Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Local Persons restriction seem a bit racist? Or am I overthinking?

358 replies

dartmoorgirl12 · 14/02/2023 08:36

We're house hunting on Dartmoor (clue's in the name!) at the moment, and we've seen a house with a Local Persons restriction on it. You have to live or work in the local or neighbouring parish for the previous five years. We actually qualify, but it got me thinking... Isn't it a bit weird that the "protected" group here are extremely likely to be white/broadly Christian. It just seems really exclusive for 2023. I do understand the idea that local communities should be protected, and that there is absolutely toxic housing pressure in Dartmoor at the moment. But ironically I live down here now because we got royally outpriced in the bit of London I grew up in. And there def doesn't seem to be any move to have Local Persons protections on various parts of London, which have been rapidly gentrified in recent times. I just thought it was interesting. Why is it that this group of white people get protected in this way?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Puffalicious · 23/03/2023 10:34

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2023 02:01

Got to be an improvement on the current setup where social mobility is effectively going backwards - someone who in the past could have afforded a three bedroom townhouse but in this generation can only afford a studio flat.

It's one house, just one which has this covenant. The rest are available to the highest bidder.

Obviously when people moan about Londoners buying up property in Cornwall, they aren't thinking of an Afro-Caribbean single mother who rents a council flat in Hackney. No chance, she can't afford to buy anywhere - she's just as much a victim of the fucked-up housing market as someone born to a family originally from St Ives. The ones people are complaining about are invariably white, probably bought a house in London 30 years ago for peanuts and have found themselves millionaires without lifting a finger. Then they retire to somewhere pretty, complain about church bells, and wonder why the village school is closing when anyone of child-rearing age has been priced out by them.

This with bells on (not church bells 😆).

Why is everything deemed racist? I want safe, affordable housing for the black, single parent in London AND the white, working-class family in Paignton. Both areas of priority need, both families in need. Why is it always boiled down to the over simplistic nature of race?

windchime321 · 23/03/2023 08:01

It’s really hard to get affordable housing for local people in desirable areas with lower income levels and I really don’t think this is racist. It’s fair enough to me that a percentage of homes on new developments should be provided as slightly cheaper homes for people who have a local connection so they can’t be bought by people from higher income areas. If this house was provided under a S106 agreement the developer would have negotiated with the local authority re that percentage. The covenant would - rightly in my view - stay on the property even if it is resold.

Everyonehasavoice · 16/02/2023 02:33

The whole housing market on the island of Guernsey has this
The local market ( some houses are only ever local and some are only general market ) properties are cheaper. The general are v expensive.
Its so that locals are not priced out of the area.

DemiColon · 16/02/2023 02:07

There's nothing wrong with a community that is mainly ethnically white. Just like there is nothing wrong with a community that is mainly not ethnically white.

I think saying that community's historic racial distribution is problematic is quite racist, rather than the opposite.

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2023 02:03

StepAwayFromGoogling · 14/02/2023 11:14

No. You read again. A primary residence clause would deal with holiday homes. Why can't someone move from London to Cornwall to be a nurse and own their own home?!

How enforceable is it in reality?

DdraigGoch · 16/02/2023 02:01

Mugparrot · 14/02/2023 11:11

So we want a system where there's no social mobility at all. Where you're born is where you end up?

It's OK if you're born somewhere lovely I suppose?

Got to be an improvement on the current setup where social mobility is effectively going backwards - someone who in the past could have afforded a three bedroom townhouse but in this generation can only afford a studio flat.

It's one house, just one which has this covenant. The rest are available to the highest bidder.

Obviously when people moan about Londoners buying up property in Cornwall, they aren't thinking of an Afro-Caribbean single mother who rents a council flat in Hackney. No chance, she can't afford to buy anywhere - she's just as much a victim of the fucked-up housing market as someone born to a family originally from St Ives. The ones people are complaining about are invariably white, probably bought a house in London 30 years ago for peanuts and have found themselves millionaires without lifting a finger. Then they retire to somewhere pretty, complain about church bells, and wonder why the village school is closing when anyone of child-rearing age has been priced out by them.

