Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think charity donations aren't appreciated?

93 replies

USERJ · 13/02/2023 22:08

I saw a viral Tik tok of a lady in what looked like a donation centre, going through the bags and making complaints about what people have put in these bags. (Dirty clothes I agree is completely unwanted!!)
But some things she complained about were a pair of high heeled shoes, a religious outfit and some items which can be considered out of fashion. Now whilst I appreciate if you had just lost everything in an earthquake you may not be thinking of high heels straight away but surely they would be of use to someone? Someone who needs heels for a job? For a job interview? Or for any special occasions coming up?
The religious outfit she seemed to mock just makes me lost for words. I then looked at the comments and similar videos were shared from different donation centres of other volunteers complaining for example a sports top that was bobbly...like really?? (My clothes are bobbly!!)
I'm not saying all donation centres do this but AIBU to be annoyed by watching this video?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WiltingLobelia · 19/02/2023 13:58

Way back in the day I was working in a job that helped sort charity donations for victims of a natural disaster.

One big shoe chain donated 100s of shoes.

Left shoes. All of them.

Not useful.

Sometimes you do think WTF! I am sympathetric to people who really want to help. That's fine, even if it can be hit or miss. It's when people ' companioes use it as an excuse to get rid of complete and utter shite. It's like the time when I had a newborn and a friend of DHs got out old and broken toys, VHS tapes etc from their garage and gave it to us commenting that it might be useful to us, otherwise we could just tip it. What he meant was 'This is no use to me, so you can tip it for me'.

SharonEllis · 19/02/2023 13:52

FKATondelayo · 19/02/2023 10:33

Onjali Rauf, the author and refugee campaigner tweeted this today:
twitter.com/OnjaliRauf/status/1627238564227346432?s=20

Nobody should be sending used clothes to people in need. It makes the giver feel better - not the recipient.

Exactly - its all about the giver. Which is why, if you say something everybody bleats about the feeling of the poor donor who was so desperate to 'do something' so you can't 'criticise'. Its white saviour, unthinking, ignorant self indulgence.Drives me up the wall.

FKATondelayo · 19/02/2023 10:33

Onjali Rauf, the author and refugee campaigner tweeted this today:
twitter.com/OnjaliRauf/status/1627238564227346432?s=20

Nobody should be sending used clothes to people in need. It makes the giver feel better - not the recipient.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 17/02/2023 08:00

It's not complicated at all @TessoftheDubonnet . Would I buy this myself. Easy question. Be realistic.

But many people who donate get really offended about it, there are countless threads about charity shop volunteers not falling over themselves in gratitude over their bags of tat. If you're unsure, pick up the phone. As if they can PAT test electronics, or take bags of rags.

TessoftheDubonnet · 15/02/2023 21:03

It's not complicated:

Disaster aid or help for underdeveloped countries: cash donations
Charity shops: good quality, nearly new clothing and shoes, books, handbags, crockery, jewellery, toys etc in good condition and without bits missing,
Clothes bank: all other (clean) textiles
(Some pet charities welcome clean towels or bed linen)

Nobody wants dirty or broken things in any shape or form, or outdated encyclopedias and the like.

earsup · 15/02/2023 20:37

I used to volunteer in a shop...a lot of old dirty items donated including a lovely pair of dungarees, whose owner at some point, had severe diarhea...why not just bin stuff like this..??...our council dump is closer than the shops so take it there !

HermioneWeasley · 15/02/2023 20:34

Warm clothes are needed, but as other have said, collecting them here and driving them to Turkey and Syria where then then have to be sorted again and distributed is not helping. If you want to help (rather than just make yourself feel better) then donate cash. I know not everyone has spare cash at the moment, and that’s fine. Just share the DEC fundraising link so others can. Don’t delude yourself that by giving an old coat in this country you’re helping in any way.

MargaretThursday · 15/02/2023 20:31

Having recently been going through a huge mound of donations then the Op is wrong.

Yes, it would be much better in a lot of ways if everyone who gave a bag of stuff gave £5, but the reality is that you get fairly little that way. People are (naturally) suspicious of giving money and also people may be happy to give the sleeping bag that was bought for DofE ten years ago and used once, cost of £30, but don't have £30 spare to give.
I would give a plea that if you are in the situation that you want to give and are happy to give money, do some research for the charity you want to support and find somewhere where you are happy your money will be used wisely. But if you want to give item, look at what they're asking for and keep within those bounds. If you're unsure then ask. They'll happily tell you whether they will send over a couple of teddies. Let them make the decision not you. It's not personal, it's practical.

When you hand your bag of worn pyjamas over to the people who have asked for good quality coats only, you need to realise that, firstly, you're by no means the only one, so it's not a case of just your little bag. Secondly the area it's stored in may be limited so by giving that bag they may be forced to turn away a more useful donation. But also, if you are sending stuff out to a disaster zone, it costs to send things. They're not going to send a lovely pair of high heels when they can send something far more essential for life. Give the high heels to a charity shop where they can get money for it, or put them on marketplace and donate the money yourself.
If they say that they'll take rags and get money for them, that's a different matter.

