Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents who let their kids 'play out' are just completely abdicating responsibility for their kids' behaviour?

571 replies

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/02/2023 09:05

We have a little walled playground near our house - little climbing frame, slide, stepping stones, toddler swing, very clearly aimed at a young primary/pre-school audience.

It's currently being completely taken over by a huge group of 10-12 preteen/early teen boys playing very rough games of football with real leather footballs. The bang the balls off the walls and hoof them in the air so they go careering everywhere at speed, they run around roughly after the ball pushing and shoving each other and getting in other people's personal space, they fight and shout aggressively and swear. Not a parent in sight of course so no-one to appeal to to get them to moderate their behaviour/find a more suitable venue (like say the massive park 5 minutes walk away). I've had a word now and again but generally just get mutinous stares and/or backchat. I can't really take my kids (2 and 6) there to play any more as it isn't safe for them and the atmosphere is so aggressive.

Why do people just turn their kids out of doors with no idea where they're going/what they're doing? It makes it impossible for other parents - either they have to tell your kid off for you (immediately in the wrong) or they simply have to either put up with inappropriate, loutish behaviour or give way to it and leave.

OP posts:
TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:26

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 14/02/2023 12:25

Thank you! I was concerned I’d be viewed as a Cher Lloyd super fan by those who don’t get the reference!

DISGUSTING!!!! Grin Grin

GrohlOnAPole · 14/02/2023 12:25

I think you’re making a lot of assumptions about what you think their parents aren’t doing. But all negative assumptions.

I would more likely think the parents do ask where they’re going, what they’re doing and who with…. they just don’t know that it’s causing issues.

I can fully imagine a boy saying “I’m going to the little park for a kick about with so-and-so”. Then coming home and saying “it was quiet down there, just a couple of little kids with their mum”. Hence parents think it’s all ok. I think there’s a difference between being unaware and not caring.

my kids are 3 and 7, and I’ll be very direct to older kids in the park “come on, that’s far too rough around the little ones, calm it down” or if they swore at me I’d be asking for their parents details. But I’d never expect kids that age to be supervised at the park by parents!

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 14/02/2023 12:25

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:21

😂😂

CherLloyd you are becoming my favourite poster and not just because of your awesome username Grin

Thank you! I was concerned I’d be viewed as a Cher Lloyd super fan by those who don’t get the reference!

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 14/02/2023 12:23

Also, as a high school teacher, allowing kids in this age group to develop independence is really important. Supervision levels at high school when not in class is basically non existent. They will be allowed to leave school premises at lunchtime, alone. They will likely walk to and from school, alone. You can’t go from supervising them at the park to giving them complete independence to do these things. That’s ridiculous. Even my 7 year old now wants a bit independence - eg to go into a small shop alone to buy a sweet while I wait outside, or not to have me hovering over her in the park.

Viviennemary · 14/02/2023 12:22

It's a park. Childrdn play in parks.,You could approach your local counvil and ask them to put up a sign no ball games. Dont know if a sign woukl be very effective though. I doubt they will be playing with leather balls.,

Nanny0gg · 14/02/2023 12:22

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/02/2023 09:10

All the time but I was a quiet and solitary type - just used to walk up and down the beach singing to myself and making up stories most of the time :P So unlikely to bother anyone bar the odd seagull. My parents had nothing to worry about.

If I knew my boisterous lad was off out to play football with his boisterous friends, I might check where they were planning to do it and remind them to be considerate of others.

Yep. That'll work...

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:21

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 14/02/2023 12:17

Because her teenage girls will be skipping along an isolated beach singing in their teenage years, a la “Sound of Music” whereas these mobbish, hooligan boys are … playing team games requiring cooperation, tactics, and communication. While exercising.

The way children play varies as they get older. Boys in that age category - although physically large - are a few years behind girls in terms of maturity. They’ll catch up soon.

😂😂

CherLloyd you are becoming my favourite poster and not just because of your awesome username Grin

WiIson · 14/02/2023 12:20

because a woman nearby sees boys as inferior and is OTT about her precious Princess being near a football?

It would seem so.

OoooohMatron · 14/02/2023 12:20

You think older kids should still be escorted to the park by their mummies? Seriously.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:19

fridaytwattery · 14/02/2023 12:16

@TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl
"I just don’t believe these boys, who are being ‘rough’ and ‘flying about’ and being fast are playing football within the confines of a tiny space between play equipment. If they were they wouldn’t be rough and flying about.

What I suspect is that they ARE playing next to the little park, and the ball rolls by the OP’s toddler occasionally.

Nonone should be playing football in a muddy clearing, it’s dangerous and filthy and probably full of dog shit"

So you don't believe the OP then?

Read the OPs first post again. They describe "a little walled playground near our house - little climbing frame, slide, stepping stones, toddler swing, very clearly aimed at a young primary/pre-school audience.

