Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health?

265 replies

Chiikichik · 14/02/2023 14:03

Before I start - I EBF both my children for the first 6 months of my life. Both took to it really well, but second time around the sheer relentless of it made me feel suicidal. Moving them on to the bottle was the best thing for us at the time.

There is always slot of discussion around how women are effected when they can’t establish BF through lack of support etc but not really for those of us who do establish but just don’t really enjoy it? Or just can’t cope with the absolutely bloody relentlessness of it?

OP posts:
Somethingsnappy · 15/02/2023 14:50

Emmamoo89 · 15/02/2023 11:44

Yeah I know they clusterfeed. But makes no difference when they're a bit older. If a baby wants to sleep it will. Doesn't matter how they feed. My son even slept 3/4 hour sometimes 5 stretches before 11 weeks. Tbf when I gave him formula at the beginning it made no difference to his sleep

Oh, I completely agree with you about the sleep. I was just pointing out that the pp you quoted was talking about something a bit different; that breast milk is digested more quickly than formula milk, so a bf baby will usually be hungry for a feed sooner than a ff baby, particularly when very young with tiny stomachs. Cluster feeding is something different again. But yes, I have 4 children, call bf for about 2 years each. They have all been good sleepers from very early on. I think what many people don't realise, is that it is actually perfect normal for a bf baby to have one long period of sleep in any 24 hour period. This can be about 6 hours long, even as a newborn. If it happens at night, it's a huge bonus.

LindorDoubleChoc · 15/02/2023 13:21

Areyouactuallyserious · 14/02/2023 21:40

OP. This kind of sweeping generalisation is so unhelpful. I BF all my children, and my youngest until 2, it was wonderful and extremely beneficial to my MH, however I would not be so naive as to think this is a universal experience, so would you think your experience is either?

Honestly, this is all that needs to be said on the subject. Everyone posting on this thread will have a slightly nuanced different experience of or feeling about breast feeding. You just can't say that it's "bad for maternal mental health" it's really a nonsense. Maybe for you, maybe for some others, but quite OBVIOUSLY not for everyone.

fruitandfibreg · 15/02/2023 12:54

With the sleeping better. My dad slept through the night the first time she was given formula at 6 months. Seems abit too much of a coincidence to me.

fruitandfibreg · 15/02/2023 12:53

I EBF my DD. While I loved it I did resent that every single feed was my responsibility. I could only do bedtime etc. with the next one I'm going to pump and combi feed (or just use formula as I hate pumping) If they'll take a bottle thag is. My daughter didn't till 6 months

Notaboutyouthistime · 15/02/2023 12:42

don't know what actual evidence there is (proper studies, etc) re sleep and FF v BF, but the narrative that ebf babies won't be able to sleep longer than a couple of hours at a time isn't helping raise bf rates in the UK (which are v v low).

In my personal experience across my friendship circle, it has proved true.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 15/02/2023 12:32

I also had a sleepy ebf baby. Dd1 did 6 hours uninterrupted overnight by six weeks, then added an hour a night per week up to 12 weeks, at which point she slept through 7-7.

I don't know what actual evidence there is (proper studies, etc) re sleep and FF v BF, but the narrative that ebf babies won't be able to sleep longer than a couple of hours at a time isn't helping raise bf rates in the UK (which are v v low).

I also didn't get zero help overnight, which is the other thing I see trotted out re FF. Dh and I took turns to be the on to get up, lift DD out of her cot, check if she needed a new nappy, etc. If it was DH's turn to do all that I stayed in bed while all that happened, then he brought DD to me, I fed her back to sleep, and he took her back to her cot and settled her. By Dd2 we did a lot of co sleeping so it didn't work out quite the same, but I didn't get left to it while dh slept.

Trekking downstairs in the night to do bottles, waiting for the kettle to boil, measuring formula while half asleep, waiting for the bottle to cool, worrying about it being too hot, too cold, all whilst baby screams his/her head off because it's hungry NOW sounds like the worst idea ever. Which is why those perfect prep machines are so popular I guess. But boobs were free and instantly available!

