Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local Persons restriction seem a bit racist? Or am I overthinking?

358 replies

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

OP posts:
Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 09:40

HeartBrokenWife · 14/02/2023 09:38

Broadly Christian makes no sense and you know it! Define it please.

Oh come on, you know exactly what OP means. Christian by heritage, as the vast majority of white British people are.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:40

HeartBrokenWife · 14/02/2023 09:38

Broadly Christian makes no sense and you know it! Define it please.

HTH... "collective worship is of a broadly Christian character if it reflects the broad traditions of Christian belief without being distinctive of any particular Christian denomination." www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/40/section/7/enacted

OP posts:
HeartBrokenWife · 14/02/2023 09:38

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:15

That's why I said "broadly Christian", @HeartBrokenWifeI thought most people would be able to understand the point. Clearly not!

Broadly Christian makes no sense and you know it! Define it please.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:37

Ok, so I'm thinking this through over the course of this thread. I suppose if you said, here's this house, which is 20% cheaper than the average house in the area and we have a group of people which is 95% white who have a special privilege or right to buy this house over the rest of the population, that would seem weird. But that's actually exactly what the Local Persons thing does.

OP posts:
Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 09:29

Chias · 14/02/2023 09:26

It does seem a bit similar to an anti immigration policy. They could build a wall between the West Country and the UK to keep everyone out. It would stop it being ruined for the locals.

Yes, that's exactly the objection to allowing immigration. People coming here taking jobs, homes, services....

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 09:28

EyesOnThePies · 14/02/2023 09:23

Who do you think would buy these homes OP?

Richer white people probably.

Minorities tend to move to wear there will be a minority community, but there always has to be a first. There are plenty of wealthy black and Asian people in UK, mostly centred around London FTB, but they have moved "out" for a better life/cheaper property just like everyone else. Why do you think none of them would go to Dartmoor?

EyesOnThePies · 14/02/2023 09:27

It’s not about groups of people with protected characteristics, it’s about planning and the development plan. Making sure that key workers and those who contribute to the infrastructure of the area have housing.

The economy.

In London the best thing that the Gvt / Mayor could do, IMO, is ban buyers from abroad buying up thousands of flats as investments and never living in them.

Chias · 14/02/2023 09:26

It does seem a bit similar to an anti immigration policy. They could build a wall between the West Country and the UK to keep everyone out. It would stop it being ruined for the locals.

EyesOnThePies · 14/02/2023 09:23

Who do you think would buy these homes OP?

Richer white people probably.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:23

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 09:16

I think it's an interesting point.

I doubt it's aim is to avoid diversity, but that is the effect whenever "incomers" are discouraged.

It would be interesting to see someone challenge it on race grounds.

I think that's what I mean, @Mugparrot By trying to protect one group with - say - a 20% discount on the house price, you're discriminating against another group. It just seems very odd.

OP posts:
WinterFoxes · 14/02/2023 09:23

Nothing to do with racism. Everything to do with preventing wealthy outsiders buying holiday homes so that locals can't afford to live where they work - usually in low paid service jobs.

Moonmelodies · 14/02/2023 09:22

Perhaps a bit racist of the OP not to acknowledge the non-white population of the West Country.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:21

And also, @Figmentof if you had a system for someone reporting that the house next door has different residents every week, and then the home owner got whacked with a fine, I think you'd find the system would start to self-police quite quickly.

OP posts:
MelchiorsMistress · 14/02/2023 09:21

MelaniesFlowers · 14/02/2023 09:06

@MelchiorsMistress It’s common practice in a lot of areas.

Maybe in social housing, but you don’t see houses listed for sale on Rightmove with a note saying that the vendors will only sell to people who meet their chosen list of criteria, because that would be seen as prejudice.

In reality people can sell their houses to whoever they want of course, but if they advertised it saying that they would only sell to certain people they would rightly be accused of discrimination.

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 09:20

LucyWhipple · 14/02/2023 09:02

Posted too soon…

But people who work locally don’t have salaries that match the new house prices and therefore are completely out priced.

