Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People on good wages saying they are struggling

370 replies

ChopSuey2 · 14/02/2023 15:06

Am I being unreasonable to be annoyed by people on good wages saying they are struggling?

I am not talking about people who have good wages but are paying off large debts or whose childcare leaves them broke, but people who say they can't afford to live on a certain amount but actually have a decent or even lots of money left after essentials. Equally, people whose essentials (food shopping and heating particularly) are ludicrously high (not including those with high costs related to disability).

I really feel like people need to read the room. People are genuinely struggling and saying you can't afford to live on a good wage is insensitive.

I'm not sure if it's relevant but I would consider myself to be on a good wage (not a higher tax payer and in London).

YABU - people can say they can't afford to live on a good wage because it's all relative
YANBU - people need to think about what being unable to afford things really means

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 19/02/2023 06:17

@PugInTheHouse we were FTBs in the mid 1990s. In 2002 those houses were probably worth £40-50k.

But the price difference is probably much larger now, ours likely around £120-150k.

I bet your £90k 2 bed from 2002 has risen more than 3 times in value now?

BarbaraofSeville · 19/02/2023 06:13

Maverickess · 16/02/2023 11:06

Benefits don't make a £30k income into an £80k income........ You can't seriously believe that is the case?!
The person on 80k still has a significantly higher income than the person on £30k, even with UC and CB.

It would be an interesting comparison to look the disposable income of single parents of two preschoolers after rent and childcare costs.

The £80k earner will get no help at all and pay 40% tax plus likely student loan repayments and possibly significant childcare costs.

Lower earners will get CB and UC to help with rent and childcare.

The gap in disposable income is likely to be far less than £80k vs £30k suggests.

PugInTheHouse · 19/02/2023 06:11

BarbaraofSeville · 19/02/2023 06:06

Another 40 something who bought before prices rose quite easily.

In our case both DP and I earned under £10k pa and saved a 2 grand deposit over a year so we could get a 95% mortgage on a 2 bed terrace for £32k. The mortgage was £180 pm compared with renting a similar house for £350. A lot of people did the same due to this.

My sister bought a 1 bed terrace for £25k on her own but she earned slightly more. Neither of us got any money from our parents.

In Yorkshire prices were low until about the mid 2000s so lots of people in their late 20s were buying then. Your peers must have lived in much more expensive areas or not bought by 30 to have missed the boat.

We moved in 2006 and it was only then starting to become unaffordable but by then you'd have to have not bought by your early to mid 30s to have missed the boat.

Wow thats a huge difference on prices, a 2 bed in SE around the same time was £90kish i guess, salaries probably higher also though. That was 2002.

BarbaraofSeville · 19/02/2023 06:06

Another 40 something who bought before prices rose quite easily.

In our case both DP and I earned under £10k pa and saved a 2 grand deposit over a year so we could get a 95% mortgage on a 2 bed terrace for £32k. The mortgage was £180 pm compared with renting a similar house for £350. A lot of people did the same due to this.

My sister bought a 1 bed terrace for £25k on her own but she earned slightly more. Neither of us got any money from our parents.

In Yorkshire prices were low until about the mid 2000s so lots of people in their late 20s were buying then. Your peers must have lived in much more expensive areas or not bought by 30 to have missed the boat.

We moved in 2006 and it was only then starting to become unaffordable but by then you'd have to have not bought by your early to mid 30s to have missed the boat.

PugInTheHouse · 19/02/2023 05:29

Ceilingplaits · 19/02/2023 00:04

Bit confused by the idea that people in their 40s were so easily able to buy houses.
I'm still friends with my groups of friends from school and university, aged 48-51, and the only ones who own their homes had huge deposits from parents or were given their houses by parents or through inheritance. None could have afforded one otherwise. Nearly all have postgraduate degrees from good universities. Same with families I know locally. Nearly all are renting.

That really seems odd, I live in an expensive area and most of my friends bought houses on their early to mid 20s (I am early 40s). I was 22. Couple of grand deposit and fees I saved by living at home, i did buy with my husband, all my friends were in LTR too and bought ada couple. We bought I 3 bedroom house but I could have got a 2 bed flat alone. I bought XH when I was 25. I wasn't a high earner at that point, maybe £22k, i wasnt earning that much when we first got the mortgage.

I did my professional qualifications at work rather than going to uni, something I am really glad about as uni wouldn't have been of any benefit career wise and obv meant I could buy a house sooner.

Fixed · 19/02/2023 00:12

@Ceilingplaits that seems insane. Are you from an insanely expensive area?

MakingTheVeganYorkshirePud · 19/02/2023 00:11

@Ceilingplaits I'm 42 and got a 100% mortgage. We didn't have a pot to piss in, but we were able to buy a house. It was very easy for us.