Emmamoo89 · 15/02/2023 11:44

Somethingsnappy · 15/02/2023 09:10

You haven't understood what that poster has written. She says that breastfed babies usually need to feed more frequently when newborn, than formula fed babies. This is true and supported by research, and is because breast milk is more easily digested than formula milk.

Yeah I know they clusterfeed. But makes no difference when they're a bit older. If a baby wants to sleep it will. Doesn't matter how they feed. My son even slept 3/4 hour sometimes 5 stretches before 11 weeks. Tbf when I gave him formula at the beginning it made no difference to his sleep

phoenixrosehere · 15/02/2023 09:12

MrsMullerBecameABaby · 14/02/2023 20:37

Actually it's a good point that it can be something to focus on if your birth was frightening and required lots of intervention.

This was the case for me too - although my brain knew that it's just luck (and possibly genetics) and not a reflection on the woman if she doesn't have a smooth "natural" birth (just as if she can't breastfeed easily or at all) it is something that women feel judged for (or judge themselves). I defensively joked that I couldn't manage a natural birth (even the term is judgemental) and needed an emergency caesarean (electives for subsequent births - even more unnatural/ inadequate/ not trying hard enough?) but at least breastfeeding came easily.

I did feel relieved that I could do that even though my body had failed me when it came to the birth. I was so aware both dc1 and I would have died if we hadn't been in a first world country in the twenty first century.

My consultants coerced me into a medically unnecessary induction, talked down to me when I asked for evidence that it was necessary (none provided) while quoting stillbirth stats and telling me I was killing my baby for three weeks until I caved so they would leave me alone. When I did go in, I asked for my bishop score and was told they had to start the process first before they could which was a lie. The registrar shouted at my DH in front of me and other HCPs because she chose to assume in less than 10 seconds of looking at us that he was preventing me from talking (a contraction was coming and he was asking her to wait) Shouting is highly triggering for me and I was in the middle of the contraction trying to tell her he isn’t (she’s still shouting) while trying to consume gas and air to keep myself calm. Didn’t work, induction failed, emcs and baby was blue (fact not told until months later after reporting them).

To this day never got an apology or told why they put me through all that over a supposedly “big” baby (he was 6lb 14oz, consultants predicting he was 8lbs at 39wks, had him at 39+3) the hospital agreed there was no evidence of a large baby, the need of an induction, or the extra tests and apts that they did. One was pushed to retired and there were changes made about consent when it comes to pregnant mothers.

I enjoyed breastfeeding and it was the one thing I felt I had consent over after all of that. Once my milk came in, and I was helped with my technique, it went swimmingly. He was a clockwork baby. Nurse for 5-8 minutes, fall asleep for 2-3 hours, change nappy, repeat. Youngest was similar except he took longer to nurse, constantly latching off to smile at me while also leading to him getting sprayed in the face if he did it too quickly and slept 5 hours at night which had us checking to make sure he was breathing because of what his brother was like and the constant saying of bf babies not sleeping long.

Somethingsnappy · 15/02/2023 09:10

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 23:22

It's not how they feed to how well they sleep. My son slept through the night since 11 weeks now 10 months and breastfed

You haven't understood what that poster has written. She says that breastfed babies usually need to feed more frequently when newborn, than formula fed babies. This is true and supported by research, and is because breast milk is more easily digested than formula milk.

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 15/02/2023 09:09

It depends.
I could only breast feed my eldest for 6 weeks due to a decline in MH.
I breast fed my eldest for a year and loved it. She was generally a much calmer baby though.

Idlikeasize8please · 15/02/2023 08:55

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/02/2023 20:00

Why did you have 3 babies in quick succession if it was detrimental to your mental health?

My first baby was such a shock after being an Independent, career focused party animal. I didn't sleep very much at all for many months. I felt tortured by exhaustion, I was weepy and overwhelmed. I didn't feel like a very good mum, she never settled to sleep and cried lots.