It is amazing how people give in such circumstances. We were overwhelmed with the amount people had brought.
There were some things that we knew couldn't be sent over due to weight or wouldn't get used, but were sensible thoughts. We made sure they went to places that would get used.
But honestly, who thinks that Turkey needs a sausage dog draught excluder or two copies of "letter A" Encyclopedia Britanica?

Lovemusic33 · 15/02/2023 20:28

Anoisagusaris · 13/02/2023 22:31

People use these charity collections as a way of clearing out wardrobes, the way they would donate to a charity shop, rather than selecting items that would actually be useful in the particular situation.

Exactly this. People just want to get rid of stuff, they don’t think about each item they are putting into the bag. Obviously heals are not really needed, warm clothes are needed, these people are living in freezing conditions, sleeping in cars or on the streets. Jumpers, scarfs, gloves, warm socks and sensible shoes are needed. I think a lot of people use it as an excuse to get rid of all there old clothes that are fit for the bin.

XenoBitch · 15/02/2023 20:24

SharonEllis · 15/02/2023 20:19

Exactly this. Donate clothes and stuff to a Red Cross shop, the money raised can be used directly where its needed. Its ridiculous to spent £1000s to ship a container of random stuff, or on fuel to drive it. Much more efficient to buy clothes and supplies in Turkey, also supporting the local economy & allowimg agencies & individuals on the ground to assess what's needed. The vast majority of stuff transported gets dumped in landfill, another burden for the country that experienced the first disaster.

This happened when the war in Ukraine started too. There were appeals for pet food, and containers of Asda Price dog food were shipped at great cost to the borders. Money is better and would go a lot further, along with supporting the local economies.

SharonEllis · 15/02/2023 20:19

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 13/02/2023 23:46

Warm clothes are needed

what’s not needed is black bags full of a random assortment of jumpers, trousers and coats being loaded into a transit van with a vague idea of driving to turkey.

Its inefficient, time consuming and causes more problems locally. Leave it to the professionals. Send cash ti the DEC.

Exactly this. Donate clothes and stuff to a Red Cross shop, the money raised can be used directly where its needed. Its ridiculous to spent £1000s to ship a container of random stuff, or on fuel to drive it. Much more efficient to buy clothes and supplies in Turkey, also supporting the local economy & allowimg agencies & individuals on the ground to assess what's needed. The vast majority of stuff transported gets dumped in landfill, another burden for the country that experienced the first disaster.

XenoBitch · 15/02/2023 20:17

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 14/02/2023 17:27

But it gives people the warm fuzzy feels to give stuff rather than handing over a tenner. Plus giving "stuff" allows the opportunity to post about it on social media, take photos and virtue signalling by "asking honestly" about who is collecting and where you can drop off your things. Bank transferring or popping into your local Red Cross/Oxfam/Save the Children with cash just isn't as social media friendly for most.

Yep, this.
Someone on my FB has posted a pic of her daughter in front of a pile of bags of donations, ready to go to a charity shop. Why??

SharonEllis · 15/02/2023 20:12

RealBecca · 13/02/2023 22:57

Is it possible some people thought the donations would be sold or sold for rags and the proceeds going to the charity to help instead of the actual items?

When I do this I separate the rags and always ask before handing them over. Not all charity shops collect rags.

KatherineJaneway · 14/02/2023 18:16

I think the reason some people give crap to a charity shop is so they don't have to throw it away themselves. However broken or unsaleable an item is, if they don't have to throw it into the landfill bin themselves, they don't feel the guilt.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 14/02/2023 17:39

Don't be so ridiculous OP.

HufflepuffRavenclaw · 14/02/2023 17:27

But it gives people the warm fuzzy feels to give stuff rather than handing over a tenner. Plus giving "stuff" allows the opportunity to post about it on social media, take photos and virtue signalling by "asking honestly" about who is collecting and where you can drop off your things. Bank transferring or popping into your local Red Cross/Oxfam/Save the Children with cash just isn't as social media friendly for most.

Whitney168 · 14/02/2023 17:07

FKATondelayo · 13/02/2023 22:59

Why do these collections still happen? Why are people in the UK sending used clothing that costs time and money to sort and ship to a country that is a major manufacturer of clothing and textiles? This cannot be a good use of limited time and resources. If you want to donate, donate cash to DEC/Red Cross.

Absolutely. Yet again we're seeing the pleas on local groups for people to pass on all their stuff. Frankly, it would be far more useful to donate just a couple of quid than it would to donate stuff that people probably don't want, and even if they do it's a huge effort and cost to get it there.

ZiriForEver · 14/02/2023 17:03

It doesn't even make sense to talk about it as about "donations".
There is a system in place for material which isn't a piece of clothing someone would like to buy anymore, but can be recycled.

