Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People on good wages saying they are struggling

370 replies

ChopSuey2 · 14/02/2023 15:06

Am I being unreasonable to be annoyed by people on good wages saying they are struggling?

I am not talking about people who have good wages but are paying off large debts or whose childcare leaves them broke, but people who say they can't afford to live on a certain amount but actually have a decent or even lots of money left after essentials. Equally, people whose essentials (food shopping and heating particularly) are ludicrously high (not including those with high costs related to disability).

I really feel like people need to read the room. People are genuinely struggling and saying you can't afford to live on a good wage is insensitive.

I'm not sure if it's relevant but I would consider myself to be on a good wage (not a higher tax payer and in London).

YABU - people can say they can't afford to live on a good wage because it's all relative
YANBU - people need to think about what being unable to afford things really means

OP posts:
ssd · 15/02/2023 08:47

I think people who complain about the COL right now cos the 2nd audi needs a new tyre are the sort who dont notice fuck all about anyone else anyway

stayathomer · 15/02/2023 08:47

A buffer of 20%?!? Really? 20% would surely be life changing/breaking for most. Sure when you’re getting your mortgage don’t even factor in that high an amount!!

LookingOldTheseDays · 15/02/2023 08:47

daffodilday · 15/02/2023 08:06

If your costs have gone up by 20% and you cannot now afford your lifestyle , you could never really afford it before , and were living beyond your means. This is different to people who simply cannot afford to eat or heat.

I agree. If you earn well, then it is possible to build in that 20%-30% buffer. It will mean a slightly smaller house/car, slightly fewer holidays etc., but if you earn well their isn't really an excuse for stretching your finances to the limit.

For low earners, they have no choice about this - every penny is needed for essentials.

Dinkeigh · 15/02/2023 08:37

BlondeBombshelf · 15/02/2023 08:27

YABU. We have a relatively good wage (£85k) but we’re still finding it quite tough right now. You’ve given all these exemptions as to why it’s ‘ok’ to struggle but these are the exact reasons that people on OK wages struggle. You sound a little bit jealous and/or insecure.

Just curious as to what you mean by struggling on £85k. Do you mean can't put a meal on the table? Or do you mean holding off booking your next holiday because you're feeling the pinch?

I'm not having a go by the way, we are high earners I was just curious what you classed as struggling.

BlondeBombshelf · 15/02/2023 08:27

YABU. We have a relatively good wage (£85k) but we’re still finding it quite tough right now. You’ve given all these exemptions as to why it’s ‘ok’ to struggle but these are the exact reasons that people on OK wages struggle. You sound a little bit jealous and/or insecure.

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 08:22

daffodilday · 15/02/2023 08:06

If your costs have gone up by 20% and you cannot now afford your lifestyle , you could never really afford it before , and were living beyond your means. This is different to people who simply cannot afford to eat or heat.

I think this is correct for high earners when planning originally. If essential bills go up 20% you usually should be able to afford this however since covid there have been many redundancies and other factors that mean this isn't necessarily the case that people are able to manage.

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 08:19

My sisters mortgage has increased by £300, this is on a £150k mortgage, house worth £200k. Plus all the bills. This is a cheap 2 bedroom house where we live. Her buffer was hundreds of £s before covid, how much buffer should she have had?

What about those on one salary already, they need a house/flat to live in with their kids. It's all very well people saying you should base your lifestyle on one salary but it's not feasible for everyone.

daffodilday · 15/02/2023 08:06

If your costs have gone up by 20% and you cannot now afford your lifestyle , you could never really afford it before , and were living beyond your means. This is different to people who simply cannot afford to eat or heat.

daffodilday · 15/02/2023 08:04

Bodybarnet · 14/02/2023 20:02

So you're saying that, despite the fact that the increase in our fixed household costs now equal 20% of my wages (yes just the increase), I'm not allowed to moan because I have a bigger house and a bigger car. That I've chosen that lifestyle and therefore I need to suck up the fact that actually we can't afford to heat the house?

