Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health?

265 replies

Chiikichik · 14/02/2023 14:03

Before I start - I EBF both my children for the first 6 months of my life. Both took to it really well, but second time around the sheer relentless of it made me feel suicidal. Moving them on to the bottle was the best thing for us at the time.

There is always slot of discussion around how women are effected when they can’t establish BF through lack of support etc but not really for those of us who do establish but just don’t really enjoy it? Or just can’t cope with the absolutely bloody relentlessness of it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KatyJ89 · 19/03/2023 23:34

endofthelinefinally · 10/03/2023 06:24

I agree with this. I visited DH's family recently (Asia). His niece has recently had a baby. She is surrounded by helpful aunties, cousins, siblings. Doesn't have to lift a finger, just rest, relax and feed baby. Baby is a happy, sociable little soul who is loved and cuddled all the time. Niece is very well rested. No cooking or shopping or cleaning. Such a far cry from the exhaustion and stress so many new mums face here. They all live in one building, all the older adults help with the little ones.

sounds lovely 😍

Bumply · 11/03/2023 22:32

I failed with breastfeeding ds1, giving up after 3 weeks.
More successful with ds2, but can't say I ever enjoyed it even when we'd got it established. I gave up after 4 months, which was earlier than required for going back to work at 6 months, because I didn't want to do it any more.

Emmamoo89 · 11/03/2023 21:14

Saschka · 11/03/2023 20:49

Found it easy (time consuming yes, DS had a tongue tie, but much easier than sterilising bottles).

We did some expressed feeds, particularly when I went back to work and had to do nightshifts, and I am SO glad I wasn’t having to do that multiple times a day while sleep deprived. Bottle feeding is a massive pain in the arse, with all the sterilising and cleaning and preparing stuff in advance.

It also made it much easier to go out for the day - put the baby in the sling, put some nappies in my handbag, and off I went for as long as I fancied, no worries about running out of bottles, warming up bottles, carrying loads of bottles, etc.

I never woke up at 3am and had to go downstairs to run the Perfect Prep. I never found I’d used my last bottle and had to do some midnight washing up. Never had to worry about how long that bottle had been in the fridge, and if it was still safe. Never came downstairs to find we only had one scoop of formula left and the shops were shut. Just put DS in the bed next to me and let him latch on while I went back to sleep. Made everything so much less faff, and took up so much less brain space.

So agree with this

Hence · 11/03/2023 21:07

I loved breastfeeding. Breastfed all four of mine past 2 years and never used formula or expressed. I would have been really upset if I couldn't breastfeed, I suspect I may have got PND as it was very important to me that I breastfed all my children for a minimum of 2 years for all our benefits.

Saschka · 11/03/2023 20:49

Found it easy (time consuming yes, DS had a tongue tie, but much easier than sterilising bottles).

We did some expressed feeds, particularly when I went back to work and had to do nightshifts, and I am SO glad I wasn’t having to do that multiple times a day while sleep deprived. Bottle feeding is a massive pain in the arse, with all the sterilising and cleaning and preparing stuff in advance.

It also made it much easier to go out for the day - put the baby in the sling, put some nappies in my handbag, and off I went for as long as I fancied, no worries about running out of bottles, warming up bottles, carrying loads of bottles, etc.

I never woke up at 3am and had to go downstairs to run the Perfect Prep. I never found I’d used my last bottle and had to do some midnight washing up. Never had to worry about how long that bottle had been in the fridge, and if it was still safe. Never came downstairs to find we only had one scoop of formula left and the shops were shut. Just put DS in the bed next to me and let him latch on while I went back to sleep. Made everything so much less faff, and took up so much less brain space.

Notaboutyouthistime · 11/03/2023 20:35

endofthelinefinally · 10/03/2023 06:24

I agree with this. I visited DH's family recently (Asia). His niece has recently had a baby. She is surrounded by helpful aunties, cousins, siblings. Doesn't have to lift a finger, just rest, relax and feed baby. Baby is a happy, sociable little soul who is loved and cuddled all the time. Niece is very well rested. No cooking or shopping or cleaning. Such a far cry from the exhaustion and stress so many new mums face here. They all live in one building, all the older adults help with the little ones.

