Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local Persons restriction seem a bit racist? Or am I overthinking?

358 replies

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

OP posts:
Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 11:46

To call this racism is very wide of the mark. It is really unfair to imply that these communities are somehow backward and unenlightened because they don't have the ethnic diversity of larger cities. We shouldn't just sneer because they happen to be white and possibly christian. And striving for diversity for diversities sake serves no purpose other than to tick a box.

I agree here. Frankly, there is no way to have census represantation of minorities equally spread into every postcode. It's just not possible.
How would that be done?
We would get to do rock paper scissors with other minority fellows over who get to stay in higher minority populated area and who gets moved to arse end of knowhere with 5 houses and 2m2 corner shop where only spice is black pepper? (Before anyone starts, this is not anti Brotish, these arses with this shop are in every country😁)

"Oi, Mo, there is 6% muslims in UK, but where you live it's actually 11% so we need you to move few hundred miles up to village where it's 1.5% so we can balance the areas. Your wife Anna can't though because because it's 1.3% of Polish in UK and your new village has 3% so we will swap you for some polish lad for her, is that ok?"

Workjobfind · 14/02/2023 11:44

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/02/2023 10:59

So to be clear, what you are all saying is that we can only live and work in the community we were born into? That's madness! My children's prospects in life will be limited to a 50 mile radius of where we live now? Nobody 'owns' Cornwall or any part of the country FFS. Twas ever thus. You live where you can afford to live. You don't artificially deflate house prices for the 'locals'.

No one's saying that. If you have a job offer in an area you should be able to access affordable housing no? Restrictions such as local connection offers ensures essential workers can move into an area

beAsensible1 · 14/02/2023 11:40

Lockheart · 14/02/2023 11:05

I would also dispute that tourism is what these areas "need".

What they need is a year-round community where their shops don't shut in the winter and which don't just cater to tourists, selling overpriced clothes and ice-cream. They need doctors and dentists and schools and vets. Those can't survive in an area without a permanent resident base. They need to be able to move about and transport goods and produce without being restricted by huge crowds of tourists between April and September. They need decent community hubs like pubs and bars which are open all year round. They need long term accomodation which means they can work and contribute to the local economy.

Mass tourism is a scourge. A drug which you get reliant on but which destroys you.

Any popular destination in the global south is a testament to this. absolute scourge on economic growth all reliant on outside money and whims.

Stops the development of any useful local infrastructures

Lockheart · 14/02/2023 11:38

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:34

Stamp duty is different if you own more than one property.

Stamp duty is not a formal election and says nothing about which property your primary residence will be or the purpose for which you are buying the additional property.

The only declaration you would make to HMRC about a principal residence would be in the context of PPR relief, which must be made within two years of the date when the combination of properties you own changes. For practical purposes, this will usually be up to two years after you buy a second property.

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 11:36

Apparently the absolute worst thing you can be on MN is middle class. Christ, the spitting venom.

There's nothing wrong with being middle class. There is something a bit wrong with being middle class and advocating for policies that will make people poorer than you worse off purely so you can get in a bit of virtue signalling.

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 11:35

Xol · 14/02/2023 08:57

The thing is that, no matter how worthy the motivation might be, if in fact this rule does favour an ethnic minority - which seems likely - it may well be found to be racist if challenged. That's particularly the case if they could achieve the same thing by having a primary home restriction.

You are allowed to discriminate in certain circumstances. Such as, for example, discriminating against children when it comes to religious schools.

It might be that this requirement could be indirectly racist but if there is enough justification, it will be accepted.

You could say the same about a Welsh language requirement for jobs in Wales, but it can be got around by learning Welsh.

The requirement is not just to stop second home ownership, it's to stop non-locals buying up housing stock at the expense of locals.

Jersey has had a requirement like this for decades, and it's much more draconian.

Everanewbie · 14/02/2023 11:35

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 11:16

Because everyone who lives on Dartmoor now is white. Except for 28 (!!) people .