Maybe the word donation should be reserved for giving something actually useful and the rest we can name somehow like "at least a bit responsibile waste management", so it would be clear that the charity shop isn't receiving some great favour they should be grateful about, but provides a valuable service (takes your old stuff away for you and deal with recycling)

xogossipgirlxo · 14/02/2023 11:46

Some donations are basically "too bothered to dump it on recycling site", so I agree with outrage, but some requests are being ridiculous. I remember one request (it wasn't in the UK) for donations of new toys and puzzles for children. Due to covid they didn't want anything not packed in brand new packaging. This is ridiculous. Ask for money instead!?

I stopped supporting big charities and donate only to small ones where I can see actual work.

ZiriForEver · 14/02/2023 11:35

Old clothing not really fit for purpose or unwanted medicine is useful only if already there - fast, immediate neighborhood help.

It can work in a small scale if someone (who knows a place and people both inside and outside of the disaster area) personally bridges the gap, but it rarely makes sense with a bigger distance than neighbor state.
Exception are things which are totally out of stock everywhere between point of need and you (balistic protection for Ukraine was such example)

Sell locally and raise money. Or just give locally.

Iceysuperslide · 14/02/2023 09:58

I sort donations out for a long standing charity. There is some absolute junk given that is for only fit for the bin. The charity has to pay for this to be disposed. Most clothes can go in the rag bag so some money but a broken candlestick or picture frame is no use.

maxelly · 14/02/2023 09:49

While I agree it's in poor taste to mock people who are just trying to help, there is an important message here, the TLDR is don't send items to disaster zones, if you want to help send cash, if you have no cash try and help in other ways such as spreading awareness, writing to your MP to push for increased government aid or volunteering time to run fundraising events. But don't send "stuff".

We had this when war in Ukraine broke out (when it seemed every man and his dog was hiring a transit van, loading it with random donated stuff and driving to Poland, the poor overwhelmed Polish border towns suddenly becoming a warehouse for all Europe's guilty conscience), and pretty much after every natural or man-made humanitarian crisis ever. It's well meaning but misguided. You will pretty much never see a reputable disaster aid charity like DEC, Red Cross, MSF ask for donations of items or 'stuff' to be sent to disaster zones, and this is a really interesting Article about why that is. Cash is much more useful and can be effectively distributed by a reputable charity towards paying for exactly what is needed on the ground, food, clothing, medical supplies (which can often be purchased locally for less than the cost of shipping the same donated goods from Europe plus this supports the local economy and makes more environmental sense), or perhaps even more importantly, to pay for medical, logistical, civil engineering, construction help to rebuild the community and people's lives, reducing the time period where people are dependent on outside help.

Whoever said about environmentalism and low waste culture perhaps contributing to the trend I think may be right, I'm a member of a few nutty "zero waste" social media groups (people who aim to literally throw away nothing, ever) and while the majority of the advice is sensible and aimed at helping people consume less and reuse what they already have, some people do chime in with nutty suggestions about what to do with obvious rubbish like very well worn underwear or broken kitchenware, which is always along the lines of making it someone else's problem - donate it to a local school or nursery for the children to play or do crafts with is a common one (like any nursery is going to give the children a handleless chipped cheap saucepan to play kitchens with or a headless Barbie for 'crafts'!), or some people do seem to think charity shops are essentially recycling centres for things that have outlived their usefulness to anyone!

Goingforasong · 14/02/2023 09:19

I have worked in a charity shop and only a small perecentage of the clothes donated ever made it into the shop. Most of the volunteers' time was spent sorting out those that were worth selling from the dross. Charity shops get so many donations now that they can't cope with the piles of waste clothing. I would ask that people only send good quality clean clothing to a charity shop and suggest they take the rest to a supermarket clothes bank so it can be recycled.

Soakitup37 · 14/02/2023 09:10

I’ve always been mindful of what I donate, I went with a bag full of nearly new baby clothes etc recently and the woman went through it in front of me and wouldn’t let me go until she had done. It was horrible for me feeling like a bad person.

she ended up taking it all without a thanks and it put me off donating again. I usually sell my stuff
now, give it away for free or recycle the fabric.

I still shop in charity shops I think that reusing clothes and minimising fast fashion is important I just wish it wasn’t such a controversial thing to do these days!

FKATondelayo · 14/02/2023 09:04

Easternext · 14/02/2023 00:39

Who has spare cash right now? these people think they are helping!!! Maybe a list off things that are acceptable should be posted all over social media so more people think bobbly jumpers and holey leggings aren't good enough, I would never donate something in a condition that I wouldn't buy it.

If you don't have spare cash, you shouldn't feel the need to donate anything - you should keep your money for you and your family. If you have spare clothes in good quality you should either sell them to support yourself or donate to those in need locally - our old school uniforms to the PTA; coats, scarves, trainers to the asylum seekers group etc.

Giving old clothes to be sorted, shipped to and distributed within a country that is one of the biggest manufacturers of clothes in the world is mental.