Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local Persons restriction seem a bit racist? Or am I overthinking?

358 replies

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

OP posts:
Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 12:45

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 12:40

All outsiders are evil rich Londoners (even if they come from Preston), including any outsider coming in to work and contribute to the local economy as a nurse, teacher or care worker or to start a business

In most cases teachers and care workers can't afford the house prices either. And the ones starting businesses are usually doing something useless like life coaching and it's a hobby job. Admittedly they might spend money in the local pub.

Also, people wanting to come in from elsewhere fuels green field developments, which wouldn't actually be needed if existing housing stock was equitably managed. And spoil the countryside so detract from what people come to the area to see anyway.

That's the developers' and the Local Authorities' fault not the buyers.

I live on the edge of the London Green Belt. There's loads of disused industrial land here, but it's much cheaper and easier (ie more profitable) to build on virgin land, so that's what they do. The option to buy houses built on brown field sites, which will often be closer to infrastructure, isn't there

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 12:43

Also it's possible to say local ownership only, or people with key job offers locally.

So you can't buy an affordable house in a new build development unless you are taking up employment as eg a care worker or a teacher. If you want to come and live in the area with your hobby job, you can't. You'll have to rent until you've met the 5 year residency requirement. Seems fair to me. Again, this sort of thing has been standard in the Channel Islands for decades (though still hasn't prevented ludicrous house prices).

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:41

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 12:34

I'm referring to the large number of posters who want to see this as standard. Who think that communities in beauty spots should be kept exclusive whilst communities is towns and cities are of no value. Who are saying on this thread that they don't want outsiders even when they move into to make the community their permanent home and work and contribute to the local economy - which apparently is "stealing our jobs".

All outsiders are evil rich Londoners (even if they come from Preston), including any outsider coming in to work and contribute to the local economy as a nurse, teacher or care worker or to start a business.

These threads always go the same way.

I haven't seen anyone say that no outsiders should come into these areas or that all properties should have local restrictions applied to them. Only that it's justifiable (and not racist!) for some properties to have local ownership restrictions.

Rightmove currently has 356 properties listed in Dartmoor. It's not as if outsiders can't currently move there.

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 12:40

All outsiders are evil rich Londoners (even if they come from Preston), including any outsider coming in to work and contribute to the local economy as a nurse, teacher or care worker or to start a business

In most cases teachers and care workers can't afford the house prices either. And the ones starting businesses are usually doing something useless like life coaching and it's a hobby job. Admittedly they might spend money in the local pub.

Also, people wanting to come in from elsewhere fuels green field developments, which wouldn't actually be needed if existing housing stock was equitably managed. And spoil the countryside so detract from what people come to the area to see anyway.

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:37

ZiriForEver · 14/02/2023 12:23

I see OP's point. It isn't racism in intention, but it has disproportionate effect on different groups. Not based on biological characteristics, but based on social characteristics.

Let's say that the area which comes with this setup is above average percentage of homeowners area, and less long-term renters area.
Let's say that white British people has higher than average proportion of home ownership.

Such protection makes property ownership more available for people (directly or through their parents) from group which already owns more (both there and more in general). It protects (among others) from competition from people who live in renters' areas (renting themselves or being children of renters).

If someone tried the same with jobs (not enough jobs, so let's artificially restrict on people similar to those already in, mostly their offsprings) it won't be fair either.

You could apply the disproportionate effect argument to any area of public policy though.

If some ethnic groups are less likely to attend university than other groups then public funding for universities benefits some groups over others. Does that mean having public funded universities is racist?

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 12:36

what you are all saying is that we can only live and work in the community we were born into

no, just that new housing is restricted to local people. You can still buy older housing (as long as it's not used for holiday lets/second homes). We don't actually have a housing crisis in the UK, despite the common view. What we do have is a crisis in how it's allocated and owned. There is enough housing to go round but it's not allocated fairly or used efficiently.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 12:34

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:11

No it wouldn't because these restrictions only apply to a tiny minority of houses.

I'm referring to the large number of posters who want to see this as standard. Who think that communities in beauty spots should be kept exclusive whilst communities is towns and cities are of no value. Who are saying on this thread that they don't want outsiders even when they move into to make the community their permanent home and work and contribute to the local economy - which apparently is "stealing our jobs".

All outsiders are evil rich Londoners (even if they come from Preston), including any outsider coming in to work and contribute to the local economy as a nurse, teacher or care worker or to start a business.

These threads always go the same way.

