Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband changed his mind about baby. AIBU

338 replies

Wantanotherandanother · 14/02/2023 12:05

Name changed for this. Need a fresh perspective on this problem please but be kind...

I'm 35 and husband is 48. Always planned to have kids, number not discussed but hoped we'd have at least two (more if I was lucky!). Had our first and at 6 months pp I was broody! Waited and waited and he didn't mention anything so recently brought it up given neither of us have time on our side and our 'baby' is nearly 2. He said he now feels he doesn't actually want any more and he's very much done. I feel a bit short changed and although so, so grateful to already have one, I always hoped to have more and he knew that. I feel like he went into this knowing he'd always refuse any more. His reasons are related to his age and that he just feels physically done with having young children around. Financially we'd be ok.

He has 3 teens to his ex and so obviously has had his fair share of nappies and sleepless nights.

AIBU? Can a marriage even survive this difference in opinion about something so huge? Neither of us wish to compromise. I feel so sad every time I see a pregnant lady or baby and don't think that ache will ever go away.

OP posts:
Canthave2manycats · 16/02/2023 17:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Canthave2manycats · 16/02/2023 17:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Andthatstheend · 16/02/2023 16:59

Neither of you unreasonable in wanting/not wanting more children, but I think YABU to not have foreseen this might happen when he already has 3 other children.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 16/02/2023 16:51

The problem with this issue is that neither @Wantanotherandanother or her dh is wrong - both of them have entirely valid feelings on the matter - but sadly there is no answer that will make both of them feel their feelings and choice in the matter have been respected. I can’t see any sensible compromise that would satisfy both parties.

Tandora · 16/02/2023 16:49

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 12:10

He has two choices. One of them is to have a baby he doesn’t want. That would be coercion and terrible for the child, which deserves to be wanted by both parties. The other is to not have a baby and face the consequences. If those consequences are that SHE leaves, it is not his fault that the family is being broken up. The only way he could’ve stopped it was by having a baby he doesn’t want, which he should never he expected to do because that is coercion. Not having an unwanted baby is a selfless act for that baby. Blaming him for not doing it to save the family is coercion.

She also has two choices. One of them is to accept the children she has, with therapy if needed. That would be good for her mental well-being and for the existing children. The other is to leave and have a baby with someone else. That would be terrible for the existing children. If SHE leaves, then she is doing so to fulfil her own wants, and prioritising herself over the kids. It is her fault that the family is being broken up. She could’ve stopped it by helping herself to accept her lot and prioritising the needs of the children. Leaving to have more kids is a selfish act based on what she wants, not what’s best for the children.

Their choices are NOT the same, and that’s why the blame is NOT equal.

This really isn’t rocket science. And I’m an ardent fucking feminist.

One of her choices is not to have a baby she desperately does want. That’s coercion. It’s terrible for the potential child and he’s not even giving then a chance at life!

see how ridiculous that sounds?

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 16:46

Who said I think that’s a ‘valid’ reason? That said, romantic attraction and love are, in current times, considered to be the foundation of a healthy marriage and generally good things to demonstrate to children. Leaving because you want more children and that desire is more important to you than the needs of the one you already have is a different matter.

I don't think any one person thinks it's a valid reason, there are always at least a couple of people who say it's selfish to leave your marriage regardless of whether you're unhappy. I just think that generally when people are unhappy and can't stop feeling that way, the majority do support them leaving. For some reason, here, people are generally dismissing the cause of her unhappiness as if it's no big deal and she should just let it go.

The two examples I gave were just random, really, but I don't think it's only ever reasons that are beneficial to the kids that cause people to leave and be supported in leaving.

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 16:37

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 16:29

That’s not why OP is wanting to leave though, is it? She’s not wanting to leave because he’s unfairly burdening her, or treating her like a servant unworthy of respect, she’s wanting to leave a relationship she’s otherwise happy in because her desire for another child is apparently the most important consideration.

