Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my children were more sociable with family members?

62 replies

harrassedmumto3 · 13/02/2023 18:17

My children were mainly raised away from the bosom of extended family (grandparents, etc), due to ex husband and I living further away for work. Family members have always lived very close to each other and see each other regularly. It follows that my kids are on the outside a bit more, as they lack the day to day continuity that the others have always had.
However over the years, we've made an effort to get everyone together. My children and I live only an hour apart from them now, and have done for years.
The only thing is, my children (16 & 13) have no real interest in them, and are completely indifferent to their younger cousins (only a couple of years apart).
My sister visited for the day with her two kids, and it was embarrassing how little my girls wanted to interact with them. They would only do it under duress. It only highlights the divide between us all Sad On the one hand, I can't really blame my kids. On the other, I think 'FFS, would it really kill you to make a bit of effort?'
My sister's kids are really lovely, so it's not like they're having to interact with total brats!
My niece let it slip that she hadn't wanted to come today (not in an unkind way) and I think it's because my daughters verge on unfriendly. Or at least completely aloof.
That made me sad and I wish I'd laid the groundwork more when they were little. We did our best but it obviously wasn't enough.
I was brought up in the belief that family is everything, and I feel I've missed the brief with my own children!
As my sister was leaving, she joked to my girls that she was so pleased she'd made the 3 hour round trip, all for seeing my girls for just a few minutes Blush Their cousins were in the room with them for a bit longer than that though.
I'm a single parent who is used to being on my own lots with my kids. I'd really appreciate your advice on how to manage future family meet-ups. Am I too pushy or not pushy enough? I just feel under pressure when they're here to be doing more to make my kids interact (I do try, without completely forcing it, which I feel would be counterproductive!) and I know that my family will be talking about it Confused
Can anyone else relate to our particular family dynamic?
Gentle words would go down particularly well, as I feel a bit sad. I used to love family and cousin get-togethers when I was a child!
Thanks for reading.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LBFseBrom · 08/04/2023 13:16

PuppyMonkey · 13/02/2023 18:23

Yikes, I’d have been the same as your kids at that age. People you barely know, be sociable to order. That’s a no from me.Grin

Same here.

However it will change as your daughters get older, op. I don't know why but it just does, quite naturally.

ilovebagpuss · 28/03/2023 20:14

Yes it definitely needs an outing or activity like Go Ape or Laser Tag or something. What were they supposed to do with younger cousins all day in their room? Play Barbie or dress up?
My older teen DD's read and listen to music or faff about they don't play.
When we get together with cousins it might be a bbq or something and they all chat with the adults and eat etc but we don't expect them to go off together and hang out.
You can't make them be best buddies but you could facilitate some fun meet ups. Canping was always a laugh just for a night or 2 something that everyone mucks about together.

Offensiveapprently · 14/02/2023 06:02

Really hard OP as someone who has felt the closeness of a very sisterly cousin relationship I k ow how important that has been to me. My kid hasn't grown up with hers but she is home from abroad now after 8 years but they clicked together like lego. Less so for a cousin he grew up down the road from. It may jut be that they have totally different personalities.

Temese · 14/02/2023 01:54

How did they only spend a few minutes with them? If they made a 3 hour round trip, then surely there was a meal involved? I would have made my dc join us at the table at least, and if they were not polite and sociable during that time I would be very cross with them, not to mention really embarrassed by their behaviour.

sandgrown · 14/02/2023 01:46

If it helps OP. My cousin and I are 12 years different in age . I remember her as a baby. We only saw each other at family occasions growing up. Now we are adults and our parents have died the family ties have brought us together . We are now great friends who make the effort to see each other despite living a distance apart and speak on the phone most weeks .

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 14/02/2023 01:38

I think you need to plan their interactions better for awhile. Do an outing where they would all have fun - like a trampoline park, or go out for pizza somewhere so they can't just leave the table and go back to their rooms. Or for home buy a special multi- player game for whatever console they have that is child friendly. The Mario games or similar are quite good for that.

They need to actually spend time together to get to know each other so you need to facilitate that.

Volhhg · 14/02/2023 00:11

My kids only see their relatives every few years at most. But they are always excited to meet them and want to interact /be friendly although they are shy and awkward. Maybe your kids see enough of your family and they have just decided they're not interested and don't value them. I don't know why that could be.