My family all formula fed and they kept telling me that it was the answer. It didn't seem like the right answer for me. In the end I coslept with the baby and she settled and slept better and I quickly felt better.

Baby 2 & 3 were a breeze - I was more relaxed and confident in my parenting. I wish I'd had more!

K37529 · 14/02/2023 23:33

I don't think breastfeeding Is detrimental to a woman's mental health, it's the perceived judgement/feelings of failure when breastfeeding isn't going well that affects a woman's mental health. On the flip side of that though I felt a lot more pressure to stop breastfeeding than to continue. When my baby was 4 months old I got mastitis, I called the doctor and she laughed down the phone and said "you actually breastfeed, that's so uncommon." This was far more detrimental to my mental health than actually breastfeeding (which I was already struggling with). Breastfeeding is so uncommon where I live and people where constantly telling me I should stop. They said things like your baby will sleep better, your babys too clingy to you, your babys too old (I stopped before the age of 2 with both). No matter how you feed your baby people will judge you. I think if other people just minded their own business and stopped being so opinionated on how others feed their babies it would really take the pressure of motherhood, especially in those early months when your mental health is already fragile.

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 23:25

Swiftswatch · 14/02/2023 17:38

Breastfed babies are easier to get out of the house with and getting out of the house is arguably very good indeed for anyone's mental health, particularly new mothers who might be feeling isolated... @MrsMullerBecameABaby

This is by no means universal. I did not find it easier to get out of the house when EBF vs when I formula fed.
The stress of where I was when baby was hungry and how appropriate/ accommodating the location was to feed was a lot more than the stress of throwing a sterilised bottle and a premade formula in the nappy bag.

I found it easy to leave the house too and fed my son anywhere and don't bother covering up. Feeding him is more important and he hates being covered.

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 23:23

WhatNoRaisins · 14/02/2023 17:55

I'm honestly not sure. I think the official line is no and that breastfeeding mums actually get more sleep and yet anecdotally and from reading various parenting forums it does seem like bottlefed babies tend to sleep more or at least start to sleep through younger.

The conspiracy theorist part of me wonders if it's hushed up to promote breastfeeding or maybe it was more true of the formulas used a generation or two ago.

Not true. Its not how they feed how well they sleep. My son is breastfed as slept through since 11 weeks now 10 months. Loves his sleep.

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 23:22

ArabellaScott · 14/02/2023 18:24

Breastmilk is more quickly and easily digested in the gut, so yes, breastfeeding babies are likely when newborn to want to feed more frequently. (Some do, but this also depends on other factors, too).

Formula tends to form a 'curd', which sits in the stomach for longer. It takes longer to pass through the gut.

I can't right now find a reference for comparison of transit times through the gut; here's one on basic differences in constituents of formulas compared to breastmilk:

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4882692/

Ah, here we go:

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0958694620302521

'Infant feeding studies show that the rate of gastric digestion and stomach clearance is related to curd the hardness of gastric curds formed (Doan, 1938). A gastric emptying study in preterm infants showed gastric emptying rate of 30 mL portions of human milk was considerably fast than of 30 mL portions of infant formula, with an average of with 24.8 mL of human milk having been emptied after one hour (Cavell, 1979). This may be related to the fact that human milk forms softer clots in the stomach than infant formula'

It's not how they feed to how well they sleep. My son slept through the night since 11 weeks now 10 months and breastfed

tenthousandmaniacs · 14/02/2023 23:13

Swiftswatch · 14/02/2023 17:38

Breastfed babies are easier to get out of the house with and getting out of the house is arguably very good indeed for anyone's mental health, particularly new mothers who might be feeling isolated... @MrsMullerBecameABaby

This is by no means universal. I did not find it easier to get out of the house when EBF vs when I formula fed.
The stress of where I was when baby was hungry and how appropriate/ accommodating the location was to feed was a lot more than the stress of throwing a sterilised bottle and a premade formula in the nappy bag.