And what about the no longer fancying him scenario? People leave relationships for many reasons, and not all of them are because the other person is mistreating them. Sometimes, it's just because they're unhappy. Why is this an invalid reason to be unhappy, whilst others are valid?

Who said I think that’s a ‘valid’ reason? That said, romantic attraction and love are, in current times, considered to be the foundation of a healthy marriage and generally good things to demonstrate to children. Leaving because you want more children and that desire is more important to you than the needs of the one you already have is a different matter.

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 16:29

That’s not why OP is wanting to leave though, is it? She’s not wanting to leave because he’s unfairly burdening her, or treating her like a servant unworthy of respect, she’s wanting to leave a relationship she’s otherwise happy in because her desire for another child is apparently the most important consideration.

And what about the no longer fancying him scenario? People leave relationships for many reasons, and not all of them are because the other person is mistreating them. Sometimes, it's just because they're unhappy. Why is this an invalid reason to be unhappy, whilst others are valid?

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 16:22

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 16:13

*It’s not emotional blackmail though, but even if it was, it’s true. She’s prioritising having another child over the stability of the child and family she already has, to the point of breaking up said family. Conversely he wants to maintain the status quo, which is significantly less disruptive.

Is her happiness solely dependent on having another child? If it is, why does this mean it’s something that should be prioritised above everything else, at the expense of the happiness of the child she does have?*

And if she was unhappy because he didn't pull his weight? Or she just didn't fancy him anymore? Would these be reasonable reasons to leave. Generally an adult leaving their non-abusive partners will be putting their wants (whether that's for someone that shares the housework and childcare more, for sexual attraction, for another child...) above the stability for their children. Yet they're not generally told they're shitty people for choosing to leave. This shouldn't be different.

That’s not why OP is wanting to leave though, is it? She’s not wanting to leave because he’s unfairly burdening her, or treating her like a servant unworthy of respect, she’s wanting to leave a relationship she’s otherwise happy in because her desire for another child is apparently the most important consideration.

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 16:13

*It’s not emotional blackmail though, but even if it was, it’s true. She’s prioritising having another child over the stability of the child and family she already has, to the point of breaking up said family. Conversely he wants to maintain the status quo, which is significantly less disruptive.

Is her happiness solely dependent on having another child? If it is, why does this mean it’s something that should be prioritised above everything else, at the expense of the happiness of the child she does have?*

And if she was unhappy because he didn't pull his weight? Or she just didn't fancy him anymore? Would these be reasonable reasons to leave. Generally an adult leaving their non-abusive partners will be putting their wants (whether that's for someone that shares the housework and childcare more, for sexual attraction, for another child...) above the stability for their children. Yet they're not generally told they're shitty people for choosing to leave. This shouldn't be different.

sally16 · 16/02/2023 16:10

Commented before realising OP has deserted this..
either unhappy with the result, or another newspaper bait post 🫠🙃

sally16 · 16/02/2023 16:07

He is maybe thinking of what age he will be when another is his teens age..
we always said 45 was my partners cut off.. because he didn't want his children potentially being young carers for him which I understand.. I didn't really want that for them either 😅 we have a ten year age gap so I've always been realistic of what we've wanted vs what's realistic.. we're stopping at 2 instead of 3..
he also maybe doesn't want a toddler as he turns 50..

Just as if this was your decision not to have another and he was upset.. he would be expected to respect your decision also

It's a shitty situation to be sitting in either way though x

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 16:04

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 15:53

In my opinion it is emotional blackmail to tell her she's a shitty person splitting up a happy family, if this situation means she is unhappy. It's not something that would be done in other situations where one person in the relationship is unhappy.

Yes if is though, all the time on here. When men, and women, put their wants before those of their children they’re routinely called out for being selfish.

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 16:01

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 14:31

I find it odd that so many people are calling out that it would be emotional blackmail to tell him he has to have a child to save his marriage, yet are in the same breath emotionally blackmailing OP into thinking she must not have another child to save her marriage. Otherwise she's a shitty person breaking up a family who are all perfectly happy (except her but she just needs to get over it).

