Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health?

265 replies

Chiikichik · 14/02/2023 14:03

Before I start - I EBF both my children for the first 6 months of my life. Both took to it really well, but second time around the sheer relentless of it made me feel suicidal. Moving them on to the bottle was the best thing for us at the time.

There is always slot of discussion around how women are effected when they can’t establish BF through lack of support etc but not really for those of us who do establish but just don’t really enjoy it? Or just can’t cope with the absolutely bloody relentlessness of it?

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 14/02/2023 19:36

KatyJ89 · 14/02/2023 18:52

I don't think it's breastfeeding as such. I think it's just the way western cultures live now. We have no real practical support, there's no village. There's nobody holding the baby while we nap, making food while we feed the baby, nobody helping clean, etc, etc. I think if we lived like that still then it may be different. Formula wouldnt make a difference to how soul destroying lonely my life is ATM (cheery I know lol)

I'm sorry to hear you're lonely! It can be like that. Up until I got into the merry go round of toddler groups and mother-and-baby meet ups it was lonely. Are there things like that round you?

lljkk · 14/02/2023 19:35

I know online is full of women who agonised & found baby feeding (milk diet phase) very stressful: but I think back in IRL, most women just get on with it. Do the best you can when you can & move on with whatever option is good enough at the time. Most people don't dwell on stuff.

Oigetoffmylawn · 14/02/2023 19:32

Studies show your wrong.

But I absolutely 100% agree with you. Breastfeed, the relentlessness of it and the sleep deprivation left me severely unwell.

EmmaDilemma5 · 14/02/2023 19:29

Twentywisteria · 14/02/2023 14:09

A lot of things about having children are detrimental to maternal mental health.

Hence I don't want any.

This. I breastfed both kids for over two years. I didn't enjoy it but I did it because it's the most natural nutrition for them.

I know other mums who loved breastfeeding.

I know mum's who wished they could breastfeed and others who never wanted to.

We're all different and like - and dislike - different aspects of parenting.

pear6782 · 14/02/2023 19:28

I’m also one for ‘fed is best’. Breastfeeding has amazing benefits but formula feeding doesn’t mean your child will be constantly sick and have a lower IQ. For me, it made me feel so depressed. I felt I couldn’t go out. Was so happy when I stopped. I’m all for doing whatever is best for mum. And many many years later, I’m absolutely sure that it really doesn’t matter.

HamBone · 14/02/2023 19:26

Of course it’s not detrimental to mental health, but for some of us it’s much easier and makes for a happier time not to.

Exactly, @TheyHadGrace . If your baby latches easily and feeds well, it’s wonderful. If they don’t, like my two, it’s a slog-but I don’t regret it. I still enjoyed the experience, I just wish they’d got the hang of it without the need for a lactation consultant, an electric pump
(although I needed that for work anyway), special bottles to train them to suck properly, the dreaded nipple shields, etc. 😂

Siameasy · 14/02/2023 19:14

I would say breastfeeding within a western society is hard work. The values are conflicting. So much in our way of life undermines breastfeeding.

Eg: BF requires slow-society demands fast. BF needs you to stop caring about the housework and sit on your arse for 4 hours while the baby cluster feeds. Society says you’re a disgrace because your house is messy.

Non-breast feeders are an absolute nightmare with their so-called advice. I’d no more take advice on driving from a non-driver but the former, who is often projecting, feels entitled to comment.

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 19:12

But yabu. Not had a bad impact on my mental health.

HeadNorth · 14/02/2023 19:10

It wasn’t detrimental to my mental health - I look back on the breastfeeding years with great fondness. Parenting a teen daughter when you’re menopausal - now that can fuck with your mental health 😝

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 19:08

It's very rewarding

Hatscats · 14/02/2023 19:07

Love 99% of it - 2 years 3 months in and 32 weeks pregnant!

I would have struggled mentally to formula feed as I didn’t want to!

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 19:04

HedgeWitchy · 14/02/2023 18:47

I enjoyed it. It came quite easily. It was an excuse to lay around and cuddle without feeling pressured to do more. Nights it meant I didn’t have to leave my cold bed. It was a generally wonderful bond into toddlerhood.

I have no urge to force it on others or say everyone should… but I reckon there must be loads like me

I loved feeding on a night having a warm baba to cuddle in to 😅

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 19:03

ZebraPyjamas · 14/02/2023 17:48

I don’t understand this idea that you should “enjoy” breastfeeding, do people “enjoy” bottle feeding? “Enjoy” night feeds or changing nappies???? It’s just something you do and there’s no arguing around it it’s better for the baby and also better for mum, physically at least. I think if we stop trying to pitch breastfeeding as this magical glorious saintly thing then people wouldn’t feel like such failures when they struggle and find it hard!

I do enjoy breastfeeding. Not at the beginning but when tongue tie got sorted I did. I love it

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 19:02

Breastfeeding was so hard in the beginning as my son had tongue tie. Just please they noticed and got it sorted. And was fine after. Absolutely love breastfeeding.

bakewellbride · 14/02/2023 18:52

Can you imagine the outcry if the thread title was the same but with 'formula feeding' instead of 'breastfeeding'?