Orangesare · 16/02/2023 01:42

It is just to ensure locals can afford to buy and the five year rule is a long enough period so people don’t move in snap up the housing. Anyone can buy if they meet the conditions
I live in a rural area in a restricted house, although not local occupancy and in an area with many houses with restrictions and it’s a good thing because recently house prices have risen so much it’s pricing local people out of the market. Where do people go when they can’t afford or find somewhere to live? If I hadn’t bought a restrictive property I would have uprooted everyone and inflicted the same problem on a poorer rural community further north. And then where do the local people there live?

Fredshred · 16/02/2023 00:26

HyacinthineMacaw · 14/02/2023 09:51

I live in the Cotswolds. The village I grew up in is within commuting distance of three cities. The houses are now so expensive they are only affordable by people who work miles away, in very well-paying jobs. They are out from 7-7 or more. Nobody is around during the day.

They have utterly priced out all the local people who work in regular jobs locally. And then complain that they can’t find childminders, gardeners, mechanics, plumbers, that there’s no shop in the village, the pub can’t get enough staff to open all weekend, that there aren’t any activities in the village for their children.

Communities are a very large part of what makes a place special. These places are turning into commuter dormitories. Local Plan policies can do a lot to address these issues of place making, and should be doing so. Diversity isn’t just about ethnic make up.

Absolutely this. But having read all of the OP’s posts, I see it’s not an issue she wants to address. It’s a very real issue (and OP, “key workers” aren’t the only ones priced out of an area. Those (many, many people), honestly working for a living but earning less than “key workers’ might also want homes to live in and resent being priced out of their local market by city commuters who artificially inflate their house prices).

Ceilingplaits · 16/02/2023 00:01

CatJumperTwat · 14/02/2023 20:01

Why on earth do you (and others in this thread) want to prop up greedy private landlords by forcing people to rent?

If you care about housing you'd want to stamp out private lettings.

I don't. Personally I believe all housing should be social housing. No one has a right to own. But I was pointing out that anyone who has lived in that area for five years is then eligible to buy the properties the OP is talking about, so if someone genuinely wanted to live there (rather than buy up properties as holiday homes or air BnB lets) they could move there and rent first.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 20:56

It's an endless pattern of destruction. Gone are those family and friend support networks. And instead paid child care, trying to manage with tiny families and limited support, isolation and poor mental health. I would think, if there's a desire for people to stay closer to home, that people should be able to secure affordable housing near their family networks so they can do that.

Exactly, and I don't agree that it should only be for key workers. As you say, what about a mum who's not a key worker but relies on family for childcare, or simply someone who wants to be safe being close to family and life-long friends?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 20:54

WiIson · 15/02/2023 20:13

Maybe the op thinks there's something in it for them.

It's very likely.

greenleader · 15/02/2023 20:48

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:00

There si difference between providing social housing (renting to those who need it) and this scheme on buying. Plus 10 years is bit disproportionate admittedly.

No one sane will try to sue this scheme. They wouldn't just be hated in area, but in every part of GB where this scheme is (not sure if s106 in all uk, but EA2010 only applies to GB so would probably need different case for NI ). They would also most likely lose and have to emigrate frankly.

Indeed. It looks like the courts would probably find that the measures in Dartmoor are indirect racial discrimination but they might be deemed acceptable and proportionate to acheive the aims being sought in a way they were not for Hillingdon. We'll only really know if the case is actually tested in court.

WiIson · 15/02/2023 20:30

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:24

I am sure you have this scheme too or will have soon. It'slaunching all over.

hoa.org.uk/advice/guides-for-homeowners/i-am-buying/first-homes-scheme/

Now the one op is talking about is older, but it's the same princip. Local workers and locals can get discount (on overpriced newbuilds though). Properties are earmarked from it in developments like with social housing for example.

I did learn something new from this thread! I was aware of it with £1 houses. You had to be local and you then had to live there for 5 years afaik. You also had to be continuously at work last 5 years.