That's emotional blackmail too. I'm surprised people don't see it and are still doing it.

It’s not emotional blackmail though, but even if it was, it’s true. She’s prioritising having another child over the stability of the child and family she already has, to the point of breaking up said family. Conversely he wants to maintain the status quo, which is significantly less disruptive.

Is her happiness solely dependent on having another child? If it is, why does this mean it’s something that should be prioritised above everything else, at the expense of the happiness of the child she does have?

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 15:53

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 15:28

@aSofaNearYou It’s not emotional blackmail to say that she has to not have another child to save her marriage. It’s a statement of fact. She literally cannot have another child in this marriage. She can have one outside of it but that would break it up. It comes down to marriage or another baby for her, end of.

People are suggesting that she work on accepting the reality of the position (not just “get over it” - therapy might help) because it will help with her well-being to do so, and yes, because it’s in the best interests of the child she already has.

I guess the alternative is for everyone to say “you go girl, split up that family to get your extra babies” but that’s, erm, not a position I’d support even remotely.

In my opinion it is emotional blackmail to tell her she's a shitty person splitting up a happy family, if this situation means she is unhappy. It's not something that would be done in other situations where one person in the relationship is unhappy.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 15:28

@aSofaNearYou It’s not emotional blackmail to say that she has to not have another child to save her marriage. It’s a statement of fact. She literally cannot have another child in this marriage. She can have one outside of it but that would break it up. It comes down to marriage or another baby for her, end of.

People are suggesting that she work on accepting the reality of the position (not just “get over it” - therapy might help) because it will help with her well-being to do so, and yes, because it’s in the best interests of the child she already has.

I guess the alternative is for everyone to say “you go girl, split up that family to get your extra babies” but that’s, erm, not a position I’d support even remotely.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 16/02/2023 14:56

To be honest, even if they did discuss numbers, and he agreed to a second child, @Wantanotherandanother‘s dh is still entitled to change his mind, once the tiring reality of having a baby and three teenagers, at the age of 48 had come home to him.

SleeplessInEngland · 16/02/2023 14:34

The OP seems to have fucked off so I guess this will fall on deaf ears but if you never discussed the numbers beforehand then I think YABU. He has every right to refuse. Your choice to leave him of course but I think it'd be quite a bad reason unless you envisage starting all over again with someone else or getting a sperm donor.

aSofaNearYou · 16/02/2023 14:31

I find it odd that so many people are calling out that it would be emotional blackmail to tell him he has to have a child to save his marriage, yet are in the same breath emotionally blackmailing OP into thinking she must not have another child to save her marriage. Otherwise she's a shitty person breaking up a family who are all perfectly happy (except her but she just needs to get over it).

That's emotional blackmail too. I'm surprised people don't see it and are still doing it.

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 14:28

mustgetoffmn · 15/02/2023 23:12

I can only give a response on my personal situation. My ex also had a child previously. I had our child in my late 30s feel I should have been more savvy about limitations age wise. Lost 3 subsequent pregnancies due to leaving it too late. My ex compliant but not so bothered. I’m sad all the time that my child didn’t get the experience of growing up with a sibling. It affected our relationship and we eventually split largely because we went through a lot of grief. For your marriage his previous children affect his position but that’s not you and partner together family. I would insist on your position because it affects the child you have together. For the partner yes they feel enough but we have these feelings of overwhelm with a baby but the future for you and immediate family is an important new family. If you cave in to partners feelings you will lose the chance for your new family. Together with your partner and child. That’s the now and the future.

His existing children are not merely his past, and nor are they outside of his current nuclear family. They are also his present and future.

