no evidence that withholding fluid or food in EoL improves anything so they give patients food or fluid if they want it, but often they don’t and sometimes it’s not safe. I feel like I read something about and EoL patients often because quite water heavy? And adding fluid to that can make them more uncomfortable and making breathing more difficult? Could someone explain it to me please? I don’t quite understand and don’t have anyone to explain in RL.

please be gentle, thank you

OP posts:
Twentywisteria · 14/02/2023 20:36

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/02/2023 20:33

As some doctor once put it, ‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

An aunt of mine refused food and drink during her last several days. I sat with her a lot and saw her repeatedly closing her mouth and turning her head away. When organs are starting to shut down, they can’t cope with food and drink.

Sadly families find this very hard to understand. I've had to stop a lot of well-meaning family members from forcing food into the mouths of dying patients because they believe eating will stop them from dying. Sometimes they've aspirated or even choked.

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 20:36

Suzi888 · 14/02/2023 20:30

My father went as @Fraaahnces describes. G.P was a family friend and came every day. Dad was at home with us, it was quite a short period of time (2 weeks). I can’t recall exactly but first of all he was eating a small amount of porridge and water, hallucinating, moving around a lot, but very uncoordinated, fell and he was very agitated.

A syringe driver was fitted and then he started to mostly sleep, medication for other ailments was stopped, he was slipping in and out of consciousness and we were wetting his lips.

It was hard for DM, it was only afterwards she realised that his death had been hastened somewhat. (We were relieved as there had been suffering prior to this). If someone is in pain, dying, you want them to pass as peacefully and quickly as possible, with as much dignity as can be afforded. If someone isn’t going to get better, what’s the point in prolonging their suffering.

Does your mum think the doctors are acting illegally? Causing pain? That the sick person could make a full recovery if they weren’t having fluids etc withdrawn?

It was difficult for us as we were initially under the impression my father was going to have chemotherapy. Then it became clear that he was being “helped on his way” as DM described it…. I wish the doctors had told us what was happening, or perhaps we were in so much shock that it didn’t really sink in at the time.

Friend, she was told she had bowel cancer that had spread and was likely incurable, she had scans that showed this, dr diagnosed from scans without a biopsy, mother then went around telling her friend that they were wrong shouldn’t have diagnosed her like that and probably wrong, low and behold biopsy confirmed what dr had said all along. They gave 4/6 weeks but then said they could look at other things, but I don’t know if these were just life extending rather than saving as I’m not close to the detail. Friend was having chemo but I guess it wasn’t working as it was stopped and then she was going to be discharged on palliative care but took a turn and never left hospital.

im sorry for your dad, that must have been incredibly hard! May he rest in peace

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/02/2023 20:33

As some doctor once put it, ‘They are not dying because they are not eating and drinking. They are not eating and drinking because they are dying.’

An aunt of mine refused food and drink during her last several days. I sat with her a lot and saw her repeatedly closing her mouth and turning her head away. When organs are starting to shut down, they can’t cope with food and drink.

Bababear987 · 14/02/2023 20:33

"Helped on their way" how exactly?

Suzi888 · 14/02/2023 20:30

My father went as @Fraaahnces describes. G.P was a family friend and came every day. Dad was at home with us, it was quite a short period of time (2 weeks). I can’t recall exactly but first of all he was eating a small amount of porridge and water, hallucinating, moving around a lot, but very uncoordinated, fell and he was very agitated.

A syringe driver was fitted and then he started to mostly sleep, medication for other ailments was stopped, he was slipping in and out of consciousness and we were wetting his lips.

It was hard for DM, it was only afterwards she realised that his death had been hastened somewhat. (We were relieved as there had been suffering prior to this). If someone is in pain, dying, you want them to pass as peacefully and quickly as possible, with as much dignity as can be afforded. If someone isn’t going to get better, what’s the point in prolonging their suffering.

Does your mum think the doctors are acting illegally? Causing pain? That the sick person could make a full recovery if they weren’t having fluids etc withdrawn?