Thats brilliant. I do hope it comes to where I am soon.

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:24

Stomacharmeleon · 15/02/2023 20:14

Wish we had it to protect the communities where I live in the South East. Depending on where you live in the country that will reflect who makes up your community and then that should be protected. I don't think it's prejudiced. Sorry.

I am sure you have this scheme too or will have soon. It'slaunching all over.

hoa.org.uk/advice/guides-for-homeowners/i-am-buying/first-homes-scheme/

Now the one op is talking about is older, but it's the same princip. Local workers and locals can get discount (on overpriced newbuilds though). Properties are earmarked from it in developments like with social housing for example.

I did learn something new from this thread! I was aware of it with £1 houses. You had to be local and you then had to live there for 5 years afaik. You also had to be continuously at work last 5 years.

WiIson · 15/02/2023 20:24

It's a big loss. My children will have to move away when it comes to trying to get housing. Same for the majority really unless they become really high earning. Or stay at home for ever. And they in turn force other communities to move out. It's an endless pattern of destruction. Gone are those family and friend support networks. And instead paid child care, trying to manage with tiny families and limited support, isolation and poor mental health. I would think, if there's a desire for people to stay closer to home, that people should be able to secure affordable housing near their family networks so they can do that.

Stomacharmeleon · 15/02/2023 20:14

Wish we had it to protect the communities where I live in the South East. Depending on where you live in the country that will reflect who makes up your community and then that should be protected. I don't think it's prejudiced. Sorry.

WiIson · 15/02/2023 20:13

Maybe the op thinks there's something in it for them.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 20:12

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:09

I am going more with hoped it will lead to some good racist posts

I'm not sure. OP's questions are very targeted and specific

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:09

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 20:04

Agreed. But OP seems to be on a mission trying to extract information on MN in order to do something. It's not clear what. Lefty MN saviours and others are obliging

Those pesky Dartmoor locals had better be prepared (especially those who are white and Christians - I'm only paraphrasing OP's words)

I am going more with hoped it will lead to some good racist posts

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 20:04

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:00

There si difference between providing social housing (renting to those who need it) and this scheme on buying. Plus 10 years is bit disproportionate admittedly.

No one sane will try to sue this scheme. They wouldn't just be hated in area, but in every part of GB where this scheme is (not sure if s106 in all uk, but EA2010 only applies to GB so would probably need different case for NI ). They would also most likely lose and have to emigrate frankly.

Agreed. But OP seems to be on a mission trying to extract information on MN in order to do something. It's not clear what. Lefty MN saviours and others are obliging

Those pesky Dartmoor locals had better be prepared (especially those who are white and Christians - I'm only paraphrasing OP's words)

Bubblebubblebah · 15/02/2023 20:00

There si difference between providing social housing (renting to those who need it) and this scheme on buying. Plus 10 years is bit disproportionate admittedly.

No one sane will try to sue this scheme. They wouldn't just be hated in area, but in every part of GB where this scheme is (not sure if s106 in all uk, but EA2010 only applies to GB so would probably need different case for NI ). They would also most likely lose and have to emigrate frankly.

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 19:58

Maybe OP you believe refugees are more worthy of being in Dartmoor than local families?

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 19:57

dartmoorgirl12 · 15/02/2023 18:59

I love that Mumsnet can come up with this stuff. Thanks so much, @greenleader , that's so interesting.

It was a refugee in this case. It's unclear where he got the funds for this

thehorsehasnowbolted · 15/02/2023 19:49

It seems the OP wants to sue. It's not clear why as she is not affected

WiIson · 15/02/2023 19:37

workistoomuch · 15/02/2023 19:26

But what about the people who grew up near London and can't afford to live there because of all the people who came with their money? Or in our case a 1 hour commute from London whose house prices have almost doubled in the last 5 years. It does seem ridiculous that there are no protections for locals in most of the South East. I've never seen any round us.

I agree there should be. Young people in in the south east are also forced out from the communities within which they grew up, away from family, friends and networks. Because they've been priced out by people from more affluent places cashing in on their expensive London properties.