AgeingDoc · 14/02/2023 12:34

I live in an area where some houses have this kind of order on them and I think it's a good idea. We're in a rural area on the edge of a very popular holiday area which is now effectively "full" so tourism is spreading outwards. There are increasingly large numbers of houses being used as second homes/holiday homes and it has pushed property prices up a lot, pricing many young locals out of the market and leading to them moving away.
It's not a simple matter. Tourism is very important to the region economically so obviously accomodation is needed, but it's not a theme park and people do want and need to live permanently here. A lot of local jobs are not well paid - hospitality jobs in particular - so recently there's been issues with staff recruitment and retention in the tourism industry which has been at least partially attributed to the lack of affordable accomodation in the area.
There are quite a lot of initiatives here at present aimed at stemming the flow of young people out of the county but that will only work if they can find places to live. We also have problems attracting people like health care professionals to the area, and inward migration is necessary. So there is a balance to be struck, and ensuring adequate accomodation for all is difficult, particularly when you add the complication of planning restrictions/the need to preserve the countryside. It's easy to be critical of the planning authorities etc but it's a difficult job.
I think local occupancy clauses have a role to play as long as used judiciously, as do primary residence clauses. Some people are talking as though they make it impossible for people to move areas at all but that's not my experience. In our area it tends to be either lower cost property, particulary ex council houses, or agricultural properties that have local occupancy clauses. Self builds tend to have a primary residence clause and restrictions whereby they can't be sold to anyone else within a certain number of years. I guess that's to stop people getting round planning restrictions by pretending they are building for themselves and then immediately sell or use as an AirBnB. But it's a minority of houses that have restrictions.
I'm not against people moving from cities to the countryside. It would be very hypocritical of me if I was, as that's exactly what we did. But I came to do a job that was much needed and could not have been filled by a local person and I like to think we have contributed a lot to the community, not just taken from it. We have raised our children here, used local businesses, volunteered in various capacities and so on. In my experience incomers are welcomed if they actually become part of the community.
But it does need to be managed to some degree. The boom in holiday accommodation and second homes has a big impact on communities, and not just on property prices. Loss of permanent residents means things like fewer pupils in village schools, so funding cuts, local transport routes being dropped as they're not used, shops and pubs closing because there isn't enough year round trade etc all of which can be very detrimental to local people. So it is important to try to preserve rural communities, whilst recognising the role that new people and indeed tourism, play in such places. It's definitely not straightforward matter of right and wrong.

duckup · 14/02/2023 12:27

It's not just Dartmoor, it happens in many other areas, and types of housing, whether it be social housing, new builds or developments or slightly older properties.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/can-access-to-housing-be-restricted-to-local-people/

ZiriForEver · 14/02/2023 12:23

I see OP's point. It isn't racism in intention, but it has disproportionate effect on different groups. Not based on biological characteristics, but based on social characteristics.

Let's say that the area which comes with this setup is above average percentage of homeowners area, and less long-term renters area.
Let's say that white British people has higher than average proportion of home ownership.

Such protection makes property ownership more available for people (directly or through their parents) from group which already owns more (both there and more in general). It protects (among others) from competition from people who live in renters' areas (renting themselves or being children of renters).

If someone tried the same with jobs (not enough jobs, so let's artificially restrict on people similar to those already in, mostly their offsprings) it won't be fair either.

VictorStrand · 14/02/2023 12:21

Developers and second homers and commuters would love to rip up rural housing rules for their own selfish reasons.
But when there are no restrictions, you're left with London - locals priced out; dying high streets; the property market flooded with international investors, oligarchs and gangsters who snap up properties then leave them vacant whilst the homeless sleep on the streets and workers are forced into long commutes. Rather than complaining about rural restrictions, it might be better to campaign for cities to take their housing and infrastructure obligations seriously.

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:11

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 11:48

That isn't what a lot of posters are saying and isn't the situation the OP describes where you need five years of previous continuous residence. That would preclude people working and living in the area unless they come from the right gene pool.

No it wouldn't because these restrictions only apply to a tiny minority of houses.

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 12:08

On Jersey it's 5 years unless you're a high net worth individual. They don't even try and pretend it's not just about keeping the riff raff out 😆

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 12:00

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 11:35

You are allowed to discriminate in certain circumstances. Such as, for example, discriminating against children when it comes to religious schools.

It might be that this requirement could be indirectly racist but if there is enough justification, it will be accepted.

You could say the same about a Welsh language requirement for jobs in Wales, but it can be got around by learning Welsh.

The requirement is not just to stop second home ownership, it's to stop non-locals buying up housing stock at the expense of locals.

Jersey has had a requirement like this for decades, and it's much more draconian.

In Wales it is tacitly understood that those Welsh-language requirements discriminate not only against non-White people, but also against working-class White people in South Wales where the majority of the population live, and Welsh-language is overwhelmingly a middle-class hobby, as opposed to North and West Wales, where many people actually speak it as a first language.

The Welsh-language requirement has made it quite easy for university graduates to keep all the best jobs while young people from the Valleys live their whole lives unemployed or on sickness benefits.

Jux · 14/02/2023 11:58

Sapphire387 · 14/02/2023 08:39

It's not about them being white, it's about ensuring local people are not priced out of the market.

There are some equivalents in London- in social housing for example, some properties will only be allocated to those who have been living and/or working in a particular borough.

I agree it would be good to extend this to houses for sale in London too.

I live quite near there. None of our youth can afford to live anywhere near where they grew up because property's so expensive and jobs so badly paid, if there are jobs.