It was difficult for us as we were initially under the impression my father was going to have chemotherapy. Then it became clear that he was being “helped on his way” as DM described it…. I wish the doctors had told us what was happening, or perhaps we were in so much shock that it didn’t really sink in at the time.

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 20:26

Unfortunately I don’t know either my mums friend or the family, so I can’t contact them. But I do wish she’d keep it zipped because the amount of harm she inflicted post both deaths was immeasurable and incredibly traumatic! My dad died 18 months ago and the other relative 5/6 years ago, she was offered counselling by the hospital but refused it. She’s quite aggressive with her views too, not the type to backdown if challenged. I’ve told her how hurtful those words would be to the family but it’s in one ear out of the other

OP posts:
Bababear987 · 14/02/2023 20:21

In my experience it's almost the opposite, the doctors almost try too much when its apparent for quite a while that the patient will not survive.

Fluids are usually given IV through canulas- often these canulas collapse or are pulled out by the patient etc and then the medical staff have to re-insert them and if this is happening daily or multiple times a day they often decide it's not worth causing the pain/discomfort to the patient.

Hospital generally doesnt withhold food and water, it's more the patients refuse it and often the refuse medications.

With regards to medications, yes a lot of them are stopped but its because theres no point. For example things like statins are stopped because we arent worried about peoples cholesterol if they arent likely to survive or arent eating. (Statins are a long-term medication to prevent future events) A lot of the time when people approach the end their blood pressure and heart rate decrease so therefore they have no need for medications that they were on when they came in to hospital.

It genuinly is all about keeping the patient comfortable and thinking about what's best for them. But sometimes families dont react well and I've seen a lot of accusations towards staff (murder, deliberate suffering, lying about giving meds, trying to free up beds etc).

Majority of times once theyve had time to understand the process and step back and their loved on does pass they thank the staff.

I dont know how to deal with your mum though, is she at the hospital quite a lot and with the family? Maybe speak to them and see if she is bothering/upsetting them and tell them if she over steps to tell her.

MissTrip82 · 14/02/2023 20:18

I care for many dying people. It’s a normal part of dying to stop eating and drinking. It’s just that most people have not seen normal dying.
It actually really bothers me how many people honestly believe I went into medicine to starve people to death. I have no idea why they think we’re monsters, or why they choose to hurt others by insisting on sharing their view with grieving people.

Nurse2022 · 14/02/2023 20:18

When my dad died, he wasn't on any regular medication so there was nothing to withdraw.
He was offered food and fluid and declined food but took small sips of fluid between sleeping.
The doctor had prescribed the anticipatory medications, but he never needed them as he was sleeping peacefully most of the time.
He still died

LaviniasBigBloomers · 14/02/2023 20:11

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 19:33

ive just received this message from her

‘Family said she was good up until 3 days ago- had that dignified death speech as I had! Then surprise surprise don’t understand why deteriorating so quickly then dugs food and water withheld forcing the body to fail together with drug line - like done to your dad. Told them this!!!’

she’s telling the bereaved family this, which from experience I know is deeply traumatising. I’ve told her to keep her opinions on this to herself, but obviously she’s not listening. Anytbing I can say to combat this?

I think if you know the other family you should get in touch to say your mum is still very upset by the two recent deaths and not moving through the stages of grief. That she is still stuck in the anger and blame stage. That you were there for both situations and the situation wasn't as she describes. Also that every situation is different and they should listen to their relative's doctors, not your mum.

And then try and get your mum to shut up, which won't be easy! She's not thinking rationally which is understandable but obvs very, very difficult for the other family. And you. You've had a rough ride op Flowers

Twentywisteria · 14/02/2023 20:10

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 16:32

Thank you! That was really helpful and so well written! I think that’s what I was remembering as being water heavy.

she’s mentioned that they stop meds too? I know this doesn’t mean pain relief right? But maybe the sort of life prolonging meds? I don’t know, would you be able to explain that for me?

thank you for your compassion!

