Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think charity donations aren't appreciated?

93 replies

USERJ · 13/02/2023 22:08

I saw a viral Tik tok of a lady in what looked like a donation centre, going through the bags and making complaints about what people have put in these bags. (Dirty clothes I agree is completely unwanted!!)
But some things she complained about were a pair of high heeled shoes, a religious outfit and some items which can be considered out of fashion. Now whilst I appreciate if you had just lost everything in an earthquake you may not be thinking of high heels straight away but surely they would be of use to someone? Someone who needs heels for a job? For a job interview? Or for any special occasions coming up?
The religious outfit she seemed to mock just makes me lost for words. I then looked at the comments and similar videos were shared from different donation centres of other volunteers complaining for example a sports top that was bobbly...like really?? (My clothes are bobbly!!)
I'm not saying all donation centres do this but AIBU to be annoyed by watching this video?

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 08:43

Quveas · 14/02/2023 08:23

My clothes are bobbly, but I wouldn’t donate them to someone who has just lost their whole world. You should be annoyed at the people who donate useless crap, not the video highlighting it.

I disagree. Items donated may not be of any practical use for all sorts of reasons, but that doesn't mean those items are "useless crap" to the person donating. You have no idea what that persons life is like or what they have in their wardrobe (assuming they have a wardrobe). Your "useless crap" could have been the best clothes they had. Not everyone is able to donate pristine clothes new from the shop. It is crass of either staff or volunteers to post such rude and judgemental videos, and they should be ashamed of themselves - to say nothing of the fact that it harms the charity.

Yes, some people may deliberately dump their rubbish on charities. It is easy enough to dispense with those things quietly. But some of that "rubbish" may be their cherished items. Not everyone enjoys the lifestyle you obviously do.

As for what someone who has lost their whole world would want, if a bobbly jumper is the thing available when it is freezing cold, I am pretty sure they'd like it. This is a disaster, not a fashion parade.

Someone's "useless crap" may be useful to another person but that doesn't justify dumping non saleable stuff on charity shops just for the feelgood factor. All you are doing is making work and costing them money.

Shipping bobbly jumpers which may or may not be suitable for the weather conditions to a disaster zone just costs them money and undermines the local economy.

Send money. If you can't send money then find someone who actually wants the stuff you no longer need, don't expect someone else to rehouse your unsaleable goods.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 14/02/2023 08:42

We love people who give us bags clearly marked "rags" or "recycling".

Thanks so much to everyone who takes the time to do that.

lljkk · 14/02/2023 08:41

Not that hard to sell stuff on ebay to benefit specific charities.

FatSealSmugSoup · 14/02/2023 08:38

I donate a lot to my local charity shop - lost socks/faded shit washed and in a separate bag marked “clean for recycling”.

im finding it difficult to part with my heels but too immobile to walk in them. I’ll definitely donate at some point and envisage the local teens tottering around on a Friday night.

I don’t sell the stuff (even if bnwt) because frankly I can’t be arsed with eBay/Vinted/postage/dishonest buyers.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 14/02/2023 08:33

But @Quveas the time taken in sorting all those donations and transporting them is just not efficient. Big charities could be on the phone this morning to a supplier in Turkey, or a second hand warehouse in Turkey and have 5000 jumpers or coats in Gazientep by this afternoon. That's what is needed. Not people all over Europe donating their old clothes which need to be assessed, sorted, transported. We are not doing a good thing by dumping our waste on them.

It really is VERY simple when it comes to donating to a charity shop. Would I pay good money for this item? Would I be happy to give it to my mum/sister/friend to use? If yes, donate it. If you wouldn't give it to a neighbour/friend but have this vague idea that "someone" might be able to get use of it, don't. Because that "someone" is probably not out there.

And also echo what @slashlover says about laws and policies. We have a big long list of what we can't sell by law, and what we don't sell by policy. Things like toy guns, anything racist/sexist/homophobic (golly toys, for example), safety equipment like car seats, life jackets, rubber rings, cot mattresses, anything fake/counterfeit, anything electrical which plugs into the mains (must be PAT tested and we can't), children's nightwear/clothing without the fire warning, toys without the CE label... list is endless.

WhatNoRaisins · 14/02/2023 08:27

Thing is no one has to donate. It's better to not donate than donate inappropriate things that just waste time. It shouldn't be about the warm fuzzy feelings of the person donating.

There is plenty of appropriate clothing being manufactured far closer to this area. Money to buy this is a no brainer.

Quveas · 14/02/2023 08:23

My clothes are bobbly, but I wouldn’t donate them to someone who has just lost their whole world. You should be annoyed at the people who donate useless crap, not the video highlighting it.

I disagree. Items donated may not be of any practical use for all sorts of reasons, but that doesn't mean those items are "useless crap" to the person donating. You have no idea what that persons life is like or what they have in their wardrobe (assuming they have a wardrobe). Your "useless crap" could have been the best clothes they had. Not everyone is able to donate pristine clothes new from the shop. It is crass of either staff or volunteers to post such rude and judgemental videos, and they should be ashamed of themselves - to say nothing of the fact that it harms the charity.

Yes, some people may deliberately dump their rubbish on charities. It is easy enough to dispense with those things quietly. But some of that "rubbish" may be their cherished items. Not everyone enjoys the lifestyle you obviously do.

As for what someone who has lost their whole world would want, if a bobbly jumper is the thing available when it is freezing cold, I am pretty sure they'd like it. This is a disaster, not a fashion parade.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 14/02/2023 08:17

And nobody wants tv units. However well made. We had two of those black glass ones in the shop for weeks, probably expensive new as they were sturdy and heavy. Think we started off at a tenner each. Didn't sell. Half priced to £4.99. Didn't sell. Half priced again to £2.49, didn't sell. At that point, one went in the skip, the other we use in the window covered with fabric to display things on. Bulky items are very hard to sell as people need to arrange transport to take them away. If you have come on the bus, you can't easily take it home.

This idea that anything will sell if it's cheap enough is just so wrong. Off the top of my head things which will not sell because nobody wants - men's "work" shirts unless BNWT. Ties, even the silk ones. Cut glass decanters. CD stands/racks. VHS video cassettes. Loom bands. Cold shoulder style tops.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/02/2023 08:16

Livelovebehappy · 13/02/2023 23:35

There’s a cost of living crisis going on in the U.K. atm. Giving ‘cash’ isn’t something a lot of people can do, the alternative being to give something that can be used by the people who need it, ie clothes, bedding etc. Warm clothes are what’s needed for the people in Turkey/Syria in the immediate aftermath. Not cash.

You know it costs money to ship objects to a third country? Quite often it costs significantly more than buying the items locally (as well as undermining local economies struggling to recover).

Additionally the type of clothing provided may not be appropriate to the conditions - most people in the UK will have no clue about what is best or sufficient for that part of the world.

Disaster zones are not dumping grounds. Sell the stuff if its any good, and send the proceeds - its more useful.

slashlover · 14/02/2023 08:15

Also, people if we reject your donation it's not personal.

Black glass TV units don't sell (even tried to give them away free at one point), we legally can't take car seats, we don't have the space for Christmas trees in January, we don't take H&S equipment such as wheelchairs as it's a liability.

We also do uplifts and ask if furniture has the fire safety label on the phone. DO NOT LIE TO US. We wont "just uplift it anyway" and you'll have wasted the charity's time.

Spanielsarepainless · 14/02/2023 08:13

And as regards the earthquake, some person on our local news was asking for unwanted medicines to be donated rather than given back to the pharmacy. She wasn't a doctor. I can't help feeling that is wrong on all sorts of fronts.

slashlover · 14/02/2023 08:11

FearTheWankingDead · 14/02/2023 08:04

I have seen my local charity shop van at the dump. They were dumping bags of clothes and other items and big items like furniture. It was all in good condition. There was a retro tv unit with glass that was expensive - maybe £100 worth.

I won’t be donating there again. Why didn’t they sell it for 50p rather than trash it?! Especially when there’s a cost of living crisis and someone skint could have bought it all.

The problem is that while something may objectively be worth £100, you need the right buyer and it might not even sell at 50p.

We've had items which sell on ebay for £20 (we have a £30 minimum for ebay items) which we can't even sell for £1 because it's niche or not commercial.

Lcb123 · 14/02/2023 08:11

Donating clothes generally is not helpful to those affected by the earthquake. Massive logistics required to sort, transport and distribute. And very demeaning to just be given clothes, esp if inappropriate. Everyone should give money if they can. It’s used best by local and international organisations who know how best to help

Spanielsarepainless · 14/02/2023 08:10

One of our local charities used to run a dress agency so the charity and the seller got half each. The place was always packed. I have things, and non-clothes, that I would love to do this with as I don't sell via eBay etc.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 14/02/2023 08:06

MrsMikeDrop · 14/02/2023 07:39

I also think people don't realise their crap is crap. I'm shocked at what some people try and sell on my local community site, stuff that you wouldn't even want for free!

This is very true. The number of times someone has handed over a bag and said "there's some really good stuff in there" and you open it up and it's all unsellable stuff like chipped mugs, fake handbags, ridiculously bobbly clothing or broken toys. People have emotional attachment to their "stuff" and convince themselves that they are being amazingly generous. I do also think they are super conscious that they don't want to put stuff in landfill so pass it to us.

Clothing which can't be sold can go to be recycled. Some of it is resold here or overseas, the stuff which is past it gets shredded, treated, and used for things like mattress stuffing.

I understand the emotional response to the earthquake and feeling that you want to help. But although it might make YOU feel better to have a bit of a clear out and hand in a bag with some old clothing and sleeping bags that is really not helping. They have clothing in other parts of Turkey. And what's more efficient - collecting thousands of bags of random clothing which has to be assessed, sorted into categories, repacked, transported across Europe, unpacked in Turkey, then find a local partner to help distribute OR let the big charities like Red Cross, Oxfam, Save the Children who have been doing this sort of work for 80 years buy 5000 jumpers/coats from one of their suppliers, fly them in on an aid flight and use their established network to distribute? Same thing happened this time last year in Ukraine.

And yes, a large amount of the problem is fast fashion, shopping as a hobby not because you need new clothes, "hauls" on Instagram. We should all be buying less stuff. The planet is drowning in it.

FearTheWankingDead · 14/02/2023 08:04

I have seen my local charity shop van at the dump. They were dumping bags of clothes and other items and big items like furniture. It was all in good condition. There was a retro tv unit with glass that was expensive - maybe £100 worth.

I won’t be donating there again. Why didn’t they sell it for 50p rather than trash it?! Especially when there’s a cost of living crisis and someone skint could have bought it all.

MinBins · 14/02/2023 08:01

This charity was asking donations for people displaced who had lost family and everything they own. If you saw the second video she explained that they received dirty underwear, unwearable items. I disagreed when they pulled out children's party dresses, with Eid around the corner it could have be worn.

I can't help but think we put ourselves on a pedestal when we expect people to be happy with these, dirty, old clothes as shown in video. Because they are people just like us. In the midst of a catastrophe. They need warm clothes, toiletries, sanitary items, nappies, blankets. Not a clear-out of cast off items deserving of the dump. It takes two minutes to buy and donate, actually useful items.

Imagine being there surviving with your kids, and not having nappies, items you really need. I think that was the essence message.

Forestdweller11 · 14/02/2023 07:54

I'm another one who has two boxes/ bags. One for rags and one for charity. I also wash and fold neatly clothes I'm donating, any games etc I make sure all bits are there. I also batch my charity boxes so that all children's clothes are in one box, books in another, kitchen bits in another etc. So that it's an easy sort at the charity end. I always think would I want to buy this. I also donate to a local volunteer group work wear, overalls, safety shoes etc for their volunteers to use. Anything not suitable for charity goes in the rag/ shoe bin, again clean/paired up .

slashlover · 14/02/2023 07:48

If I have a bundle of clothes that are past their best, l put them in a separate bag clearly marked “rags” as the shop will get money.

I work in a charity shop. Thank you for marking the rag bags, it helps us so, so much.

Things we have had in the past - used sex toys, bag of clothes with a used condom randomly in the middle, clothes which stick of smoke/weed, bedclothes which had obviously just been taking off of a bed and shoved in a black bag, broken toys, broken crockery, bags of used socks, bags of clothes which kitchen knives randomly inside.

Also, if you're one of the people who dumps stuff outside while we're closed then there's a special place in hell for you.

Imnoonesfool · 14/02/2023 07:42

i currently volunteer for a baby charity where we take donations for babies up to one year and toys we are able to sell. I can honestly say I will empty a full donations bin (think dumpster size) and there will only be a handful of suitable items we can use the rest has to be ragged or binned. But the majority of toys we get are either broken/very old or have missing parts. Lots of clothes are dirty or stained or not relevant to our charity. Then the worst which is most days we are sifting through bags where people are clearly having a clear out. Think old pencil cases and there contents, odd socks, mens old boxer shorts etc etc.

mot saddens me as we have to rag perfectly good clothes which are just not suited to our charity.

MrsMikeDrop · 14/02/2023 07:39

I also think people don't realise their crap is crap. I'm shocked at what some people try and sell on my local community site, stuff that you wouldn't even want for free!

HaroldTheStallion · 14/02/2023 07:32

I think a big part of the problem for charity shops is that so many people are selling their nicer secondhand clothes on Vinted or elsewhere. Therefore they only give things to charity shops that aren't worth selling. I don't know what the solution is though.

So what is the best thing to do with clothes that are bobbly but basically OK? I have too many long sleeved plain cotton shirts for example that are bobbly that I wear under jumpers. Do I throw them in the bin when having a clear out or donate them somewhere? I really don't know what is best and I'd imagine a lot of other people don't either.

And another reason charity shops are getting rubbish - for a lot of people (hoarders and those with hoarding tendencies) having a clear out is a very difficult thing psychologically and, depending on the amount of stuff, potentially physically. People may not have the energy to sort things properly, wash them, etc. Not excusing it just pointing it out.

Indáirire · 14/02/2023 07:12

I think it's unreasonable of charities to expect lots of cash or brand new clothes. Most people would just buy new clothes for themselves if they have the money. Who can afford new clothes for a charity, unless they're very rich? I dropped in a bag of clothes to the charity shop yesterday: all spotlessly clean, in good condition. Obviously leaving used knickers in a bag is a absolutely disgusting but I guess there's no way of sussing out who has done that.

UdoU · 14/02/2023 06:30

SueVineer · 13/02/2023 22:50

That’s the point of charity shops though. That’s why they are getting stuff for free

No one wants your old rubbish, Sue.

Nimbostratus100 · 14/02/2023 06:29

high heels are a total obscenity with no place in the modern world

Piece of military kit designed for remaining on your horse during a cavalry charge, sexualised into an item of clothing that disables a woman

No one should be "normalising" that crap - surely we have moved on as a species

Swipe left for the next trending thread