I would hate that. I don't want to sit there. I want to have an excuse to bustle around with baby in a sling

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/03/2023 18:30

Anyway if you believe in a woman’s choice in this matter there is no ‘worst’ or ‘bad’ rate.

Cuppasoupmonster · 10/03/2023 18:30

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/03/2023 17:34

Given that the UK has the worst bf rates in the entire world it should have the best maternal MH in the world on this hypothesis

Personally I throughly enjoyed breastfeeding and it had a positive impact on my MH.

It doesn’t, actually.

jemimapuddlepluck · 10/03/2023 17:54

I know from day dot I didnt want to be the only one getting up during the night. My mental and physical health was important to me, I knew I would struggle with both if I exclusively breastfed. From birth I/we combi fed both, I look back on the newborn days and early months and it was blissful really. I felt very strongly about this so it never bothered me if people judged me, and a couple of my breastfeeding friends most certainly did. Water off a ducks back.
I have no opinion on how anyone else feeds their baby and I would 100% encourage a friend to go with their instincts, either persevering or swapping to formula. Despite reading on here not too long ago that you can totally tell which babies were bottle fed and which were formula fed 🙄you really really can't. Happy mum, happy baby is the most important thing in those early weeks and months! We put far too much pressure on ourselves to mainly prove to other people how good we are, it stops being about what's best for baby very quickly because as soon as baby arrives people are quick to pass comment on what you should be doing and you want to prove them wrong! Or prove something to yourself. I dunno.

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/03/2023 17:34

Given that the UK has the worst bf rates in the entire world it should have the best maternal MH in the world on this hypothesis

Personally I throughly enjoyed breastfeeding and it had a positive impact on my MH.

Cozytoesandtoast00 · 10/03/2023 17:18

I breasted one baby and formula fed another.
Not counting the first month, I can honestly say the breast fed baby woke less overnight and she was generally easier.
I think feeding choice doesn't always make a difference.

Scottishskifun · 10/03/2023 09:09

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 10/03/2023 05:37

I do think one of the problems with bf is that it breeds a very strong attachment to just one parent. My little one is lovely, but has woken every night (he’s 3.5) and every night insists on me. I’d love it if just one night he’d insist on his dad. I’m so exhausted I really struggle at work some days, and my own sleep pattern is shot to pieces (hence phone at 5:30!). Maybe that’s why the gender pay gap is so big. Exhausted mothers.

This is more DC specific and I don't think has anything to do with bf.
My eldest only wants daddy during the night and to put him to bed....bf til nearly 2!
Youngest is 13 months and if he wants milk then only I will do but first thing in the morning and again bedtime only daddy will do (I don't feed to sleep)

toomuchlaundry · 10/03/2023 07:50

@endofthelinefinally living in the same building as extended family would be detrimental to my mental health.

OlympicProcrastinator · 10/03/2023 07:16

It’s not breast feeding per se that is the problem, it’s the context in which it occurs. In the UK especially, it happens in a culture that is not sufficiently supportive of the practice. It happens in a sea of judgment and shame and in terms of ‘failure’ and ‘success’.

The instinct to provide the very best care to our infants is extremely powerful and the insecurities that brings can sometimes make mothers judge and criticise one other.

I have been banging the drum for years about forgetting the utterly useless Breast is Best useless mantra. Until social policy recognises women as complete, multi dimensional human beings who are inextricably linked to the wider community in which they live, absolutely nothing can change.

That is because there are a myriad of considerations that come with feeding choices and each one impacts mother, baby, family, work, finances, emotions, physiology, mental load and wider community in very different ways.

Mamabearprotectinghercub · 10/03/2023 06:51

For me it has been my proudest achievement, which has helped me mentally. I have suffered from mental health problems most of my life, and breastfeeding is the one thing that’s helped me. As a single mother who isn’t very organised at the best of times (could be ADHD), I couldn’t have handled formula feeding as I struggle with washing dishing and tidying, all the sterilising and preparing bottles etc. would’ve been too much for me, it’s so much easier for me to get my boob out! I did educate myself about everything breastfeeding related and problems that can be encountered with it prior to giving birth so think this also helped me. Breastmilk is the healthiest nutrition for a baby and I’m so glad I’ve been able to give my baby that.