Any meds that are for long-term benefit (statins, BP meds designed to prevent cardiovascular complications) are generally stopped.

Doctors prescribe "anticipatory meds" - generally one for nausea, one for pain, one for breathlessness/anxiety and one for the secretions people get when EOL.

You may want to read "With the End in Mind" by Kathryn Mannix, as it's a really beautiful explanation of EOL care from a palliative care doctor.

Concerns you've raised are not unxoom feelings from people unfamiliar with death. We dont discuss dying enough so people don't know what to expect. Cases like Shipman have sadly given morphine and EOL analgesia a really scary reputation (some non EOL patients post-op think they're dying if you give morphine for pain relief).

It sounds like she's grieving and naturally wanting someone to blame. Which isn't unusual.

Yazo · 14/02/2023 20:04

They don't at all, my dad had terminal cancer and they tried every last course of antibiotics and would have operated if he'd turned a corner, that was after having cancer for years. Sadly they did have to end the antibiotics the day before he died as they weren't working. It was fine. My dad lived for 4 days longer than they expected and this was in the pandemic when they only called relatives to visit (we were lucky) when they have hours left not days, so I couldn't see anything that hastened my dad's death. It was peaceful and lovely in hospital, I can't quite describe how but if I had to pick a way to go it would have been that. He had pain relief, not much in the way of anything else but he'd not been eating or drinking anyway, by the time the cancer is so advanced it's really difficult, every cell of your body is affected so things aren't as they are when healthy. Good luck to her friend and their family

Flossiemoss · 14/02/2023 19:57

The trouble with adding supplementary fluids at eol stage is that as the body shuts down it doesn’t pump the fluid around the vascular system the way it should. Consequently fluid ends up flooding the lungs and making the person more breathless and less comfortable. That’s why we try and steer away from supplementary fluid at the end stage.

some people find death very hard to handle and I can understand your mums reaction when your df was passing. Especially if it was traumatic ( I’m assuming that from your
mentiom of icu) . Did she have any bereavement counselling after that? It’s not uncommon for relatives of icu patients to develop ptsd as a result of the experience of having a loved one ill enough to be in icu. I wonder if her response to dying is a reaction to that. She sounds angry? That can also be part of the grieving process.

If it’s a conversation you can have with her it may be worth exploring her feelings about dying and your df and see if she would be open to counselling. Some people aren’t open to that so don’t be disappointed if that’s also the case.
It sounds hard for you.

Fraaahnces · 14/02/2023 19:55

Also, re agitation & gasping, etc….
Morphine is often given at this stage because it depresses the “air hunger” helps calm the body and stop the “gasping” (This is often not even always genuine breaths at this stage, but residual movement caused by the brainstem)

Untitledsquatboulder · 14/02/2023 19:42

My dad died of old age (and Alzheimers) at home last week. In the last weeks of his life he ate less and less and during the last few days eating anything at all made him vomit - the gp told us that as death approaches the body's organs start shutting down and digestion is one of the first to go . Then towards the very end he stopped producing urine (kidneys packed up) and oedema started. He lost the ability to swallow his tablets 3 days before his death which probably hastened things but death was a release for him by that point. It wasn't a beautiful death but it was largely peaceful and he suffered very little.

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 19:33

ive just received this message from her

‘Family said she was good up until 3 days ago- had that dignified death speech as I had! Then surprise surprise don’t understand why deteriorating so quickly then dugs food and water withheld forcing the body to fail together with drug line - like done to your dad. Told them this!!!’

she’s telling the bereaved family this, which from experience I know is deeply traumatising. I’ve told her to keep her opinions on this to herself, but obviously she’s not listening. Anytbing I can say to combat this?

OP posts:
Chevronsareshite · 14/02/2023 18:06

Second recommendation for Dr Kathrine Mannix. Her book ‘with the end in mind‘ is in places a sad/hard read, but it does explain normal dying very well.

