Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sense of loss after some one has lost weight.

190 replies

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 21:05

I had a male friend for three years. We were very close. He was very overweight all that time. I never thought it was a bad thing. That is just how he was.

I moved away to work in another country for a couple of years. I recently moved back near him, and we started talking again.

In those three years, he lost a huge amount of weight. He is literally more than half the size he was. He doesn't look anything like his former self. All of his features have completely changed.

I am happy for him that he is healthy.

However, I feel a real sense of loss for the person I knew. He doesn't look anything like him at all. I feel like I really miss the person I knew. He had such a drastic change in looks.

I know he is the same person, but he is not the person I knew.

I miss the old person. And that person is gone.

I know it's a weird way to feel but if someone changes looks very drastically maybe it is natural to miss the old person?

OP posts:
BonnetDeDoucheRodney · 13/02/2023 23:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Same question I asked upthread, good luck getting an answer.

Interesting how the personality transplant wasn't in the OP.

PlumbleCrumble · 13/02/2023 23:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sorry I somehow missed that comment!

New theory: he has been replaced by an imposter and only his true friends know

DuplicateUserName · 13/02/2023 23:11

The last time I saw her, I burst out crying, as her looks had changed so much.

That is very far from a normal reaction OP.

I really hope you didn't do it in front of her.

PlumbleCrumble · 13/02/2023 23:09

NOT the same thing at all, but this reminds me of Love Is Blind, where contenstants 'fall in love' with someone by talking to them but not seeing them. And sometimes when they get out of the pod, they havr difficulty integrating the voice and person they know with what they look like in person/ letting go of the way they pictured that person when they were talking to them.

Is it that basically that you thought you were talking to him and picturing him looking as he always did, and now you realised he was actuLly looking quite different to what you assumed, and it wad quite jarring?

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 23:08

I have to say, looking at this in a light-hearted way, some of the quotes on here did make me laugh.

One was "you lost your fat friend, thoughts and prayers to you"

OP posts:
Valentinesquestion · 13/02/2023 23:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Valentinesquestion · 13/02/2023 23:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 23:05

Tandora · 13/02/2023 23:05

🤣🤣🤣🤣 can’t think of much creepier than the thought of OP clutching an old photo of her friend still fat while talking to him on the phone

Haha. That actually made me laugh.

OP posts:
Tandora · 13/02/2023 23:05

PlumbleCrumble · 13/02/2023 23:02

Maybe you should just talk to him more by phone, while looking at a photo of what he used to look like?

Keep his contact saved with an old photo?

Surely as his personality has not changed you can slowly intergrate his personality and voice etc back into what he looks like now?

I get you might have happy memories of him looking one way and now he looks different, so maybe talking to him/hearing his voice will remind you he is still him!

🤣🤣🤣🤣 can’t think of much creepier than the thought of OP clutching an old photo of her friend still fat while talking to him on the phone

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 23:04

saraclara · 13/02/2023 22:56

A huge shock, yes. And I think that when someone's loses a lot of weight from their face, it can seem like they're the same person, but looking ill. If they'd always looked like that, it would be normal. But his face now looks drawn and droopy, as if he's really unwell. So I'd say that yes, it makes me feel weirdly sad, and I have to remind myself that he's not ill, in fact he's healthier than he's ever been!

The loss thing? Yes, it is a kind of loss. It's not a word I'd have used without prompting, but nor can I say that it doesn't fit how I feel.

I'm sure that had I not experienced it, I'd have been telling the OP off for over-reacting, too. But there we go. I've learned something through the experience. In time I'm sure the new J will become the J I know. But it's early days and my brain hasn't caught up yet.

What country are you in saraclara? Pm me if you want to answer that way. I'm in ireland

OP posts:
saraclara · 13/02/2023 23:04

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 23:01

My friend's name also begins with J.

Imagine if it was the same person. It's a small world.

😧

Ha! No, my J is very happily married, and hasn't changed in personality at all!

PlumbleCrumble · 13/02/2023 23:02

Maybe you should just talk to him more by phone, while looking at a photo of what he used to look like?

