Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local Persons restriction seem a bit racist? Or am I overthinking?

358 replies

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

OP posts:
Grumpybutfunny · 14/02/2023 19:33

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:50

It's not to protect against second homers. You can just put a restriction on it saying it has to be a primary home!

That's fine but if it's bought as a second home they could just declare the actual primary home as their secondary. We were priced out of our local city in our 20s, we are now 32 could afford to go back but have no desire. People should be able to live and buy where they want without restrictions.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 19:32

And it's part of a s.106 agreement, @Applesandcarrots
They used to have something called the Devon Rule, but that's not it.

OP posts:
Bamboozle123 · 14/02/2023 19:30

Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 19:20

I just googled it. Is it s157 of HA?
Because I am pretty sure actual lawyers looked at it (not just mn) and it's still fine in use...

Afaik it's not on all properties. Former council ones? Seems from the article by a lawyer I just had a look at.

Maybe so but quite often the lawyers advice is not tested until someone actually takes them to court...

Puffalicious · 14/02/2023 19:30

CatJumperTwat · 14/02/2023 10:17

So people like me should have to rent forever at the mercy of greedy landlords?

Sorry? Sorry, but where have I said anything of the sort? This is about inflated London prices where home owners there bought a place years ago, sell it and bring these huge amounts to buy properties in small, beautiful places- thus driving prices up, and eventually out of reach for those who work locally.

I'm sick of hearing about friends of friends who moved to London in the 90s, made big bucks in finance and then took the huge profits to buy a house outright in every coastal/ country beauty spot up and down the country. It means the local nurse can't get a property, or the area can't attract new professionals into the area/ business because houses are totally unaffordable.

It's happened across Cornwall- where I have relatives- and is happening in Northumberland as we speak (DS GF comes from there) as well as swathes of Scotland. My friend was able to rent a little cottage in Skye really cheaply 25 years ago - she worked as a shepard- now it's impossible to rent for less than a month's wages, never mind buy. It's just wrong and I fully support the 5 year rule.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 19:27

Would you mind linking to the article, @Applesandcarrots ? This isn't ex council.

OP posts:
Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 19:20

I just googled it. Is it s157 of HA?
Because I am pretty sure actual lawyers looked at it (not just mn) and it's still fine in use...

Afaik it's not on all properties. Former council ones? Seems from the article by a lawyer I just had a look at.

amgine · 14/02/2023 19:15

Rural poverty is a thing. Plenty of people priced out of those own communities by the market. I still cloud afford to buy in the villiage I grew up in, even despite being on a decent salary. Plenty of people only stay living in these areas as property passes down who’d never afford them otherwise - which makes the property more rare to come by and more expensive).

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 19:15

Bamboozle123 · 14/02/2023 19:00

Yes I think this could be a fair case for it for sure - CAB

This thread demonstrates how far we still need to come with critically evaluating our policies and procedures from a D&I perspective

Thanks for that - it just seemed quite obvious to me, but clearly lots of people on this thread didn't agree! (And totally don't mind a bit of debate, because the thread has actually been really helpful for clarifying my own views on it! Started off wondering if I was overreacting - not any more...)

OP posts:
Bamboozle123 · 14/02/2023 19:00

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 18:35

Yes, indirect indiscrimination - that's exactly what I think it is...

Yes I think this could be a fair case for it for sure - CAB

This thread demonstrates how far we still need to come with critically evaluating our policies and procedures from a D&I perspective

KarmaStar · 14/02/2023 18:53

Don't be stupid.
Racist?
the world has gone mad.

Applesandcarrots · 14/02/2023 18:44

Nearly anything can be indirect discrimination if you think hard enough.

Isn't this restriction just on new builds btw? Not on all sales?

Weirdwonders · 14/02/2023 18:42

It isn’t protecting a group of white people or Christians. That’s disingenuous. It’s to ensure people who live and work locally have a chance of buying a house without being outbid by people no doubt more financially privileged. Even under the time restriction, you would still qualify regardless of race or where you moved from.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 18:35

Bamboozle123 · 14/02/2023 17:49

Yeah this is spot on!

It more than likely does indirectly discriminate

Yes, indirect indiscrimination - that's exactly what I think it is...

OP posts:
dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 18:33

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 18:04

Then schools, hospitals, care homes and other employers will struggle to get the qualified staff they need when neighbouring areas are offering jobs which don't punish good applicants by forcing them off the housing ladder as a precondition of employment.

Every area needs movement in and out, not just a preserved gene pool which will lose some of its most capable youngsters as they move for opportunities irrespective of housing costs.

The issue of second homes and holiday lets is managed better in some areas than others if people vote for effective local authorities. If your local authority isn't doing this then maybe campaign and vote for another one next time which will focus on this rather than simply making it more difficult for potential new skills and economic contributors to join the area.

Ironically, I wonder if some of the local young people don't move away partly because they're frustrated by this sort of insular policy-making (note - not saying that the people are insular, just that this policy is). Also, we don't get to vote on the DNPA - we just get landed with them. Believe me, if there was a way of voting, no one would end up with the current lot.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 18:04

Ceilingplaits · 14/02/2023 17:44

No, anyone moving into an area can rent like anyone else does. Or rather, like anyone else could if so many places weren't second homes or air BnB let's!

Then schools, hospitals, care homes and other employers will struggle to get the qualified staff they need when neighbouring areas are offering jobs which don't punish good applicants by forcing them off the housing ladder as a precondition of employment.