Correct. The key word here is “chosen “. You chose to live your lifestyle when you could not afford it (with a buffer)

Maverickess · 15/02/2023 08:03

Bodybarnet · 15/02/2023 06:47

Bollocks. If you commute then having an old banger (4k down to 1.5k) would be false economy and really quite stressful. You'd have to save any money you made incase you needed them for repairs. Who wants to leave the house every day not knowing of they'll make it to work and back. If you want to then that's fine but it's not everyone's choice nor is it a luxury to have a reliable vehicle which enables you to work.

Absolutely true, if of course you have access to the £4k to make that choice in the first place.

And no one wants to leave the house not knowing if they'll get there and back, but if they don't have the luxury of a choice about it, then that's just part of their life.

So as that poster says, that's the difference, the ability to consider a £4k car a necessity rather than a luxury.

HRTQueen · 15/02/2023 07:31

There is a huge difference between tightening your belt and struggling

im having to tighten my belt at the moment (I earn just over the average wage) colleagues I know who are on below average wage are struggling

im still managing to put food on the table, buy some clothes, book a holiday if you are able to do this (and many I know are who claim to be struggling) you are not just maybe having got the choices you are used to

puppacup · 15/02/2023 07:30

Thing is there is a huge issue around wage stagnation & housing & childcare costs particularly for young people & young families who are working & feel like it's pointless. No wonder so many HCPs are going abroad.

Mummadeze · 15/02/2023 07:24

I know my salary is decent. But I run out of money in week three of the month every month. There are things I need to change like not buying ready meals, swapping to cheaper products. But really, other than bills and rent, food shopping is the only thing I spend badly on. And I feel hard done by that I work hard, earn a good wage that I have got to after years of focussing on my careers and I can’t afford to buy the food I want to eat. I don’t moan to anyone on a lower salary than me because it would be tone deaf. I wouldn’t have posted this either if it wasn’t anonymous.

puppacup · 15/02/2023 07:24

We chose a mortgage years ago based on one salary as a worse case scenario. Cleared it several years ago. We live well within our means.

It can be done but many people are very materialistic out there and want expensive property, cars etc. Living modestly pays off.

I think the key message here is a mortgage years ago. I don't want an expensive property, particularly the fact it's only a bog standard small terrace, But I don't have much choice due to my age. However my mortgage is still cheaper then rent.

PrincessConstance · 15/02/2023 07:23

We have a new vehicle and one used one.
The used one is now causing issues a very bloody week, it's not even that old 6yrs. The aim is to refresh both vehicles as they're essential for us to get to and from work. It's not just about looking good or being fancy. With 15 hrs plus of commuting every week and a management position and business with staff we need to keep on the road.
It is an essential need.
Pre covid we were ready to choose a luxurious new home. Then we changed tack, a cheaper house (2/3 rds less) so we weren't leveraged just in case. 5 yr fixed, and upon renewal, we'll go for a 10-yr fixed. At least we'll know what our housing costs are every month for the next decade. It's such a weight off our minds. Even if the worst would happen all our bills and life can be covered by one salary.
Food shopping has always been kept under control, this isn't anything to do with covid, it's just how we deal with finances.
Holidays, of course, we could afford 5-star plus, renting villas, but we can holiday 5-6 times ayr instead of 2 or 3. Or if the worst comes to the worst we could just go lay in the dunes in Blackpool.

BrendaWearingBaffies · 15/02/2023 07:17

We live off one income so are used to limited amounts of money, no mortgage. Family vehicle paid outright too.

We chose a mortgage years ago based on one salary as a worse case scenario. Cleared it several years ago. We live well within our means.

It can be done but many people are very materialistic out there and want expensive property, cars etc. Living modestly pays off.

puppacup · 15/02/2023 07:13

And that speaks to the underlying problem: that we have a society where housing in particular is so expensive that people can be earning quite a lot and still in need of support.

Yes housing makes a massive difference & people underestimate costs.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 07:05

puppacup · 15/02/2023 06:44

Bollocks.

from about 30k + you get very little in the way of benefits, and nothing from 37k+.

That's not true though. It depends on circumstances, housing situation & childcare costs.