MrsAvocet · 13/02/2023 22:41

My children are polite to their cousins when they see them, and they do have more common interests with some more than others, but they are not particularly close with any of them and aren't really interested in being so. I imagine it's mutual. My MIL seems to think that her grandchildren should all have some kind of special bond, by virtue of their shared 12.5% DNA or whatever it is, but the reality is that they don't. They don't have anything against each other but they have grown up hundreds of miles apart with very different interests and lives and that doesn't magically change when they meet at Christmas or whatever. All I ask of my children in such situations is that they are pleasant and polite, as they should be to any guest.
I guess it's probably different if you grow up near to your cousins and spend a lot of time with them in your formative years, but if you don't, there is no reason that you should be any closer to them than anyone else really. If you've had that experience of a large, close extended family it is understandable that you would value it and want it for your own children, but unfortunately I don't think you can force the situation. And at 13 and 16, even a couple of years age difference can feel like a lot, so your DC's may feel like they are being made to spend time with younger kids who are basically strangers. As time goes on, the age difference may become less significant and they'll perhaps feel they have more in common when they are a bit older. If my children are anything to go by, any attempts to manipulate them into seeing more of their cousins is likely to be counterproductive I'm afraid.

Powaqa · 13/02/2023 22:39

When my nan was alive, the family used to regularly meet up at her house. We (the cousins) all knew each other but didn't play together or really interact. We were there with our parents and they were the ones interacting. I was the oldest and didn't really get on with any of them as I was at least 3 or 4 years older.
I haven't really seen any of my cousins since she died 40 years ago and obviously wouldn't know any of them if I passed them in the street. Some of the younger ones still meet up with each other.
You can't force a relationship. Just because siblings have a relationship doesn't mean their children should.

Rogue1001MNer · 13/02/2023 22:17

My mum insisted on my dd and my dsis's dc getting together regularly.

She facilitated it.

It often wasn't happy.

My niece in particular was often not kind to my daughter.

It caused a lot of stress at the time over a lot of years

I'm sooooo glad my mum did this. My dd is the youngest and she's 21 now and the kids love each other
Family is important.
But you can't force it, I don't think.

If they weren't familiar with each other in their formulative years, they're not going to suddenly be now

BareGrylls · 13/02/2023 22:11

At 16 and 13 I'd really lay the law down beforehand and insist they don't just "make an effort " but actively work to make the guests welcome and entertain them.
Promise a reward afterwards if they do it well.

Puddywoodycat · 13/02/2023 22:06

Ps last summer we had a few small visitors and my two had. Definitely not only became better at "what to do" but they had more fun overall and also were able to say when they had had enough.

Puddywoodycat · 13/02/2023 22:03

@harrassedmumto3.

Sometimes you need to prime the dc before hand and help them see what the little ones feel.

Eg when we have the odd rare visitor I say to mine they are not expected to entertain the small dc all day but they must make some effort at interaction and I help them with toys and ideas of what to do. I also said after the initial playing they can tag team.

I reminded them of how when they were little they adored someone interaction with them. Of their ages and it means a lot. They must be polite a d make Ana bit of effort.

I wouldn't expect this to just happen unless the dc were well used to smaller dc...

GriddleScone · 13/02/2023 22:02

My dcs were the oldest cousins and the younger ones were always desperate to see them. It was especially tough on my daughter, who was expected by relatives to want to look after them. DS, on the other hand, was allowed to slope off. I never pushed any relationships on them. I'm sure they would have resented it.

Mariposista · 13/02/2023 21:49

PeekAtYou · 13/02/2023 21:05

I think that schools don't help in this regard. People generally socialise with their year group with the occasional plus or minus a year so I can imagine a couple of years being a big deal. If yours are 16 and 13 then I'm assuming that the younger cousins are early secondary/late primary.
I have a 16yo who has a cousin that he is indifferent to and if he was visiting then ds would probably go out with a football or basketball then take him to the coop to get some sweets as that's what him and his friends "do" and it's the easiest way to spend time with someone much younger.

You could be right there. My son is a swimmer, and even though he is 14, he has friends who are 17, and also others who are 11. The club is like a second family to them, so they wouldn't not be mates with someone on the grounds of their age. But if you don't have that experience it would be easy to pass off younger children as 'babyish' and 'I have nothing in common with them'.

PeekAtYou · 13/02/2023 21:05

I think that schools don't help in this regard. People generally socialise with their year group with the occasional plus or minus a year so I can imagine a couple of years being a big deal. If yours are 16 and 13 then I'm assuming that the younger cousins are early secondary/late primary.
I have a 16yo who has a cousin that he is indifferent to and if he was visiting then ds would probably go out with a football or basketball then take him to the coop to get some sweets as that's what him and his friends "do" and it's the easiest way to spend time with someone much younger.

FallonofDynasty · 13/02/2023 21:02

Mine were the same, youngest still is. Those years are peek awkwardness.
A couple of years apart can be a lot at that age.
Mine have cousins that are about 5 / 7 years younger , makes things easier as there's no pressure for them to be best pals.
Eldest now complains that eg her uncle hasn't conversed with her, probably forgetting the years of awkwardness.

