Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband changed his mind about baby. AIBU

338 replies

Wantanotherandanother · 14/02/2023 12:05

Name changed for this. Need a fresh perspective on this problem please but be kind...

I'm 35 and husband is 48. Always planned to have kids, number not discussed but hoped we'd have at least two (more if I was lucky!). Had our first and at 6 months pp I was broody! Waited and waited and he didn't mention anything so recently brought it up given neither of us have time on our side and our 'baby' is nearly 2. He said he now feels he doesn't actually want any more and he's very much done. I feel a bit short changed and although so, so grateful to already have one, I always hoped to have more and he knew that. I feel like he went into this knowing he'd always refuse any more. His reasons are related to his age and that he just feels physically done with having young children around. Financially we'd be ok.

He has 3 teens to his ex and so obviously has had his fair share of nappies and sleepless nights.

AIBU? Can a marriage even survive this difference in opinion about something so huge? Neither of us wish to compromise. I feel so sad every time I see a pregnant lady or baby and don't think that ache will ever go away.

OP posts:
DeadButDelicious · 15/02/2023 21:26

It's all very well and good saying he's selfish and he knew she wanted multiple children, for all we know he did want multiple children with OP but the reality of a newborn at 48 can be quite sobering, the fact is he has 4 kids, deciding that adding a 5th isn't something he wants is perfectly acceptable. Of course it's sad for the OP and she is entitled to be upset and even to consider if this is a deal breaker for her but he is allowed to change his mind. That doesn't make him a villain or wrong.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/02/2023 21:15

A lot of women just see men as walking sperm providers, honestly.

It’s not “more nuanced” and “totally different” when the sexes are reversed. Y’all just think that what a woman says about babies goes, and men have to fall in line.

It’s sick.

Sheerdetermination · 15/02/2023 21:03

I think this man has been very selfish. As the OP said, he knew she wanted children, plural. He should have been honest from the start, but probably wasn’t being he didn’t want to frighten off his young love. You deserve better treatment than this, OP. Good luck.

whumpthereitis · 15/02/2023 20:44

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 20:36

“He doesn’t owe her children because he married a younger woman. He knew he was marring a younger woman, yes, but equally she knew she was marrying an older man that already had children.”

you have entirely missed my point.
some things are more nuanced than the weight of what one person wants over another. Really. There aren’t blanket rules and there aren’t simple answers where someone’s desires for their whole life are concerned.
a baby ache is real and a little person is real, beyond being “another baby”, which is abstract. And the balance in relationships can also be nuanced. At the end of the day - he is making as much of a big decision for his family as OP is by his refusal. Sibling relationships are really quite important - especially in “blended” families where a little one could be left feeling isolated in his or her experience, or as if there is no solid “hundred percent” family around them.

Except it’s not nuanced in this instance, is it? He’s not said he’s unsure of having more children, he’s said he doesn’t want more. That’s blanket.

He’s happy with the status quo, whereas OP wants to add a member, or potentially leave. The latter is certainly more of an upheaval than the former.

sibling relationships are not the be all and end all of a family relationship. It’s also not necessarily the primary concern. Not having a sibling is not ostensibly worse for a child than being an only child, or having your family break apart. In fact, it’s arguably better.

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 20:40

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 20:18

@Tandora what would you say if it was the woman who didn’t want another but the man did? What do you think should happen in that scenario?

Arg! Here we go. The make versus female experience here really is different! Yes, that scenario would also be a head scratcher worth a thread BUT 1) totally hypothetical and 2) really unhelpful! Because it is NOT comparable. Men and women ARE different and carrying a baby as a woman is totally different to fathering a child. Yes both valid situations but also not at all comparable. Don’t even go there. These days we have to pretend like men and women are totally equivalent blah blah blah bollox.

MysteryBelle · 15/02/2023 20:40

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 15/02/2023 20:35

The OP said they didn't discuss a number.

You left out the rest of her sentence that she always hoped for at least two or more when she discussed children with him, as in they didn’t talk about a specific number but she apparently was clear with him that she wanted more than one.

it’s never been a secret as the rest of her post demonstrates.

whumpthereitis · 15/02/2023 20:36

MysteryBelle · 15/02/2023 20:32

If this marriage is his forever marriage which I’m assuming of course it is, I think he should compromise and have second baby with you. He’s already got 3 previous and he got to have that experience but you haven’t, so it’s unfair on you. Why can’t he do this. He should have thought about his age when he agreed on two or more with you a few years ago.

That’s not a compromise though, is it?

She’s a grown woman that also knew his age and the number of children he already had. It’s not his duty to provide her with more children. Ones he doesn’t want.

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 20:36

“He doesn’t owe her children because he married a younger woman. He knew he was marring a younger woman, yes, but equally she knew she was marrying an older man that already had children.”

you have entirely missed my point.
some things are more nuanced than the weight of what one person wants over another. Really. There aren’t blanket rules and there aren’t simple answers where someone’s desires for their whole life are concerned.
a baby ache is real and a little person is real, beyond being “another baby”, which is abstract. And the balance in relationships can also be nuanced. At the end of the day - he is making as much of a big decision for his family as OP is by his refusal. Sibling relationships are really quite important - especially in “blended” families where a little one could be left feeling isolated in his or her experience, or as if there is no solid “hundred percent” family around them.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 15/02/2023 20:35

MysteryBelle · 15/02/2023 20:32

If this marriage is his forever marriage which I’m assuming of course it is, I think he should compromise and have second baby with you. He’s already got 3 previous and he got to have that experience but you haven’t, so it’s unfair on you. Why can’t he do this. He should have thought about his age when he agreed on two or more with you a few years ago.