Diversity in a community is really important but not at the expense of people being unable to live where they’ve grown up - if that’s what they want to do - and not at the expense of local industries failing because no one with the skills to do those jobs can afford to live in the area anymore.

But very often that is why people have moved out of London and the South East. I live in a not nice part (ie "cheap") of SE. An ex council flat here is now about £300k, an ex council terrace about £450k. Rent one a 2 bed house about £1200 pm.

There are some big salaries locally, but still lots of people working for minimum wage or in relatively low income jobs. How do you afford to live here on an average salary? Our DC can't afford to live where they grew up either.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:19

Figmentof · 14/02/2023 09:12

It might be easy to introduce a primary home restriction, but how do they monitor that on an ongoing basis, forever more, multiplied by thousands of course. A criteria that needs to be met up front (like five years in the area) needs to be checked just the once.

Completely bizarrely, Dartmoor also has restrictions to ensure that certain homes can only be used as holiday homes (which is absolutely batshit, but a different issue.) They certainly do police that. It's much easier to police whether a house is being used as an Airbnb (is it on Airbnb y/n) than it is to check up on someone quietly living in a holiday home.

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 14/02/2023 09:17

It's nothing to do with racism. My nephew works in the utilities sector and has been travelling down to Devon and Cornwall mon-Fri from the North West for months. They have load of vacancies for well paid employment but can't recruit because nobody can actually afford to live there!!
They need affordable housing for local residents

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 09:16

I think it's an interesting point.

I doubt it's aim is to avoid diversity, but that is the effect whenever "incomers" are discouraged.

It would be interesting to see someone challenge it on race grounds.

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:15

That's why I said "broadly Christian", @HeartBrokenWifeI thought most people would be able to understand the point. Clearly not!

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 09:15

LucyWhipple · 14/02/2023 09:02

Posted too soon…

But people who work locally don’t have salaries that match the new house prices and therefore are completely out priced.

Diversity in a community is really important but not at the expense of people being unable to live where they’ve grown up - if that’s what they want to do - and not at the expense of local industries failing because no one with the skills to do those jobs can afford to live in the area anymore.

Local people sell those homes to second home owners.

Local authorities can put restrictions on primary residence, whack up taxes on second home ownership, tax AirBNBs more aggressively as businesses, reserve some shared ownership homes for essential local occupations. Where they choose not to use these its not uncommon to find the local families doing nicely from the industry in dominant positions in local politics, and yet people still vote for them.

Local industries can employ people moving in as much as people moving out. Nobody has automatic right to live where they grew up - never have done.

hryllilegur · 14/02/2023 09:14

It’s not just the enormous second homes problem it’s trying to address, it’s about the problem where significant numbers of people move out of London to nice, scenic places and drive up housing prices (both to buy and rent) such that they’re wildly unaffordable for the people who live in the area.

Displacement is a big issue in many areas.

Figmentof · 14/02/2023 09:12

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:52

This is exactly what I mean, @HedgeWitchy They could easily introduce a primary home restriction, which would be far far far more effective for reducing the number of AirBNBs down here. This isn't that.

It might be easy to introduce a primary home restriction, but how do they monitor that on an ongoing basis, forever more, multiplied by thousands of course. A criteria that needs to be met up front (like five years in the area) needs to be checked just the once.

Lannielou · 14/02/2023 09:11

I live in North Devon with my kids. We are currently in temporary accomodation as the landlord is selling the property. I think having a restriction on who can live in a property is a good thing. There is a real housing crisis in Devon and Cornwall.

HeartBrokenWife · 14/02/2023 09:10

Great bit of virtue signalling OP. You win today’s prize 🏆 I’m loving the thought of Dartmoor being overrun by huge gangs of Christians by the way. I knew Dartmoor ponies ran wild in the area, but I’ll be sure to look out for the herds of Christians next time I’m down there 😂

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 09:09

@MelchiorsMistress Interesting point. Someone else on the thread said it was important for local industries to keep going, but absolutely every single person I've met down here who's involved in traditional jobs (hedge laying and shepherding spring to mind) actually moved here fairly recently, in part because none of the locals were interested in the jobs!

OP posts: