Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband changed his mind about baby. AIBU

338 replies

Wantanotherandanother · 14/02/2023 12:05

Name changed for this. Need a fresh perspective on this problem please but be kind...

I'm 35 and husband is 48. Always planned to have kids, number not discussed but hoped we'd have at least two (more if I was lucky!). Had our first and at 6 months pp I was broody! Waited and waited and he didn't mention anything so recently brought it up given neither of us have time on our side and our 'baby' is nearly 2. He said he now feels he doesn't actually want any more and he's very much done. I feel a bit short changed and although so, so grateful to already have one, I always hoped to have more and he knew that. I feel like he went into this knowing he'd always refuse any more. His reasons are related to his age and that he just feels physically done with having young children around. Financially we'd be ok.

He has 3 teens to his ex and so obviously has had his fair share of nappies and sleepless nights.

AIBU? Can a marriage even survive this difference in opinion about something so huge? Neither of us wish to compromise. I feel so sad every time I see a pregnant lady or baby and don't think that ache will ever go away.

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 16/02/2023 11:59

I can understand a parent at nearly 50 with 4 DC has said 'I am done'

I can understand why you would want another DC

You need decide whether this impasse is worth breaking up over.

You need to keep talking, not to persuade each other to change their stance but to see whether you are strong enough as a couple to work through this.

Tandora · 16/02/2023 11:49

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 10:21

@Tandora No, he can’t expect her to remain and if he tried to then that would be coercive. However, if she chooses to leave and he doesn’t stand in her way, then it is her that is choosing to break up the family. She cannot say that he forced her to do it by refusing to have a child, because that is coercion. The facts are the facts, and what she chooses to do with them is completely on here. His choice is have a baby he doesn’t want or divorce. Coercion. Her choice is have counselling to live with and be satisfied with what she has, or prioritise a need for more babies elsewhere and divorce. She has an option that involves no coercion. He doesn’t.

That’s why people say she’s responsible, because he has no option to keep the family together except be forced to father a child, whereas she has a way of keeping the family together without forcing another person to have a child.

No no no no. She is not “choosing” to break up the family any more than he is. They are both equally responsible. They both have needs and they both have choices. It’s totally unjust to make his needs the “default”, so that if she insists on her needs it’s “coercion” , but if he insists on his, it’s just the way things are and she should just “be satisfied with what she has”. I honestly can’t understand the hypocrisy/ double standards here.

Steppered · 16/02/2023 11:46

I haven't read all the replies on here, however I felt compelled to respond because I have been exactly in your position.

When I married my husband he had 3 children with his ex and had them pretty much 50-50. I really wanted 2 children and felt we had pretty much agreed that. We had our first child together and then I brought up the topic of a second ... and he was not keen. At all.

It was devastating really. I felt it was so unfair that he had the number of children her wanted and I didn't. Felt enraged that I expended to so much time, energy, emotion and money looking after our child AND his existing children and felt I was getting a pretty crappy deal at times. He felt overwhelmed physically and financially, worried he/we couldn't cope or spread his time fairly. 4 children is a lot but 5 would have been a stretch for all those reasons plus practical ones too such as bedrooms, car, holidays etc.

Neither of us were right. Neither of us were wrong. We both had strong feelings. Maybe - maybe I could have begged, pleaded, sulked or "accidental pregnancy" changed his mind but I think it always would have been there under the surface. I didn't want to split up and start again with someone else; with the knowledge that I'd only see my child part-time and have to split christmas etc.

We did not have another child. I have, for the most part, made peace with it. I do sometimes feel sad about it. (But I sometimes feel relief when I see my nephews being hellions.) My daughter has sibling relationships.

I've had to challenge a lot of my own existing thoughts around things: why did I want 2 kids? (Because I was one of 2). Not wanting an "only child" (actually I quite like being able to give them my all and tell them they are my favourite). How it would have impacted me physically and financially with work. As older parents, what if there had been additional needs that overwhelmed us?

It is entirely up to you and your husband to work through. I 100% understand how difficult it is and how you feel. Keep having some really honest conversations with each other and I wish you the best for your future.