MonkeyPuddle · 14/02/2023 17:34

I’m sorry that was distressing for you @Tiddlywinx , I am sure your presence and love will have brought him untold comfort.

MonkeyPuddle · 14/02/2023 17:27

Yes I have the same conversations @goldenfolder it’s very normal of us to want to feed and water our loved ones when they’re unwell, on the sofa, bowl
of chicken soup, feed them up, make them strong. I explain that their loved ones bodies are slowly switching off, that the thirst and hunger we around them feel, their loved ones don’t feel that. There is no distress from no oral intake as the body doesn’t want it any more, it doesn’t need to be sustained.

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 17:25

All, thank you for taking the time to share your professional knowledge, whilst I thought I knew certain things, I guess I wasn’t 100% on their rational, thanks for explaining and clarifying, it’s actually a huge weight off. When my father (one of the relatives who passed) was slipping away my mother used to scream and shout murder, sadly audibly to DF who still understood what was happening until the very end, I can only imagine that scared him, but it also made the whole experience so much harder for me. You all have lightened my load.

i worry she’ll be saying similar things to the family of her friend and first hand I know how much more difficult that will make everything for them, especially for her friends children

OP posts:
goldenfolder · 14/02/2023 17:17

One way of thinking about it is that often, patients aren't dying because they are not eating and drinking more they are not eating and drinking BECAUSE they are dying. Whenever I talk to family members I try and frame it like that. It's innate to want to feed and nurture people through oral intake and it often feels cruel and difficult to not see that happening but as has been said already, it really is part and parcel of the end of life process to ensure it is as comfortable and dignified as possible.

Minerbee · 14/02/2023 17:11

if people want to read or listen more I would also recommend Dr Katherine Mannix, a now retired palliative care consultant who does a lot of demystifying the process of death.

rioseco · 14/02/2023 17:11

What a wonderfully informative and compassionate thread.
The very best of Mumsnet. Thank you.

Faz469 · 14/02/2023 16:56

Tiddlywinx · 14/02/2023 16:32

Thank you! That was really helpful and so well written! I think that’s what I was remembering as being water heavy.

she’s mentioned that they stop meds too? I know this doesn’t mean pain relief right? But maybe the sort of life prolonging meds? I don’t know, would you be able to explain that for me?

thank you for your compassion!

Hi. I'm a nurse. We stop regular medications too because they also become difficult to swallow and also any life sustaining medications ie antibiotics has the potential to drag out the process and leave the patient suffering for longer. This is also hard for the families to watch.

We concentrate on what we call comfort care medications that are for symptom management in the last days of life. Pain relief to help with any pain. Sedatives to prevent agitation. Then a medication that helps with their breathing as the fluid and secretions builds up in their lungs.

All of these are very small doses at regular intervals. We tend to let the family decide what they want to be done. Either we can assess the patient at regular intervals if the family wishes or they can be left in peace to be with their dying relative and inform us if they feel any medications are required. It's the same with pressure relief. We ask the family what they would prefer. Some like regular turns, other wish to be left alone.

It's a very sensitive time and we do our best to make it as dignified and (for want of a better word) nice as it possibly can be.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 14/02/2023 16:50

My mum (83) was eating the odd mouthful of ice cream or yoghurt up until 3 days before she died, and drinking sips and talking lucidly (between long periods of sleep and confusion) until about 30 hours before she died.

Fluids and antibiotics were stopped 2 days before because the antibiotics weren't working. She was no longer passing urine in any quantities and she was, as you say, water heavy (although I've never heard the term before it's a good description).

During her last 24 hours she did receive morphine and sedatives in response to symptoms, and I am in no doubt that this will have hastened the end by maybe a couple of hours. But she was already close to dying, and deserved the dignity and peace that the medicines gave her. The agitation was difficult to witness.

To the PP whose mum is near the end Flowers. It's not possible to predict how it will go, but although it was very sad for us, it was a privilege to help deliver my mum out of this life as she delivered us into it. I hope it's the same for you.