Yep, that's just plain wrong. If you have high enough childcare and/or rent costs, you can be well into the 40% tax bracket and still getting UC. I was reading something the other day about the small but growing group of UC claimants who earn too much for full child benefit. The 37k figure has been pulled out of that poster's arse.

And that speaks to the underlying problem: that we have a society where housing in particular is so expensive that people can be earning quite a lot and still in need of support.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 07:02

Bodybarnet · 15/02/2023 06:47

Bollocks. If you commute then having an old banger (4k down to 1.5k) would be false economy and really quite stressful. You'd have to save any money you made incase you needed them for repairs. Who wants to leave the house every day not knowing of they'll make it to work and back. If you want to then that's fine but it's not everyone's choice nor is it a luxury to have a reliable vehicle which enables you to work.

Especially given the way second hand car prices have spiralled in the last couple of years. One sees quite a few posts on here from people who clearly haven't had cause to look for one during the pandemic. If people are going to talk to us about their 1.5k bangers, they should really tell us when they bought them.

Bodybarnet · 15/02/2023 06:47

TaRaDeBumDeAy · 14/02/2023 23:12

This is where the difference shows though, isn't it.

The most expensive car I've ever bought was 1500 quid. If I was skint I'd sell my 4k car and get a banger runaround. But that's what I'm used to, taking my chances on whether it's going to get me to work from one week to the next. Having a newer, guaranteed to run and run nicely car, is a privilege, as is having a banger is considered a privilege to someone that has to walk everywhere.

Bollocks. If you commute then having an old banger (4k down to 1.5k) would be false economy and really quite stressful. You'd have to save any money you made incase you needed them for repairs. Who wants to leave the house every day not knowing of they'll make it to work and back. If you want to then that's fine but it's not everyone's choice nor is it a luxury to have a reliable vehicle which enables you to work.

puppacup · 15/02/2023 06:45

why did you commit to a “huge mortgage” in an expensive area that would be unsustainable if circumstances change?

I bet it was still cheaper then renting!

puppacup · 15/02/2023 06:44

Bollocks.

from about 30k + you get very little in the way of benefits, and nothing from 37k+.

That's not true though. It depends on circumstances, housing situation & childcare costs.

MakingTheVeganYorkshirePud · 15/02/2023 02:00

I agree OP. We have a high household income. Whilst I moan about our energy bills to my DP, which I think I'm vocalising more out of anguish for those who are actually struggling, we are certainly not struggling and I wouldn't dream of saying we were to anyone.

You made the point in your OP that you weren't talking about those on high incomes, with large outgoings, and I think you are talking more about people who have money and are frivolous, therefore I agree.

Crumpledstilstkin · 14/02/2023 23:59

Newnamenewme23 · 14/02/2023 23:21

Bollocks.

from about 30k + you get very little in the way of benefits, and nothing from 37k+.

you need to practically homeless and starving before you get a council house.

this exactly what this thread is about. High earners like yourself whinging about having no money because “poor people” just get houses and money thrown at them by the benefits office.

try it and see. It is not comparable at all.

And if you'd read my post properly you'd have seen that there were two examples there. Of course someone who is on bugger all and doesn't get those things is worse off than someone who can work for a higher wage without having to pay for fuel and childcare to do so. Just as someone who gets that support may be better off in the short term in terms of disposable income than someone else on a much higher wage. The point the OP made about disposable income after essentials is massive and should absolutely inform whether someone is being insensitive or not.

xogossipgirlxo · 14/02/2023 23:46

Newnamenewme23 · 14/02/2023 21:48

Genuine question.

why did you commit to a “huge mortgage” in an expensive area that would be unsustainable if circumstances change? Presumably if the house upkeep is so significant as well it must be a reasonable size.

especially if you have no savings to tide you over should they do so.

My dad died suddenly leaving my mum in the shit completely. So everything in our household is based on being affordable if one of us died.

so we have a relatively small mortgage. Could have afforded more but chose not to so not to be left with a huge mortgage should one of us lose a job or worse.

I agree. I could not sleep knowing I am stretched out on good salary. If anything crops up and you can’t afford mortgage repayments, it means that you could never afford this house/car/private school etc.