CatJumperTwat · 16/02/2023 11:39

Yet when these topics come up, women are told that their needs and feelings don’t matter, that DH’s wishes take priority and if she leaves because she is so deeply unhappy, then she is the one responsible for breaking up the family

No. The EXISTING CHILD'S needs take priority. Or they do to any decent parent.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 16/02/2023 10:27

Tandora · 16/02/2023 09:40

It’s not the “right to produce” with a specific individual. You misunderstand me. My point is he can’t expect her to remain in the relationship, if she wants a baby and he doesn’t . That’s just as much of an “ultimatum” and just as “coercive” as her demanding he has a baby or she will leave. They are precisely the mirror situations of each other. Yet when these topics come up, women are told that their needs and feelings don’t matter, that DH’s wishes take priority and if she leaves because she is so deeply unhappy, then she is the one responsible for breaking up the family. It’s totally twisted and hypocritical.

It's a poor and badly expressed point, then.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 10:21

@Tandora No, he can’t expect her to remain and if he tried to then that would be coercive. However, if she chooses to leave and he doesn’t stand in her way, then it is her that is choosing to break up the family. She cannot say that he forced her to do it by refusing to have a child, because that is coercion. The facts are the facts, and what she chooses to do with them is completely on here. His choice is have a baby he doesn’t want or divorce. Coercion. Her choice is have counselling to live with and be satisfied with what she has, or prioritise a need for more babies elsewhere and divorce. She has an option that involves no coercion. He doesn’t.

That’s why people say she’s responsible, because he has no option to keep the family together except be forced to father a child, whereas she has a way of keeping the family together without forcing another person to have a child.

KimberleyClark · 16/02/2023 09:46

Yet when these topics come up, women are told that their needs and feelings don’t matter, that DH’s wishes take priority and if she leaves because she is so deeply unhappy, then she is the one responsible for breaking up the family. It’s totally twisted and hypocritical.

It’s her wants, not her needs. Her existing child has needs.

Tandora · 16/02/2023 09:44

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 20:15

I can’t work out if you’re being wilfully obtuse or not. I hope it’s wilful. Otherwise…

How so? I’m quite sincere.

Tandora · 16/02/2023 09:43

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 20:02

I am glad to see someone else with announce of understanding. Agreed.

So glad I’m not the only one. The advice given on these threads is always so twisted.

Tandora · 16/02/2023 09:40

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 20:08

It's a very 'consent' way of thinking. Because for starters, you can't make someone have unprotected PIV with you so a child they don't want can be conceived. Well you can, but it's generally considered unethical. Should a child be conceived anyway, the situation changes, but it's not like one person can do anything if the other chooses to get sterilised/vasectomy or refuse sex without condoms. It's all very well having an abstract discussion about the right to reproduce with someone else, but reality is going to bite quite hard if they don't wish to cooperate.

It’s not the “right to produce” with a specific individual. You misunderstand me. My point is he can’t expect her to remain in the relationship, if she wants a baby and he doesn’t . That’s just as much of an “ultimatum” and just as “coercive” as her demanding he has a baby or she will leave. They are precisely the mirror situations of each other. Yet when these topics come up, women are told that their needs and feelings don’t matter, that DH’s wishes take priority and if she leaves because she is so deeply unhappy, then she is the one responsible for breaking up the family. It’s totally twisted and hypocritical.

Tandora · 16/02/2023 09:35

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 20:18

@Tandora what would you say if it was the woman who didn’t want another but the man did? What do you think should happen in that scenario?

Actually I don’t think the experience of men and women can be remotely compared in relation to reproduction.

However there was a female poster recently in that situation you have posed and everyone was posting telling her she was BU, she should stop leading him on and leave the relationship 💁🏼‍♀️

queenspark12 · 16/02/2023 07:29

Smineusername · 14/02/2023 15:25

I totally disagree with everyone here he should give you your second child and suck it up. I would not accept this

Bullshit on stilts.

No one is entitled to, or owed, a baby. A baby, however, is entitled to be wanted and cherished by both parents!