How appropriate/accommodating the location was to fed? What sort of place do you mention? I breastfed at The Ritz, Fortnum & Mason and Corinthia with no problem whatsoever.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/02/2023 22:46

Honestly no idea how you'd cope with a baby needing resettling 8+ times a night without a boob tbh.

It’s a self fulfilling prophecy. If they fall asleep on the boob then they become shocked and distressed when they wake up and it isn’t there, so they cry for it to get back to sleep again. If they’re used to dropping off without it, they wake less, on the whole. So you wouldn’t really be up with them 8+ times a night. I never fed to sleep, DD didn’t seem interested frankly as she just pulled away when she was full.

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 22:34

@Siameasy I work and still manage to breastfeed...

pointythings · 14/02/2023 22:33

@Smineusername don't be ridiculous, plenty of women manage to make breastfeeding work and also manage to work full time. I'm one of them, and I'm old enough that I didn't get a whole year off either.

Cuppasoupmonster · 14/02/2023 22:28

Smineusername · 14/02/2023 15:43

The problem people have today is that they aren't willing to learn the lessons their bodies are teaching them. Breastfeeding is beautiful. It is a privilege to be able to do it. Motherhood isn't easy and it isnt meant to be squeezed in around a 9 to 5 job. You need to surrender to the process to reap the rewards, which are infinite

😂

ChaosAndCrumbs · 14/02/2023 21:46

I had to bottle feed my ds due to my medication. I suffered with PND and anxiety during his babyhood. With my daughter, I was off meds and breastfed from the word go. It made the world of difference to my mental health and I was calmer and happier. The first 6-8 weeks were pretty painful and she used to breastfeed continuously for 9h a night, but I loved those snuggles to pieces and felt so lucky to have that experience. She’s reduced feeding now, as a toddler (still feeds at night and on occasion in the day), but I think the impact on my mental health was only positive.

It totally depends on the situation though. I was desperate to try breastfeeding and was so disappointed first time around not to. My ds also had health issues that meant he literally never slept and cried in pain all night and we were constantly in and out of hospital for the first year and a half, so I was beyond exhausted and terrified for him because no one could get to the bottom of what was going on. 9h breastfeeds were the easier option in that case! She was healthy and happy and so was I. I’m sure if dd was my first and had tongue tie or something, it would have been a very different story.

Areyouactuallyserious · 14/02/2023 21:40

OP. This kind of sweeping generalisation is so unhelpful. I BF all my children, and my youngest until 2, it was wonderful and extremely beneficial to my MH, however I would not be so naive as to think this is a universal experience, so would you think your experience is either?

olderthanyouthink · 14/02/2023 21:24

Chiikichik · 14/02/2023 14:18

But no support is going to help you when your baby six months in wants to feed 2-3 hours at night? So it’s all very well saying supported is best (which of course helps) but what about when it just becomes physically impossible to continue?

2-3 hours would have actually been decent compared to some of the rough patches DD had, bedsharing and breastsleeping made it manageable, I didn't really have to wake that much. She refused and still refuses her dads care so it still likely would have been me up in the night.

Honestly no idea how you'd cope with a baby needing resettling 8+ times a night without a boob tbh.

Emmamoo89 · 14/02/2023 21:23

eighteenthirteen1 · 14/02/2023 21:15

I breastfed them, has improved my mental health, as, when I’m finding things tough, I can assure myself I have tried my best by them.

I tried my best by my children even though I bottle feed.

That comment has annoyed me.

Why have you took offence to that

olderthanyouthink · 14/02/2023 21:20

@whitebreadjamsandwich same! Only realised I may have ADHD a few years into breastfeeding but boy does the whole having milk in and clean bottles sound like it's too much for me. I cannot forget my boobs.

It was also a godsend for my ND DC1, emotional regulation all day and night, and I don't think she'd have been any easier bottle fed... just really hard to get off them.