Keep his contact saved with an old photo?

Surely as his personality has not changed you can slowly intergrate his personality and voice etc back into what he looks like now?

I get you might have happy memories of him looking one way and now he looks different, so maybe talking to him/hearing his voice will remind you he is still him!

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 23:01

saraclara · 13/02/2023 22:56

A huge shock, yes. And I think that when someone's loses a lot of weight from their face, it can seem like they're the same person, but looking ill. If they'd always looked like that, it would be normal. But his face now looks drawn and droopy, as if he's really unwell. So I'd say that yes, it makes me feel weirdly sad, and I have to remind myself that he's not ill, in fact he's healthier than he's ever been!

The loss thing? Yes, it is a kind of loss. It's not a word I'd have used without prompting, but nor can I say that it doesn't fit how I feel.

I'm sure that had I not experienced it, I'd have been telling the OP off for over-reacting, too. But there we go. I've learned something through the experience. In time I'm sure the new J will become the J I know. But it's early days and my brain hasn't caught up yet.

My friend's name also begins with J.

Imagine if it was the same person. It's a small world.

OP posts:
Eyerollcentral · 13/02/2023 23:01

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:57

It's so predictable to call women weird on here. You know the bullies are out on Mumsnet when they start calling women weird, crazy, nutjobs. It's so predictable. If you used an original insult, I might be slightly impressed. But you didn't.

OP listen to what people are telling you. Both examples you have given are well outside the realms of normal reactions to a friend losing weight or seeing a younger cousin grow up in the space of 2-3 years. I have some personal experience as I didn’t see my USA based nieces and nephews for 2-3 years due to covid. I defo didn’t burst in to tears. Again, you must have seen photos of the child in the intervening years. Seems like again it’s all about you 🤷‍♀️

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:59

saraclara · 13/02/2023 22:56

A huge shock, yes. And I think that when someone's loses a lot of weight from their face, it can seem like they're the same person, but looking ill. If they'd always looked like that, it would be normal. But his face now looks drawn and droopy, as if he's really unwell. So I'd say that yes, it makes me feel weirdly sad, and I have to remind myself that he's not ill, in fact he's healthier than he's ever been!

The loss thing? Yes, it is a kind of loss. It's not a word I'd have used without prompting, but nor can I say that it doesn't fit how I feel.

I'm sure that had I not experienced it, I'd have been telling the OP off for over-reacting, too. But there we go. I've learned something through the experience. In time I'm sure the new J will become the J I know. But it's early days and my brain hasn't caught up yet.

Yes that is always how I think about my friend! That his face looks deflated and sick and unwell.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 13/02/2023 22:58

😂 bullies

Sure.

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:57

Bubblebubblebah · 13/02/2023 22:53

It's weird you are that distraught by other people's bodies changing.

And no, it doesn't reallly compare to dad's not seeing their kids often (there is completely different issue which is highlighted by growing up and missing it) or mothers being sad their kids aren't babies anymore

It's so predictable to call women weird on here. You know the bullies are out on Mumsnet when they start calling women weird, crazy, nutjobs. It's so predictable. If you used an original insult, I might be slightly impressed. But you didn't.

OP posts:
saraclara · 13/02/2023 22:56

Tandora · 13/02/2023 22:36

do you feel sad every time you look at him though? And would you describe his body changing as a “huge shock” and “loss”.

A huge shock, yes. And I think that when someone's loses a lot of weight from their face, it can seem like they're the same person, but looking ill. If they'd always looked like that, it would be normal. But his face now looks drawn and droopy, as if he's really unwell. So I'd say that yes, it makes me feel weirdly sad, and I have to remind myself that he's not ill, in fact he's healthier than he's ever been!

The loss thing? Yes, it is a kind of loss. It's not a word I'd have used without prompting, but nor can I say that it doesn't fit how I feel.

I'm sure that had I not experienced it, I'd have been telling the OP off for over-reacting, too. But there we go. I've learned something through the experience. In time I'm sure the new J will become the J I know. But it's early days and my brain hasn't caught up yet.

Eyerollcentral · 13/02/2023 22:56

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:50

It is a very normal reaction.