JorisBonson · 16/02/2023 06:14

I can't believe the word compromise is being used when talking about a human life. This should be wanted by both parties.

T1Dmama · 16/02/2023 00:26

It’s incredibly difficult when you want more children and for any reason can’t.
My husband had fertility issues and we were incredibly lucky to have our daughter. He decided he didn’t want to try IVF, so we stayed at 1 child… I’m in my 40’s now, we’ve recently split & part of me does wish I hadn’t allowed him to stop me trying for a 2nd…. However my daughter and I couldn’t be closer… and it’s too late now to have another anyway….
I think marrying a man so much older who already had 3 children meant that for him at least 1 more with you was probably always his limit..
Talk to him, tell him you’d always hoped for another so your son had a sibling. Ultimately though if he’s almost 50 I don’t really blame him… no one wants teenagers at 65

abilouhardy · 16/02/2023 00:03

I also think here there is an assumption amongst those who are saying OP IS BU that those who say she isn’t are also inferring DH should shut up and put up. I personally have at no stage said he should be forced to father a child against his will for her sake - not a bit of it. I opine that her need is real and she needs to sort this out with DH. If after having a proper grown up chat together he feels the same and she does too, they may need to go their separate ways to avoid a marriage where one spouse spends the rest of it feeling slightly bitter; for a child to grow up in that would be terrible, agreed - so I think a child growing up unwanted by one partner would be awful and no should not happen, but for the child they already have to grow up in an environment where the relationship has become embittered or passively acrimonious is also very damaging. I do not advocate that OP has a child with her hubby whether he likes it or not - I advocate better communication and total honesty followed by doing what is most important - following through with what turn out to be the actual priorities. That might be separating because OP really needs that baby, or it might be clearing the air and settling happily with their one.

those are my thoughts, but I think it is important for OP to be validated, and also, from what I gather of this unique situation, to point out that it sounds a little as if DH has been abrupt in his delivery of a verdict and isn’t making the effort to be understanding and supportive of OP, even if he doesn’t want to change his mind.

this is about the relationship - and whether OP stays or goes. Shutting up, appreciating his position, shutting down her own desires and carrying on in the marriage regardless is a recipe for every person in the family to end up damaged by it all.

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 23:48

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/02/2023 21:15

A lot of women just see men as walking sperm providers, honestly.

It’s not “more nuanced” and “totally different” when the sexes are reversed. Y’all just think that what a woman says about babies goes, and men have to fall in line.

It’s sick.

I did not imply men “have to fall in line” at all. My point is it is not a comparable discussion. If a bloke came on here wanting kids and his missis didn’t, he’d be in a tough situation and I hope he would be shown understanding and support same as OP is looking for. It is not a case of “it is different for men and therefore I am a man hater/men are spent donors”. If you look at my first response to OP I made the point that I reckon the relationship is the main thing here - that they need to listen empathically to each other - they are married. Who knows, after having a real heart to heart maybe OP would change her mind, feeling better for that intimacy and honesty. Right now she wants something badly and feels she hasn’t been fairly heard or understood. This is a relationship issue and the onus lies with both parties to be adults who love each other and can talk honestly.

mustgetoffmn · 15/02/2023 23:12

I can only give a response on my personal situation. My ex also had a child previously. I had our child in my late 30s feel I should have been more savvy about limitations age wise. Lost 3 subsequent pregnancies due to leaving it too late. My ex compliant but not so bothered. I’m sad all the time that my child didn’t get the experience of growing up with a sibling. It affected our relationship and we eventually split largely because we went through a lot of grief. For your marriage his previous children affect his position but that’s not you and partner together family. I would insist on your position because it affects the child you have together. For the partner yes they feel enough but we have these feelings of overwhelm with a baby but the future for you and immediate family is an important new family. If you cave in to partners feelings you will lose the chance for your new family. Together with your partner and child. That’s the now and the future.

SweetStrawberry · 15/02/2023 22:08

Urgh it's not selfish to change your mind about wanting another child, it's more selfish to bring a child into this world knowing that the other parent doesn't want them surely?