I don't know anyone who thinks restrictions on who to sell to is a bad idea - far too many idiots movein, complain about the church bells which have been rung like 'this' or 'that' since time immemorial and waste everyone's time and money trying to get them stopped.... complaining about god knows what etc.

I know many people don't want to do that, and many incomers don't, of course. But the problem is bad enough that combined with the problems brought about by second home owners and the major problem of not enough housing for our youth, that I know no one local who doesn't heartily approve of restricted selling.

Sorry.

Try something outside the Park. Make yourselves into welcome locals, people who support the local community and way of life. Then try for something more like what you're after in 10-20 years. That's about the pace we do things in out here.

StephanieSuperpowers · 14/02/2023 11:57

The same thing is happening in every inner city borough in working class & ethnic minority communities of London. not single bit of protection there, just greedy local council taking backhanders from developers

That sounds like a problem for the voters in those communities to solve, not a reason to prevent more proactive communities from acting to prevent the slow death of rural and village life.

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 11:57

VictorStrand · 14/02/2023 11:53

The posters complaining on this thread are from other areas and think they should be able to ride roughshod over rural planning and housing because they've decided they might like to live in the country. 🙄
Could a member of a minority group challenge the restriction as it pertains to them? Possibly. Can people who simply think they'd like a second home in the country or a commuter base? Nope.

I can't think of anything worse than living somewhere like this, even part-time. I'm London born and bred (and when I die I'll be London dead 😉) I've never learned to drive, I need 24-hour shops within walking distance, and I am miserable without the buzz of millions of different people around me and loads of culture. I don't like mud or cold or dark. Oh, and I'm not White.

But of course racism plays a part. I can't imagine wanting to live somewhere as one of the less than 30 people out of 1200 who isn't White, and especially so if I'd taken the local authority to court for the right to live there!

VictorStrand · 14/02/2023 11:53

The posters complaining on this thread are from other areas and think they should be able to ride roughshod over rural planning and housing because they've decided they might like to live in the country. 🙄
Could a member of a minority group challenge the restriction as it pertains to them? Possibly. Can people who simply think they'd like a second home in the country or a commuter base? Nope.

beAsensible1 · 14/02/2023 11:53

KillingLoneliness · 14/02/2023 11:24

We need to protect our local communities in Devon, locals can’t afford to buy here anymore and are being forced to move away from their families and friends.
How would you prove that it would be someone’s primary residence? You can easily prove that someone’s lived and worked within the area for many years and they’d much rather the property be sold to a local vs someone from London.

The same thing is happening in every inner city borough in working class & ethnic minority communities of London. not single bit of protection there, just greedy local council taking backhanders from developers

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:51

Jijithecat · 14/02/2023 11:50

Do you not think they'd figure out quite quickly that they'd been shopped by the neighbours? How many threads have you read on Mumsnet where people have been querying whether they should report something and the thread is just full of people telling them to keep out of it, to mind their own business etc.
People have to be majorly inconvenienced by something before they will report it. The majority of people will join moan about nothing being done rather than being proactive.

If the neighbours are never there it wouldn't matter? 😆

Jijithecat · 14/02/2023 11:50

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:21

And also, @Figmentof if you had a system for someone reporting that the house next door has different residents every week, and then the home owner got whacked with a fine, I think you'd find the system would start to self-police quite quickly.

Do you not think they'd figure out quite quickly that they'd been shopped by the neighbours? How many threads have you read on Mumsnet where people have been querying whether they should report something and the thread is just full of people telling them to keep out of it, to mind their own business etc.
People have to be majorly inconvenienced by something before they will report it. The majority of people will join moan about nothing being done rather than being proactive.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 11:48

Workjobfind · 14/02/2023 11:44

No one's saying that. If you have a job offer in an area you should be able to access affordable housing no? Restrictions such as local connection offers ensures essential workers can move into an area

That isn't what a lot of posters are saying and isn't the situation the OP describes where you need five years of previous continuous residence. That would preclude people working and living in the area unless they come from the right gene pool.

Lawandsawdus · 14/02/2023 11:47

If a local person buys can it be second home and are they allowed to Air B&B/holiday cottage?

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 11:46

pattihews · 14/02/2023 11:25

You're arguing that it's okay to drive valuable workers out of the area they grew up in and where they are desperately needed because of a lack of affordable housing. Really?

A nurse will earn the same wherever they come from. What you are saying is you don't want anyone from outside the area even if they are working and contributing to the local economy.

That is a very different proposition from restricting holiday lets.

UncannySerenity · 14/02/2023 11:46

A price cap would surely be better. To stop greedy locals profiting from the money of wealthy Londoners?

I have zero desire to leave London for the sticks and never will. I like Cornwall for holidays but the behaviour of those in SW villages towards those wanting an escape during the pandemic was quite the eye-opener so I won’t go again.

But I am uncomfortable with restriction of movement. Especially for those being priced out of cities. Not sure where they will be allowed to buy. This will end up with villages staying mainly white and cities being diverse. Maybe everyone is ok with that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread