Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think charity donations aren't appreciated?

93 replies

USERJ · 13/02/2023 22:08

I saw a viral Tik tok of a lady in what looked like a donation centre, going through the bags and making complaints about what people have put in these bags. (Dirty clothes I agree is completely unwanted!!)
But some things she complained about were a pair of high heeled shoes, a religious outfit and some items which can be considered out of fashion. Now whilst I appreciate if you had just lost everything in an earthquake you may not be thinking of high heels straight away but surely they would be of use to someone? Someone who needs heels for a job? For a job interview? Or for any special occasions coming up?
The religious outfit she seemed to mock just makes me lost for words. I then looked at the comments and similar videos were shared from different donation centres of other volunteers complaining for example a sports top that was bobbly...like really?? (My clothes are bobbly!!)
I'm not saying all donation centres do this but AIBU to be annoyed by watching this video?

OP posts:
plumduck · 14/02/2023 06:27

Jelly89 · 13/02/2023 23:12

Just think, if you and your family were suddenly made homeless without any belongings would you want high heels and a random religious outfit? Most people wouldn’t have use for these and most charities work in crisis situations and don’t have use for these items either.

Yes this. If it was for the earthquake then people need to think!

BubziOwl · 14/02/2023 06:27

FKATondelayo · 13/02/2023 23:27

Shipping vast quantities of second hand western clothing to African countries has destroyed local clothing manufacture and retail.

I really think we need to stop thinking passing on our used clothing is charitable. It really isn't and it locks us in a cycle of buying too much and then thinking we can get rid of it in a benevolent and helpful manner. I wonder if an unintended effect of having so many charity shops is this fast fashion cycle.

Definitely agree with this

BubziOwl · 14/02/2023 06:25

I've volunteered in several charity shops over the years and I must say that I had a different experience to many on here in that we were quite happy to have unwearable clothes donated as we would send them to the rag man for money 🤷‍♀️ we also definitely would sell wearable but bobbly clothes for £1 or so, and there was no problem getting them sold (I myself bought many of them!).

We did have enough volunteers to sift through all the donation bags though, so I suppose that helped.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 14/02/2023 06:16

treasurefoil · 14/02/2023 01:11

We should feel guilty about the amount of waste we produce. Though it seems cheaper to buy online and at primark for example, than to actually buy clothes from charity shops. There's a big gap now in what's right and more education and understanding needs to happen. School uniforms are a big issue for Me, expecting parents to pay more and more for uniform which then can't be recycled because they need everything badged. That's not giving anyone a chance

I know in the past (not so much now as I don't really buy clothes anymore) but it used to make me feel a bit ill mentally calculating how much all these unworn or worn once clothes must've cost. I'm lucky I wasn't a teen in the whole cheap fast fashion, I would've been out of control

treasurefoil · 14/02/2023 01:11

Whatifthegrassisblue · 14/02/2023 00:25

I'm finding this thread really interesting. I've always had a charity box and most of my things are (what I deem) to be good quality items. I wonder if when we donate, really we are trying to alleviate guilt of being wasteful? The thought of throwing these items horrifies me a bit, but I've noticed in the past couple of years that charity shops seem to all have plenty if not too much in the first place. I now try and give away items on my local neighbourhood site so it goes to people who want the items and I'm not clogging up stores with unwanted goods. I'm starting to feel embarrassed and quite claustrophobic with just how much stuff I have, equally I don't buy that much anymore but I do still buy things that I probably don't need

We should feel guilty about the amount of waste we produce. Though it seems cheaper to buy online and at primark for example, than to actually buy clothes from charity shops. There's a big gap now in what's right and more education and understanding needs to happen. School uniforms are a big issue for Me, expecting parents to pay more and more for uniform which then can't be recycled because they need everything badged. That's not giving anyone a chance

FelicityBeedle · 14/02/2023 00:51

Oops I didn’t upload the picture of the mountain of donations at this warehouse

To think charity donations aren't appreciated?
Easternext · 14/02/2023 00:39

FKATondelayo · 13/02/2023 22:59

Why do these collections still happen? Why are people in the UK sending used clothing that costs time and money to sort and ship to a country that is a major manufacturer of clothing and textiles? This cannot be a good use of limited time and resources. If you want to donate, donate cash to DEC/Red Cross.

Who has spare cash right now? these people think they are helping!!! Maybe a list off things that are acceptable should be posted all over social media so more people think bobbly jumpers and holey leggings aren't good enough, I would never donate something in a condition that I wouldn't buy it.

MrsMikeDrop · 14/02/2023 00:26

USERJ · 13/02/2023 22:45

Not everyone can afford to go out and buy new clothes for themselves never mind new clothes to donate. I don't see anything wrong with donating clothes that have been worn that may not fit anymore, everyone has a use for something. I agree that fancy dress / lingerie type clothing is not appropriate but even so donating shirts, or smart items of clothing could be of use to someone.
It wasn't just the earthquake donations it was a few different videos linked in the comments and I couldn't believe the comments some of the volunteers were making about clothes being "tacky" or saying "err what is that" about something that is reasonable to wear but might not be their taste!

Maybe this is where you are mistaken though, not everything is of use to someone. That may have been the case, but I don't think it is anymore

Whatifthegrassisblue · 14/02/2023 00:25

I'm finding this thread really interesting. I've always had a charity box and most of my things are (what I deem) to be good quality items. I wonder if when we donate, really we are trying to alleviate guilt of being wasteful? The thought of throwing these items horrifies me a bit, but I've noticed in the past couple of years that charity shops seem to all have plenty if not too much in the first place. I now try and give away items on my local neighbourhood site so it goes to people who want the items and I'm not clogging up stores with unwanted goods. I'm starting to feel embarrassed and quite claustrophobic with just how much stuff I have, equally I don't buy that much anymore but I do still buy things that I probably don't need

MichaelFabricantWig · 13/02/2023 23:50

Livelovebehappy · 13/02/2023 23:35

There’s a cost of living crisis going on in the U.K. atm. Giving ‘cash’ isn’t something a lot of people can do, the alternative being to give something that can be used by the people who need it, ie clothes, bedding etc. Warm clothes are what’s needed for the people in Turkey/Syria in the immediate aftermath. Not cash.

The big charities involved in disaster response say to give money. However well meaning most of the crap people donate will end up in landfill not actually helping anyone.

MichaelFabricantWig · 13/02/2023 23:49

YABU

People just use “charity” as an excuse to offload all the old crap they have that they can’t be arsed taking to the dump. Give cash not old junk.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 13/02/2023 23:46

Warm clothes are needed

what’s not needed is black bags full of a random assortment of jumpers, trousers and coats being loaded into a transit van with a vague idea of driving to turkey.

Its inefficient, time consuming and causes more problems locally. Leave it to the professionals. Send cash ti the DEC.

Livelovebehappy · 13/02/2023 23:35

Clymene · 13/02/2023 23:05

I wish all the donations of stuff would just stop. Give cash

There’s a cost of living crisis going on in the U.K. atm. Giving ‘cash’ isn’t something a lot of people can do, the alternative being to give something that can be used by the people who need it, ie clothes, bedding etc. Warm clothes are what’s needed for the people in Turkey/Syria in the immediate aftermath. Not cash.

ZiriForEver · 13/02/2023 23:32

The world is full of used clothing. Full. Only a part is worth donating to someone as an item if clothing. Recycling rags isn't act of kindness, it is a simple responsibility.
When it comes to disasters and tragedies abroad, the quality and appropriateness matters even more - why would anyone waste fuel, storage space and time of several people in the chain.

Not everyone has money to buy new stuff to donate - yes, and it is ok. Just don't expect gratitude for the bobbly stuff. It will be dealt with, but the less quality pieces are part of the reality and the real work, not something which should be highly appreciated.

FKATondelayo · 13/02/2023 23:27

Shipping vast quantities of second hand western clothing to African countries has destroyed local clothing manufacture and retail.

I really think we need to stop thinking passing on our used clothing is charitable. It really isn't and it locks us in a cycle of buying too much and then thinking we can get rid of it in a benevolent and helpful manner. I wonder if an unintended effect of having so many charity shops is this fast fashion cycle.

Reugny · 13/02/2023 23:21

When I do a clear out of my clothes and shoes only 5% I deem good enough to go to a charity shop. The rest gets put in a textile recycling bin or in landfill.

With my DD clothes at the moment 80% of her stuff can be reused by someone even though some of it is already second hand.

There are enough programmes that are available online which shows your dirty, stained and bobbly clothing will be shipped to developing countries to cause pollution as no one wants it.

Northernsouloldies · 13/02/2023 23:13

The rule of thumb I use is if I wouldn't wear it, use it, or eat it I wouldn't donate it. Think that every time I see tins of ye old oak tins of hotdogs in food bank collection trollies.

Jelly89 · 13/02/2023 23:12

Just think, if you and your family were suddenly made homeless without any belongings would you want high heels and a random religious outfit? Most people wouldn’t have use for these and most charities work in crisis situations and don’t have use for these items either.

Lbnc2021 · 13/02/2023 23:11

my mum worked in a charity shops, she’s found dirty sanitary towels and all sorts in the bags.

Violinist64 · 13/02/2023 23:10

I regularly donate to charity shops. If I have a bundle of clothes that are past their best, l put them in a separate bag clearly marked “rags” as the shop will get money. My rule of thumb for donations is whether they are in a good enough condition to be sold. Clothing and textiles should be freshly laundered. This should surely also apply to clothes being sent out to refugees.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 13/02/2023 23:08

I am a volunteer in a charity shop. A lot of what we get is not sellable. In very bad condition, misshapen, missing buttons, broken zips, very washed out, stained. And that’s just the textiles. Let’s not get started on the chipped mugs, broken toys and ripped books.

at least we can send all the textiles to be recycled. The rest of the stuff costs is money to get rid of.

seriously it’s not hard. “Would I pay my orb money for this”? If you would, donate it. If not, recycle.

I dint make videos of sons of the worst donations though. Maybe I should.

Anoisagusaris · 13/02/2023 23:07

At least with charity shops they have a chance of selling the kid’s Halloween costume or sequinned mini skirt or beach dress whereas none are remotely useful to people in a cold climate in the immediate aftermath of an earthquake.

Gazelda · 13/02/2023 23:06

I think you are being unfair OP.

You admit that you don't know where this activity took place, nor what cause it was for. So how can you possibly judge if the sorters were being unreasonable.

Your title is also unfair. Of course charities are grateful for donations. They couldn't operate without donations.

is the purpose of your post to spark debate? Or is it to find any old reason to criticise charities?

Clymene · 13/02/2023 23:05

I wish all the donations of stuff would just stop. Give cash

Grimchmas · 13/02/2023 23:04

It's a massive problem and drain on the resources of all of the charities/groups who collect nd distribute donations.

It's a waste of time having to pick out the dirty clothes, the high heeled shoes and the fancy dress witch outfits when you're taking the clothing to the immediate afternath of an earthquake zone. You then have to PAY out of charity funds to get rid of the crap. They may or may not be able to redonate or redistribute to a more appropriate outlet who may be able to sell them in a charity shop, but if what they've asked for is warm, clean clothing, anything else is actively hindering their relief efforts.

It's a big problem.