KatyJ89 · 14/02/2023 18:52

I don't think it's breastfeeding as such. I think it's just the way western cultures live now. We have no real practical support, there's no village. There's nobody holding the baby while we nap, making food while we feed the baby, nobody helping clean, etc, etc. I think if we lived like that still then it may be different. Formula wouldnt make a difference to how soul destroying lonely my life is ATM (cheery I know lol)

HedgeWitchy · 14/02/2023 18:47

I enjoyed it. It came quite easily. It was an excuse to lay around and cuddle without feeling pressured to do more. Nights it meant I didn’t have to leave my cold bed. It was a generally wonderful bond into toddlerhood.

I have no urge to force it on others or say everyone should… but I reckon there must be loads like me

ArabellaScott · 14/02/2023 18:24

namechangetheworld · 14/02/2023 18:15

I agree. I'm no conspiracy theorist either but every single breastfeeding mother I have spoken to has struggled with lack of sleep to varying degrees.

I truly believe a thorough list of pros and cons of ALL feeding options should be given to pregnant mothers to let them make a decision that suits them and their family, instead of having one pushed on them and then having subsequent struggles with their mental health. And practical support should be given for mothers regardless of their feeding choices.

I was gutsy enough to stand up for myself when being lectured by midwives when in LABOUR about my feeding choices, but lots aren't and would just cave in.

Breastmilk is more quickly and easily digested in the gut, so yes, breastfeeding babies are likely when newborn to want to feed more frequently. (Some do, but this also depends on other factors, too).

Formula tends to form a 'curd', which sits in the stomach for longer. It takes longer to pass through the gut.

I can't right now find a reference for comparison of transit times through the gut; here's one on basic differences in constituents of formulas compared to breastmilk:

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4882692/

Ah, here we go:

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0958694620302521

'Infant feeding studies show that the rate of gastric digestion and stomach clearance is related to curd the hardness of gastric curds formed (Doan, 1938). A gastric emptying study in preterm infants showed gastric emptying rate of 30 mL portions of human milk was considerably fast than of 30 mL portions of infant formula, with an average of with 24.8 mL of human milk having been emptied after one hour (Cavell, 1979). This may be related to the fact that human milk forms softer clots in the stomach than infant formula'

phoenixrosehere · 14/02/2023 18:24

The stigma around choosing directly not to breastfeed needs eliminating.

The stigma of how a mum chooses to feed regardless needs eliminating. Mothers are stigmatised either way.

It wasn't for me. In fact it was very beneficial for my MH. I don't think this is an issue where it's good to generalise.

Agree. It gave me something to focus on after poor and traumatic treatment with the birth of my first.

I feel more touched out now than when I was nursing and mine are 5 and 8.

weegiemum · 14/02/2023 18:21

I had bad pnd with all 3 of my dc and was hospitalised with dc1. I breastfed all of them to 12 months, 15 months and 2 years. It was the one thing I knew I was getting right and helped me recover from depression.

Breastfeeding was I would say essential to my MH with dc1 and very important with 2&3.

ArabellaScott · 14/02/2023 18:18

I think absolutist statements are detrimental to maternal mental health.

Hear, hear.

Every mother, every baby and every situation is different. There is evidence, data, and statistics, of course, but none of that really changes the fact that these choices depend on the individual situation.

Littleoakhorn · 14/02/2023 18:18

YABU for assuming a universal experience and for attributing the cause to breastfeeding instead of to the ridiculous expectations and scrutiny placed on new families and especially mothers.

EveSix · 14/02/2023 18:16

When growing up (not in the UK), I never saw any new mother not breastfeeding. Everyone breastfed. It was the norm and no-one seemed depressed or suffering with poor mental health or lack of support. There were lots of babies in my parents' family and friendship circle.
I'd been bottle fed as had a medical issue at birth, and it had been a real cause for concern among health visitors and family. It was a big surprise to me that bottle feeding is such a big thing in Britain. I've often wondered since why it seems so different.
I breastfed DC 1 and 2 until they were 2 and 3 respectively. Of course there was some broken sleep, but we coslept (gorgeous) so it was minimal, and the many benefits 100% outweighed this.

namechangetheworld · 14/02/2023 18:15

WhatNoRaisins · 14/02/2023 17:55

I'm honestly not sure. I think the official line is no and that breastfeeding mums actually get more sleep and yet anecdotally and from reading various parenting forums it does seem like bottlefed babies tend to sleep more or at least start to sleep through younger.

The conspiracy theorist part of me wonders if it's hushed up to promote breastfeeding or maybe it was more true of the formulas used a generation or two ago.

I agree. I'm no conspiracy theorist either but every single breastfeeding mother I have spoken to has struggled with lack of sleep to varying degrees.

I truly believe a thorough list of pros and cons of ALL feeding options should be given to pregnant mothers to let them make a decision that suits them and their family, instead of having one pushed on them and then having subsequent struggles with their mental health. And practical support should be given for mothers regardless of their feeding choices.

I was gutsy enough to stand up for myself when being lectured by midwives when in LABOUR about my feeding choices, but lots aren't and would just cave in.

thefamous5 · 14/02/2023 18:15

Yes.

It might be detrimental to someone's mental health but a sweeping statement. No.

I am still bf at almost four years. At times it's been one thing that's kept me going when my mental health has plummeted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread