Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health?

265 replies

Chiikichik · 14/02/2023 14:03

Before I start - I EBF both my children for the first 6 months of my life. Both took to it really well, but second time around the sheer relentless of it made me feel suicidal. Moving them on to the bottle was the best thing for us at the time.

There is always slot of discussion around how women are effected when they can’t establish BF through lack of support etc but not really for those of us who do establish but just don’t really enjoy it? Or just can’t cope with the absolutely bloody relentlessness of it?

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 14/02/2023 15:11

Yes it can be if the baby isnt gaining weight or is being sick.Sore nipples and so on. I think if it's a huge struggle bottle is a better option.

afinishedkiss · 14/02/2023 15:11

Breastfeeding absolutely broke me mentally.

HamBone · 14/02/2023 15:10

Both of mine had difficulty latching and I had to pump and use a special bottle to help them master it. As a result, feedings took twice as long as they should’ve and it was exhausting!

I don’t regret doing it, but no one should feel that they have to.

Isithotinhere · 14/02/2023 15:09

Breastfeeding helped me bond - and was less stressful that having clean bottles, formula etc, so definitely not damaging to my mental health.

Looking after a new born is relentless- and harder when you have a toddler too, so I'm not sure how much breastfeeding can be held responsible.

We all know that breastfeeding is best for both baby and mother, but it's not life and death, so if you want to stop, then stop. Most British women do.

Bingoflings · 14/02/2023 15:08

Pressed post too early.
When I say nicer. I mean that personally for me, I have to think about other people's needs. I used to be a bit selfish (me personally). It isn't meant to say those who choose not to have kids aren't nice 🙈

dizzydizzydizzy · 14/02/2023 15:05

Dinkleberg · 14/02/2023 14:13

Oops pressed send too soon. Anyway... I think a big problem is a woeful lack of BFing support. We're always told breast is best when we're pregnant, but once baby is born we're pretty much left to it.

This.

I was very lucky to get some good support. I would not have succeeded without it.

Bingoflings · 14/02/2023 15:04

Twentywisteria · 14/02/2023 14:09

A lot of things about having children are detrimental to maternal mental health.

Hence I don't want any.

You have a point.
I don't recognise myself anymore.
I love my children but I've lost who I used to be. I think I'm probably a stronger and nicer person but I get hardly any time to myself. I don't judge anyone for saying no this isn't for me.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/02/2023 15:03

shivermetimbers77 · 14/02/2023 14:52

I personally disagree that breastfeeding is bad for mental health, it’s current societal expectations that make it difficult to breastfeed in a way that is supportive of child and maternal wellbeing: we are evolved to breastfeed and throughout most of human history humans have coslept, and either carried our babies with us all day or had a close network of women around to help us between feeds or to wet nurse each other’s babies. Modern society with its emphasis upon smaller families, sleeping separately (which only really began in Victorian times, wealthier Western families only) , and parents returning to work outside the home as soon as possible makes it much more stressful for women. So I personally believe it’s not breastfeeding to blame, it’s the context around it.

I guess it's easy to say this when you're not trying to feed a fractious baby that just wants to sleep; or when you have bleeding nipples and recurring mastitis, and everyone around is saying 'just carry on, it's the best thing for your baby.'

whitebreadjamsandwich · 14/02/2023 15:03

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/02/2023 14:17

That's very interesting. I have adhd and I know that I'd have really struggled with formula feeding, but I had never connected the two.

OP, I think you're wrong to say that breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health because that clearly isn't the case for many people. Tbh, I think it saved my sanity in that first year. However, yanbu to say that it can be detrimental because that is obviously your experience and one that others may share.

I 100% wouldn't have managed to keep on top of the purchasing, cleaning and prep - I could never forget my boobs!

reddwarfgeek · 14/02/2023 15:01

No, I don't think so.
I had post partum psychosis and wanted my old life back when DD was born. Breastfeeding her was my way of bonding with her. She did feed for hours at night and it was very tough, but I'm so glad I saw it through.
I didn't feed her exclusively for that long though , 4 months.

Wrongsideofpennines · 14/02/2023 15:00

I think the stats actually suggest that breastfeeding women have lower rates of things like post natal depression. So there is evidence to the opposite of what you're suggesting but obviously that's trends and not individual cases. But perhaps this is because those that want to but can't (for any number of reasons) then struggle with their mental health. And if support and normalising how bloody hard it is was more common then women wouldn't feel like a failure if things don't go swimmingly.