As it happens of the 2373 people living on Dartmoor, 2300 are white, 12 Asian, 16 Black. (from an earlier post in the thread)

To call this racism is very wide of the mark. It is really unfair to imply that these communities are somehow backward and unenlightened because they don't have the ethnic diversity of larger cities. We shouldn't just sneer because they happen to be white and possibly christian. And striving for diversity for diversities sake serves no purpose other than to tick a box.

At first glance it does look a bit like a 'local houses for local people' insular thing. But people forget that these areas are not Disney World. They're not on this earth for peoples amusement and entertainment. People have real lives and need to work, educate their children, procure food and so on. If certain places are beautiful, people may like to visit, and industries grow up around that, but sometimes that needs to be tempered slightly to keep 'real life' thriving.

Ideally, we should avoid interventions in the open market, but in this case, I think a proportion of properties having selling restrictions is sensible. I would like to see a limit/waiting list for holiday lets and second homes too where there are particular problems.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 11:34

pansiesinmygarden · 14/02/2023 11:13

What does going to Dartmoor have to do with social mobility. The OP allegedly lives in London!

The OP states in the OP that they qualify under the five year rule. ie she already lives locally.

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:34

Lockheart · 14/02/2023 11:32

No you don't. You can make a nomination to HMRC up to two years after you acquire / sell properties / move house regarding a primary residence, and it only impacts you for capital gains tax and PPR relief should you sell one property.

Stamp duty is different if you own more than one property.

Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 11:34

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:23

Yes, that was my point earlier. If money's no object you can rent for 5 years and buy then (also qualifying for the money saving schemes?) so a 5 year restriction is unlikely to helps someone who grew up in the area?

It greatly reduces the outside buyer pool because not everyone is willing to do that and wait.

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:32

Presumably it's locals who sold the properties for inflated prices in the first place...

Lockheart · 14/02/2023 11:32

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:27

You have to declare if the house is a primary residence when you buy it (wherever it is) for tax purposes.

No you don't. You can make a nomination to HMRC up to two years after you acquire / sell properties / move house regarding a primary residence, and it only impacts you for capital gains tax and PPR relief should you sell one property.

MadeOfSteel · 14/02/2023 11:31

If it helps stop locals, people who've lived in the area for years, maybe all their lives, from being priced out of the area where they work, then it has to be a good thing.

melj1213 · 14/02/2023 11:30

YABU - I live in the Lake District and every other bloody house is a holiday home these days.

This means that locals can't afford property because as soon as a house goes on the market (for over inflated prices) it is snapped up by someone wanting a holiday let as opposed to a young local wanting to move on to the property ladder.

This means that young locals can't afford to live in the towns and villages they were brought up in and so have to move further and further afield to find housing. Invariably this means that they then work elsewhere because they aren't going to commute in to a low paid job (especially when public transport is non existent except tourist "sightseeing buses" etc) when they can get one locally because the only viable employment in their town is tourist based - gift shops or hospitality - hotels, cafes, pubs and restaurants, cleaning holiday lets etc. Even that is limited to the tourist heavy months and the people who work in those industries can't live there because they can't afford a house (either to rent or buy) on the NMW they earn for those jobs.

This then means companies struggle to keep staff and things shut down or are 100% aimed at the tourists as they bring the most money in eg the local pub only opening at weekends except in the summer because they can't afford the staff and running costs of opening 7 days a week and as weekends/summer are when the tourists and holiday makers visit then they're when they make the most money.

This just perpetuates the cycle of there being nothing for locals, as they can't afford to live in the town when they're only able to get weekend/holiday work and they can't go out or enjoy their village as there's nowhere to go (can't go to the pub as it's shut unless it's the weekend but you're working the whole weekend, same for the restaurants/bars/cafes etc) so they leave and their properties become even more holiday lets, bought up by rich people who have only ever spent a week or two in the Lakes as a summer holiday. Equally the other infrastructure is dwindling - got to drive 3 towns over to find a bank/school/dentist/doctors/library/post office/supermarket etc because there isn't enough of a permanent community to sustain them so they close and all the people move elsewhere, leaving the towns and villages to the tourists.