Whatever, I hope you make the correct decision for you OP but honestly, don't try and pressure someone who doesn't want a potential child into having them. Leave if you feel this is a deal breaker, stay if you think you can eventually move past it. It's shit for you but something you probably could of seen coming if you hadn't discussed a number, knew your partner was in his mid to late 40s even with the first one and who already had 3 older children. Sorry to be blunt but it wasn't outside the realm of possibility.

Watermonkey13 · 15/02/2023 21:58

I don't think you are being unreasonable. I can see his side with now having 4 chn and being older. You still have time. I feel like men always do this to women and just expect them to be fine with it as if what they say is what goes and that's it. I think he is being really selfish. Just weigh up what you value most in life, the family unit you have currently or having more children. If you would rather split and have more children you have the right to do so although there's no guarantee you will have more unless you go for a sperm donor situation. Good luck ❤

aSofaNearYou · 15/02/2023 21:52

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/02/2023 21:40

@aSofaNearYou Err no, not if her wanting more than one is going to lead to splitting up the family. Then the children should be the first priority, not mum’s desire to have more kids.

That wasn't my point. My point is she isn't a mum of four, she's a mum of one.

A mum of four wanting another is very different to a mum of one wanting more.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 15/02/2023 21:52

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 21:30

I don’t think men and women are the same when it comes to bearing children, but the argument is valid. Once the child is born, both would be equal parents.

And that is not something you can force on a person. Women are not more entitled in this scenario. Women don’t get the casting vote just because they bear the pregnancy. And I am the last person to holler about ‘men’s rights’ 🤢

If one person doesn’t want a child that is it. End of discussion. If that is a deal breaker, the other parents is free to do as they see fit.

I think some posters are looking at this through their own experiences and feelings and it’s clouding their judgement of it.

This is not about one parent preventing the other from having a child, it’s about one parent not being entitled to force the other to have a child.

Exactly.

The physical differences and how they relate to the issue of consent would be relevant if OP were already pregnant and they disagreed over whether to continue with the pregnancy or not. They just don't affect the issue of consent or right of either partner to refuse to have another child before then.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/02/2023 21:40

@aSofaNearYou Err no, not if her wanting more than one is going to lead to splitting up the family. Then the children should be the first priority, not mum’s desire to have more kids.

aSofaNearYou · 15/02/2023 21:38

Badsox · 15/02/2023 20:29

You already have four children OP, You are step mother to his older three. It does not feel as if they are particularly valued in this scenario. Personally, I would focus positively on what you have and enjoy them rather than choosing to make them all victims of a divorce.

No she does not, let's not start that nonsense. She should be considered like any other mother of one who wanted more than one.

SweetStrawberry · 15/02/2023 21:34

People who are suggesting the OPs partner should have another child for her really need to give their heads a wobble. No child should be brought into this situation where one parent is unwilling. Why would anyone choose to do that to a child?

ItchyBillco · 15/02/2023 21:30

abilouhardy · 15/02/2023 20:40

Arg! Here we go. The make versus female experience here really is different! Yes, that scenario would also be a head scratcher worth a thread BUT 1) totally hypothetical and 2) really unhelpful! Because it is NOT comparable. Men and women ARE different and carrying a baby as a woman is totally different to fathering a child. Yes both valid situations but also not at all comparable. Don’t even go there. These days we have to pretend like men and women are totally equivalent blah blah blah bollox.

I don’t think men and women are the same when it comes to bearing children, but the argument is valid. Once the child is born, both would be equal parents.

And that is not something you can force on a person. Women are not more entitled in this scenario. Women don’t get the casting vote just because they bear the pregnancy. And I am the last person to holler about ‘men’s rights’ 🤢

If one person doesn’t want a child that is it. End of discussion. If that is a deal breaker, the other parents is free to do as they see fit.

I think some posters are looking at this through their own experiences and feelings and it’s clouding their judgement of it.

This is not about one parent preventing the other from having a child, it’s about one parent not being entitled to force the other to have a child.