I do remember someone asking me when my baby was tiny and needing to be fed and held constantly - would it be any different with a bottle? Babies are hard however they are fed. They still need constant attention. It's still relentless. Maybe we need to just be more supportive of mums/families overall.

Switchwitch · 14/02/2023 15:00

Breastfeeding is not the problem, it's lack of support for new mums. My DM said that you were in hospital for a week after having a baby in the 70s, lots of time to ensure you were established feeding and starting to feel yourself again. Now it's home asap to free up a bed. I went home without being able to feed my dd. No one cared or answered my requests for help. I don't have family nearby so I was on my own trying to learn this whole new world. I wouldn't have got through it without Facebook groups to be honest!

Thewheelweavesasthewheelwills · 14/02/2023 14:59

I do wish I had known that the odd bottle of formula wouldn't irreparably damage my child. I EBF for the first 14 weeks and I was exhausted. He fed CONSTANTLY 12/14 hrs a day on me, min about 8ish. I had given him some expressed bottle buts that mean I had to express.

My GP diagnosed me with PND and said to stop breastfeeding. That made things way worse because I missed him. But I soon found my happy balance which was mostly BF with a bottle (given by DH) in the evening if I wanted a break.

Some 'support' groups made me feel like I would destroy my supply if I pumped and that I shouldn't even consider formula.

Sandals12 · 14/02/2023 14:56

dizzydizzydizzy · 14/02/2023 14:13

I think having a baby, no matter what you do,
Is relentless hard work. I personallly liked breastfeeding . In fact, I felt proud of it, so I would say it was good for my mental wellbeing. We are all different.

Ditto. I had problems with first child, mastitis, undiagnosed tongue tie, top ups, a lot of pain...but I'm proud to have carried on and fed him until the morning my second was born 3.5 years later. I feel I would've had MH problems if I gave up. Bf often takes a lot if determination but worth it in my eyes.

Second baby was a doddle to feed and I was grateful for the handiness of it all. No pumping or bottles this time around.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/02/2023 14:56

I agree @Chiikichik

For full disclosure, I breastfed and found it the easiest thing in the world, I never had pain or upset or anything.

But I will fight to the death for the woman who is so upset and tired but feels she has to carry on breastfeeding for the good of the child. Stopping breastfeeding doesn't have a negative effect on your child, but carrying on might have devastating effects for you. A mother is as important as her child.

Breastfeeding support shouldn't just be alternative ways to do it. It should be someone who can gently say, you're bleeding, you're upset, you just don't want to do it anymore - you don't need permission but please don't carry on to the detriment of your mental health.

Bornin1989 · 14/02/2023 14:55

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/02/2023 14:51

@Bornin1989
why do u feel u would have failed your daughter
?

Because I do believe the "breast is best" mantra, and I wanted to give that to my DD - I didn't want to let myself get in the way of that for her. I don't mind what other people feed their kids, but I wanted to BF and the pig-headedness is what got me through the first 3 months of pain.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 14/02/2023 14:53

shivermetimbers77 · 14/02/2023 14:52

I personally disagree that breastfeeding is bad for mental health, it’s current societal expectations that make it difficult to breastfeed in a way that is supportive of child and maternal wellbeing: we are evolved to breastfeed and throughout most of human history humans have coslept, and either carried our babies with us all day or had a close network of women around to help us between feeds or to wet nurse each other’s babies. Modern society with its emphasis upon smaller families, sleeping separately (which only really began in Victorian times, wealthier Western families only) , and parents returning to work outside the home as soon as possible makes it much more stressful for women. So I personally believe it’s not breastfeeding to blame, it’s the context around it.

Well said.

shivermetimbers77 · 14/02/2023 14:52

I personally disagree that breastfeeding is bad for mental health, it’s current societal expectations that make it difficult to breastfeed in a way that is supportive of child and maternal wellbeing: we are evolved to breastfeed and throughout most of human history humans have coslept, and either carried our babies with us all day or had a close network of women around to help us between feeds or to wet nurse each other’s babies. Modern society with its emphasis upon smaller families, sleeping separately (which only really began in Victorian times, wealthier Western families only) , and parents returning to work outside the home as soon as possible makes it much more stressful for women. So I personally believe it’s not breastfeeding to blame, it’s the context around it.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 14/02/2023 14:52

I had twins who came very early. One did better than the other but both were kept in the NCU for 13 weeks. Pumping for them was bloody hard (all that time, 24 hours) but it kept me going. I was determined not to give up, and am convinced it was best for them. I eventually bf until they were nearly a year old, although the stronger one needed a bottle sometimes. I loved it, although it was hard at first. The difference with me is that I got a lot of support in the hospital, so by the time they came home I had it sussed. But it might've been different if they'd been term and I'd just been sent home.