Outside of high tourist seasons the places are like ghost towns as everything is shut, half the houses are standing empty and there's no community because the community has been priced out of their homes.

VictorStrand · 14/02/2023 11:29

There are lots of reasons for local residency restrictions. They are used to keep ex Council housing stock in the ownership of people within the community. They are used in National Parks to ensure the property will be used all year round not just for holidays or be used by essential workers. This is tied to complicated negotiations about protecting the greenbelt and not using national parks as trojan horses for sneaking housing into areas of natural beauty.
There are lots of restrictions around housing. Local plans tend to look beyond 'can this one person move here?' and consider what's best for the built and the natural environment.
It strikes me that the ones who are complaining are people who have never even considered rural housing issues and are suddenly shocked they can't just wave around money and do whatever they like.

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 11:29

Why do they have to be rich? Poor people get priced out of areas and need to move too!

Because these houses would be very expensive to buy if there was no restriction on ownership.

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:27

KillingLoneliness · 14/02/2023 11:24

We need to protect our local communities in Devon, locals can’t afford to buy here anymore and are being forced to move away from their families and friends.
How would you prove that it would be someone’s primary residence? You can easily prove that someone’s lived and worked within the area for many years and they’d much rather the property be sold to a local vs someone from London.

You have to declare if the house is a primary residence when you buy it (wherever it is) for tax purposes.

pattihews · 14/02/2023 11:25

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/02/2023 11:14

No. You read again. A primary residence clause would deal with holiday homes. Why can't someone move from London to Cornwall to be a nurse and own their own home?!

You're arguing that it's okay to drive valuable workers out of the area they grew up in and where they are desperately needed because of a lack of affordable housing. Really?

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 11:25

pansiesinmygarden · 14/02/2023 11:18

Shock horror!

I was answering that poster's question. Sorry you didn't understand that.

KillingLoneliness · 14/02/2023 11:24

We need to protect our local communities in Devon, locals can’t afford to buy here anymore and are being forced to move away from their families and friends.
How would you prove that it would be someone’s primary residence? You can easily prove that someone’s lived and worked within the area for many years and they’d much rather the property be sold to a local vs someone from London.

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:23

Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 11:21

Afaik this restriction is only for buying not renting so if someone wants to they can "put the roots" and buy later. Like many of us did everywhere anyway.
Doesn't matter whether you are black or white, christian or muslim, scouser or londoner.

It's not favouring ethnic minority, but locals. Everyone else is affected the same no matter what protected characteristic.

Yes, that was my point earlier. If money's no object you can rent for 5 years and buy then (also qualifying for the money saving schemes?) so a 5 year restriction is unlikely to helps someone who grew up in the area?

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/02/2023 11:22

Apparently the absolute worst thing you can be on MN is middle class. Christ, the spitting venom.

Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 11:21

Afaik this restriction is only for buying not renting so if someone wants to they can "put the roots" and buy later. Like many of us did everywhere anyway.
Doesn't matter whether you are black or white, christian or muslim, scouser or londoner.

It's not favouring ethnic minority, but locals. Everyone else is affected the same no matter what protected characteristic.

beAsensible1 · 14/02/2023 11:20

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

imagine if they started doing this in hackney all the "shire" transplants would be spitting blood and maybe all the local kids could spend less time being harrased by the police for being "too loud" when sitting outside in the bloody day time.

Theluggage15 · 14/02/2023 11:20

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:11

So we want a system where there's no social mobility at all. Where you're born is where you end up?

It's OK if you're born somewhere lovely I suppose?

‘Won’t anyone think of the middle classes?’ Social mobility my arse.

We have affordable housing in my area which is only available to locals, which is as it should be.