The OP said they didn't discuss a number.

MysteryBelle · 15/02/2023 20:32

If this marriage is his forever marriage which I’m assuming of course it is, I think he should compromise and have second baby with you. He’s already got 3 previous and he got to have that experience but you haven’t, so it’s unfair on you. Why can’t he do this. He should have thought about his age when he agreed on two or more with you a few years ago.

OhmygodDont · 15/02/2023 20:29

Nobody is forcing her to have no more children. She’s just not entitled to have one with him. She has no right to his sperm.

If that means they separate then they separate that’s her choice if she wishes to leave to chase a second child.

Badsox · 15/02/2023 20:29

You already have four children OP, You are step mother to his older three. It does not feel as if they are particularly valued in this scenario. Personally, I would focus positively on what you have and enjoy them rather than choosing to make them all victims of a divorce.

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 20:18

@Tandora what would you say if it was the woman who didn’t want another but the man did? What do you think should happen in that scenario?

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 20:15

Tandora · 15/02/2023 20:01

No one’s forcing him to parent another child. If he wants to leave and find another woman who doesn’t want any more babies that’s his lookout!

I can’t work out if you’re being wilfully obtuse or not. I hope it’s wilful. Otherwise…

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 20:08

Tandora · 15/02/2023 19:59

Why though? Why is the need not to have a child seen as more significant than the need to have a child? I feel like this is a very “western” way of thinking.

It's a very 'consent' way of thinking. Because for starters, you can't make someone have unprotected PIV with you so a child they don't want can be conceived. Well you can, but it's generally considered unethical. Should a child be conceived anyway, the situation changes, but it's not like one person can do anything if the other chooses to get sterilised/vasectomy or refuse sex without condoms. It's all very well having an abstract discussion about the right to reproduce with someone else, but reality is going to bite quite hard if they don't wish to cooperate.

bossyrossy · 15/02/2023 20:05

Is he a good father to your baby? If he is, then you should seriously consider the effect it would have on your two year old to deprive him/her of a loving and caring parent.

whumpthereitis · 15/02/2023 20:03

Tandora · 15/02/2023 19:59

Why though? Why is the need not to have a child seen as more significant than the need to have a child? I feel like this is a very “western” way of thinking.

Presumably because not having a child can be a problem for two people, whereas having an unwanted child/den has an impact on at least three.

arethereanyleftatall · 15/02/2023 20:03

What did you honestly think would happen when you got together with an older man who already had 3 kids? There's no at I'd want a baby at 48.

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 20:02

Tandora · 15/02/2023 19:03

Ugh I hate it when these threads come up because of the way people respond.
YANBU OP.
Don’t let people tell you his needs trump yours, or it’s your responsibility to make the sacrifice to keep the family together.

I am glad to see someone else with announce of understanding. Agreed.

Tandora · 15/02/2023 20:01

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 19:56

No one is forcing her to not have another child. What’s the matter with you? If she wants to leave and have a kid with someone else, that’s her lookout. But you cannot force someone to parent a child. It is wrong.

No one’s forcing him to parent another child. If he wants to leave and find another woman who doesn’t want any more babies that’s his lookout!

joles12 · 15/02/2023 20:00

You are not being unreasonable to want another child but neither is DH to feel like it was hard work and he’s done. One thing worth adding into the discussions might be the longer term implications for him of an “only” child vs 2. In reality the gap between his first three and your little one make them tantamount to an only - who as they get older will need more and more of your/ his time to play with / occupy them - as opposed to having two who can play with each other - inside / outside / on holiday etc. Is your DH up for being the entertainer for the next 9 years ?

Tandora · 15/02/2023 19:59

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 19:54

I agree with some of that, but in this situation one person's needs absolutely take priority over the other. It's those of the person who doesn't want another baby together.

Why though? Why is the need not to have a child seen as more significant than the need to have a child? I feel like this is a very “western” way of thinking.

TaxiFor1 · 15/02/2023 19:56

No advice sorry, but I totally get where your coming from. I'm 37 this year and DH will be 46, we have a 4yr old. We always both said we would try for 2 children and I really thought by now we would have at least started trying. We've spoke about it and financially it would be a squeeze with childcare but still managble. Sometimes having another baby is all I think about and at times I physically feel pain with the thought of never having another baby but then other times I don't even think about it. It's a very strange feeling but I guess only time will tell.

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 19:56

Tandora · 15/02/2023 19:26

You can’t force another person to have another child, you can’t force another person not to have another child.

No one is forcing her to not have another child. What’s the matter with you? If she wants to leave and have a kid with someone else, that’s her lookout. But you cannot force someone to parent a child. It is wrong.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 19:54

I agree with some of that, but in this situation one person's needs absolutely take priority over the other. It's those of the person who doesn't want another baby together.

Swipe left for the next trending thread