Bornin1989 · 14/02/2023 14:52

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/02/2023 14:48

@Dinkleberg

realistically though what would more support look like?

Besides having someone come in and do a couple of feeds for you to give you a break (which is obviously impossible)

Support in the form of people to ask questions to if things aren't going right. I had no idea that a tongue tie had implications for my nipples for example. I was also shown different BF positions, how to get DD to latch properly.

There was a local BF support group for me, which helped, I got very little support at DD's birth (e.g. tongue tie cut was offered but not explained - as far as they were concerned my DD was getting milk in her mouth so that was fine and dandy).

mrsoodles · 14/02/2023 14:52

It's different for every woman

Personally breastfeeding my children was one of the best things I've ever done, and my mental health massively benefited

At no other stage of life and parenting have I ever had the opportunity to lie back and take ten minutes normally half an hour of doing nothing/reading/television without feeling guilty

WeWereInParis · 14/02/2023 14:52

I think absolutist statements are detrimental to maternal mental health.

Agreed. It's different for everyone, and different between babies for the same woman. I loved breastfeeding DD1, and love breastfeeding DD2. However I did have severe PND with DD2. This wasn't due to breastfeeding, but the sleep deprivation didn't help. So adding in a bottle of formula at night so I could sleep more helped my mental health but that's not because breastfeeding specifically was bad. Formula would have been no better if I didn't have a supportive partner who did the vast majority of night wakes so I could get some sleep.

LuckySantangelo35 · 14/02/2023 14:51

Bornin1989 · 14/02/2023 14:49

Statistically speaking if you breastfeed you're at lower risk of MH issues. My DD was born with a tongue tie and I pig-headedly carried on breastfeeding through the pain (literally sobbing at 2am feeds because of it) until she finally got her tongue tie cut aged 3 weeks old - it was offered at birth but nobody explained why it would be better to have it done and so I declined as I had no idea of the consequences to my poor, sore nips (I was just told it didn't matter either way for DD). It took 12 weeks for my nipples to finally be pain free. I had access to a breastfeeding support group which massively helped too.

Did it damage my mental health short-term, quite possibly, but I think I would have felt like I'd failed my DD if I hadn't come out the other side and the consequences of that on my mental health would have been much, much worse. We are still BF at 16 months old and, other than a recent bout of nipple nipping at bedtime, we both enjoy it.

But I am me, and you are you, and you know what's best for your own mental health.

@Bornin1989
why do u feel u would have failed your daughter
?

Blughbablugh · 14/02/2023 14:50

Twentywisteria · 14/02/2023 14:09

A lot of things about having children are detrimental to maternal mental health.

Hence I don't want any.

This! I have two and whilst I adore both my kids, I feel that my mental health and physical health would probably be better had I not had them. I have also breastefed both and whilst challenging at times do not feel this is what has affected my mental health.

Notaboutyouthistime · 14/02/2023 14:50

TokenGinger · 14/02/2023 14:42

For me, I agree. I desperately wanted to feed DD myself because of all of the information we're told that breast is best, which I'm not disputing. I ended up with mastitis which was so severe, I was admitted to hospital on the sepsis pathway and spent four days on an IV drip with a newborn still attached to my breast, with me screaming and howling in pain whenever she latched. The pain was unbearable and I began to enter a really bad place mentally. I was constantly crying, dreading DD needing a feed, in constant pain. My DP was visiting at hospital and saw me howl in pain and begin sobbing due to the pain and he went straight out and bought formula so I had the option. I continued on until 6am the following morning after she'd been on me continuously since midnight and she was screaming with hunger. I mustn't have produced enough. I gave her a bottle of formula and she slept three hours straight.

Even now, four weeks later, I feel such guilt at not feeding her. It's really battered my mental health.

You're a super hero for continuing past the admission to hospital. I would not have.