Ceilingplaits · 19/02/2023 00:04

Bit confused by the idea that people in their 40s were so easily able to buy houses.
I'm still friends with my groups of friends from school and university, aged 48-51, and the only ones who own their homes had huge deposits from parents or were given their houses by parents or through inheritance. None could have afforded one otherwise. Nearly all have postgraduate degrees from good universities. Same with families I know locally. Nearly all are renting.

ConfessionsOfAMumDramaQueen · 16/02/2023 11:20

For those saying people overstretched ... no one knew how things were going to go. When we bought our house, the mortgage was just under 50% of one of our wages, and to rent an equivalent sized house was 50% more than our mortgage. We borrowed only about half the amount the bank would have lent us. Thats not mortgaging up to the eyeballs.

Now, interest rates means our mortgage is hundreds more expensive (still cheaper than renting though), gas and electricity has more than doubled. But our wages haven't really gone up, with the industry citing they can't afford it. Now one persons wages just barely covers the basics. Childcare takes up the second wage almost entirely.

We got a house we could afford on one person because we knew we were planning on having children and maternity leave and childcare early days would be expensive. Then 3 years later here we find ourselves not unable to afford food, but we have nothing left over each month, which is insane when we are both above average earners with postgraduate degrees.

Maverickess · 16/02/2023 11:06

Lostinalibrary · 16/02/2023 10:01

Is it though? The 30k will still be entitled to child benefit and probably UC if renting. So actually who is better off?

Benefits don't make a £30k income into an £80k income........ You can't seriously believe that is the case?!
The person on 80k still has a significantly higher income than the person on £30k, even with UC and CB.

xogossipgirlxo · 16/02/2023 10:52

Lostinalibrary · 16/02/2023 10:01

Is it though? The 30k will still be entitled to child benefit and probably UC if renting. So actually who is better off?

UC isn't life changing amount of money, especially when you rent.

Newnamenewme23 · 16/02/2023 10:31

Lostinalibrary · 16/02/2023 10:01

Is it though? The 30k will still be entitled to child benefit and probably UC if renting. So actually who is better off?

Don’t be daft. Benefits won’t double your net income. Especially on 30k.

I’ve just run 2 adults 2 children, renting, in the north through entitled to. Overall income 34k, one child in childcare.

£400/month in UC.

not really doubling income is it?

Xenia · 16/02/2023 10:16

I don't think it is silly to remortgage to decorate. I have never done that and in fact my house is pretty much as we bought it in 1997 as I was more interested in over paying mortgage (I still have one but I hope to get it paid this year (or next)). It is just another choice people make. Just as I chose to pay school fees and indeed university fees for all my children - I am sure a lot of people think tha tis ridiculous in London where there are so many good schools and given student loans are available.

Luckily it is still a free country where you keep at least some (but not much before the state steals it for tax) of your money and decide how you want to spend it.

Comparison is the thief of joy is an old saying which is pretty correct in relation to any of us comparing ourselves to others. I always think my best thing (other than the children) is that I am not often ill and usually happy. I couldn't put a price on that - it is so valuable. Obviously it partly comes from not drinking or smoking and being well off enough to get enough sleep, etc

Lostinalibrary · 16/02/2023 10:01

ExistenceOptional · 15/02/2023 16:50

More than double a day's pay is an enormous difference

Is it though? The 30k will still be entitled to child benefit and probably UC if renting. So actually who is better off?

lieselotte · 16/02/2023 09:44

There's a stark lack of consciousness around money and what it actually is, and how to manage it. A prime example is remortgaging the home to renovate the home, a silly idea

I disagree. If you take money out of your home eg to put in a new kitchen and bathroom and that adds to the value of the house by more than you paid (including interest on the loan) that is surely worthwhile. I wouldn't do it because I'd be concerned about redundancy and being able to afford the loan if I lost my job (also why I pay for cars outright from savings), but if you have a "safe" job, I can't see the issue.

lieselotte · 16/02/2023 09:42

Hankunamatata · 15/02/2023 18:05

Hate 'read the room' just because someone is on a good wage and struggling with budget doesn't make them less worthy to moan or ask questions on here than those who need food bank

I don't disagree with that - "read the room" is a horrible expression and just aims to suppress dissenting opinions. But I do think those who are well off and just not able to afford as much need to stop moaning. Asking for advice on how to save money in certain areas is fine, moaning isn't.

Ticketybloop · 16/02/2023 09:05

I said YANBU because your thread reminded me of someone I know who constantly moans about how poor they are. She is a SAHM and her husband earns around 750k/year I expect, which is obviously healthy even for tier 1 global cities. Last time she said it, I (slightly naughtily) asked very sympathetically if they were struggling with the COL crisis, to which she immediately replied they weren’t and seemed almost offended I had asked.