He is quite reasonable to not want further children, and he would also be quite reasonable if he didn’t have other children. He isn’t obliged to have children he doesn’t want, he’s not denying OP something he owes her. Her ‘feelings that overwhelm’ are not something so important that have to be prioritised at all costs, they’re something she’s going to have to deal with for herself. She isn’t entitled to have them indulged at the expense of everyone around her.

whumpthereitis · 16/02/2023 14:20

Tandora · 16/02/2023 11:49

No no no no. She is not “choosing” to break up the family any more than he is. They are both equally responsible. They both have needs and they both have choices. It’s totally unjust to make his needs the “default”, so that if she insists on her needs it’s “coercion” , but if he insists on his, it’s just the way things are and she should just “be satisfied with what she has”. I honestly can’t understand the hypocrisy/ double standards here.

Yes, she would be choosing to break up the family, whereas he’s choosing to maintain the status quo. Not cowing to emotional blackmail and the threat of divorce is not the same thing as actively choosing to break up a family.

She is not owed more children by him, and putting her desire (not ‘need’) for more children over the well-being of the child she already has is a shitty thing to do.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 13:47

It’s completely ridiculous @ItchyBillco - I’m assuming wilful refusal to understand or like you said, skin in the game. I think a young child could understand why it’s not the same.

ItchyBillco · 16/02/2023 13:33

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 12:10

He has two choices. One of them is to have a baby he doesn’t want. That would be coercion and terrible for the child, which deserves to be wanted by both parties. The other is to not have a baby and face the consequences. If those consequences are that SHE leaves, it is not his fault that the family is being broken up. The only way he could’ve stopped it was by having a baby he doesn’t want, which he should never he expected to do because that is coercion. Not having an unwanted baby is a selfless act for that baby. Blaming him for not doing it to save the family is coercion.

She also has two choices. One of them is to accept the children she has, with therapy if needed. That would be good for her mental well-being and for the existing children. The other is to leave and have a baby with someone else. That would be terrible for the existing children. If SHE leaves, then she is doing so to fulfil her own wants, and prioritising herself over the kids. It is her fault that the family is being broken up. She could’ve stopped it by helping herself to accept her lot and prioritising the needs of the children. Leaving to have more kids is a selfish act based on what she wants, not what’s best for the children.

Their choices are NOT the same, and that’s why the blame is NOT equal.

This really isn’t rocket science. And I’m an ardent fucking feminist.

I honestly don’t know what is wrong with that poster, that they cannot see the difference. It beggars belief.

I can only assume they’ve some skin in the game via personal experiences.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 16/02/2023 13:06

@Steppered - your post is eloquent and wise. Sadly I don’t think that @Wantanotherandanother is coming back to the thread, to read what you wrote.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 16/02/2023 12:10

Tandora · 16/02/2023 11:49

No no no no. She is not “choosing” to break up the family any more than he is. They are both equally responsible. They both have needs and they both have choices. It’s totally unjust to make his needs the “default”, so that if she insists on her needs it’s “coercion” , but if he insists on his, it’s just the way things are and she should just “be satisfied with what she has”. I honestly can’t understand the hypocrisy/ double standards here.

He has two choices. One of them is to have a baby he doesn’t want. That would be coercion and terrible for the child, which deserves to be wanted by both parties. The other is to not have a baby and face the consequences. If those consequences are that SHE leaves, it is not his fault that the family is being broken up. The only way he could’ve stopped it was by having a baby he doesn’t want, which he should never he expected to do because that is coercion. Not having an unwanted baby is a selfless act for that baby. Blaming him for not doing it to save the family is coercion.

She also has two choices. One of them is to accept the children she has, with therapy if needed. That would be good for her mental well-being and for the existing children. The other is to leave and have a baby with someone else. That would be terrible for the existing children. If SHE leaves, then she is doing so to fulfil her own wants, and prioritising herself over the kids. It is her fault that the family is being broken up. She could’ve stopped it by helping herself to accept her lot and prioritising the needs of the children. Leaving to have more kids is a selfish act based on what she wants, not what’s best for the children.

Their choices are NOT the same, and that’s why the blame is NOT equal.

This really isn’t rocket science. And I’m an ardent fucking feminist.