It's currently being completely taken over by a huge group of 10-12 preteen/early teen boys playing very rough games of football with real leather footballs. The bang the balls off the walls and hoof them in the air so they go careering everywhere at speed, they run around roughly after the ball pushing and shoving each other and getting in other people's personal space, they fight and shout aggressively and swear. "

I'm choosing to take the OP at their word, about their experience. If it's as they describe in their first post, then that is wholly unacceptable behaviour when OP is present with their children wanting to use the facilities as they were intended to be used.

To defend it comes across as "what is my pre-teen supposed to do?"
If there are no facilities for that age group or they don't feel safe going to the larger park, that is something to take up with the council. It's not ok to lump the problem of no space for pre teens on pre schoolers and their parents.

No I don’t believe the OP. Who has also said there’s a free space behind some benches BTW. She’s changed her story quite a bit on this thread so it’s fair to believe she’s not being wholly truthful about the park set up.

Most park have a large free space. This one obviously does. It just isn’t far away enough for the OP and she sees it as a toddler space

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 14/02/2023 12:18

BethDuttonsTwin · 14/02/2023 09:18

I agree with you but MNetters love pontificating about the need to learn “independence” and “responsibility” while conveniently ignoring that their darlings are making other people’s lives difficult while they supposedly learn these skills and said MNetters pat themselves on the back for not being like those foolish “helicopter” parents who don’t allow their kids out to piss about aimlessly annoying others.

Surely there are more than just the two options - helicopter parenting or letting kids learn independence whilst pissing about aimlessly annoying others, though, @BethDuttonsTwin?

You can teach your child good behaviour and respect, and let them know that increasing independence comes with increased responsibilities, and that poor behaviour will lead to loss of that new independence. I didn't follow my boys around everywhere once they were teenagers, but dh and I had taught them our standards, and they knew that we wouldn't turn a blind eye to bad behaviour if it was reported back to us - and it would lead to consequences, of course. And despite us living in a fairly small village, where people tend to know each other, we were never told our boys were behaving unacceptably.

anya21 · 14/02/2023 12:18

Is it a council run playground? I think you should make them aware.There is usually a sign saying no ball games?

CherLloydbyCherLloyd · 14/02/2023 12:17

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 11:59

Why do you think it will be so different from parenting teenage girls?

As a mother of both, I am FAR less worried about DS being a teen than I am DD.

Because her teenage girls will be skipping along an isolated beach singing in their teenage years, a la “Sound of Music” whereas these mobbish, hooligan boys are … playing team games requiring cooperation, tactics, and communication. While exercising.

The way children play varies as they get older. Boys in that age category - although physically large - are a few years behind girls in terms of maturity. They’ll catch up soon.

madeyemoody · 14/02/2023 12:17

Pre teens fill a little kids play area that's always empty anyways. They litter, shout, throw stuff around and generally try and intimidate you as you walk around the field. But to be honest, it's expected and kind of concentrated in that one spot...so it doesn't bother me that much, I know two of the kids parents and have told them they kids are acting like dickheads and they have thanked me and been embarrassed. Don't know what else parents are supposed to do. They are told to get out off their screens and then they dick about but kids at that age are particularly vile.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:17

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 14/02/2023 12:14

@TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl

Deep sigh.

If they are getting in people's personal space they are therefore too close and intimidating.

OP feels she can't go there because of their behaviour despite it being a walled area containing play equipment aimed at the age her children are. Why should she and her children miss out because boys of a certain age who behave aggressively haven't got a clue?

A group of children accidentally kicking a ball the wrong way sometimes shouldn’t be intimidating. If OP finds it intimidating that’s clearly (and it really IS clear from her posts on this thread) her anxieties - and THATS why her kids are missing out. Why should a group of boys having fun and meaning no harm (and causing no distress unless a football triggers you) have to stop their play because a woman nearby sees boys as inferior and is OTT about her precious Princess being near a football?

fridaytwattery · 14/02/2023 12:16

@TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl
"I just don’t believe these boys, who are being ‘rough’ and ‘flying about’ and being fast are playing football within the confines of a tiny space between play equipment. If they were they wouldn’t be rough and flying about.

What I suspect is that they ARE playing next to the little park, and the ball rolls by the OP’s toddler occasionally.

Nonone should be playing football in a muddy clearing, it’s dangerous and filthy and probably full of dog shit"

So you don't believe the OP then?

Read the OPs first post again. They describe "a little walled playground near our house - little climbing frame, slide, stepping stones, toddler swing, very clearly aimed at a young primary/pre-school audience.

It's currently being completely taken over by a huge group of 10-12 preteen/early teen boys playing very rough games of football with real leather footballs. The bang the balls off the walls and hoof them in the air so they go careering everywhere at speed, they run around roughly after the ball pushing and shoving each other and getting in other people's personal space, they fight and shout aggressively and swear. "

I'm choosing to take the OP at their word, about their experience. If it's as they describe in their first post, then that is wholly unacceptable behaviour when OP is present with their children wanting to use the facilities as they were intended to be used.