endofthelinefinally · 10/03/2023 06:24

KatyJ89 · 14/02/2023 18:52

I don't think it's breastfeeding as such. I think it's just the way western cultures live now. We have no real practical support, there's no village. There's nobody holding the baby while we nap, making food while we feed the baby, nobody helping clean, etc, etc. I think if we lived like that still then it may be different. Formula wouldnt make a difference to how soul destroying lonely my life is ATM (cheery I know lol)

I agree with this. I visited DH's family recently (Asia). His niece has recently had a baby. She is surrounded by helpful aunties, cousins, siblings. Doesn't have to lift a finger, just rest, relax and feed baby. Baby is a happy, sociable little soul who is loved and cuddled all the time. Niece is very well rested. No cooking or shopping or cleaning. Such a far cry from the exhaustion and stress so many new mums face here. They all live in one building, all the older adults help with the little ones.

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 10/03/2023 05:37

I do think one of the problems with bf is that it breeds a very strong attachment to just one parent. My little one is lovely, but has woken every night (he’s 3.5) and every night insists on me. I’d love it if just one night he’d insist on his dad. I’m so exhausted I really struggle at work some days, and my own sleep pattern is shot to pieces (hence phone at 5:30!). Maybe that’s why the gender pay gap is so big. Exhausted mothers.

Bloopsie · 10/03/2023 05:21

Chiikichik · 14/02/2023 14:03

Before I start - I EBF both my children for the first 6 months of my life. Both took to it really well, but second time around the sheer relentless of it made me feel suicidal. Moving them on to the bottle was the best thing for us at the time.

There is always slot of discussion around how women are effected when they can’t establish BF through lack of support etc but not really for those of us who do establish but just don’t really enjoy it? Or just can’t cope with the absolutely bloody relentlessness of it?

I have ebf-d 4 babies from birth to 12-18 months and think breastfeeding is the most amazing thing ever. Beside food irs a source of comfort, boosts immune system, cure for teething pains, baby unsettled? Give a boob sleep guaranteed in no time, feeding through sickness when baby has a fever so no need to use ibuprofen or paracetamol as much or none at all etc.

Best combo- cosleeping and breastfeeding, i wake up enough to lift the shirt etc baby feeds quickly back to sleep and we nod off again. Cant imagine having to get up to measure powder heat water wash bottles etc :oI

juliettesmother · 10/03/2023 04:47

TheOrigRights · 15/02/2023 14:57

If breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health? becomes "[something related to motherhood] can be detrimental to maternal mental health?" then I think that covers everything.

I think people are aware that becoming a parent/mother is a huge adjustment.
If people listen more, judge less and offer support I'd like to think women would feel less pressure and isolation.

Yes! Honestly, so much judgement and debate, and at the end of the day, it means very little.

I had 4 c sections and often was given pity looks for 'not giving birth properly'. But I BF all four, successfully for a minimum of 6 months, maximum of 3 years, depending on the DC. I also loved it, despite thinking I would not at the beginning. Some DC were easier than others, one was very hard work and it took us 5 weeks to establish (if he had been my first, and I had lacked support and confidence, he would have been bottle fed, and I would have felt no shame about that either).

Everyone's journey is different.

We should all be supporting each other, and helping to make sure our babies thrive.

StripyHorse · 09/03/2023 21:55

What I think is detrimental is the push to breastfeed which puts pressure on women. I hope things have changed, but 16 years ago at antenatal classes we were told about breastfeeding, but had to stay behind after class if we wanted info on bottle feeding. I was naive and hungry (classes were straight after work) so I didn't. Only later did I realise I was lucky but stupid not to get all the facts about both.

What should be done is explain pros and cons of both, and what you need to know about (including potential problems) and let women do what works best for their family.

Everyone is different...

For me, I liked not having to faff with bottles etc. I also liked the perfect excuse to disappear from family gatherings, especially when MIL was being a bit overbearing. I used to remain out of the way longer than necessary for some down time.

For others the above could be seen as not being able to share the load of feeding, and being excluded from family time when they want to join in. Neither is right, it is just that people are different.

Notaboutyouthistime · 09/03/2023 20:52

BMEC · 15/02/2023 14:57

Second this!
I have felt unbelievably proud of my BF journey the first 2 weeks were great and then the following 4 weeks I had oversupply issues and my baby was struggling with wind which made me feel like a failure. But he was ģaining weight and loved the boob! The best advice someone gave me was wait it out for 6 weeks before deciding to quit or carry on. Best thing I ever did. My baby is now 11 weeks and thriving. Ive found there to be a lot of support if you want it.. I signed up to the Koala BF support after giving birth and had weekly phonecalls from them to check how everything was going.

It's sad that so much pride and shame is tied up in it - the last thing sensitive new mums need is a hill to die on. That's not healthy and could have gone the other way. But I'm glad it's worked out for you.

stargirl1701 · 15/02/2023 15:18

No, I think it is rooted in the fact we evolved to raise children in family groups (villages). Your sisters, your aunts, your mother and grandmother could all have cared for your baby and breastfed her if you were busy. The load was shared. Babies were raised by a village.

We live in a WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrial, Rich, Democratic) country which prioritises individuality. Raising a baby where you spend most of your 24 hour day either alone or with one partner is not how our species evolved.

It is our context that causes us such emotional distress when breastfeeding.

I struggled massively with DD1. I felt I had failed. Failed her, failed myself, failed motherhood. I lasted 10 days EBF. I know now I WAS FAILED by the circumstances of MY birth (when I was born, where I was born, etc).

If I had given birth in Scandinavia in 2012, I would've had a much higher chance of breastfeeding successfully.

If I had given birth in Scotland in 1812, I would've had a much higher chance of breastfeeding. But...would I have survived childhood to live long enough to have a child? Would I have survived the post-birth infection I had or would my DD1 be motherless?

With DD2, I knew what I needed to change to try and provide that 'village' and it worked. DD2 breastfed until natural term at nearly 6 years with the first six months EBF. Ironically, it was the physical health benefits that made me want breastfed yet it is the mental health benefits for her that have lasted. Saying that, in consultation with the NHS, we managed to eliminate most of her food allergies through breastfeeding (CMPA, soya, nuts, egg) to natural term.

I feel at peace with what happened with DD1 over a decade ago now. It wasn't my failing or fault. When (if) she asks I can explain what happened AND why.

BMEC · 15/02/2023 14:57

NotMyDayJob · 14/02/2023 14:16

I think absolutist statements are detrimental to maternal mental health.

Breastfeeding has been absolutely essential to my wellbeing (and I didn't have an easy ride to start either time) but do I think that means everyone should breastfeed? Of course not. I just get a bit sad when women who want to feed don't get good support.

Second this!
I have felt unbelievably proud of my BF journey the first 2 weeks were great and then the following 4 weeks I had oversupply issues and my baby was struggling with wind which made me feel like a failure. But he was ģaining weight and loved the boob! The best advice someone gave me was wait it out for 6 weeks before deciding to quit or carry on. Best thing I ever did. My baby is now 11 weeks and thriving. Ive found there to be a lot of support if you want it.. I signed up to the Koala BF support after giving birth and had weekly phonecalls from them to check how everything was going.

TheOrigRights · 15/02/2023 14:57

If breastfeeding is detrimental to maternal mental health? becomes "[something related to motherhood] can be detrimental to maternal mental health?" then I think that covers everything.

I think people are aware that becoming a parent/mother is a huge adjustment.
If people listen more, judge less and offer support I'd like to think women would feel less pressure and isolation.

Emmamoo89 · 15/02/2023 14:55

Somethingsnappy · 15/02/2023 14:50

Oh, I completely agree with you about the sleep. I was just pointing out that the pp you quoted was talking about something a bit different; that breast milk is digested more quickly than formula milk, so a bf baby will usually be hungry for a feed sooner than a ff baby, particularly when very young with tiny stomachs. Cluster feeding is something different again. But yes, I have 4 children, call bf for about 2 years each. They have all been good sleepers from very early on. I think what many people don't realise, is that it is actually perfect normal for a bf baby to have one long period of sleep in any 24 hour period. This can be about 6 hours long, even as a newborn. If it happens at night, it's a huge bonus.

Oh I know that breastmilk digests better and quicker than formula :) more natural.

Swipe left for the next trending thread