Every area needs movement in and out, not just a preserved gene pool which will lose some of its most capable youngsters as they move for opportunities irrespective of housing costs.

The issue of second homes and holiday lets is managed better in some areas than others if people vote for effective local authorities. If your local authority isn't doing this then maybe campaign and vote for another one next time which will focus on this rather than simply making it more difficult for potential new skills and economic contributors to join the area.

Bamboozle123 · 14/02/2023 17:49

Yeah this is spot on!

It more than likely does indirectly discriminate

Ceilingplaits · 14/02/2023 17:44

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 11:48

That isn't what a lot of posters are saying and isn't the situation the OP describes where you need five years of previous continuous residence. That would preclude people working and living in the area unless they come from the right gene pool.

No, anyone moving into an area can rent like anyone else does. Or rather, like anyone else could if so many places weren't second homes or air BnB let's!

Ceilingplaits · 14/02/2023 17:33

I am all for the protection, not sure whether it can be counted as racist...more that it excludes those of us who are poor and from other areas (as well as its targeted wealthy second home owners), which would include a lot of people from ethnic minorities.

I find it upsetting that we don't have similar in London, especially since council and housing association homes are no longer passed on to our children. The result is so many adult children in London either living in cramped council homes with their parents, or having to leave London. So many communities breaking up. At the same time, we',be longed to move to near family in Wales or Dartmoor for decades, but can't afford it.

LlynTegid · 14/02/2023 17:22

The basic premise of restricting house sales and purchase in some parts of the country I agree with. As one of a number of measures to reduce low occupancy (or almost nil occupancy) of property, a way of increasing the availability of housing.

Five years in an area not unreasonable, providing there are limited exceptions to this for say those working in the NHS and some other key workers, with a sell-on restriction clause.

I'd ban second homes in many areas. Perhaps also to set an example, no second home allowance for MPs.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 17:17

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 15:43

If you want more dynamism and opportunities in the local economy then part of that is more movement. What fascinates me in so many of these areas is that failure to see the connection between a thriving community and movement of people both in and out

As I said in one of my other posts, for me, it's about new housing. Anything that is newly built (especially if on green field land) should be for local people, or those who are taking up key worker-type roles. I am not advocating a complete ban on sales to people from outside an area or county, just restrictions on new builds to try to attract the sort of buyers that will contribute to the area.

Also a local person restriction prevents people buying as second homes and holiday lets as well, so it's a win win.

That kind of planning management to attract and support a mixed local community is in the gift of the local authorities. So typically that would be a mix of 2/3 and some 4 bed units including some low rise apartments and some social housing. On larger developments it should include ammenity accommodation for a nursery, clinic etc.

In the areas I know best, where I have family, the elected authorities have almost without exception approved developments (sometimes of several hundred houses) which are mostly 4/5 bed detached, some 3 bed detached, no accommodation for amenities and minimal "affordable". The price of affordable is skewed by the estate being built as upper end of the market.

That elected authority is dominated by the local business/land owners and unsurprisingly their interests are well represented. They would need to be caught buggering sheep on TV before anyone else got a sniff of a vote because the voting is so tribal. The same cohort blocks moves to increase council tax on second homes, restriction on holiday lets etc.
But still the blame for the housing problems is all ascribed to rich outsiders from London (although in fact most of the incomers to that area are from the midlands and working). And of course the movement of young people away from the area was common long before house prices went up.

Jadviga · 14/02/2023 16:47

Disclaimer : I'm not british.

That's probably a matter of cultural difference but I find bizarre the idea that a family should have the "protected right" to live in one given place at certain prices, generation after generation. Tbh I find it bizarre to even want that.

If the holiday homes are such an issue they could always be taxed and the money used for the betterment of the community, I suppose. Or there could be quotas of how many holiday homes are allowed (I assume people have to declare their primary résidence for tax purposes so should be easy enough to check). I'll admit I find it odd to buy a home to stay there a few weeks a year anyway, it far easier and more efficient to rent, I'd sooner buy to let personally.

StephanieSuperpowers · 14/02/2023 15:46

They just don't understand the dynamism of having a large proportion of homes idle for most of the year and people who would live in them having to move away.

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 15:45

I also read today that the Balearic Islands want to stop foreigners buying up all their houses as there are 60,000 foreigners there.
Are they racist, or are they just trying to protect their housing stock for the existing community?

lieselotte · 14/02/2023 15:43

If you want more dynamism and opportunities in the local economy then part of that is more movement. What fascinates me in so many of these areas is that failure to see the connection between a thriving community and movement of people both in and out

As I said in one of my other posts, for me, it's about new housing. Anything that is newly built (especially if on green field land) should be for local people, or those who are taking up key worker-type roles. I am not advocating a complete ban on sales to people from outside an area or county, just restrictions on new builds to try to attract the sort of buyers that will contribute to the area.

Also a local person restriction prevents people buying as second homes and holiday lets as well, so it's a win win.

HeartBrokenWife · 14/02/2023 15:37

And still the OP is disgusted that people native to a particular country might form the majority of the population of said country. I lived in Spain for five years because of work and, shock, horror most people I met there were Spanish! Was that a bad thing? if so, why?

There have been houses with agricultural ties on them for a long time now. It’s to ensure that farmworkers can afford to live and raise their families near the land on which they work. What’s wrong with that? Yes, I might like a well priced country cottage for myself, but I’d be no use around a tractor, or a herd of Christians, sorry, I mean cows 🐄🤣