To defend it comes across as "what is my pre-teen supposed to do?"
If there are no facilities for that age group or they don't feel safe going to the larger park, that is something to take up with the council. It's not ok to lump the problem of no space for pre teens on pre schoolers and their parents.

tattygrl · 14/02/2023 12:15

RedToothBrush · 14/02/2023 12:10

It's age appropriate and part of kids learning independence.

The idea that kids shouldn't play in public and should be supervised at all times is bloody nuts.

What are you proposing? Locking them indoors until their 18th birthday

The issue is with anti-social behaviour. That doesn't really sound like what you describe though. You describe teenagers who are fairly normal. And if they are playing footy they aren't up to shit. A certain amount of 'fighting' I'd question as to whether it's just normal teenage boy behaviour rather than going further to a point where it's problematic.

You've got a bad case of nimbyism going on there. You might want to get it checked out before it gets worse.

This! It's like people want to be able to pretend others don't exist in the world, and have every right to use it and make noise as anyone else. Like when people protest there being crying babies in public.

Jellycatspyjamas · 14/02/2023 12:15

We have a small park round the corner from the house and another larger park 10/15 minutes walk away. My 9 and 10 year old were allowed to go to the smaller park close by but not the bigger park - could it be these kids have a similar restriction in terms of location and so need to play in the smaller park because they aren’t allowed to go as far as the big park?

Sharing public space is tricky, but it does sound like they’re just playing football. My DD would kick the ball very high etc as part of the game. I don’t sit at the park and watch because at 10 and 11 (now) they need room to grow and develop some degree of independence within parameters (eg how far they are allowed to wander).

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 14/02/2023 12:15

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 10:33

I think all that wandering around the beach singing alone has meant you’ve not much experience in how children play, develop and socialise. Added to the fact you think teenagers should have a parent sat on bench watching them ‘play’ shows how out of touch you are

I agree with this.

Your childhood experience of solitude isn’t normal and I’m wondering why you didn’t hang out with friends like most kids do. I just hope you don’t let it rub off on your kids and they way you treat them.

Yeah I was a weird, dreamy, bookish kid. I had a few friends who were the same as I got into my teens, lots of them at uni when I found my tribe. Of them I selected a weird, dreamy, bookish partner and had two kids. I'd love to imagine they'll grow up to be wildly outgoing, sporty, extroverted women but I fear genetics and early socialisation may be against them! Fortunately there is (theoretically) a principle of tolerance and acceptance for weirdos nowadays, and if they do follow my appalling weird and bookish example they won't be entirely ostracised from society. One can only hope.

OP posts:
MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 14/02/2023 12:14

@TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl

Deep sigh.

If they are getting in people's personal space they are therefore too close and intimidating.

OP feels she can't go there because of their behaviour despite it being a walled area containing play equipment aimed at the age her children are. Why should she and her children miss out because boys of a certain age who behave aggressively haven't got a clue?

WiIson · 14/02/2023 12:14

Well complain to the council for anti social behaviour then. It's hardly the same as boys playing footie in the park, where kids are supposed to be, is it. They can't win really can they. Unless they stay indoors or only go out with adult supervision in case their presence upsets someone 🙄

tattygrl · 14/02/2023 12:13

You're not unreasonable for personally disliking particular behaviour or there being groups of kids around, but you are unreasonable for thinking kids, especially older ones, shouldn't be allowed to play out unsupervised. Honestly, kids can't win. Either they're spoilt, lazy and should be playing out more like "we did in the good old days", or they're viewed as a public nuisance for playing out and making noise (heaven forbid!) without their parents hovering.

Kids making noise is simply part of life. What do you want, a quiet world outside? Not gonna happen. Let kids exist. Hovering parents doesn't do anyone any favours.

Tidsleytiddy · 14/02/2023 12:12

WiIson · 14/02/2023 12:11

Then tell them you'll take it away if they don't stop.

Then they’d just get another one. Honestly this went on for years. It’s stopped now thankfully because they’ve grown up or moved away but it was relentless

WiIson · 14/02/2023 12:12

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:09

And there we have it - OP just hates boys and casts them as ‘bad’.

IME of working in a school, girl and boy bullying and violence is pretty equal. But girls bullying other girls is always so much more nuanced and long lasting.

I agree.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 14/02/2023 12:11

BethFromThisIsUs · 14/02/2023 12:09

Tell you what I really hate though.

Dads and sons (and it’s ALWAYS dads and sons in my experience) who stand at opposite ends of a busy public swimming pool throwing a ball backwards and forwards.

i don’t care if it is an unreasonable gripe. It drives me mad.

I’d just swim in their way anyway 😂

I don’t mind playing in a swimming pool but what grinds my gears is people having a chat at the end of the lanes in lane swimming area! Blocking everyone coming their way. And not even kids, grown adults! I say “Excuse me the coffee shop is outside the changing rooms you can chat there”. My friend just swum into people doing this once and then kicked off them as she would the wall to turn around 🤣