My uncle only sees one of his grandchildren twice a year due to a custody battle between the girls parents.

Every time he sees her he cries to me about how much she's changed and how taller she has gotten.

I see mothers post on Facebook all the time about being upset at their own children changing. they post about the years flying by, and their children changing so much, and getting taller. And how sad they are about it. And could we just "please pause time for a moment"

Your uncle is crying because he doesn’t see his grandchild ffs. You are crying because a cousin’s looks changed!!!! Your cousin is not your child. Totally OTT response

Bubblebubblebah · 13/02/2023 22:55

Cherrysoup · 13/02/2023 22:53

I lost half my body weight and I went to visit a friend I hadn’t seen for ages. I didn’t tell her I’d lost weight, we weren’t really in touch for ages then decided to meet up. She was gobsmacked when she saw me. On a related note, my uncle said his visual memory of me is as an overweight person and he was shocked every time he saw me when I was slim. I understand your point, OP.

The clincher is that your friend has obviously gained massive confidence and has changed how he talks/thinks about women and for you, that seems to be the biggest change and not a nice one.

But were they sad and grieving the oerson who isn't there anymore?
That's the issue, not the surprise

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:55

Cherrysoup · 13/02/2023 22:53

I lost half my body weight and I went to visit a friend I hadn’t seen for ages. I didn’t tell her I’d lost weight, we weren’t really in touch for ages then decided to meet up. She was gobsmacked when she saw me. On a related note, my uncle said his visual memory of me is as an overweight person and he was shocked every time he saw me when I was slim. I understand your point, OP.

The clincher is that your friend has obviously gained massive confidence and has changed how he talks/thinks about women and for you, that seems to be the biggest change and not a nice one.

Thanks for that Cherrysoup. Yeah my visual memory of him is how he was.

I had to adjust to how he looked now

OP posts:
AlmostaMamma · 13/02/2023 22:54

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:51

Even though another woman on here has said she felt exactly the same about her friend losing a lot of weight?

Ok then. We are weird. Cuz you said so.

Not just her. 89% of the people who have voted think YABU. That’s the overwhelming majority.

You wanted to know if you were being reasonable. You’ve been told ‘yes’. You appear unwilling to accept this.

Tandora · 13/02/2023 22:54

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:50

It is a very normal reaction.

My uncle only sees one of his grandchildren twice a year due to a custody battle between the girls parents.

Every time he sees her he cries to me about how much she's changed and how taller she has gotten.

I see mothers post on Facebook all the time about being upset at their own children changing. they post about the years flying by, and their children changing so much, and getting taller. And how sad they are about it. And could we just "please pause time for a moment"

Are you a mother? That’s definitely not how I would describe it at all. Yes of course there’s a little pang when I think of my babies when they are tiny, I miss that, but I would never ever say i experienced feeling sad every time I looked at my children, or a sense of loss. It’s overwhelming happiness, pride, joy in how they’ve grown, with the littlest bittersweet pang / heart tug of missing how little they used to be. But happiness . Nothing at all akin to what you are describing of your feelings towards your friend.

Cherrysoup · 13/02/2023 22:53

I lost half my body weight and I went to visit a friend I hadn’t seen for ages. I didn’t tell her I’d lost weight, we weren’t really in touch for ages then decided to meet up. She was gobsmacked when she saw me. On a related note, my uncle said his visual memory of me is as an overweight person and he was shocked every time he saw me when I was slim. I understand your point, OP.

The clincher is that your friend has obviously gained massive confidence and has changed how he talks/thinks about women and for you, that seems to be the biggest change and not a nice one.

Bubblebubblebah · 13/02/2023 22:53

Mooshamoo · 13/02/2023 22:51

Even though another woman on here has said she felt exactly the same about her friend losing a lot of weight?

Ok then. We are weird. Cuz you said so.

It's weird you are that distraught by other people's bodies changing.

And no, it doesn't reallly compare to dad's not seeing their kids often (there is completely different issue which is highlighted by growing up and missing it) or mothers being sad their kids aren't babies anymore