I can’t tell if she actually thinks they are poor (based on whatever ‘poor’ means in her social group), if it’s a wafer thin attempt at faux humility, or if it’s some kind of twisted power trip way of putting everyone else who earns less into their place. Whatever the reason, it is patently ludicrous and does elicit eye rolls from us whenever we have to listen to it.

Dinkeigh · 16/02/2023 07:59

Hankunamatata · 15/02/2023 18:05

Hate 'read the room' just because someone is on a good wage and struggling with budget doesn't make them less worthy to moan or ask questions on here than those who need food bank

But surely you should totally be 'reading the room' if you're on a good wage.

Good wage and struggling to budget because let's say you've booked a few too many breaks and needing to hold off a bit, or went wild at Christmas so feeling the pinch a bit now, or feeling the pinch running both decent cars in the household to the various out of school clubs and events that have been attended.

Or struggling to put a meal on the table so needing a food bank.

You wouldn't 'read the room' in that situation no?

PugInTheHouse · 16/02/2023 07:39

@Tomorrowillbeachicken I'd not heard of that before, looks like a great idea. The monzo bank accounts are brilliant also, they have 'pots' you can move your money into.

PrincessConstance · 16/02/2023 07:27

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 15/02/2023 20:35

The problem in this country is that schools teach Shakespeare but doesn’t teach any money management or even basic budgeting in schools

There also needs to be a discussion of what money is.
Most people sell their time for others working endless hrs for less than £67 per day. People need to understand money is all about value, the less valuable your skills or ability to solve problems is the less money you will have.
You have to find your niche. When you understand something, you understand its market, that's the key.
Ownership is the key, an idea, a business, a specialized service, a niche, be a Ferrari, not a Ford. The next level is actually owning property that others use.

There's a stark lack of consciousness around money and what it actually is, and how to manage it. A prime example is remortgaging the home to renovate the home, a silly idea.

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 16/02/2023 00:10

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 20:49

I agree, I'm an accountant and budget for everything, I have a cashflow sheet l, a bank rec and that's how I know we will be ok in X number of months/years. I also can manage when to pay bills or hold back on stuff. I save monthly for everything, including birthday/Xmas presents, additional food at Xmas and every tiny little thing, so there are no surprise bills (in an ideal world)

Even with doing all that there are surprises along the way such ad DH losing his job, the dog having to have major surgery and the insurance excluding a massive chunk of it. I know we are tight for cash right now but I have the knowledge to budget to the last penny which obviously helps manage the situation.

Of course you don't need to be an accountant to do this, basic budgeting taught at schools/colleges to me is extremely important and its disappointing this still doesn't happen.

I have to admit that I pay for and use YNAB. It works well for me and stops me overspending

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 15/02/2023 23:50

Newnamenewme23 · 15/02/2023 21:02

Judging by the responses on the “middle name for Hero” thread they don’t teach much Shakespeare either 😳

Sorry that made me lol

BluebellBlueballs · 15/02/2023 21:21

Toadallyinlove · 14/02/2023 17:50

I applied for a job in 2011 that was £19000 and deemed average for the SW (Marketing. Degree required. 5 years experience)

It was readvertised yesterday. Same job at the same firm. £19500 and still deemed average for the SW (Still asking for a degree and 5 years experience!)

Rent for a 2 bed semi in 2011: £550
Rent for a 2 bed semi in 2023: £1000

That's the South West for you :/

Yep, in 2010 I was on 32k, promoted now but jobs at that level in 2023 are paying maybe 35- 36k.

And all this time the cost of everything has gone up and up

Newnamenewme23 · 15/02/2023 21:02

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 15/02/2023 20:35

The problem in this country is that schools teach Shakespeare but doesn’t teach any money management or even basic budgeting in schools

Judging by the responses on the “middle name for Hero” thread they don’t teach much Shakespeare either 😳

PugInTheHouse · 15/02/2023 20:49

Tomorrowillbeachicken · 15/02/2023 20:35

The problem in this country is that schools teach Shakespeare but doesn’t teach any money management or even basic budgeting in schools

I agree, I'm an accountant and budget for everything, I have a cashflow sheet l, a bank rec and that's how I know we will be ok in X number of months/years. I also can manage when to pay bills or hold back on stuff. I save monthly for everything, including birthday/Xmas presents, additional food at Xmas and every tiny little thing, so there are no surprise bills (in an ideal world)

Even with doing all that there are surprises along the way such ad DH losing his job, the dog having to have major surgery and the insurance excluding a massive chunk of it. I know we are tight for cash right now but I have the knowledge to budget to the last penny which obviously helps manage the situation.

Of course you don't need to be an accountant to do this, basic budgeting taught at schools/colleges to me is extremely important and its disappointing this still doesn't happen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread