Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local Persons restriction seem a bit racist? Or am I overthinking?

358 replies

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

OP posts:
winterpastasalad · 14/02/2023 14:48

If all communities across the UK suddenly became 'protected' for locals only it would be disastrous for the socio-economy. I come from a town which is known as "retirement by the sea". Very popular with tourists and those wanting to escape cities. There's no hospital, no university, very little diversity, a lot of racists and so on. If you wanted to go to university you had to leave. The vast majority of those who left never came back. My mind was literally blown when I left and I met people of different colours, religions, backgrounds etc. I can't think of anything worse than having to stay there and subject the next generations! And I say that as someone who will never be able to get on the property ladder anywhere.

VictorStrand · 14/02/2023 14:22

Everyone who knows about the restrictions realises they only apply to certain areas and certain properties.
Yet again, it's posters pretending they care and trying to cause fights, who are deliberately creating strawmen ... or maybe some other kind of men because I get the impression they're not in rural environments enough to have any straw. Grin

Hope551 · 14/02/2023 13:49

@dartmoorgirl12 couldn't quote sorry. Yes maybe the case now, when I knew people there it was 15 years ago so all might of changed. I know the actual land history is pagan (stone circles monuments) so perhaps over years it's been taken over. (Hope that doesn't sound bad saying) but in old old days it was meant to be sacred pagan land through the historic artefacts. But as modern days changes it may all of changed. If that's the case then I don't get the criteria to live there, I don't see how being in an area 5 years suddenly makes you local. I do if like with housing you need ties to an area like family. But tbf I think they should more cater to what the area needs, ie someone moving down who works in conservation, it would be madness to turn them away. Frustrating, I would love to live there but sounds like I would never meet the criteria haha x

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 13:44

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 13:33

So you would rather nobody got the 20% discount then?

No, but I'd expect that the group that got the discount to reflect the diversity across the UK, and that's palpably not the case here. This is quite clearly designed to consolidate and reinforce the status quo, which is substantially less diverse than the rest of the country.

OP posts:
NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 13:33

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 13:12

Yes, but those 356 properties won't have 20% off the market price which is precisely the point.

So you would rather nobody got the 20% discount then?

Firstdays · 14/02/2023 13:29

Hope551 · 14/02/2023 13:02

Dartmoor is really not Christian. It's actually a place of Pagan origins. If you visit you will notice stones placed on top of each other in little villages. Lots of pagan symbolism and throughout certain events in the year, pagans ands covens congregate there to celebrate events of the year and things. I think if you go around talking about Christianity to the locals in Dartmoor you might offend quite a few people as obviously their whole way of life has been targeted by extremists in that religion. I'm not pagan but having lived in the area I'm aware, it's just not broadcasted as there can be a lot of hostility between groups and most people just want a peaceful life.

Other areas of Devon I don't think has this rule in place. But I'm not surprised dartmoor has as it's considered quite sacred land and locals are very protective of it, rightly so it's beautiful. I know people moving there might get annoyed but its not just a place to work or a home to some of the locals there, it's precious to them and some have lived their for generations. I'm sure in other countries there too is some areas protected for natives, and with so much choice to live anywhere I'm not sure why one tiny bit of area has to have issues that people can just make dibs on that too.

I don't live there just giving a bit of background info on the area, personally I would love people to move their who specialise in agriculture and land, as it has so much diversity with animals, land I would love it to remain protected. There a few historic woods and places that have already been destroyed by visitors or youngsters partying, which is so sad for the local wildlife.

Paganism is reported under "other" in the census. In the 2021 census, Dartmoor had 44 people who reported "other".

EyesOnThePies · 14/02/2023 13:27

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 10:02

But that's happened in London through immigration too? The new diversity is supposed to be a good thing there?

Immigration has not displaced Londoners by putting up housing prices. The availability of high paid jobs in the city has pushed up prices, as has the sale of huge swathes of property to non resident investors.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 13:23

Hope551 · 14/02/2023 13:02

Dartmoor is really not Christian. It's actually a place of Pagan origins. If you visit you will notice stones placed on top of each other in little villages. Lots of pagan symbolism and throughout certain events in the year, pagans ands covens congregate there to celebrate events of the year and things. I think if you go around talking about Christianity to the locals in Dartmoor you might offend quite a few people as obviously their whole way of life has been targeted by extremists in that religion. I'm not pagan but having lived in the area I'm aware, it's just not broadcasted as there can be a lot of hostility between groups and most people just want a peaceful life.

Other areas of Devon I don't think has this rule in place. But I'm not surprised dartmoor has as it's considered quite sacred land and locals are very protective of it, rightly so it's beautiful. I know people moving there might get annoyed but its not just a place to work or a home to some of the locals there, it's precious to them and some have lived their for generations. I'm sure in other countries there too is some areas protected for natives, and with so much choice to live anywhere I'm not sure why one tiny bit of area has to have issues that people can just make dibs on that too.

I don't live there just giving a bit of background info on the area, personally I would love people to move their who specialise in agriculture and land, as it has so much diversity with animals, land I would love it to remain protected. There a few historic woods and places that have already been destroyed by visitors or youngsters partying, which is so sad for the local wildlife.

This is v much just my personal experience, but all the pagan types I know around here are v much incomers!

OP posts:
Sturmundcalm · 14/02/2023 13:18

I live on the edge of an incredibly tourist-y area which has these kind of restrictions on some properties (only a fairly small number though as it's specific to the planning permission that was given at the time of building in the last 25 years). A bit further away is a rural area that isn't as tourist-y but is still v attractive and LOTS of houses there are second homes - many not even used as Air BnBs, they just sit empty for 3-10 months of the year. I look at the way that area is declining rapidly and think that something should be done! There are no easy answers when it comes to this because we take a capitalist/free market approach to housing people in the UK which sees some people own multiple properties on the basis of "investment" while others don't have a secure roof over their heads.

I can't see how a primary residence requirement would help because it's virtually impossible to police unless the property is let out.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 13:18

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 11:03

. As it happens of the 2373 people living on Dartmoor, 2300 are white, 12 Asian, 16 Black.

Fucking hell.

It seems really weird that people can't see that these figures are... A little odd. And that maybe - just maybe - the fact that they are deliberately creating planning restrictions that are designed to reduce the number of "incomers" might have something to do with it. Particularly when it relates to one of the beautiful parts of the country.

OP posts:
dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 13:12

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:41

I haven't seen anyone say that no outsiders should come into these areas or that all properties should have local restrictions applied to them. Only that it's justifiable (and not racist!) for some properties to have local ownership restrictions.

Rightmove currently has 356 properties listed in Dartmoor. It's not as if outsiders can't currently move there.

Yes, but those 356 properties won't have 20% off the market price which is precisely the point.

OP posts:
dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 13:09

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:37

You could apply the disproportionate effect argument to any area of public policy though.

If some ethnic groups are less likely to attend university than other groups then public funding for universities benefits some groups over others. Does that mean having public funded universities is racist?

Yes, but in most areas of public policy, it is considered. Ie if a university had a policy in place that made it more likely to benefit to benefit one specific group over another, it would be told to sort it out. (Whether that would have any effect or not is another thread!)

OP posts:
Hope551 · 14/02/2023 13:05

Also so sorry about grammatical and spelling errors, I'm typing on a phone 😬

Hope551 · 14/02/2023 13:02

Dartmoor is really not Christian. It's actually a place of Pagan origins. If you visit you will notice stones placed on top of each other in little villages. Lots of pagan symbolism and throughout certain events in the year, pagans ands covens congregate there to celebrate events of the year and things. I think if you go around talking about Christianity to the locals in Dartmoor you might offend quite a few people as obviously their whole way of life has been targeted by extremists in that religion. I'm not pagan but having lived in the area I'm aware, it's just not broadcasted as there can be a lot of hostility between groups and most people just want a peaceful life.

Other areas of Devon I don't think has this rule in place. But I'm not surprised dartmoor has as it's considered quite sacred land and locals are very protective of it, rightly so it's beautiful. I know people moving there might get annoyed but its not just a place to work or a home to some of the locals there, it's precious to them and some have lived their for generations. I'm sure in other countries there too is some areas protected for natives, and with so much choice to live anywhere I'm not sure why one tiny bit of area has to have issues that people can just make dibs on that too.

I don't live there just giving a bit of background info on the area, personally I would love people to move their who specialise in agriculture and land, as it has so much diversity with animals, land I would love it to remain protected. There a few historic woods and places that have already been destroyed by visitors or youngsters partying, which is so sad for the local wildlife.

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 13:00

BlondeBombshelf · 14/02/2023 12:54

🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️ Totally overthinking it. I know Dartmoor well and yes, the white people were probably there first. So? They just want to keep it local, if any local black people want to buy then they won’t be prevented. You’re seeing a problem where there isn’t one.

There are no local Black people. Oh sorry, there are 12.

(See stats posted above.)

DuckityFuck · 14/02/2023 13:00

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 12:48

I'm priced out of the bit of London I grew up in, mainly due to people from outside London who have no idea of London society, many of whom will move back out to the countryside once they've made some money here. Do you think I should have got preferential treatment so I could buy a house there?

I don’t think it’s for all houses, just a proportion, and yes I think you should have that in London too.

I think some of the issues we have in this country could be helped by more of a sense of community, and part of that comes from people being able to live near family, continue on traditions and a way of life that they grew up with, and hope that their own children can do the same. You set down roots in a place you feel you belong, which for a lot of people is where they grew up, and you care more about what happens to that area and the people in it.

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 12:59

Lockheart · 14/02/2023 12:52

I can't speak for the poster you quoted but I think you should.

It's a sorry state of affairs when housing stock is depleted to the detriment of communities in the interests of those who have no interest in said community. Gentrification has been a huge issue in London.

The thing is, I'm a 3rd-generation immigrant (from outside the UK) and I'm raising my children here, I hope they stay. Most of the people I know who have built their lives here are also 1st, 2nd, 3rd or 4th generation immigrants to the UK.

There is no way to distinguish on paper between those of us whose families moved here and see this as our home for the foreseeable future, and people who move here after 'uni' but then retreat back to the all-White, all-English countryside once they've had a couple of kids. And sometimes those people do decide to stay and make it their permanent home.

Some of my husband's relatives are exactly this type and yes, they have no interest in building or supporting the community around them - it's all about house prices and 'avo on toast'.

But even though I'd have benefited from it, I wouldn't support this kind of legislation at all. I love London because it's dynamic and ever-changing and always interesting. Any restrictions on 'incomers' is absolutely going to discriminate against those of different ethnicities and nationalities, even if that's not the primary motive for it. I don't want to live somewhere that's actively hostile to 'outsiders', even if they do annoy the fuck out of me when they stand on the left.

BlondeBombshelf · 14/02/2023 12:54

🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️ 🤦‍♀️ Totally overthinking it. I know Dartmoor well and yes, the white people were probably there first. So? They just want to keep it local, if any local black people want to buy then they won’t be prevented. You’re seeing a problem where there isn’t one.

Lockheart · 14/02/2023 12:52

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 12:48

I'm priced out of the bit of London I grew up in, mainly due to people from outside London who have no idea of London society, many of whom will move back out to the countryside once they've made some money here. Do you think I should have got preferential treatment so I could buy a house there?

I can't speak for the poster you quoted but I think you should.

It's a sorry state of affairs when housing stock is depleted to the detriment of communities in the interests of those who have no interest in said community. Gentrification has been a huge issue in London.

concincencuncan · 14/02/2023 12:49

It's a good idea! We only got our house because the owner didn't want to sell to a landlord. My great aunt accepted a lower offer because she wanted a family to buy her house instead of another landlord pricing regular families out.
I'll always think well of her for that.

Daizie · 14/02/2023 12:49

I think you need to educate yourself on racism.

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 12:48

DuckityFuck · 14/02/2023 12:46

I saw these kind of restrictions on some houses in the Peak District when I was looking to buy. I think they’re fantastic.
I grew up in a Cotswold village - I am well and truly priced out of that entire area now. It’s sad, the area has just become a second-home/commuter/home-working area populated by townies with no idea of rural society and little to contribute to the rural economy.

I'm priced out of the bit of London I grew up in, mainly due to people from outside London who have no idea of London society, many of whom will move back out to the countryside once they've made some money here. Do you think I should have got preferential treatment so I could buy a house there?

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 12:47

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 12:40

All outsiders are evil rich Londoners (even if they come from Preston), including any outsider coming in to work and contribute to the local economy as a nurse, teacher or care worker or to start a business

In most cases teachers and care workers can't afford the house prices either. And the ones starting businesses are usually doing something useless like life coaching and it's a hobby job. Admittedly they might spend money in the local pub.

Also, people wanting to come in from elsewhere fuels green field developments, which wouldn't actually be needed if existing housing stock was equitably managed. And spoil the countryside so detract from what people come to the area to see anyway.

You excised the context from that quote which was describing the way these threads go.

If you want to put a community in aspic and prevent outsiders moving in and contributing to the economy, thereby keeping the community dependent on the same few landowners - fill your boots.

If you want more dynamism and opportunities in the local economy then part of that is more movement. What fascinates me in so many of these areas is that failure to see the connection between a thriving community and movement of people both in and out.

This is completely separate from the issue of second homes/holiday lets, for which local authorities already have considerable powers around primary residency, higher council tax and other deterrents. However local people need to vote for councils willing to implement those deterrents and also to support development of social housing (which makes less money for the local developer/landowners).

ClearMoth · 14/02/2023 12:47

NotDavidTennant · 14/02/2023 12:37

You could apply the disproportionate effect argument to any area of public policy though.

If some ethnic groups are less likely to attend university than other groups then public funding for universities benefits some groups over others. Does that mean having public funded universities is racist?

Lots of people have argued that, hence there are schemes that aim to redress that balance (e.g. better offers for those whose parents didn't go to university, or who went to state school, etc.)

DuckityFuck · 14/02/2023 12:46

I saw these kind of restrictions on some houses in the Peak District when I was looking to buy. I think they’re fantastic.
I grew up in a Cotswold village - I am well and truly priced out of that entire area now. It’s sad, the area has just become a second-home/commuter/home-working area populated by townies with no idea of rural society and little to contribute to the rural economy.