EarringsandLipstick · 13/02/2023 20:54

I agree with a lot of PPs.

Firstly a few years gap can be huge at that age - how much younger are the cousins?

Secondly meeting without a shared activity to counter awkwardness is hard

But this

As my sister was leaving, she joked to my girls that she was so pleased she'd made the 3 hour round trip, all for seeing my girls for just a few minutes doesn't sound much of a joke, it sounds like a dig at your DDs, and kinda mean tbh. And guaranteed to make them more awkward the next time!

SalviaOfficinalis · 13/02/2023 20:48

I think I would have died with awkwardness personally if I were your teens! You can’t force it unfortunately.

You describe being on the outside of the wider family, and it sounds like you’ve made lots of effort… but has your sister made a similar amount of effort with your DDs? It goes both ways.

Madeintowerhamlets · 13/02/2023 20:43

I would feel the same as you OP but I think you’re taking on too much responsibility for this dynamic. You can’t force it really & even if the cousins had been close as young children they might not be as teenagers. I only have one daughter & she’s much younger than your girls but because she’s an only I feel a lot of responsibility to create social opportunities for her. But I’ve realised that I can only create the opportunities & I can’t guarantee they will be successful!

Daisybuttercup12345 · 13/02/2023 20:32

I used to see some of my cousins once a year at Christmas. Fine when we were little and all played with toys but by teens we had nothing in common and hardly spoke. Never see them at all now. Not even fb friends. Sad really.

commentnotaquestion · 13/02/2023 20:14

"some children are raised to be sociable and how to make small talk and to respond and make conversation when adults or others talk to them...and some children just aren't raised that way. I'm sorry OP they do sound a bit ignorant and rude and I'd have been mortified if my children did this."

Honestly I don't think it's as simple as that. I am extremely sociable, friendly, and good at making conversation. I tried to raise my teen that way, but he's a shy introvert who struggles with people he doesn't know. He's well able to make conversation with people he knows and can be delightful company but finds it very difficult with strangers. Do I find this rude? Yes. Am I mortified? Yes! Do I think he'd be any different if I'd raised him differently? Probably not.

AngelinaFibres · 13/02/2023 20:07

My parents were both only children and extremely / painfully self contained. As a child my mother was happiest reading in her room and hated it when friends came round to play. My father was socially awkward all his life. As a result we had no cousins and didn't go to friends of my parents and play with their children because they just didn't have any. My father didn't have a single friend for his entire life. Because of all this we were painfully shy. There are 3 of us and we are very ,very close in age so we always had each other to play with so didn't need to learn to play with other people. My brain used to turn to mush when we met someone they knew in the street. We would be expected to speak clearly and confidently but none of us could do it. Once you know you can do it it just makes the next time 1000 million times worse. My mum had a cousin and his children were a similar age to us. If we stayed with our grandparents they would always visit. It was excruciating. It makes me feel sick thinking about it. Their daughter was very pretty, had a fabulous shiny bob haircut and did ballet that she liked to demonstrate. I had mousy hair , awful clothes and was gangly and sooo massively awkward. Everyone gushed over how fabulous X was whilst I sat and wanted the ground to swallow me .It really didn't help my lack of confidence. My grandads brother ( one of 9) used to come on his way to the football. He was incredibly loud, probably because he was one of nine. He had this game where he would throw a rubber mouse into the room and then shout ( in a Derbyshire accent) " Bluddy 'ell a rubba maaaase". He thought it was hilarious. We just wanted to get behind the sofa and hide until he had gone. The louder he got,the more we hid, so the louder he got. I didn't become less awkward until I left home and went to college.Now I am very at ease meeting new people and being in any social situation. I really enjoy it. It was only because there was no longer any expectation that I would behave in a particular way. My father's very worst habit was to dissect all the interactions afterwards and to criticise everything and suggest improvements for next time; hilarious given he couldn't do small talk for his entire life. He wanted us to be confident but his, and my mother's, behaviour made it impossible. It might be very much easier for your daughters if you met up at a farm park or a go ape type thing so they are doing 'a thing' rather than having to forcibly play and to just let them be. You may find that they start to play if there is no expectation but trying to force it will just make it more stressful for them.
Sorry its so long.

Rowthe · 13/02/2023 19:42

Or just take them bowling

Tireddoggymum · 13/02/2023 19:42

I think the age of your children is part of the problem. Teenagers can be very awkward and they don’t have the confidence that an older person would have .
Maybe next time organise to go out somewhere interesting .